Between Jimsolo's organization, the Shadow Crooks, and the slight derail in the thread on Van Richten, I thought it might be good to make a general thread for this. Apologies if there's already one elsewhere.
And I know domains like Richemulot and Dementlieu basically thrive on the manipulation of facts.
So, misinformation. Who trades in it? Who benefits? Who suffers? What are some specifics (aims, methods, details)?
Misinformation, Mischief and Propaganda
Misinformation, Mischief and Propaganda
Last edited by Hazgarn on Thu Sep 27, 2012 8:28 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Deranged Comics Fan
Strife-monger
Daughter of a Troll
Strife-monger
Daughter of a Troll
Re: Misinformation, Mischief and Propaganda
For my own campaign, I've been thinking about domain specific disinformation and propaganda (what might a Falkovnian soldier think he knows about Darkon?). I vaguely remember (probably from one of HuManBing's threads on Falkovnia, so it's probably not canon) some discussion of Darkonese undead (and Azalin in particular, either as lich or necromancer) as a focal point of Falkovnian indoctrination and propaganda, giving the military machine the grand purpose of routing the unnatural rule of a (potentially darker) tyrant.
Given the importance of the Requiem to my future campaign plans, this could be a key way of giving the players less-than-reliable information that could still ultimately give them a place to start. I think the original thread used the idea that Drakov could be aware of Azalin's lichdom, which with the propaganda puts Falkovnia in an interesting position if this knowledge is part of what is publically known, but dismissed by surrounding nations as simply being lies used by a tyrant to manipulate his uneducated and backward subjects.
Given the importance of the Requiem to my future campaign plans, this could be a key way of giving the players less-than-reliable information that could still ultimately give them a place to start. I think the original thread used the idea that Drakov could be aware of Azalin's lichdom, which with the propaganda puts Falkovnia in an interesting position if this knowledge is part of what is publically known, but dismissed by surrounding nations as simply being lies used by a tyrant to manipulate his uneducated and backward subjects.
Deranged Comics Fan
Strife-monger
Daughter of a Troll
Strife-monger
Daughter of a Troll
Re: Misinformation, Mischief and Propaganda
1. Falkovnia has an elite group of falconers who train their birds to capture, not kill, other nations' carrier pigeons. The pigeons and their messages are delivered to the Nachrichtendienst (Falkovnian Intelligence Ministry), decoded, and then either returned to the pigeons and re-released to their original destination, or cunningly-forged messages are put in their place.
2. Darkon's memory loss quirk is used as a means of neutralizing people with troublesome pasts. Exile them to Darkon and keep them there for a few months, and poof! They can't remember any troublesome secrets.
3. Back when Gundarak and Barovia were separate bordering nations, Azalin sent Kargat to arm peasants along the borders of both nations so they could continually raid and pillage each other. Although Strahd's agents correctly deduced the source of this interference, Gundar's never did.
4. The Eternal Order continues to preach that the vengeful dead are kept at bay only by powerful magicks woven by Azalin (the staunchest ally the living has ever known) and the continued propitiation by the masses.
5. Drakov believes Azalin is the same person as Bishop Trandamere from Thenol (Dragonlance setting), another necromantic NPC. He tries to raise awareness of Darkon's undead leadership, and works to build support in neighboring human countries against Azalin. This meets with indifference or opposition. His attacks against Darkon have actually been well-planned, logistically sound military campaigns, but they were undone by a mixture of Azalin's overwhelming numerical superiority in undead, and Drakov's inability to personally follow them out of the domain. His campaigns against the neighboring domains initially started off as "police actions" to replace their complacent leaders with those who supported the overthrow of Azalin, but those too failed thanks to the supernatural power of Dark Lords.
6. A necromancer managed to keep a haunted forest all to himself through a particular clever trick. He made sure that villagers saw him conducting rituals to raise the dead, leaving empty graves everywhere. The villagers hired adventurers to seek out and destroy his undead, but they only managed to kill a few dozen, whereas the number of exhumed graves numbers nearly a hundred. Unable to stamp out the rest of the undead, the villagers left the necromancer to his forest in peace. (In truth, there only ever were a few dozen undead - the remainder of the supposedly exhumed graves were just uninhabited holes he dug in the soil to inflate the estimated numbers and ensure the villagers could never "find 100% of the undead".)
2. Darkon's memory loss quirk is used as a means of neutralizing people with troublesome pasts. Exile them to Darkon and keep them there for a few months, and poof! They can't remember any troublesome secrets.
3. Back when Gundarak and Barovia were separate bordering nations, Azalin sent Kargat to arm peasants along the borders of both nations so they could continually raid and pillage each other. Although Strahd's agents correctly deduced the source of this interference, Gundar's never did.
4. The Eternal Order continues to preach that the vengeful dead are kept at bay only by powerful magicks woven by Azalin (the staunchest ally the living has ever known) and the continued propitiation by the masses.
