Some Curse Ideas: Critique/Feedback

Discussing all things Ravenloft
Post Reply
User avatar
Hazgarn
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 342
Joined: Wed Mar 26, 2008 12:17 am
Location: Sacramento, CA
Contact:

Some Curse Ideas: Critique/Feedback

Post by Hazgarn »

These are some things I'm developing for my campaign, and I'm fairly inexperienced when it comes to balancing things (I'm strong in story, but weak when it comes to crunch), so I was hoping to get some input on what I have so far.

Audhill Maceith's Cursed Hat of Disguise
This item is supposed to seed plot that will (hopefully) eventually lead to an adventure in Paridon involving a sect of its disenfranchised lower-class youth worshiping Cas (god of grudges from Heroes of Horror, with a few changes because my players are not going to find a god with a moose's head scary, but a stag's could be)

Backstory: The hat belonged to a Zherisian hatter whose father was ruined by a wealthy businessman. The father died in debt and disgraced, and the son, Audhill Maceith, was drawn into the worship of Cas and sought revenge. His plans for revenge involved the businessman's children (killing them, abducting them, not sure) and were thwarted by his own sister (working as their nursemaid to get by) killed him with a blow to the head mean only to knock him out.

(hat of disguise seems random, but was chosen to be desirable to the players)

The Gist: The hat would be loot on an unstable but otherwise normal bandit (who bore many of the signs of the curse). Anyone who uses the hat is at risk of being taken over by the personality of the dead hatter, eventually being driven to return to Paridon to complete his revenge as follows (uncertain about the DCs, willing to take advice):
Audhill Maceith's cursed hat of disguise—Whatever form this hat takes, the small makers mark stamped inside it's crown is visible: A faint golden impression of a single branching antler with the words
"Maceith Hatters - Broadbill St. - Paridon" written in Zherizian.

Whenever it's ability of disguise self is used, the user must make a Will save or begin to come under it's spell. Each time a save is failed, the curse moves up a step.

First save is DC 10, and failure will make the person incredibly reluctant to give up the hat to anyone else. A Wisdom check of 15 will allow people around them to detect the faint scent of mildew following the party, or 25 to realize it is clinging to the character wearing it. If the hat is taken from them and kept away for an entire day, the effects will fade. (During this time, all mental scores are at a -2 penalty, min 1).

The second save is DC 15, and failure causes the veins in the affected person's left eye burst, giving a distinctive bloody sclera that will not heal naturally, and if healed by magic soon recurs. A Wisdom check of 15 will allow those around them to detect the scent of mildew clinging to them. They will not voluntarily give up the hat without a Will save of 20. If the hat is taken from them, keeping them apart from it for three days will allow the effects to dissipate. (During this time, all mental scores are at a -4 penalty, min 1).

The third save is DC 17, and failure causes the affected person to begin having indistinct dreams: Paridon's crowded streets and dark sewers, blood and rage and screaming, the bloody antlers of a statue of Cas. They also take on the verbal quirk of repeating a word in their speech three times. Anyone who gets close can detect the scent of mildew clinging to them, and their OR is increased by 1. They may be moved to violence if someone tries to take the hat from them (a DC 20 Will save can be made to stop themself, and another must be made every day to resist further violence trying to get the hat back), swearing in Zherisian as they attack (even if they do not speak it). If the hat is taken from them, keeping them apart from it for full week will allow the effects to dissipate. (During this time, all mental scores are at a -6 penalty, min 1).

The fourth save is DC 20, and failure causes alignment change to chaotic evil, becoming filled with unquenchable rage. The character no longer identifies by their own name, but may continue to answer to it to deceive others (calling for Bluff checks). They have a desire to return to Paridon ("home", even if Paridon is not their home) and seek to complete the dead man's revenge. They will actively cooperate with any efforts that lead toward Paridon, or toward investigation of the curse, and violently oppose the opposite. They gain the maniac template (d20 Modern). This can only be undone by finding a way to remove the curse.

