New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
So I've been kicking around adding a new organization into my game. I call it the Shadow Crooks. (The name stems from their symbol, a black shepherd's crook on a field of red.)
Formed by a group of Outlander adventurers, the Shadow Crooks were formed with the intent of discovering the true nature and purpose of the land of Mists. Tragically, they've come to a few erroneous conclusions. Perhaps even more tragically, they've come to some rather sinister ones as well.
The Shadow Crooks believe that Ravenloft is not the playground, nor is it a prison, they believe. The Shadow Crooks have come to the conclusion that the Demiplane of Dread is in fact a training ground for some nefarious being or beings. They believe that the purpose of the various domains is to train specialists or generals for the armies of these shadowy beings, for use in some future campaign of extraplanar conquest.
What they know:
1. They have reasoned that some being or group of beings is in control of the Mists and the Demiplane of Dread. (The Dark Powers, although they don't call them that.)
2. They have discovered that each domain is home to a being or group of beings that are the principal focus of the domain. (The Darklords) They mistakenly believe that some domains have not one Darklord, but a group of Darklords. They call these beings the Shadow Generals.
3. The Shadow Generals are all cursed in some way. Many of them seek to escape.
What they believe that they know:
1. Each Shadow General has been chosen for a specific purpose. (Strahd is intended to be the military leader, Azalin the chief magician) Some Shadow Generals have been chosen who are in direct competition with one another. These Shadow Generals (Strahd and Drakov, for instance) must eventually destroy one or the other.
2. The purpose of the curses that have been laid upon the Shadow Generals is to keep them on their toes, to keep them from becoming complacent. This keeps them growing more and more wicked, influential, and capable at their chosen roles.
Errors they've made:
1. They have misidentified several Darklords. They believe that Dr. Mordenheim is the Darklord of Lamordia. They also believe that the patriarchs of the five families in Nova Vaasa form a collective group of Darklords. They have inaccurately identified the Darklords of Dementlieu (they believe it is the Brain), Tepest (Wyan), and Sithicus (Azrael Dak). They also believe that the entire Dilisnya family are the Darklords in Borca.
2. They believe that the Vistani are somehow directly serving the mysterious entities that direct the Land of the Mists. They distrust and avoid them whenever possible.
Operations:
1. The Shadow Crooks operate in cells, with each competent member controlling other, lesser cells beneath them. Each level down in the organization knows less and less, with perhaps only one or two individuals in any domain knowing "the truth" as the organization believes it. Many of the higher members of the Crooks believe that they serve one or two Darklords. Only a handful know the full extent of the organization.
2. The cells operate by encouraging a Darklord towards the purpose they believe that the Dark Powers have for it. Examples might be stirring up support for a military invasion of Barovia. (They would of course make sure that Strahd was aware of the threat in time to respond and destroy it.) They might release a potent monster in Darkon that could only be overcome by the powerful magics of Azalin himself. They do not wish to see their Shadow Generals made to be complacent, but rather to overcome their curses by fulfilling their true purposes. They will, however, encourage the Darklords to struggle with their curses, and as such, they will seek out rumors of ways for the Darklords to which they are loyal to overcome their curses. (Such as a powerful teleportation item to give to Harkon Lukas.)
3. Often, this means that they will encourage heroes to oppose the machinations of the Darklords. The leads that they give the heroes will not be enough to truly defeat their foes, and often times the information will be tainted in such a way as to lead to the defeat of the heroes at the hands of the very Darklord they thought they had been given the secret to stopping.
So what do you guys think? Too wonky? Too powerful? Too genre-breaking? I've been laying down groundwork to introduce them, but I thought I would seek feedback before pulling the trigger and bringing them in.
Formed by a group of Outlander adventurers, the Shadow Crooks were formed with the intent of discovering the true nature and purpose of the land of Mists. Tragically, they've come to a few erroneous conclusions. Perhaps even more tragically, they've come to some rather sinister ones as well.