5. Drakov believes Azalin is the same person as Bishop Trandamere from Thenol (Dragonlance setting), another necromantic NPC. He tries to raise awareness of Darkon's undead leadership, and works to build support in neighboring human countries against Azalin. This meets with indifference or opposition. His attacks against Darkon have actually been well-planned, logistically sound military campaigns, but they were undone by a mixture of Azalin's overwhelming numerical superiority in undead, and Drakov's inability to personally follow them out of the domain. His campaigns against the neighboring domains initially started off as "police actions" to replace their complacent leaders with those who supported the overthrow of Azalin, but those too failed thanks to the supernatural power of Dark Lords.
6. A necromancer managed to keep a haunted forest all to himself through a particular clever trick. He made sure that villagers saw him conducting rituals to raise the dead, leaving empty graves everywhere. The villagers hired adventurers to seek out and destroy his undead, but they only managed to kill a few dozen, whereas the number of exhumed graves numbers nearly a hundred. Unable to stamp out the rest of the undead, the villagers left the necromancer to his forest in peace. (In truth, there only ever were a few dozen undead - the remainder of the supposedly exhumed graves were just uninhabited holes he dug in the soil to inflate the estimated numbers and ensure the villagers could never "find 100% of the undead".)
Re: Misinformation, Mischief and Propaganda
The "Housewife's Run" was an infamous smuggling operation to bring a potent Elven narcotic, powdered night rose petal, from Sithicus to Darkon. The initial half-elf boss of the operation was captured by a Darkonian baron for largely political reasons, so his wife (likewise a half-elf) ran the smuggling operation for a while. The Sithican elves did not believe that she had what it took to smuggle the drug back into Darkon, so they gave her a stiff challenge: take a sizeable quantity back to Nevuchar Springs with her, crossing all domain boundaries, and bringing it undetected to Darkon. Then hand it over to one of their cartel members in Darkon within a day of crossing the border back into Darkon.
The wife was completely distraught over this, knowing that Darkon's police were sure to disassemble all her luggage to look for any reason to arrest her. As it was, she was specifically stopped at the border and subjected to numerous violations of her person as the Darkonians searched for any trace of the powdered night rose petals. Eventually, they let her go but kept a tail on her. She went straight to her homestead and stayed there.
As it turned out, she threw away the entire package of the contraband the moment she left Sithicus, knowing it was too dangerous to keep on her. She then sent message back home by carrier pigeon for her cronies to immediately locate some old stock contraband from that same supplier, and to deliver it to a third party holder until she got back. Once she crossed the border, they were to release it to the Sithican contact within the one-day margin.
This ruse worked, as the particular composition of the drug matched the Sithican supplier's usual quality. The Housewife's Run remained a tightly-kept secret until the leadership changed, thus allowing its perpetrators to speak freely of it.
The wife was completely distraught over this, knowing that Darkon's police were sure to disassemble all her luggage to look for any reason to arrest her. As it was, she was specifically stopped at the border and subjected to numerous violations of her person as the Darkonians searched for any trace of the powdered night rose petals. Eventually, they let her go but kept a tail on her. She went straight to her homestead and stayed there.
As it turned out, she threw away the entire package of the contraband the moment she left Sithicus, knowing it was too dangerous to keep on her. She then sent message back home by carrier pigeon for her cronies to immediately locate some old stock contraband from that same supplier, and to deliver it to a third party holder until she got back. Once she crossed the border, they were to release it to the Sithican contact within the one-day margin.
This ruse worked, as the particular composition of the drug matched the Sithican supplier's usual quality. The Housewife's Run remained a tightly-kept secret until the leadership changed, thus allowing its perpetrators to speak freely of it.
Re: Misinformation, Mischief and Propaganda
Love that idea of the necromancer digging holes to make it look like pillagd graves. Definitely using that.
I thought I would take a second to try and categorize the motives behind large-scale deceptions.
1. Camoflage - Disguise yourself, your organization, or something dangerous, as a much more innocuous thing. This is the kind of deception you see primarily in lycanthropes, or by those members of the Kargat that appear to be human. Heck, Azalin himself does this whenever he is maintaining his guise as a human being. Strahd does this when he goes abroad in disguise.
2. Bluff - The opposite of camoflage, the Bluff is designed to mask yourself as more threatening than you really are. Vampyres who pretend to be real vampires are a good example of this. The aforementioned necromancer has done some fine work here as well.
3. Coercion - This type of deception is the spreading of misinformation to get someone to do something they would not normally do. When a disguised Adam tells a group of PCs that Mordenheim is cooking up an army of horrid half-golem warriors (when the doctor is not really doing so), when really he just wants them to break into the mad doctor's lab and wreck up the place, that's an example of coercion.
4. Bottom Deal - The Bottom Deal is closely related to the Coercion. In the bottom deal, the information that is spread is true, it is the motive of the informant that is being disguised. (In the previous example, if Adam were telling the truth, it would be a Bottom Deal, because he still doesn't care about the half-golems, he just wants to cause trouble for Mordenheim.)
5. Red Herring - The Red Herring is a deception intended to distract someone. The necromancer who 'helpfully' provides a map for the PCs to the lair of "whatever nogoodnik has been raising those zombies" in order to get enough time to high-tail it is using a Red Herring.
