What's In the Box?
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
What's In the Box?
In my current Ravenloft game, one of the party snuck into a manor home that doubled as a monastery for the Order of the Guardians.
While he didn't get very far before he had to turn back (and didn't find the true item they were guarding) he did snatch up a lesser object they had set aside, a locked box that pulled to him empathically.
This was a bit of an improvised scene, as I had not planned on theft becoming an option. But the idea of a lesser cursed object was too tempting to pass up.
So my question is: what's in the box?
What does it do? How is it cursed?
While he didn't get very far before he had to turn back (and didn't find the true item they were guarding) he did snatch up a lesser object they had set aside, a locked box that pulled to him empathically.
This was a bit of an improvised scene, as I had not planned on theft becoming an option. But the idea of a lesser cursed object was too tempting to pass up.
So my question is: what's in the box?
What does it do? How is it cursed?
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: What's In the Box?
Well, the obvious solution would be... the box is cursed by enticing the character, making him covetus and welcoming him to try to open it. It shows a faint transmutation aura and enchantment aura and has a good quality lock that also seems enchanted.
THe box doesn't actually open at all. It's not locked, it's closed. There's clever illusion and transmutation to make it appear as it can be opened.
The curse is that with time and wasted effort the thief develops an obsession with the object, the more he tries to open it. The magic of the box makes it difficult to eventually impossible for the victim to realize that the box just doesn't open. Attempts to persuade the character that the box doesn't open or to abandon it with diplomacy or threats have a DC of 18+2/week the character had the box in his possession (max 25). The character gains a +1 to will saves/week the box is in his possession (max +5) against magical attempts to convince the character to surrender the box (suggestion, dominate, etc).
There are rumors about a person that when his house caught on fire, he rushed out with the box, living the rest of his belongings aside and starved to death in the winter, the thought of selling the box never crossing his mind. There are also some notes about a famous puzzle solver that received this cursed box by a rival telling him the box opens with a puzzle. The puzzle solver eventually died from starvation trying to open the box.
The box itself is hard to destroy. If it is burned or smashed outside of a hallowed or blessed ground, it will re-appear sound and sturdy after the next midnight in the possessions of the box's owner. If the character successfuly abandons the box himself without being forced or magically coersed, he's free from the box's curse and he may even realize that the box just doesn't open.
If the character is forced to abandon the box or loses it (a thief steals it), he obsesses with reclaiming it for 1 week (effects like those of the lesser Geas), after which the effects slowly fade within a day. Of course, if he gets the box back, the new thief is under the same compulsion to take it and it would lead to bloodshed.
It was made by a judgemental wizard to punish thieves by exploiting their greed. The effects of the box can be broken with break enchantment, or by a remove curse spell with a caster level check 11+box maker's lvl. Failure to break the curse with the remove curse spell may enrage the victim of the curse and can be tried once per week. Subjequent uses of the spell within the week automatically fail.
The creator is immune to the curse.
Box of obsession: Caster lvl 9, craft wondrous items, Lesser Geas, Suggestion, Nystul's magical aura, Market price 10000 gp+the cost of a nice box. Cost 5000 gp + the cost of a nice box and 400XP.
Creating this cursed magical item is not by itself worthy of a power's check. Gifting the box could be a reason for a power's check even if it's just for lying.
THe box doesn't actually open at all. It's not locked, it's closed. There's clever illusion and transmutation to make it appear as it can be opened.
The curse is that with time and wasted effort the thief develops an obsession with the object, the more he tries to open it. The magic of the box makes it difficult to eventually impossible for the victim to realize that the box just doesn't open. Attempts to persuade the character that the box doesn't open or to abandon it with diplomacy or threats have a DC of 18+2/week the character had the box in his possession (max 25). The character gains a +1 to will saves/week the box is in his possession (max +5) against magical attempts to convince the character to surrender the box (suggestion, dominate, etc).
There are rumors about a person that when his house caught on fire, he rushed out with the box, living the rest of his belongings aside and starved to death in the winter, the thought of selling the box never crossing his mind. There are also some notes about a famous puzzle solver that received this cursed box by a rival telling him the box opens with a puzzle. The puzzle solver eventually died from starvation trying to open the box.
The box itself is hard to destroy. If it is burned or smashed outside of a hallowed or blessed ground, it will re-appear sound and sturdy after the next midnight in the possessions of the box's owner. If the character successfuly abandons the box himself without being forced or magically coersed, he's free from the box's curse and he may even realize that the box just doesn't open.
