Winter of 755.
The PCs, members of the Falkovnian Special Forces (known simply as "Unit 43") have received new information from one of their sources in Mordentshire that a member of the Kargat has uncharacteristically tipped his hand and is about to make his move. Seeing how 43 has only been successful in exposing and eliminating six of seven Kargat members in a decade (their primary objective is to expose and eliminate members of the Kargat, yet their successes are largely with destroying/disrupting the Kargatane), this information needs to be acted upon post-haste. The current commanding officer, a PC named Urich (who had inadvertently taken command eight years ago after a violent confrontation with the old CO, who was mindblanked by a senior Kargat agent behind the scenes), has been given orders by his superiors at the Ministry of Intelligence to take along the newest member of 43, Ephraim. The other members of the group, three PCs, are grumbling with this new addition (cliquish/distrusting bunch, but reasonably so given their profession), but have no choice but to obey. They have yet to be introduced to Ephraim.
This is where I'd like some input.
Urich has become a family man in the past few campaign years and is starting to mellow some, as the others have noticed but kept their thoughts to themselves. Thus far. He's still good at what he does (he's pretty much the core of 43), but he's been roleplayed to appear...distracted. He's been talking to his wife's lock of hair, and his kid's miniature carved soldier. He mumbles about home, about retiring, that sort of thing. He's been played to be on the brink of a midlife crisis. And for a while I've been wanting to play that out and throw 43 a nice curve ball.
Intro Ephraim.
My idea is this: Ephraim is not real. He's a personality break from Urich. The shadow aspect. The gung-ho old soldier in him. I want to roleplay him as a completely new character (I have always played a rotating fifth member of 43), but I need to tred lightly and not reveal Urich's madness to the others too soon. I was thinking Fight Club, but as I said, I need to trick the players at least enough to cause some group "alpha friction", if you know what I mean.
My question to the community is this: What are some of the ways that I can roleplay a non-existent character?
Roleplaying Ephraim and Urich will be easy. But the others...? I can only play the "Urich's effin' with us, ha ha" angle a few times. After that, I really got nothing at this moment.
If anybody needs more details or what not, then I'll provide them. And thanks in advance. Cheers.
Campaign help; roleplaying non-existent characters
Campaign help; roleplaying non-existent characters
"A very piteous thing it was to see such a quantity of dead bodies, and such an outpouring of blood - that is, if they had not been enemies of the Christian faith."
- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
- A G Thing
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1216
- Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
- Gender: Female
- Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan
Re: Campaign help; roleplaying non-existent characters
What level and class is Urich? Does he know anything about what is going on as well or is it just like fight club? Did something traumatic cause this split in him and if so what? Is Urich's family actually still alive and well?
Is the Falkovnia they are working for different in any way that could become important? Is the world different in some way that is important? Is their job in the military intelligence one they could live beyond or not?
Is there some specific role Ephraim has to play in the plot or even party make up that would necessitate some specific action or ability or such? Does Ephraim have any ideas on how he plans to progress? Does Ephraim know what is going on like Tyler did? Does Ephraim even like Urich or at least care about him?
Since you are more worried about how the other characters are going to react then what are the details of those other characters? Personalities? Classes? Gender? Is there some friction in the group we should be aware of? Do any of them have plans or goals that are openly known? Any have plans they think are secret? Does Urich know of these plans?
Finally how long has the group been together and what are some noteworthy accomplishments in their past? Have they saved each others lives? Have they had to separate or deceive each other to succeed at a mission? Do they share any dark secrets that could destroy each other or the group which Urich would know of?
If you answer at least a few of these I think at least I could maybe help you more!
Is the Falkovnia they are working for different in any way that could become important? Is the world different in some way that is important? Is their job in the military intelligence one they could live beyond or not?
Is there some specific role Ephraim has to play in the plot or even party make up that would necessitate some specific action or ability or such? Does Ephraim have any ideas on how he plans to progress? Does Ephraim know what is going on like Tyler did? Does Ephraim even like Urich or at least care about him?
Since you are more worried about how the other characters are going to react then what are the details of those other characters? Personalities? Classes? Gender? Is there some friction in the group we should be aware of? Do any of them have plans or goals that are openly known? Any have plans they think are secret? Does Urich know of these plans?
Finally how long has the group been together and what are some noteworthy accomplishments in their past? Have they saved each others lives? Have they had to separate or deceive each other to succeed at a mission? Do they share any dark secrets that could destroy each other or the group which Urich would know of?