If they manage to track down the street in Paridon, they will find that one of the buildings was indeed a hat shop years ago. A silent old woman lives there, who saved herself from the maniac—her older brother who invoked Cas seeking blood-vengeance against their father's disgrace by attempting to murder the children of the man who ruined him. His sister killed him in defense of the target's very young children, and he died before his satisfaction could be delivered.

Removing the Curse:
1. The businessman's two children survive, now adults. If these two are sacrificed to Cas on the shrine in the sewers under Paridon, the curse can be lifted without destroying the hat.
2. If the hat is destroyed on the altar of Cas it will release the ghost of the hatter, whose defeat will break the curse.
3. Track down a third option (like chasing down a midnight cat and making a deal or something).
My main concern is that I want this to be a curse that creeps up slowly. One that will (hopefully) be hanging around for a while before they even realize there's a curse, and have time to actually seek a fix. So those DCs might not be what I want them to be.

With luck, they'll realize there's something fishy when the eye thing happens, as I plan to have a Vistani make a comment about it: "Beware of spite, lest the bloody eye of the Red Grudge [Cas] set its gaze upon you."

Fickle dice
What is your opinion of this item as treasure for a 1st level party? And I have no idea what the creation stats or backstory might be for them.
fickle dice: Two dice, one of aged yellow-white ivory, one dark ebony. Once per day, a person may roll these dice and gain a bonus of +1 to a random ability score and a penalty of -1 to another. Roll two d6s, declaring which is which before hand. The "white" die gives the bonus and the "black" die the penalty as follows: 1-Str, 2-Dex, 3-Con, 4-Int, 5-Wis, 6-Cha.
The bonus and penalty last 24 hours, and until that time has lapsed no one else can gain benefits from this item. As long as their effects are active, if only one die is rolled, or if the dice are separated from each other, they function as normal dice.
Player curse
I've got a player thinking about starting play as a male outlander from Forgotten Realms cursed into a female form for acting like a pig lech/misogynist to a Vistani seer. Obviously, the efforts to reverse of this curse would be a plot point, but I have no idea what action might be appropriate as an escape clause.
Also, just the gender change isn't much, so I was thinking there should be other parts of it. Depending on whether he decides his character was a lech making unwanted advances or just dismissive of women, what are some ways in which this curse could have a more tangible effect?

Random unrelated question: Mist elementals' infuse evil ability. How does the alignment change for that one work? Is it a subtle effect, or would the character suddenly become hostile?
Deranged Comics Fan
Strife-monger
Daughter of a Troll
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Re: Some Curse Ideas: Critique/Feedback

Post by A G Thing »

Audhill Maceith's Cursed Hat of Disguise

Okay, looking at what you wrote I think there are a couple things you could do to stretch and maybe help the curse a bit.

1st: When a player refuses outright to give up an item it tells everyone at the table that they are cursed and that is the item. So change the refusal to be like the first symptom listed as if they were more wanting it back. Tell the player to be insistent about it but not too much so if they are in on it even taking it back while others are not using it but still willing to loan it for a while. If however that player is not in on it then start making it obvious to that player they need the hat for things by perhaps giving intelligence checks for such and phrasing it different if they pass or fail. A passed check could give a good reason for its use but a bad check could just make it seem like a minor suggestion when nothing else fits. Don't do that too much... Then as soon as they ask for it back the other players who have some sort of insight might disagree. Especially if you have done this with notes and given the players conflicting ideas. Still just don't push to hard but make it seem reasonable.

2nd: When the effects would fade if the others take away the hat consider making it only until the next save is failed when the victim uses the hat. This way they might rejudge the hat as fine while they used it but did not fail only to have a sudden relapse when the previous person failed again.

3rd: Or perhaps when a person not as far down the curse fails, then the one who has failed more gets jealous of them using their hat. So perhaps they try to sabotage the effort just to spite the other user as if to prove they should use the hat instead.