The Shadow Crooks believe that Ravenloft is not the playground, nor is it a prison, they believe. The Shadow Crooks have come to the conclusion that the Demiplane of Dread is in fact a training ground for some nefarious being or beings. They believe that the purpose of the various domains is to train specialists or generals for the armies of these shadowy beings, for use in some future campaign of extraplanar conquest.
What they know:
1. They have reasoned that some being or group of beings is in control of the Mists and the Demiplane of Dread. (The Dark Powers, although they don't call them that.)
2. They have discovered that each domain is home to a being or group of beings that are the principal focus of the domain. (The Darklords) They mistakenly believe that some domains have not one Darklord, but a group of Darklords. They call these beings the Shadow Generals.
3. The Shadow Generals are all cursed in some way. Many of them seek to escape.
What they believe that they know:
1. Each Shadow General has been chosen for a specific purpose. (Strahd is intended to be the military leader, Azalin the chief magician) Some Shadow Generals have been chosen who are in direct competition with one another. These Shadow Generals (Strahd and Drakov, for instance) must eventually destroy one or the other.
2. The purpose of the curses that have been laid upon the Shadow Generals is to keep them on their toes, to keep them from becoming complacent. This keeps them growing more and more wicked, influential, and capable at their chosen roles.
Errors they've made:
1. They have misidentified several Darklords. They believe that Dr. Mordenheim is the Darklord of Lamordia. They also believe that the patriarchs of the five families in Nova Vaasa form a collective group of Darklords. They have inaccurately identified the Darklords of Dementlieu (they believe it is the Brain), Tepest (Wyan), and Sithicus (Azrael Dak). They also believe that the entire Dilisnya family are the Darklords in Borca.
2. They believe that the Vistani are somehow directly serving the mysterious entities that direct the Land of the Mists. They distrust and avoid them whenever possible.
Operations:
1. The Shadow Crooks operate in cells, with each competent member controlling other, lesser cells beneath them. Each level down in the organization knows less and less, with perhaps only one or two individuals in any domain knowing "the truth" as the organization believes it. Many of the higher members of the Crooks believe that they serve one or two Darklords. Only a handful know the full extent of the organization.
2. The cells operate by encouraging a Darklord towards the purpose they believe that the Dark Powers have for it. Examples might be stirring up support for a military invasion of Barovia. (They would of course make sure that Strahd was aware of the threat in time to respond and destroy it.) They might release a potent monster in Darkon that could only be overcome by the powerful magics of Azalin himself. They do not wish to see their Shadow Generals made to be complacent, but rather to overcome their curses by fulfilling their true purposes. They will, however, encourage the Darklords to struggle with their curses, and as such, they will seek out rumors of ways for the Darklords to which they are loyal to overcome their curses. (Such as a powerful teleportation item to give to Harkon Lukas.)
3. Often, this means that they will encourage heroes to oppose the machinations of the Darklords. The leads that they give the heroes will not be enough to truly defeat their foes, and often times the information will be tainted in such a way as to lead to the defeat of the heroes at the hands of the very Darklord they thought they had been given the secret to stopping.
So what do you guys think? Too wonky? Too powerful? Too genre-breaking? I've been laying down groundwork to introduce them, but I thought I would seek feedback before pulling the trigger and bringing them in.
Last edited by Jimsolo on Thu Sep 27, 2012 10:33 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
Okay, now I'm scared at how similar our brains are working. I just posted an idea about a cell organization in the Van Richten discussion just over a minute ago. You beat my initiative roll!
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
Well, I have to say that a shepherd's crook on a red flag reminds me of communists... perhaps do away with the red flag and have it as gray?
Also, how large is this organization? From your description (cells under cells in many domains) we're looking at 100s of misled people. That's kinda big for that era and the population restrictions.
What if it was a conspiracy of 15-20 members misled persons that infiltrated cells of anarchists and discontent nobles etc?
Also, how large is this organization? From your description (cells under cells in many domains) we're looking at 100s of misled people. That's kinda big for that era and the population restrictions.
What if it was a conspiracy of 15-20 members misled persons that infiltrated cells of anarchists and discontent nobles etc?