If you answer at least a few of these I think at least I could maybe help you more!
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Campaign help; roleplaying non-existent characters
This is a really creative and ambitious idea, I love it. But I gotta be honest, I have no clue how you'd work it. 
The thing is, in Fight Club, and other stories like this, likenobody meets both identities without immediately figuring it out. Remember that in Fight Club (I guess we're just assuming everyone's seen it.
) Tyler's minions knew him as Tyler, even though they only saw the Ed Norton version. The only person to see the Brad Pitt version was "Tyler/The Narrator" himself.
You can have Ephraim do stuff offscreen and Urich report it to the PCs. But you just can't have Urich introduce Ephraim to the PCs and keep up the illusion.
Now, this is D&D, and unlike Fight Club-world, you have access to magic. You could give him a hat of disguise, or a power granted by the Dark Powers to change his face, and never have the two in the same place at the same time.... that might work.
The thing is, in Fight Club, and other stories like this, like
VIEW CONTENT:
You can have Ephraim do stuff offscreen and Urich report it to the PCs. But you just can't have Urich introduce Ephraim to the PCs and keep up the illusion.
Now, this is D&D, and unlike Fight Club-world, you have access to magic. You could give him a hat of disguise, or a power granted by the Dark Powers to change his face, and never have the two in the same place at the same time.... that might work.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
Re: Campaign help; roleplaying non-existent characters
This may not work depending on other factors, but you could try setting Ephraim up as a double-agent supplying them with information on whatever group they are going up against. That way, he has an excuse to not compromise his identity. First, Urich gives them information he's received from Ephrayim's movements, then eventually sends them on a mission with Ephraim himself. He wears a mask so that if any of them are captured, they cannot be coerced or tortured into giving away his hidden role to the enemy. But perhaps his voice, accent, or mannerisms are distinctive in some way.
Later on, the party might encounter a group of the enemy Ephraim has infiltrated...and be shocked to find Urich among them. Then even more shocked when his voice and body language identify him as Ephraim.
Later on, the party might encounter a group of the enemy Ephraim has infiltrated...and be shocked to find Urich among them. Then even more shocked when his voice and body language identify him as Ephraim.
Deranged Comics Fan
Strife-monger
Daughter of a Troll
Strife-monger
Daughter of a Troll
Re: Campaign help; roleplaying non-existent characters
Lots of questions. Ok, cool. Let me knock 'em off now.
The world? The Grim Harvest never happened, and won't happen. At least, not in the near future. I might isolate and downscale later, but for now it's an alternate Ravenloft as far as I'm concerned.
Magic is NPC/plot-based. Esoteric. Divine magic is PC-friendly, and is based around what I call "blessings". Blessed food and water act as healing magic. Regular food and water, natural medicines and the like provide small hit point recovery outside of the standard Healing nwp and sleep.
Skills-heavy. No nonweapon proficiency groups. Do the time, gain the proficiency. In fact, if I had my time back I would've revamped the whole system to include attempts=incremental proficiency. Practise makes perfect. Abandon the whole proficiencies per level thing, to better encourage non-combat roleplaying. Or I could just reverse-engineer the 3E skill ranks concept. Meh. I'm well past the time for tinkering for this campaign. Maybe some other time. Anyway:
No demihumans (thus encountered). Elves are like sasquatch, dwarves and halflings are human, caliban the rest. A trip to Sithicus is on the radar however, so elves will be a nice savage change of pace. Well, their arrows anyway. Heh.
Not sure what other changes are relevant...
Their jobs can be a bridge burned, but that would lead to a life on the road. They know too much (a couple pieces of the Falkovnian jigsaw) to just retire or be allowed walk away. They suspect as much, but they're not entirely convinced. It's one of those smirk moments for me actually. What they've talked about is true, but they've also managed to talk themselves out of the truth. So continues the dance.
Classes? Dual Fighter 3/Thief 10, Thief 12, Cleric 14.
As with Urich, these characters are standard no frills 2E classes that have evolved beyond rulebook description. In short, the text doesn't capture what the characters actually are. They're just baselines. Know what I mean? We were going to kit them all up, but we said muck it, let's just go simple and elaborate from there. We might not have said those words back then, but that's the gist of it.
No real friction or secrets between the group besides standard brothers in arm/teammate/buddy/friend kinda things. And believe me, if there was, I'd angle it. Nah, close-knit group. A nice development actually. And one that I'm trying to fragment (see purpose of this thread). Heh.
