Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: I do believe in pure good in Ravenloft, but perhaps it's my upbringing speaking when I say I think that good in Ravenloft is "less good" when its inspired by pure goodness from the Heavens. Ravenloft's remote connection to the Divine is a sort of crucible where good can be put to the test without knowing for certain that there's a reward waiting. One can have faith that there is a reward, and believe it completely, but never know with proof, because there aren't Deities walking the earth, Angelic hosts inspiring humans, free planar travel to Heaven, etc... If there's a pure angel walking around with all the answers, that does have the potential to turn good into boring, IMHO.
I don’t think we disagree on this at all. As I see it, Ravenloft operates on two completely different levels: the Dark Powers-eye-view, where good and evil are clear, absolute and immiscible, and the PCs-eye-view, where things are much, much murkier. And you’re completely right when you say there’s no real place for a pure angel to be walking around with all the answers—at the PC level. This is what I was getting at when I was talking about the subtlety required of outsiders.
Take the Exorcist, for example. Let’s assume that because there’s a demon in there, there’s an angel in there too for reasons of balance. And this angel is pure and flawlessly good. Now, I don’t remember a 7 foot tall glowing creature with wings and fiery sword in the Exorcist, and I feel the presence of such a figure might undermine the story the Exorcist was trying to tell.
I do, however, remember Lt Kinderman. Kindly. Brings information to Chris that helps her face the truth that (a) Regan is actually possessed and (b) guilty of desecration and murder. He also helps Karras face truths (a) and (b), encourages him, and generally acts as a facilitator to help Regan and Chris and get the demon out. All in what, 2 or 3 scenes?
This is the way I see angels as being able to operate in Ravenloft: by providing a little word of advice here, a helpful piece of equipment there, a bit of encouragement over there. All from the guise of normal, everyday people. If you were the Dark Powers (which, as a GM, you are), you’d see they were a blazing presence manipulating events quietly for good, but to the people of the world, they’re indistinguishable from normal (good) people. It’s similar to the Vistani, except the Vistani are neutral and the angels are good. Similar to what Alhoon said, there aren’t angels for the PCs to turn to to ask for help; they’re there, but they’re hidden, and they’re helping ways other than “Thou shalt now attack Strahd’s castle, and remember not to drink the red wine.”
As in game evidence that this is how it works, look at Carnival: it explicitly tell us that Isolde’s superiors warned her that she must stay in a human body, and all of her really overt powers (like turning into a ball of light) are blocked (or perhaps, forbidden except in times of great duress). For that matter, look at VRGtFiends: even though you’d expect fiends to squirm around rules whenever they can, the only fiend that doesn’t habitually disguise its true nature behind a human shell is Drigor (who can’t, but still hides himself away from the eyes of mortals) and the Whistling Fiend (who still assumes human form sometimes, and as a tanar’ri, you’d expect it to be the most likely to break the rules). You’ll also notice there are long periods when we don’t know what the fiends are up to; presumably they’re trying to steer those around them to evil with a hint here and a bribe there, which is why we don’t see them.
Also, I would imagine that angels want people to choose to do good of their own free will. There’s a long storytelling history of outsiders not being able to force mortals to good or evil; they have to choose it freely. In which case, perhaps all they can do is make suggestions and hint, rather than being overt?
As for the Abominations, I’m not sure that we know enough about what’s going on inside them to really judge whether it’s a good act or not. On one hand, we know that Isolde approves of the Twisting, cannot control the changes and that it makes a creature’s inner nature become manifest physically. A lot of them seem designed to teach someone a lesson (the Gargantuan and the Living Skeleton are clear examples, where the effects of the Twisting will lessen if Morla becomes her own person and Rasulid becomes a better one). We also know that the Troupers have enacted the Death of a Thousand Knives, which they *believe* to be merciful compared to Isolde’s punishment for murder. Which she has only done 6 times in 10 years, and at least one (and potentially more) of those was a servant of the Gentleman Caller. We also know that the intelligence of the Abominations is vastly reduced (2-4) so they’re little more than animals. We only have Pacali’s word for it that they’re suffering, and he actually quite clearly says he doesn’t know.
What if the 6 Abominations were all servants of the Gentleman Caller (they’re all CE after all), and their form just represents the spiritual corruption of allying with a demon? What if reducing their intelligence is her mercy, so they suffer less in their new forms? It’s only a cruel and unusual punishment if they’re suffering. What if Pacali’s right but his interpretation is wrong: they have some sense of what they used to be and what they did to deserve their current form, but they also know the hope of redemption, and that with enough time and work (thinking good thoughts, essentially), they can return to normal? That’s why Isolde won’t allow them to be killed – because she wants them to have the chance to redeem themselves.
My point here is that whether the Abominations’ existence is a smut on Isolde’s soul or not depends very much on what’s going on inside her head and the heads of the Abominations, and we have almost no access to either. I think it’s an open question.
Of course, even if she’s a fallen angel, she’s still a CG angel. Fallen, but not fallen too far.