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Re: New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
As a for example as to size: The Shadow Crooks in Lamordia number around fifty. Of those fifty, about thirty of them believe that they are grunt workers for a shipping enterprise, with no knowledge that they are even involved in anything nefarious of any kind. Beyond them, another fifteen or so know that their group also does smuggling and banditry. Another five or six (the leaders of the smuggling ring) know that they are part of a larger organization, and that part of their shipping involves sending things from one group of the Crooks to others in different domains.
Only one Shadow Crook in Lamordia has any idea about the Shadow Generals or the big plan. (And she's currently working as Dr. Mordenheim's newest assistant.) She has gently prodded Mordenheim in the direction of creating the eisenherz, and then into selling the half-construct warriors to Falkovnia.
Originally I thought about having the Shadow Crooks only consist of the manipulators at the very top, but I felt like it would keep the PCs from realizing how often they would run into this group. (Since, if everything goes as I have foreseen, they should never come into conflict with Mordenheim's assistant, and she should escape.) I liked the idea that the Crooks consider even their dupes to be part of the organization (including having them carry the handkerchief with their symbol on it) as part of their camoflage. While it makes them harder to hide, having so many lower member with no usable knowledge keeps the higher members safe. By the time any group of adventurers have carved their way to the top, the one or two people in charge have already cut and run.
My idea was that there was, in most domains that have a Shadow Crook presence, only one or two Shadow Crooks with the full knowledge of what the organization was all about.
Only one Shadow Crook in Lamordia has any idea about the Shadow Generals or the big plan. (And she's currently working as Dr. Mordenheim's newest assistant.) She has gently prodded Mordenheim in the direction of creating the eisenherz, and then into selling the half-construct warriors to Falkovnia.
Originally I thought about having the Shadow Crooks only consist of the manipulators at the very top, but I felt like it would keep the PCs from realizing how often they would run into this group. (Since, if everything goes as I have foreseen, they should never come into conflict with Mordenheim's assistant, and she should escape.) I liked the idea that the Crooks consider even their dupes to be part of the organization (including having them carry the handkerchief with their symbol on it) as part of their camoflage. While it makes them harder to hide, having so many lower member with no usable knowledge keeps the higher members safe. By the time any group of adventurers have carved their way to the top, the one or two people in charge have already cut and run.
My idea was that there was, in most domains that have a Shadow Crook presence, only one or two Shadow Crooks with the full knowledge of what the organization was all about.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
Sounds solid.
Write them up and send them to QtR.
Perhaps throw in a feat or something.
Write them up and send them to QtR.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Re: New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
This is an interesting idea, and a misinformed group of antagonists makes a nice balance to those which know more than the players.
How do the Shadow Crooks expect to be rewarded for helping to guide the Shadow Generals toward their intended roles. Also, if they believe they are furthering the interests of the Dark Powers, why do they distrust the Vistani for(supposedly) serving the same masters?
How do the Shadow Crooks expect to be rewarded for helping to guide the Shadow Generals toward their intended roles. Also, if they believe they are furthering the interests of the Dark Powers, why do they distrust the Vistani for(supposedly) serving the same masters?
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
I'm not sure they work for the benefit of darklords, but I see them (from the description) as people that want to "help along destiny". I.e. if they came to the conclusion that the purpose of Azalin was to blow up Il Aluk, they would help along, although that eventually was harmful for Azalin. The same for Hazlik. If they figure his purpose is to mass-fry the Mulans in a big boom, along with himself, they will help along even if that means Hazlik would be incenerated too.
I believe they are more interested in "helping" the Dark Powers, rather than the DP "pawns" which are the darklords. And I believe they see the Power checks as benefits that come with side-effects, not as curses that come with tempting benefits to pave the way to destruction.