Lives saved numerous times. Dark secrets, none really (though the priest has received "favours" from several barmaids cough*whores!* under his moral table, I'd hardly call that a Ravenloft/Dark Powers dark secret). Several missions involved me breaking down the campaign into one-on-one story/mission isolation sessions. They're a specialist group made up of specialists. Missions dictate group patterns.
Hopefully that answers all(?) of your questions!
Dual Thief 4/Fighter 9.A G Thing wrote:What level and class is Urich?
He doesn't know any of my plans yet. The trauma was ultimately player induced; I jumped on it and am currently in development. His family is alive and well...as far as Urich knows. He also knows that 43 has made many enemies of the years, both enemies of the state and personal. One of the Kargat senior agents has managed to remained faceless despite the PCs' attempts at exposure for elimination and has taken on the role of group nemesis. They continue to mastermind and manipulate certain aspects of my campaign and their careers. Urich and the rest of the group would check in more frequently on their families if it weren't for this particular agent, but leaving a trail for them to find and follow is not an option. it's paranoia for protection, as far as the players are concerned. NPC "friendships" have already been targeted and disposed of because of this Kargat Moriarty.Does he know anything about what is going on as well or is it just like fight club? Did something traumatic cause this split in him and if so what? Is Urich's family actually still alive and well?
My version of Falkovnia may not be by the text, but it's not a whole lot different either. It has achieved more during the Dead Man's Campaign than written, but the end result remains the same. The Falkovnian army almost reached Il Aluk. Towns along the way switched flags; people ran, people rejoiced, people shrugged. Soldiers aren't ALL evil; there are many pragmatists enlisted and some are just simply patriotic. The depravations and cruelty as written are largely reserved for an inner circle of officers in my version.Is the Falkovnia they are working for different in any way that could become important? Is the world different in some way that is important? Is their job in the military intelligence one they could live beyond or not?
The world? The Grim Harvest never happened, and won't happen. At least, not in the near future. I might isolate and downscale later, but for now it's an alternate Ravenloft as far as I'm concerned.
Magic is NPC/plot-based. Esoteric. Divine magic is PC-friendly, and is based around what I call "blessings". Blessed food and water act as healing magic. Regular food and water, natural medicines and the like provide small hit point recovery outside of the standard Healing nwp and sleep.
Skills-heavy. No nonweapon proficiency groups. Do the time, gain the proficiency. In fact, if I had my time back I would've revamped the whole system to include attempts=incremental proficiency. Practise makes perfect. Abandon the whole proficiencies per level thing, to better encourage non-combat roleplaying. Or I could just reverse-engineer the 3E skill ranks concept. Meh. I'm well past the time for tinkering for this campaign. Maybe some other time. Anyway:
No demihumans (thus encountered). Elves are like sasquatch, dwarves and halflings are human, caliban the rest. A trip to Sithicus is on the radar however, so elves will be a nice savage change of pace. Well, their arrows anyway. Heh.
Not sure what other changes are relevant...
Their jobs can be a bridge burned, but that would lead to a life on the road. They know too much (a couple pieces of the Falkovnian jigsaw) to just retire or be allowed walk away. They suspect as much, but they're not entirely convinced. It's one of those smirk moments for me actually. What they've talked about is true, but they've also managed to talk themselves out of the truth. So continues the dance.
Ephraim and Urich haven't met yet. As to the specifics of Ephraim, I was asking for your help so he's not fully sketched yet. He's not key to the campaign, but he will be a big part of Urich's character history and hopefully a decent chapter in 43's biography.Is there some specific role Ephraim has to play in the plot or even party make up that would necessitate some specific action or ability or such? Does Ephraim have any ideas on how he plans to progress? Does Ephraim know what is going on like Tyler did? Does Ephraim even like Urich or at least care about him?
It's not that I'm more worried about how the other characters are going to act, it's more the line of: I'm building this for the group entertainment, and I'd like to be able to brainf them for a bit. A solid "look back" moment for the players.Since you are more worried about how the other characters are going to react then what are the details of those other characters? Personalities? Classes? Gender? Is there some friction in the group we should be aware of? Do any of them have plans or goals that are openly known? Any have plans they think are secret? Does Urich know of these plans?
Classes? Dual Fighter 3/Thief 10, Thief 12, Cleric 14.