4th: Have the eye thing not just show up when they use the hat but when the player feels some sort of extreme emotion such as combat or an argument making it look natural. Perhaps also give them bonuses or penalties depending upon the emotion to make them seem to be more emotional or such and describe small hints otherwise. You could even have them have traces of past disguises personality quirks they used starting to bleed into your descriptions of these events. Another part of showing these signs is perhaps before they failed any saves at all that the item after one week cause symptoms similar to high blood pressure which is usually responsible for such sclera. Something that a physician might notice or treatments might affect but nothing serious at first. The hat should also smell of mildew at first but can be cleaned so when the smell returns later they don't suspect!

5th: The nightmares may be hard to conceal as directly a part of it and may lead to problems but I find that madness even if not permanent may help. Use the madness effects of delusions and paranoia not as a rule but as a tool where the afflicted believes that something else is causing these things and send the party on a wild goose chase for a nighttime enemy that is actually the hat and you will perhaps derail them long enough for it to run its course. If the victim imagines they are the ones being hunted they may try to use the hat more and more to escape notice.

6th: Have the length of time for these to last when the hat has been taken from them be longer than say a day in the further steps. Perhaps a day then a week then two and finally no length of time.

Fickle dice

The item sounds cool but the effect seems a little weak in some regard, and yes the back story is what matters most. I would bump it to a +2 and a -2 as that would give a bonus and a penalty to any user but if you don't then perhaps they are just not so magical to be noticed by all and I guess that is fine. Just very low power and if they have even scores they won't gain anything from it. Besides that it looks like the items once per day and only one person function are what would be the best story basis. Someone who was adventurous but fickle may have used the dice to decide things often. Maybe they began to rely upon the dice once the figured them out but they found that when they did the two dice began to trade effects almost at random so the black die would do what the white die did before. Maybe the numbers did not mean the same thing every day. Maybe the dice were connected to the moon or the seasons or numbers on the calender or all of those and more. Thing is you as the DM could roll a d% to determine what happens.

1% Both effects are a -2 penalty for the day.
2% to 25% There is no change to the effect.
26% to 50% Reverse which die is the bonus and which is the penalty.
51% to 75% Roll 2d6 of your own and determine what the numbers are that day.
86% to 99% There is no change to the effect.
100% Both effects are a +2 bonus instead for the day.

But hey it is up to you. Just an idea!

Player Gender Curse

Part 1 the Dismissive Curse!

Okay if he was dismissive then I suggest if you want to make it harsher then perhaps a good old "You can't say what you are effect!" like seen in "Howl's Moving Castle". Since he was dismissive or thought women behaved a certain way then make it so he cannot tell anyone he is a man. He can say he is cursed and can even try to talk about his past but anything that would hint that he is not or was not a she cannot be said written or communicated by him in anyway. Even if the person knew him before he cannot agree or do anything to confirm their crazy story. He can behave as he once did since women can behave anyway they choose just as a man can so the only restrictions to his behaving how he imagines a man should would be how others view him and he views himself. This should lead to introspection and even thinking before he speaks but it also stops him from just using the whole "I AM A MAN!" card when men try to flirt.

But maybe half the fun for you would be in him screaming to the heavens that his gender has changed which comes with other problems as well. Perhaps part of the curse then is that he is dismissed often for his new gender just as he did to women before. If he proclaims loudly or tries to defend his position he comes off even more feminine even if he was trying to be manly. He is not stopped from proving or claiming he is a man but he appears feminine or to exhibit traits like a woman would have that are unintentional and thus he suffers embarrassment. Those who act like he did (or may still do) to women are inclined more so to treat him as they treat women by dismissing him. Same effect of being treated like a woman but he can still tell others about his curse and they could still treat him like he is mad. Perhaps with enough ranting in a town you can increase his Outcast Rating as people start to think he is a freak. This would be more about punishment and less about teaching a lesson so this may be the crueler addition to the curse but realistically the reason it is so bad is because he is getting back at him an amplified dose of what he gave.

Part 2 The Letch Curse...