I believe they are more interested in "helping" the Dark Powers, rather than the DP "pawns" which are the darklords. And I believe they see the Power checks as benefits that come with side-effects, not as curses that come with tempting benefits to pave the way to destruction.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Re: New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
You bring up a good point Alastor. I hadn't thought about the Vistani thing. I think that their issue is one of uncertainty. The DPs picked the Vistani, and they are just volunteers. They don't really know where they fit in. As to reward, they fully believe that when the time comes, the Shadow Generals will be turned loose upon an unsuspecting elsewhere-plane. (The leader of the organization is a Faerunian elf, so that's where his money is...) When that happens, they believe that (for their loyalty) they will have positions of power in the invasion force, as well as whatever evil-overlordship follows the takeover.
And they do, in fact, work for the benefit of the Darklords. The Dark Powers are unknowns to them, but they can see and interact with the 'Shadow Generals.' They just happen to not always agree on which Darklord they should back. For instance, those in the know believe that Strahd and Dragov are destined to either destroy or conquer one another, since they have similar roles in 'the big plan.' One group might be backing Strahd, while another is assisting Drakov. The Shadow Crooks seek to both challenge and help their Darklord. In your example about Hazlik and Azalin, the Crooks who are working for Hazlik might very well help him kill all the Mulan people. They would also sabotage the work in such a way that Hazlik himself would survive. (They want him challenged, not dead.) On the flip side of that, however, the Crooks loyal to Azalin might very well help Hazlik destroy himself. (Since that helps their patron.) If and when the organization gets into a situation where it is conflicting with itself, the leader (Rolo Moonjewel, the aforementioned elf) or one of his immediate subordinates will step in to see if the situation requires mediation to keep the group's interests at heart. (Which doesn't mean he will necassarily stop them from fighting each other. He takes it on a case-by-case basis.)
Sorry if you got the 'helping along destiny' impression, alhoon. The organization is mostly interested (especially at the higher levels) in helping along themselves. Hopefully, by getting the hell out of Ravenloft. (Because the core membership is primarily outlanders.) That's the motives of the couple dozen members (Core-wide) who are at least partially "in the know." The rest of the lower echelons believe whatever load of garbage their superiors have fed them.
Thanks for the feedback guys! That Vistani thing is a real killer, Alastor, I'm glad you brought it up before a player did. I'm not hung up on them hating and distrusting the Vistani, though. Any suggestions on other ways they could feel about the Vistani, or perhaps other reasons they dislike/distrust them?
And they do, in fact, work for the benefit of the Darklords. The Dark Powers are unknowns to them, but they can see and interact with the 'Shadow Generals.' They just happen to not always agree on which Darklord they should back. For instance, those in the know believe that Strahd and Dragov are destined to either destroy or conquer one another, since they have similar roles in 'the big plan.' One group might be backing Strahd, while another is assisting Drakov. The Shadow Crooks seek to both challenge and help their Darklord. In your example about Hazlik and Azalin, the Crooks who are working for Hazlik might very well help him kill all the Mulan people. They would also sabotage the work in such a way that Hazlik himself would survive. (They want him challenged, not dead.) On the flip side of that, however, the Crooks loyal to Azalin might very well help Hazlik destroy himself. (Since that helps their patron.) If and when the organization gets into a situation where it is conflicting with itself, the leader (Rolo Moonjewel, the aforementioned elf) or one of his immediate subordinates will step in to see if the situation requires mediation to keep the group's interests at heart. (Which doesn't mean he will necassarily stop them from fighting each other. He takes it on a case-by-case basis.)
Sorry if you got the 'helping along destiny' impression, alhoon. The organization is mostly interested (especially at the higher levels) in helping along themselves. Hopefully, by getting the hell out of Ravenloft. (Because the core membership is primarily outlanders.) That's the motives of the couple dozen members (Core-wide) who are at least partially "in the know." The rest of the lower echelons believe whatever load of garbage their superiors have fed them.
Thanks for the feedback guys! That Vistani thing is a real killer, Alastor, I'm glad you brought it up before a player did. I'm not hung up on them hating and distrusting the Vistani, though. Any suggestions on other ways they could feel about the Vistani, or perhaps other reasons they dislike/distrust them?