6. Tiger Bait - Tiger Bait is a Red Herring that is intended to kill the distracted party. (In the previous example, if the map led to a cave full of ettins, it would be Tiger Bait.)
7. Blindfold - The Blindfold is intended to confuse. Sentient haunted houses (since there's a number of ways to make that happen in Ravenloft...) frequently use Blindfold tactics, keeping their victims scurrying around and around with rooms that make no sense, staircases to nowhere, and nonexistent 'ghost' tormentors.
8. Lizard Tail - The Lizard Tail is a tactic employed as damage control. A leader of a guild of thieves who keeps a visible safe in his office with a few pieces of cheap jewelry and a few hundred coins in it is a good example. His real vault, of course, is hidden, the intent being that a burglar will plunder the visible safe and then skedaddle with his "big score."
The reason I broke these down the way that I did was because I find it easier to build plots if I understand the fundamental building blocks. Can anyone point out any I missed? (I'm sure this isn't an exhaustive list...) The Lizard Tail jumps out to me as one that Harkon Lukas would be likely to use. ("Horrible murders that look like they've been fed on by a wolf? Well, lemme tell you about this guy that people seem to think is a lycanthrope..." And then the happy little PCs go off and lynch the wolfwere who had to bad luck to owe Lukas a couple of bucks...)
Is that the kind of thing you were looking for Haz?
I thought I would take a second to try and categorize the motives behind large-scale deceptions.
1. Camoflage - Disguise yourself, your organization, or something dangerous, as a much more innocuous thing. This is the kind of deception you see primarily in lycanthropes, or by those members of the Kargat that appear to be human. Heck, Azalin himself does this whenever he is maintaining his guise as a human being. Strahd does this when he goes abroad in disguise.
2. Bluff - The opposite of camoflage, the Bluff is designed to mask yourself as more threatening than you really are. Vampyres who pretend to be real vampires are a good example of this. The aforementioned necromancer has done some fine work here as well.
3. Coercion - This type of deception is the spreading of misinformation to get someone to do something they would not normally do. When a disguised Adam tells a group of PCs that Mordenheim is cooking up an army of horrid half-golem warriors (when the doctor is not really doing so), when really he just wants them to break into the mad doctor's lab and wreck up the place, that's an example of coercion.
4. Bottom Deal - The Bottom Deal is closely related to the Coercion. In the bottom deal, the information that is spread is true, it is the motive of the informant that is being disguised. (In the previous example, if Adam were telling the truth, it would be a Bottom Deal, because he still doesn't care about the half-golems, he just wants to cause trouble for Mordenheim.)
5. Red Herring - The Red Herring is a deception intended to distract someone. The necromancer who 'helpfully' provides a map for the PCs to the lair of "whatever nogoodnik has been raising those zombies" in order to get enough time to high-tail it is using a Red Herring.
6. Tiger Bait - Tiger Bait is a Red Herring that is intended to kill the distracted party. (In the previous example, if the map led to a cave full of ettins, it would be Tiger Bait.)
7. Blindfold - The Blindfold is intended to confuse. Sentient haunted houses (since there's a number of ways to make that happen in Ravenloft...) frequently use Blindfold tactics, keeping their victims scurrying around and around with rooms that make no sense, staircases to nowhere, and nonexistent 'ghost' tormentors.
8. Lizard Tail - The Lizard Tail is a tactic employed as damage control. A leader of a guild of thieves who keeps a visible safe in his office with a few pieces of cheap jewelry and a few hundred coins in it is a good example. His real vault, of course, is hidden, the intent being that a burglar will plunder the visible safe and then skedaddle with his "big score."
The reason I broke these down the way that I did was because I find it easier to build plots if I understand the fundamental building blocks. Can anyone point out any I missed? (I'm sure this isn't an exhaustive list...) The Lizard Tail jumps out to me as one that Harkon Lukas would be likely to use. ("Horrible murders that look like they've been fed on by a wolf? Well, lemme tell you about this guy that people seem to think is a lycanthrope..." And then the happy little PCs go off and lynch the wolfwere who had to bad luck to owe Lukas a couple of bucks...)
Is that the kind of thing you were looking for Haz?
Re: Misinformation, Mischief and Propaganda
:Tips hat:
That's a great list JimSolo! A good summary of the various social means of winning a war of wills.
That's a great list JimSolo! A good summary of the various social means of winning a war of wills.
Re: Misinformation, Mischief and Propaganda
In the Ravenloft Gazetteers, the mysterious S erroneously assumes Wyan to be the Darklord of Tepest, does she not? While we all know the three hags to be the Darklords of that domain, I can't help but wonder if the hags realize that people in the know about Darklords could easily make that mistake. And if they do, are they encouraging people in that belief? If so, that would be a pretty good deception.
Re: Misinformation, Mischief and Propaganda
¨Night rose petals¨ are an elven narcotic? I´m not sure if that was your intention, but this makes me wonder whether the flowers the PCs in When Black Roses Bloom were sent after were really spell components...The "Housewife's Run" was an infamous smuggling operation to bring a potent Elven narcotic, powdered night rose petal, from Sithicus to Darkon.