As with Urich, these characters are standard no frills 2E classes that have evolved beyond rulebook description. In short, the text doesn't capture what the characters actually are. They're just baselines. Know what I mean? We were going to kit them all up, but we said muck it, let's just go simple and elaborate from there. We might not have said those words back then, but that's the gist of it.
No real friction or secrets between the group besides standard brothers in arm/teammate/buddy/friend kinda things. And believe me, if there was, I'd angle it. Nah, close-knit group. A nice development actually. And one that I'm trying to fragment (see purpose of this thread). Heh.
Character group has been together officially for 15 years, Unit 43 for 10. But three of the PCs grew up together, all being sons of another close-knit group of Dead Man's Campaign vets (which also happened to be roleplayed in our first mini-campaign). The cleric (we call him "priest" IG) being the outsider-insider.Finally how long has the group been together and what are some noteworthy accomplishments in their past? Have they saved each others lives? Have they had to separate or deceive each other to succeed at a mission? Do they share any dark secrets that could destroy each other or the group which Urich would know of?
Lives saved numerous times. Dark secrets, none really (though the priest has received "favours" from several barmaids cough*whores!* under his moral table, I'd hardly call that a Ravenloft/Dark Powers dark secret). Several missions involved me breaking down the campaign into one-on-one story/mission isolation sessions. They're a specialist group made up of specialists. Missions dictate group patterns.
Hopefully that answers all(?) of your questions!
"A very piteous thing it was to see such a quantity of dead bodies, and such an outpouring of blood - that is, if they had not been enemies of the Christian faith."
- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
Re: Campaign help; roleplaying non-existent characters
Well, I think you hinted at it. Ephraim has to maintain a secret identity. Therefore, only one person from the team is allowed to meet with him. The players will typically start to mistrust someone who they are not allowed to meet. They may try to spy on the meetings. Then you have your well-oiled team start working against each other.
If they start to suspect Ephraim is a Kargat agent, even better. It could make them think that Urich is being influenced. You should spend a little time with Urich's player alone each session. Let the other players stew and plot amongst themselves for a while. You could also pass Urich notes from time to time. They don't have to be anything meaningful. But the fact that the rest of the team is being left out will help the secrecy.
Be as subtle as you need to be for your timeline. If you want this to be a one night story, be like a brick through stained glass. If you want it to last for a long time, take it slow and easy.
When your players start to suspect Ephraim, you know things are well on their way. Then you can start dropping rumors about things that Ephraim has done on his own. Just be sure to make these things happen when Urich is away from the group. Sleeping works quite well so long as the group doesn't have a chance to see him leave. Don't let them see Urich sneaking out at night until the paranoia is already running full steam.
Of course, Ravenloft is a world of magic. Tyler didn't actually exist. But in a magical world, it's possible that a personality break could result in an actual second character as real as the original. This leads towards doppelganger though.
If they start to suspect Ephraim is a Kargat agent, even better. It could make them think that Urich is being influenced. You should spend a little time with Urich's player alone each session. Let the other players stew and plot amongst themselves for a while. You could also pass Urich notes from time to time. They don't have to be anything meaningful. But the fact that the rest of the team is being left out will help the secrecy.
Be as subtle as you need to be for your timeline. If you want this to be a one night story, be like a brick through stained glass. If you want it to last for a long time, take it slow and easy.
When your players start to suspect Ephraim, you know things are well on their way. Then you can start dropping rumors about things that Ephraim has done on his own. Just be sure to make these things happen when Urich is away from the group. Sleeping works quite well so long as the group doesn't have a chance to see him leave. Don't let them see Urich sneaking out at night until the paranoia is already running full steam.
Of course, Ravenloft is a world of magic. Tyler didn't actually exist. But in a magical world, it's possible that a personality break could result in an actual second character as real as the original. This leads towards doppelganger though.
Re: Campaign help; roleplaying non-existent characters
BTW, I love the ideas you have about gaining proficiencies in 2nd Edition. I wish I would have thought of that when I was still playing those rules.
Re: Campaign help; roleplaying non-existent characters
Yeah, the concept is solid but in RPG tableform it's hard to implement. No visual tricks to back the psychosis.Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:The thing is, in Fight Club, and other stories like this, likenobody meets both identities without immediately figuring it out. Remember that in Fight Club (I guess we're just assuming everyone's seen it.VIEW CONTENT:) Tyler's minions knew him as Tyler, even though they only saw the Ed Norton version. The only person to see the Brad Pitt version was "Tyler/The Narrator" himself.