Last edited by Jimsolo on Thu Sep 27, 2012 10:34 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- Manofevil
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1729
- Joined: Sat Dec 20, 2003 11:12 pm
- Location: Why should I say? No one ever visits!
Re: New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
This is ccol and all guys but, It's DraKov. 
Do us a favor Luv, Stick yer 'ead in a bucket a kick it!
So, gentlemen, that's how it is. Until Grissome.... resurfaces, I'm the acting president, and I say starting with this... anniversary festival, we run this city into the ground! :D
So, gentlemen, that's how it is. Until Grissome.... resurfaces, I'm the acting president, and I say starting with this... anniversary festival, we run this city into the ground! :D
Re: New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
Too right, MoE. Corrected. (At least I think I got em all.) My bad.
On a humorous note, when I read your message, my first thought was "Is he trying to tell me the 'K' should be capitalized? I'm pretty sure he's wrong..." It took me a while to catch on...
On a humorous note, when I read your message, my first thought was "Is he trying to tell me the 'K' should be capitalized? I'm pretty sure he's wrong..." It took me a while to catch on...
Re: New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
They would probably be divided in how they feel about the Vistani based on their position in the imagined Strahd/Drakov conflict, since they appear to be allies of the first and enemies of the second. If any of them work with Malocchio in the belief that he is a General, they would probably be hostile to the Vistani as well.Any suggestions on other ways they could feel about the Vistani, or perhaps other reasons they dislike/distrust them?
Re: New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
My thought was that they would probably view the Vistani as competitors: a rival group that is ALSO trying to curry favor with the Dark Powers, and which refuses to work with them.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
Why would the vistani "refuse" to work with the shadow Crooks? At least in some things I can see them co-operating.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Re: New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
Sorry that wasn't clear alhoon. They don't work with the Shadow Crooks towards the 'end goal' because the Vistani don't know anything about the 'end goal' as Rolo sees it. The Vistani don't really work with the Dark Powers and aren't really conspiring to unleash an army led by the Darklords onto an unsuspecting material plane. Even if they were, one of the defining features of the Vistani is that they keep their secrets to themselves. Assuming that, for some crazy reason, Rolo and his Shadow Crooks are right, then the Vistani would have no reason to trust their plans and motives to a bunch of giorgio.
There is nothing preventing the Crooks from working with the Vistani, it's just that they don't trust the Vistani since they believe the gypsies are "holding out on them" by not spilling the beans about the Dark Powers. For their part, the Vistani can't reveal a truth that they don't actually know anything about.
Again, sorry for any confusion you had. The thing about the Shadow Crooks is that the evidence they have of their conclusion is largely circumstantial, and there is absolutely no reason to believe that they are correct. The motives of the Dark Powers, as well as their true nature (and that of the Vistani, and the Mists) is a mystery in my game, and will remain so. If the Vistani were to work with the Shadow Crooks, then it would pin them down more than I am comfortable with.
There is nothing preventing the Crooks from working with the Vistani, it's just that they don't trust the Vistani since they believe the gypsies are "holding out on them" by not spilling the beans about the Dark Powers. For their part, the Vistani can't reveal a truth that they don't actually know anything about.
Again, sorry for any confusion you had. The thing about the Shadow Crooks is that the evidence they have of their conclusion is largely circumstantial, and there is absolutely no reason to believe that they are correct. The motives of the Dark Powers, as well as their true nature (and that of the Vistani, and the Mists) is a mystery in my game, and will remain so. If the Vistani were to work with the Shadow Crooks, then it would pin them down more than I am comfortable with.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: New Organization: The Shadow Crooks (Feedback wanted)
OK, makes sense for the Vistani. What I mean, is that occasionally a vistani may work for the shadow Crooks without even realizing it, or that perhaps once a while the vistani work with a group affiliated with the Shadow Crooks for some intermediate goal. If for example The Strahd-backing SCrooks, support a group of Anarchists in Falkvovia, and that group of anarchists plans to break into a Falkovian prison to save some vistani, I see no reason why the Vistani wouldn't help.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