If the character is forced to abandon the box or loses it (a thief steals it), he obsesses with reclaiming it for 1 week (effects like those of the lesser Geas), after which the effects slowly fade within a day. Of course, if he gets the box back, the new thief is under the same compulsion to take it and it would lead to bloodshed.
It was made by a judgemental wizard to punish thieves by exploiting their greed. The effects of the box can be broken with break enchantment, or by a remove curse spell with a caster level check 11+box maker's lvl. Failure to break the curse with the remove curse spell may enrage the victim of the curse and can be tried once per week. Subjequent uses of the spell within the week automatically fail.
The creator is immune to the curse.
Box of obsession: Caster lvl 9, craft wondrous items, Lesser Geas, Suggestion, Nystul's magical aura, Market price 10000 gp+the cost of a nice box. Cost 5000 gp + the cost of a nice box and 400XP.
Creating this cursed magical item is not by itself worthy of a power's check. Gifting the box could be a reason for a power's check even if it's just for lying.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Re: What's In the Box?
Greetings,
well, a few years ago I was introduced to whachamacallit a chinese box. It only opens if you move the right pieces in the right order. It's hard to describe it if you haven't seen one before, but essentially, there are a few moving pieces on the box (normally seven, but can be up to 21)
Just an idea, try it if you like
k.
well, a few years ago I was introduced to whachamacallit a chinese box. It only opens if you move the right pieces in the right order. It's hard to describe it if you haven't seen one before, but essentially, there are a few moving pieces on the box (normally seven, but can be up to 21)
Just an idea, try it if you like
k.
Morn came and went – and came, and brought no day
– George Gordon, Darkness
– George Gordon, Darkness
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: What's In the Box?
I love alhoon's idea. But for the extra perverse twist, if smashed open, I would say that inside.... is another identical box. 
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
Re: What's In the Box?
Here is some inspiration.
Here is some more.
That being said, those are the really obvious ones. Alhoon's suggestion is good too. Personally, I would reward his thievery while punishing him at the same time, and all of the above options seem long on stick and short on carrot.
All these options have been done before, though. If you want something which is both unique and topical to your game, I would recommend taking a step back and examining it from the Order's perspective. What is in this box that was valuable enough to keep, dangerous enough to hide, and either rare enough (or tough enough) to not be destroyed? Possibilities include a monster, a map, a prophecy, or a magical item. (Perhaps with a potent curse.)
Hope that helps.
Here is some more.
That being said, those are the really obvious ones. Alhoon's suggestion is good too. Personally, I would reward his thievery while punishing him at the same time, and all of the above options seem long on stick and short on carrot.
All these options have been done before, though. If you want something which is both unique and topical to your game, I would recommend taking a step back and examining it from the Order's perspective. What is in this box that was valuable enough to keep, dangerous enough to hide, and either rare enough (or tough enough) to not be destroyed? Possibilities include a monster, a map, a prophecy, or a magical item. (Perhaps with a potent curse.)
Hope that helps.
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Re: What's In the Box?
I really should do a Campaign Journal at some point.
The character in question is one Elijah "Book" Mordenkeinin, an 8-year-old prodigy with an animate shadow and grandson of Dr. Richard Weathermay, a cousin of George Weathermay.
The staff at Book's father's home was pulled into the ethereal plane and is living as phantoms (a haunted house in Mordent not haunted by the dead), slowly dying of starvation and thirst over several weeks. The party was trying to negotiate for the Transubstantial Halo from the Guardians. When that failed, Book decided to sneak in himself and get the Halo. He ventured into the crypt being used to store the Halo and stayed in the dark, so he was unaffected by the basilisk guardian. But did not get near the Halo.
Give the character is 8 I don't want to punish too much...
The character in question is one Elijah "Book" Mordenkeinin, an 8-year-old prodigy with an animate shadow and grandson of Dr. Richard Weathermay, a cousin of George Weathermay.
The staff at Book's father's home was pulled into the ethereal plane and is living as phantoms (a haunted house in Mordent not haunted by the dead), slowly dying of starvation and thirst over several weeks. The party was trying to negotiate for the Transubstantial Halo from the Guardians. When that failed, Book decided to sneak in himself and get the Halo. He ventured into the crypt being used to store the Halo and stayed in the dark, so he was unaffected by the basilisk guardian. But did not get near the Halo.
Give the character is 8 I don't want to punish too much...
Re: What's In the Box?
