Player Knowledge and Powers Check

Discussing all things Ravenloft
Post Reply
User avatar
Azimer the Mad
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 8
Joined: Mon Jul 23, 2012 10:15 am

Player Knowledge and Powers Check

Post by Azimer the Mad »

I have a player trying to run a kindly old necromancer who only breaks his morals at the promise of eternal life. It's working so far. The problem I now have is that he's obtain the Raiments of Clarity book from Van Richten's Guide to the Walking Dead. He asked me about the skill Reign Undead, which lets him train obediant undead.

He wants to know if putting ranks in the skill would automatically make him fail a Powers Check.

The answer is yes, of course. Spelled out in the text, and I agree with it. But would there be any reason for him to learn in or out of character? Should I as a DM tell him, or stick to "You don;t know"? Could his Knowledge (Ravenloft) help his character?
User avatar
High Priest Mikhal
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1642
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
Gender: Male
Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.

Re: Player Knowledge and Powers Check

Post by High Priest Mikhal »

Azimer the Mad wrote:I have a player trying to run a kindly old necromancer who only breaks his morals at the promise of eternal life. It's working so far. The problem I now have is that he's obtain the Raiments of Clarity book from Van Richten's Guide to the Walking Dead. He asked me about the skill Reign Undead, which lets him train obediant undead.

He wants to know if putting ranks in the skill would automatically make him fail a Powers Check.

The answer is yes, of course. Spelled out in the text, and I agree with it. But would there be any reason for him to learn in or out of character? Should I as a DM tell him, or stick to "You don;t know"? Could his Knowledge (Ravenloft) help his character?
Welcome to one of the most common problems of RPGs. I'd say don't answer since this is as much a learning experience for the player and the character. Sometimes you have to learn things the hard way. Just like in real life. If his character has ranks in Knowledge (the Planes)--which is what Knowledge (Ravenloft) was rolled into in 3.5, albeit as a cross-class skill for all classes--then he could learn that it does require powers checks if he succeeds on the roll (at a high DC since Reign Undead's very existence is an extremely rare fact).
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
User avatar
Jimsolo
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 468
Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2012 10:34 pm

Re: Player Knowledge and Powers Check

Post by Jimsolo »

Personally, I say "no."

Part of the inherent paranoia-inducing nature of Powers Checks is that the players don't know what necessarily triggers them, or how bad they are. When I give out XP receipts for my players, I include a section that tells them how many Powers Checks they made in the previous game, but I don't tell them what they were for. I let them try and decide what moral crimes they committed all on their own.

One of the writers for the 3rd ed Ravenloft series said that the concept of the Powers Check is inherently scary because you're being judged by an unseen force who is holding you accountable according to a set of rules and guidelines that you don't even know. And that can be pretty scary...

If my players ask me "Does this cause a Powers Check?" I always ask them if they think it should and change the subject. I highly recommend keeping the DP Check mechanics a secret.
User avatar
Trike
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 262
Joined: Wed Jul 11, 2012 12:04 am
Location: North Carolina

Re: Player Knowledge and Powers Check

Post by Trike »

I don't remember if this was canon. But I didn't really use the Powers Check as something that the characters were conscious of within the story. For me, it was more of a game mechanic that helped define a descent into darkness. So, in my case, I would not warn the characters exactly when a powers check was coming or whether they had failed.

However, I always felt that the character would have a foreboding feeling that what they were doing was dark. That would be their "warning."

On the other hand, the elderly necromancer risking the descent into darkness because of the fear of dying is a great character for your game. Whether he turns to evil or good in the end, you have a memorable story arc.

I would also have no problem with the character seeking an understanding of raising obedient undead creatures. He would be gaining knowledge that he knew he should never actually use. It's not putting the spell in your spellbook that causes the power check. It's actually casting the spell. Then the temptation is always there. That's a nice touch.
User avatar
High Priest Mikhal
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1642
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
Gender: Male
Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.

Re: Player Knowledge and Powers Check

Post by High Priest Mikhal »

It's canon for characters not to know a thing about powers checks. Even those who fail them. All they should realize is they have some new ability that is balanced out by and equally powerful curse (when said curse comes into play, that is). One who gains low-light vision might find they also suffer light sensitivity in normal light, for example.