Your argument about killing baby Vecna needs to be teased apart, because it’s unanswerable without explicating whether Ravenloft is deterministic or not (that is, how powerful Fate is compared to free will). If free will exists, you can’t say that this baby will grow up to be Vecna; you can only say this baby has a strong chance of doing so. In that case, the baby is still an Innocent at this stage, and if I were the angel I’d ensure it went to some very loving and supportive parents and had a proper education in responsibility and ethics. If his fate is set in stone, then I see it as more like putting down a rabid dog. A rabid dog has no responsibility for what it is, but it has no ability to be anything other than what it is, which is a lethal danger to almost all mammal life in that area. Likewise, if baby Vecna has no chance of ever not being a crazy undead wizard god who will cause untold suffering across *all* the planes of existence, then I think you’re probably justified in putting him down. That baby cannot be said to be Innocent. I think it’d probably be a bit upsetting for the angel, though.
Having said that, I think the first example is the one that actually represents the way Ravenloft works.
Your other example (of catching 2 people who are falling, and it only has time to save one): being physically unable to save someone is not an evil act. It’s not even a neutral act. There may be times when trying to save both and failing is the best (most good) way; there may be others when you just have to accept you can only save one, and do it (again, probably a bit upsetting). In some cases, letting the good person die and saving the neutral might be the best thing to do, because (at a spiritual level), the good person has already been “saved” but this gives the neutral the chance to make their life right. So while I’m not qualified to say which is right, an angel (even one incapable of doing wrong like Alhoon is suggesting) is, and would do it.
As a fallible human, you can write it into your game because you completely control the consequences of actions in the world. In essence, moral quandaries become a lot easier if you are actually the god of that world. If the angel cannot do otherwise than choose the best path, whichever path you choose for it is the best path. Of course, as I said before, that is not always clear to people in the world, including the PCs, so it’s still quite simple to have moral debates, murkiness and good angel antagonists.
On AG Thing’s point:
I don’t think they’re automatons. I do think you can be pure good and still have free will. In essence, it’s not that you can’t choose option B, it’s that it would never occur to you to do so. It’s just not in your makeup. Yes, of course you could just stand there and watch the orphanage burn, but
who would do that? Then, angels can fall because they become aware of option B and take it instead.
However, my main point is that (going right back to the point of this thread), transposition is not necessarily vile, and that not only is it in theme to have pure good angels in gothic horror, you can do everything with them that you could do with a fallen angel (because humans don’t have the same kind of foresight angels do, and may end up with the wrong end of the stick), and that fallen angels everywhere are an overused and lazy device which guts the power and importance of the struggle of good and evil by making good look weak and hypocritical.
Seriously: think about how many fallen angels there are in D&D: Asmodeus, *all* erinyes, Baalzebul/Triel, Trias the Betrayer, Zalatian XXIII, etc etc. Now think of all the fallen fiends: Falls from Grace and Eludecia (both succubi), and possibly A’kin the Friendly Fiend (although that might be a bluff).
As regards LG vs CG: I think if you’re going to take the D&D alignment system seriously, you need to treat LG and CG as separate things, rather than different interpretations of the same thing. That is, an archon is not Good, and Lawful: it is lawfulgood, and the lawfulness informs but doesn’t adulterate the goodness.
Specifically, an archon believes that the best, if not the only, way to goodness is through order and community (and, you will note, this says nothing about the word of the local law). What is good for one is good for all. Individuals are viewed within the context of society, and an orderly, good society will create and nurture good in all of its members, starting from the youngest. An unjust law is no law at all.
An eladrin/azata believes that freedom, the rights of the individual, and respecting others’ choices are the way to goodness. They prefer to take life as it comes, rather than planning everything. This is not to say they don’t occasionally agree with tradition or law – any rule should be questioned, but questioning is not the same as overthrowing, and sometimes the authority is perfectly reasonable. Freedom entails dealing with the consequences of your actions. Ideally, a free people will still choose to do good, out of mutual respect – do unto others, etc.
Lawful good is not “more good” than chaotic good; it’s a different type. I can’t accept that CG celestials are more likely to fall than LG ones (in fact, the opposite seems to be true).
The reason mortals can act inconsistently with their alignments is that they’re not exemplars – they’re not pure LG in the way an archon is/might be/should be. If you (Trike) see it as a failure, I think you might be misunderstanding or overinterpreting the system.
And finally,
Deewun wrote: Ravenloft is founded in gothic and evolved to pull its references/building blocks from elsewhere in horror. There is a lot to mine with Angels/the Host/law v. good. And I think discounting it is the surest way to miss out on GREAT ideas being added to Ravenloft as a whole, which keeps the setting growing in new and interesting ways.
I get that, and agree. I just think we’re ignoring non-grimdark opportunities.
Also, sorry to nitpick, but Pharazia is the second cousin of Vathek (one of the most famous gothic novels, which is also set in “Arabia”), Vechor is not based on a Midsummer Night’s Dream, and Timor is based on Stephen King’s IT, not Alien. But I do take your point about Ravenloft not being all gothic all the time- e.g. The Shadow Rift/Tepest and my bogeymen are based in fairy tale horror. Still, it's more about themes than trappings (e.g. of Europe rather than Persia).