Weapon Question
Weapon Question
In Ravenloft are there rules for weapons that gain experience? I am not sure what you call that. If so what are the rules for that? Thanks in advance.
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Weapon Question
The closest thing I can think of to that is:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weapons_of_Legacy
Which isn't Ravenloft-Specific, but could be used there.
There's also a similar concept in Van Richten's Arsenal, the weapon quality "Protection" which gives an additional bonus when the weapon is used to protect the group that the item is attuned to. I used this in my campaign to have a weapon "level up" when used by a Knight of the Shadows, since I knew one PC was headed to that PrC. When he got there, the weapon suddenly improved.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weapons_of_Legacy
Which isn't Ravenloft-Specific, but could be used there.
There's also a similar concept in Van Richten's Arsenal, the weapon quality "Protection" which gives an additional bonus when the weapon is used to protect the group that the item is attuned to. I used this in my campaign to have a weapon "level up" when used by a Knight of the Shadows, since I knew one PC was headed to that PrC. When he got there, the weapon suddenly improved.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
Re: Weapon Question
Dion published an excellent Ravenloft add-on for Weapon's of Legacy: Shadow and Steel: Weapons of Legacy in Ravenloft. I think you do still need WoL, to understand the rules. Oh and note that most D20 players recommend omitting the harsh costs of legacy weapons.
The rules for Relic weapons from Complete Divine are a bit similar.
A simpler way is to have nice complex intelligent weapons and let players only slowly discover all the abilities...
The rules for Relic weapons from Complete Divine are a bit similar.
A simpler way is to have nice complex intelligent weapons and let players only slowly discover all the abilities...
Re: Weapon Question
I used to own Weapons of Legacy, but it was one of the first supplements I ebayed. I'd suggest if you do take a look at those rules, you give them some long hard thought before deciding whether to incorporate them into your setting. Personally, I liked the effects of boosting weapon powers, but the level and feat requirements were way too expensive to make it worthwhile.
I would count "bonding with your weapon" to be something that's best taken care of through role-play and prior agreement between the DM and player. The weapon is a separate NPC to the PC, effectively, and I'm not convinced that spending feats and meeting level/attribute requirements is the way to go. I had the exact same protest against 3rd ed's Cityscape supplement, which required PCs to buy contacts, allies, etc. with feats, when those things are best handled through role playing.
I can understand the idea of spending something to buy increased familiarity with a weapon - that's what skill points are for. But the WoL rules required investments of feats and arbitrary "you must be this level to get this power" types of rules, and those didn't sit well with me at all. Feats come along very rarely, and the calculation cost of working out feats, skills, attributes, and levels to meet some arbitrary set of prerequisites was probably the least enjoyable part of the entire game system for me.
The fact that supplements came out with little mutual system support for each other didn't help either.
Your mileage may vary, but I'd just say if you want to play a specific "Weapon Bond" type of hero, just talk it over between player and DM and work out what sorts of effects you'd like. Be open to the DM's interpretation of balance, and have fun with it. The WoL rules were patchy and not well balanced at all.
I would count "bonding with your weapon" to be something that's best taken care of through role-play and prior agreement between the DM and player. The weapon is a separate NPC to the PC, effectively, and I'm not convinced that spending feats and meeting level/attribute requirements is the way to go. I had the exact same protest against 3rd ed's Cityscape supplement, which required PCs to buy contacts, allies, etc. with feats, when those things are best handled through role playing.
I can understand the idea of spending something to buy increased familiarity with a weapon - that's what skill points are for. But the WoL rules required investments of feats and arbitrary "you must be this level to get this power" types of rules, and those didn't sit well with me at all. Feats come along very rarely, and the calculation cost of working out feats, skills, attributes, and levels to meet some arbitrary set of prerequisites was probably the least enjoyable part of the entire game system for me.
The fact that supplements came out with little mutual system support for each other didn't help either.
Your mileage may vary, but I'd just say if you want to play a specific "Weapon Bond" type of hero, just talk it over between player and DM and work out what sorts of effects you'd like. Be open to the DM's interpretation of balance, and have fun with it. The WoL rules were patchy and not well balanced at all.
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
Re: Weapon Question
As I said most DMs just ignore the WoL feat, skill or even hp requirements completely and just use the rituals. I hear it's still not unbalanced. Withou doubt the weapons are very flavorful so definately take a look at Dion's netbook.