But instead of abandoning the idea, I figured I'd tap the collective here for solution(s). Lots of wonderfully warped heads here, from what I've read.
I think that's my main angle, to be honest. Complemented with Hazgarn's suggestions:You can have Ephraim do stuff offscreen and Urich report it to the PCs. But you just can't have Urich introduce Ephraim to the PCs and keep up the illusion.
Hazgarn wrote: you could try setting Ephraim up as a double-agent supplying them with information on whatever group they are going up against. That way, he has an excuse to not compromise his identity. First, Urich gives them information he's received from Ephrayim's movements, then eventually sends them on a mission with Ephraim himself. He wears a mask so that if any of them are captured, they cannot be coerced or tortured into giving away his hidden role to the enemy. But perhaps his voice, accent, or mannerisms are distinctive in some way.
Later on, the party might encounter a group of the enemy Ephraim has infiltrated...and be shocked to find Urich among them. Then even more shocked when his voice and body language identify him as Ephraim.
"A very piteous thing it was to see such a quantity of dead bodies, and such an outpouring of blood - that is, if they had not been enemies of the Christian faith."
- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
Re: Campaign help; roleplaying non-existent characters
Where to start?Trike wrote:Well, I think you hinted at it. Ephraim has to maintain a secret identity. Therefore, only one person from the team is allowed to meet with him. The players will typically start to mistrust someone who they are not allowed to meet. They may try to spy on the meetings. Then you have your well-oiled team start working against each other.
If they start to suspect Ephraim is a Kargat agent, even better. It could make them think that Urich is being influenced. You should spend a little time with Urich's player alone each session. Let the other players stew and plot amongst themselves for a while. You could also pass Urich notes from time to time. They don't have to be anything meaningful. But the fact that the rest of the team is being left out will help the secrecy.
Be as subtle as you need to be for your timeline. If you want this to be a one night story, be like a brick through stained glass. If you want it to last for a long time, take it slow and easy.
When your players start to suspect Ephraim, you know things are well on their way. Then you can start dropping rumors about things that Ephraim has done on his own. Just be sure to make these things happen when Urich is away from the group. Sleeping works quite well so long as the group doesn't have a chance to see him leave. Don't let them see Urich sneaking out at night until the paranoia is already running full steam.
Of course, Ravenloft is a world of magic. Tyler didn't actually exist. But in a magical world, it's possible that a personality break could result in an actual second character as real as the original. This leads towards doppelganger though.
That last bit has been floating around in my head, to be perfectly honest. I wouldn't mind finding a way to have that split become real, and at the same time become a Kargat manipulation. The shadow aspect would be an awesome counter to the brains/poster boy of Unit 43. And if "Spectre" (the jive moniker of that senior Kargat I mentioned earlier) was involved, then even better. Spectre was due for another move anyway, so, bonus.
I don't want a doppelganger, but a dark double. No established D&D monster restrictions. Something fresh, something...barbed.
In the meantime, this experiment of Spectre would be multi-layered. 43's leader gets battered on a psyche level, distrust and doubt gets sown amongst the unit, internal jockeying for position results (not to mention the emotional drain of seeing a childhood friend have such a breakdown), and a champion of darkness is born. Even if Urich recovers and the group dynamic is hanging in shreds, they would still have to face something that would be nearly impossible to outmaneuver: themselves.
From a PC perspective, they need to weather the storm, unburden the emotional toll on their leader (thus establishing the difference in their dynamic that would be crucial in overcoming the shadow Urich), and turning Spectre's plot on its arse. Instead of tearing the unit apart, overcoming this hurdle would reinforce their resolve in taking the war back to the Kargat, Spectre, and maybe even Azalin himself.
Drakov would be secretly smiling if he ever found out that his enemies have created (and handed to him) such patriotic propaganda...I mean, "heroic nationalists".
Azalin would be pissed if he finds out a senior member of his elite walked so foolishly in to such a position.
Heh.
All I really have to do is retrofit Spectre's plans/plot...
Anyway, that's that. I think. Not closing the thread, just sayin'. Thanks for the responses regardless. I appreciate them.
Any other suggestions on how I (or anybody else in a similar position) could roleplay a non-existent character?
"A very piteous thing it was to see such a quantity of dead bodies, and such an outpouring of blood - that is, if they had not been enemies of the Christian faith."
- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