Is the player eight, the character, or both? If it's an adult playing a child, then punish away! It makes it all the more horrible that the victim will be a child, but Ravenloft's a horrible place. Perhaps the box could contain something providing exposition? Perhaps correspondence from the former occupants, which might provide background on what happened to them.
And, as a side note, I fully empathize, since I find myself in a similar position as a DM. Were it me, I would go with a severed head. One of the PCs severed heads, apparently aged by several decades. And then I would never provide a satisfactory explanation for them...
And, as a side note, I fully empathize, since I find myself in a similar position as a DM. Were it me, I would go with a severed head. One of the PCs severed heads, apparently aged by several decades. And then I would never provide a satisfactory explanation for them...
Re: What's In the Box?
The box could be a great way to seed a new storyline, too. You could talk to the character about not opening the box until the end of the current storyline. Or, even better, let both plots flow as they must and let the characters prioritize their goals.
My box would have a series of letters written in a feminine hand. They would tell the story of a girl falling in love with a con man who would later kill her. These letters are over a decade old. The characters have to use details found in the letters to track down a murderer who thinks he is safe.
Since the character is a child, maybe the author of the letters is also a child. They are hunting a step-father or step-mother perhaps. Or anyone the family trusted that murdered the child instead.
For an added bit of flavor, have your characters realize that the final letter was written after the child was already dead. The murder was described in terrible detail in a letter written from beyond the grave.
My box would have a series of letters written in a feminine hand. They would tell the story of a girl falling in love with a con man who would later kill her. These letters are over a decade old. The characters have to use details found in the letters to track down a murderer who thinks he is safe.
Since the character is a child, maybe the author of the letters is also a child. They are hunting a step-father or step-mother perhaps. Or anyone the family trusted that murdered the child instead.
For an added bit of flavor, have your characters realize that the final letter was written after the child was already dead. The murder was described in terrible detail in a letter written from beyond the grave.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: What's In the Box?
While Jimsolo's idea is interesting I still prefer my approach because it takes the question of "what's in the box? How is it cursed?" and turns it to an answer by itself. 
Also, the curse I presented can be defeated early on when the DCs for diplomacy aren't high and the obsession hasn't taken a full root.
Also, the curse I presented can be defeated early on when the DCs for diplomacy aren't high and the obsession hasn't taken a full root.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Re: What's In the Box?
Perhaps the box is the entryway to a pocket domain whose darklord preys on children. You could do a ''Coraline''-type solo adventure, with a boogeyman or similar menace as the enemy. Defeating the threat would require cleverness and trickery, not combat; think ''Labyrinth'' or ''The Wee Free Men''.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: What's In the Box?
Nice one. Star Trek: TNG, "Time's Arrow"?Jimsolo wrote:One of the PCs severed heads, apparently aged by several decades. And then I would never provide a satisfactory explanation for them...
I quite like Trike's idea. I like it a lot. Reminds me of the little girl ghost from The Sixth Sense, with the videotape evidence against
VIEW CONTENT:
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
Re: What's In the Box?
Lol, I hadn't thought of the Star Trek connection. Oh well. 
Re: What's In the Box?
There was an Oglaf cartoon about a magical box which was enchanted to make you really want whatever was inside the box, even if it was something worthless like a pine cone.
This would allow the holder to offer the pine cone to other people and they would do faintly unreasonable things for it.
This would allow the holder to offer the pine cone to other people and they would do faintly unreasonable things for it.
- Zilfer
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4231
- Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
- Contact:
Re: What's In the Box?
I suppose a small person/leprecan named.... "jack" is out of the question? Yes i went there. xD
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Re: What's In the Box?
I will be finishing my current micro-arc in the next session, so this item could launch a new story. Or cause some stories and tension.
I've also been thinking about its placement a little more. Its introduction was spontaneous so there is a dash of illogic behind its ease of recovery and placement.
However, as I had the box near to where the monks were keeping the Transubstantial Halo, perhaps the contents are something the Guardians could use, something kept nearby because it was useful in protecting the Halo, the true item they are guarding.
Maybe something that lets the monks see into the near ethereal so they can check for ghosts.
I've also been thinking about its placement a little more. Its introduction was spontaneous so there is a dash of illogic behind its ease of recovery and placement.
However, as I had the box near to where the monks were keeping the Transubstantial Halo, perhaps the contents are something the Guardians could use, something kept nearby because it was useful in protecting the Halo, the true item they are guarding.
Maybe something that lets the monks see into the near ethereal so they can check for ghosts.