Okay now changing someones gender to teach them about equality based out of a sort of dismissal due to preconceptions is one thing but to do so because of how they lust after or treat the other gender as a tool for mental/physical gratification and they know what they are doing is another. Essentially you are now trying more to punish not because he thinks them deficient for their gender but because that gender has what he desires and so he will get what he wants and he will get it however he thinks will work. This could range from him being bad and flirting and crass in his suggestions to some extreme sort of pervert who actually abuses his proximity to women to touch them or make them feel pressured into something by his influence. His desire is obviously sex or at least submission to his ideals of what a woman is to a man at a physical/desire based level and he may only be this messed up in this one area but bad.

So now you are pretty much giving him that thing but telling him that he cannot enjoy it from the whole conquest role and you are taking his main tools away because he used them badly. Assuming his masculinity is important to him (and it had better be if this is going to be a curse) then the following is likely to happen and you should plan around it.

To be honest if the letch enjoys being with women as a virile man type then this will most likely be more than enough to make him miserable because now he has a woman he can get any time but he is her so he can never have her. On top of this he now has to deal with everything he did not want to consider about women while he was lusting after them. He cannot be proud of his sexual prowess or attractiveness as a man and for a letch absorbed in such he would perhaps become ashamed or even angry.

This might even cause him to rebel as he tries to continue on with his behavior. He cannot get perhaps the women he wants and even if there was one perhaps he is not comfortable with the role he would have to play or he just does not feel anything for them in this body or has issues with attraction now that he is a she. The idea of going from virile to fertile may disturb and scare him and also the possibility that he might be physically attracted to men could frighten him more. He had used these women to get a comfort and feeling of control that was assured by his behavior and his superior station in such as a life time had built up. Now he has to look at it from the other side and realize he cannot use his new gender to dominate the situation just with confidence and privilege of birth alone.

But once again he may try to push through and maybe now that he is a woman he decides that he should adjust and he just tries to be himself but flirt with men (maybe just to control the situation again). If he cannot be his ideal man then maybe he can be his ideal woman for certainly he thinks he knows what a woman should be. He sets out to prove this mostly to himself but soon finds that his new fantasy falls apart fast. If he is that desperate to steal comfort and have control to feel safe then this is when things get bad. Men that are attracted to crass women like he is behaving as only want one thing and he does not like it coming back at him because he can see it clearly and knows how they might act. Those men think they are in control of him and they don't care about him anymore than he did and now he gets to see how disgusting he was or even worse. He may try to go after chumps or men that he does not feel threatened by but finds that many more noble men are put off by his unladylike behavior. He needs to realize that his ideas about both genders were so wrong and see that his rewards were shallow deceptions that he believed. Still that might not be easy.

The more he puts himself out there no matter how he looks or pretends to be people see the real him and he either begins lying to himself more or admits he has to change and show honest vulnerability. He has to risk being hurt and you may decide that he will not get it easy and the first person he opens to may actually hurt him bad. But to get past this he has to look around and see how petty his past relationships or just how crass his flirting style was and that building something more and taking time could lead to a relationship that he might not have a chance at as a man if he never gets rid of the curse. The loneliness of wanting love or at least someone to share a night with (even just for company) starts to tie in with respect and this may finally brow beat him into a lesson if he tries to learn it but there are no sign posts on the way in this type of thing.

The fact is that the letch for good reasons has it hard enough already because unless the escape clause is really easy he has to face up to all he did and see how bad things really were. His crimes were so personal in nature by his being so deceptive or even vile in behavior that to let him get away without a hard look at it is an insult. In this regard the escape clause for a letch needs to be either harder than normal or cruel. This like I said is more about punishment then teaching and they knew exactly what they were doing when they abused these women.

Part 3 The Escape Clause...

The first three here are mostly for the dismissive curses... The ones specifically for the Letch are labeled as such. Still these first three clauses if intensified for the letch could possibly work as well...