The phenomenon of player knowledge coming into play is called meta-gaming and should be discouraged heavily. Nothing ruins the mood more than meta-gaming.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Player Knowledge and Powers Check

Post by HuManBing »

High Priest Mikhal wrote:The phenomenon of player knowledge coming into play is called meta-gaming and should be discouraged heavily. Nothing ruins the mood more than meta-gaming.
I've had experiences going both ways on this. Some gaming groups (including one I run now) the GM purposefully keeps the players in the dark about specific canon issues which their characters not meant to know. This makes it easier for the characters to react realistically and appropriately. If the players prematurely stumble on the truth, I'll acknowledge it and then ask them to role play their characters realistically in ignorance of this realization.

However, I did play one game where the GM specifically revealed a very significant portion of his setting's workings to us ahead of time, and then relied on our maturity and collaboration as knowledgeable players to ensure that the characters had the correct amount of ignorance. This approach does require a great deal of faith in your players' willingness to "play dumb" with their characters and to support roleplaying as a priority above powergaming.

It's your call. You need to know your player well enough to judge whether they would appreciate being "kept in the dark" about the mechanics, or conversely whether they would feel like the GM or game system has misled or entrapped them by staying silent about the specifics of their actions and then enforcing irreversible or profound consequences.

In this specific issue, I'd probably lean towards giving the player a decent amount of information. After all, it deals with the issue of morality, and that is an extremely subjective issue depending on culture, outlook, philosophy, circumstances, etc. Discuss it with the player to figure out what you two can agree on as actual guidelines, and then it's up to the player himself when and if his character decides to cross that line.

If you decide to go the path of "player in the dark" and if the character does fail a powers check, you may want to play it safe and give them an earnest attempt at redemption, or else they may feel that they have lost control over their character's behavior even after specifically asking for (and being denied) clarification.
User avatar
Jimsolo
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 468
Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2012 10:34 pm

Re: Player Knowledge and Powers Check

Post by Jimsolo »

I feel like I should ammend my previous statement. While "Does this act provoke a Power Check?" is a question I would always dodge, I also think that players should be able to piece together clues about certain actions. For instance, in this example, I think it should be fairly obvious through some research that Necromancers are more vulnerable than specialists in any other school to go crazy/develop strange mutations/turn evil, or in general descend into darkness. If the player acquires a reasonable knowledge to realize that Necromancy spells present a greater risk than other spells, or just neglects to do the research at all, then two things are true: you've given them more than enough slack, for one. And for two, they have opted to use that extra slack to hang themselves. As DM, don't feel guilty about kicking the barrel out from under their feet.
User avatar
High Priest Mikhal
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1642
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
Gender: Male
Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.

Re: Player Knowledge and Powers Check

Post by High Priest Mikhal »

HuManBing wrote:
High Priest Mikhal wrote:The phenomenon of player knowledge coming into play is called meta-gaming and should be discouraged heavily. Nothing ruins the mood more than meta-gaming.
I've had experiences going both ways on this. Some gaming groups (including one I run now) the GM purposefully keeps the players in the dark about specific canon issues which their characters not meant to know. This makes it easier for the characters to react realistically and appropriately. If the players prematurely stumble on the truth, I'll acknowledge it and then ask them to role play their characters realistically in ignorance of this realization.

However, I did play one game where the GM specifically revealed a very significant portion of his setting's workings to us ahead of time, and then relied on our maturity and collaboration as knowledgeable players to ensure that the characters had the correct amount of ignorance. This approach does require a great deal of faith in your players' willingness to "play dumb" with their characters and to support roleplaying as a priority above powergaming.

It's your call. You need to know your player well enough to judge whether they would appreciate being "kept in the dark" about the mechanics, or conversely whether they would feel like the GM or game system has misled or entrapped them by staying silent about the specifics of their actions and then enforcing irreversible or profound consequences.

In this specific issue, I'd probably lean towards giving the player a decent amount of information. After all, it deals with the issue of morality, and that is an extremely subjective issue depending on culture, outlook, philosophy, circumstances, etc. Discuss it with the player to figure out what you two can agree on as actual guidelines, and then it's up to the player himself when and if his character decides to cross that line.

If you decide to go the path of "player in the dark" and if the character does fail a powers check, you may want to play it safe and give them an earnest attempt at redemption, or else they may feel that they have lost control over their character's behavior even after specifically asking for (and being denied) clarification.
True, it is a subjective issue. I've had players who knew the rules but didn't act like they knew them in-game, and others who deliberately didn't want to know so they could find out as they went. And of course I've had a few who wanted to know specific mechanical numbers in-game, which is the meta-gaming I'm talking about. If I wanted to have raw numbers thrown in my face I'd play an MMO (where raw numbers is all most care about).
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: Player Knowledge and Powers Check

Post by Zilfer »

My player's only know it vaguely. :D Probably better that way,
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
Post Reply