Asymmetric warfare - what to do when you're the weaker side

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

A late post about guard towers (pillbox turrets, treetop archers, what have you).

In situations where you have a small number of combatants, but each able to do considerable ranged damage, it may be useful to work in a circular formation instead of the usual line defense. Thus, if any one element gets attacked, even if by surprise, the rest can all refocus on the new direction of attack quickly. You have no flanks if you're a circle!

Position your people so that they are roughly circular, and each position can see at least two others in its field of view without too much rotation. This way each of your defensive elements can cover the other, and help focus firepower on incoming threats. Once you have the ranges of your attacks worked out, and you've deduced your fixed positions, then start camouflaging them or otherwise strengthening them. A low-tech example would be archers in treetops. A high-tech example would be fixed bunker towers or gun turrets. If you do the camouflaging really skilfully, the enemy may actually stumble into your territory past the perimeter, allowing 360º coverage by your people!

Whichever side the enemy attacks from, your people can bring almost their entire firepower to bear (geometry allowing), making surprise very difficult and ensuring a hard fight.
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Asymmetric warfare - what to do when you're the weaker s

Post by HuManBing »

A U.S. naval simulation in 2002 put a former U.S. Marine Corps officer, Lt. Gen. Van Riper, in charge of hypothetical hostile force Team Red. Van Riper was able to cobble together a cheap, mobile, and devastating naval force that inflicted huge losses on the cutting-edge high tech U.S. Navy.

Team Red knew that Blue (the U.S. joint attack force) would launch preemptive strikes on Red's communication networks, taking out their cell phones and computer network. Red therefore had ready a fleet of motorcycle messengers and semaphore flag signallers ready to put in a low-tech solution. Messages could still be relayed effectively to ground troops and even to get their air force into the air, despite the worst technological damage that Blue could inflict.

Team Red also knew that Blue's primary force was coming by sea. In order to force Blue to adhere to that, and to remove any land threat to Red's borders, Van Riper ordered the assassination of all Blue-sympathetic regional allies, throwing the land allies into confusion. That meant Blue was acting alone in the hostilities and would not be able to land boots on any friendly soil in the region.

Blue gave Van Riper a 24-hour ultimatum to stand down or be deposed by force - and in doing so, Blue accidentally tipped their hand. Red now knew that Blue's navy must be nearby, within one day's striking distance, so Red deduced its position by using small boats with visual confirmation, rather than high-tech surveillance. Red then launched a massive assault of cruise missiles against the fleet, overwhelming its automated defenses with sheer numbers. He followed up with suicide attacks and rocket attacks from speedboats, which were radar-invisible and hard for the technologically superior US fleet to counteract effectively. By the time the hypothetical naval exercise was over, 16 US naval vessels were destroyed, including an aircraft carrier, 10 cruisers, and five amphibious ships. If this had been a real conflict, over 20,000 US armed forces personnel would have died.

New York Times link. Wikipedia article.

The exercise was such a resounding disaster that they hit the reset button and then forced Red to turn on all of his anti-aircraft radar so they could be destroyed by Blue, and then forced him to adhere to a pre-planned script to allow Blue to predict everything he would do. They then declared the exercise a success and granted Blue the victory.

Honestly, the exercise is probably more valuable for what it teaches the low-tech side to do rather than the high-tech side.
Post Reply