1st An escape clause for this curse might be that he "proves beyond words that he truly is a man" which as vague as it is may be just a way to prove his actions without the crutch of his gender but what is right since man is just a word anyways. A truly noble deed that reveals the truth of his person thus making him true to form again. Or maybe a chance to do the right thing by supporting or aiding someone in the same position he dismissed them in to cause such.

2nd Or if it is crueler still perhaps "you have to find someone who accepts you for who you really are!" which could mean he has to find someone who either knows everything about him and still loves and supports him for who he is or maybe just someone willing to love him unconditionally which could run the gamut from a friend, family member, lover or even a child (adopting an orphan might work in place of pregnancy!). That person would ultimately have to see a fair and decent person and see them honestly and love them for who they are in an honest fashion. If you want to make it worse then add a time limit such as a year or such.

3rd Or to be hard but still not as cruel perhaps "you must lie in no way to no one for a year!" thus he has to learn to accept his gender and that he is still himself even if he is now herself and that nothing really has changed. If he does not see the truth of the world and realize it applies to everything then he will live with this till he can. Plus he can't lie at all or risk invalidating the year. Silence takes care of not lying to others but real thought and truth with yourself would be hard.

4th For the letch you could take any of the above clauses and take them to the extreme and they might work as well but for an example of what could really work for such a character maybe "May you stay the way you are until your lies become the truth for both you and another!" for say a letch who claimed love and used love who can only be cured the moment he finds real love with another. To discover the truth of love only to have it ripped away especially after building it up would be not only a fitting penance but a true test to the character on how they take such a blow from being cured. Depending on how true the love was for the once letch and if their partner is hurting now they are male again it may be a worse punishment than the curse.

5th For the letch who coerced and forced his wants on a woman this clause of "For every moment you touched another's (heart and/or flesh) falsely may you must find two which are true!" meaning that while he may have forced or deceived his way into passion of the soul or body before unless he does so honestly twice as much as he had falsely he won't be cured. Any further abuse to the hearts or even passions of others could add to this sentence. Worse still is that if his partner is false with him then it adds to his total.

6th Finally for the letch who uses honor or privilege to abuse women and then dismiss them then this one might be difficult. "For every year you abused your place above, deceived those below and reaped the gain of false honor may you now live as year with the other sides pain in true service and diligence to what you held so cheap..." This would force the cursed victim to live the same number of years they already had as if they were now a female member of that institution they used. A noble man forced to live as a noble woman and actually hold on to their honor while abiding by their commitments to their station. If they fail in either they would just keep lengthening the years as they lived falsely.

Of course you could always combine any of these but that might be next to impossible for some and really unfair for such but then again. Curses don't have to be fair.
User avatar
Trike
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 262
Joined: Wed Jul 11, 2012 12:04 am
Location: North Carolina

Re: Some Curse Ideas: Critique/Feedback

Post by Trike »

I was thinking about your cursed hat. It always helps to have the PC want to be a part of the curse. If you want the curse to be around long enough to make a story out of it, you need to make the cursed PC want to be a part of that story.

It would probably be better for you to roll the Will saves yourself. That would obfuscate the direct nature of the curse for a time. The players will get the idea that you are rolling dice concerning this hat. But they won't be sure there is a curse yet.

It might help to give out little bonuses for failing Will saves. That way, the player is enabling the curse at the early stages. He may find that a bad effect isn't so bad if he is getting a bonus somewhere else. Later, the curse develops to the point where the PC is trapped.

This entices the players to risk the curse until you are able to lay the seeds of the story. Then you can encourage them to follow the clues and deal with this cursed item once and for all.
User avatar
Hazgarn
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 342
Joined: Wed Mar 26, 2008 12:17 am
Location: Sacramento, CA
Contact:

Re: Some Curse Ideas: Critique/Feedback

Post by Hazgarn »

Didn't mean to just let this sit. thank you both for your input. :)
Deranged Comics Fan
Strife-monger
Daughter of a Troll
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Re: Some Curse Ideas: Critique/Feedback

Post by A G Thing »

No problem! I know sometime it can be hard to get back to the boards quickly all the time. Hope it is helpful!
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
Post Reply