Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign - How much should it cost?
- Zilfer
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4231
- Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
- Contact:
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign - Question about book statist
I see I missed poor Ulric..... (von lichtenstein xD)
- A G Thing
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1216
- Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
- Gender: Female
- Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign - Question about book statist
Patence of Nobility is required to post here! 
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign - Question about book statist
Lol, there has been several hassles surrounding his name. I kept thinking it was Urich at first until I had to look at his character sheet for something and noticed my error. I swear he's changed it back and forth.
- Zilfer
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4231
- Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
- Contact:
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign - Question about book statist
Look... feed me, cloth me, and let me ride that horse a bit and it will be yours.
It's called a lance...... heeeeello!
he's raised taxes in his kingdom four times this year.... his people starve while he sits at banquet..... (whispering) probably true.
You see how hungry I am?
Any minute now.....
(yeah don't get me started if i was in this campaign i'd try to throw almost every single line in that movie into some situation xD)
My good people i missed my introduction!
The protector of Italian virginity! the enforcer of our lord god!
ok before i derail more..... i'll stop.
It's called a lance...... heeeeello!
he's raised taxes in his kingdom four times this year.... his people starve while he sits at banquet..... (whispering) probably true.
You see how hungry I am?
Any minute now.....
(yeah don't get me started if i was in this campaign i'd try to throw almost every single line in that movie into some situation xD)
My good people i missed my introduction!
The protector of Italian virginity! the enforcer of our lord god!
ok before i derail more..... i'll stop.
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign - Question about book statist
Lol, s'okay. As DM I have thus far resisted all the urges to throw A Knight's Tale references at him, but there will eventually come a day when someone is going to give him a serious thrashing while telling him that he has been "weighed, measured, and found wanting."
So here's the plan for upcoming days: A chance meeting will put Franky (who is unaware that he is harboring a slow burning case of mummy rot) in contact with Dr. Mordenheim. The good doctor will offer to heal his mummy rot, since he has heard of Franky's recent loss and can sympathize, as someone who also understands "the pain of losing the woman that anchors us." He will take Franky back to Schloss Mordenheim and indeed cure the mummy rot. (I don't think that's too out of the question for Mordenheim.) While there, he will offer a sympathetic ear for Franky and relay his own sob story, which he presents entirely from his own point of view. Should the PCs bring up the island of gypsies with the cages on their legs, he will point out that he couldn't have possibly done that, since it happened over fifty years ago. Eventually, he will offer Franky the chance to get his sister back, via cloning. All he asks for is the brain of the mature clone when they transfer Sasha's old brain into the new body. (They have her body preserved with Gentle Repose, which I reason will keep her brain viable.) If they object on moral grounds, Victor consoles them by telling them that he'll never even wake the clone.
So then I will have them piddlefart around for a bit. Primarily during the winter, say, while the clone is growing. I have a plot all prepared for that, I'll tell you all about it later on.
When they return, they will find that Schloss Mordenheim had been broken into. The clone, fully matured, has been stolen by Adam. The PCs will go to Adam's hideout to recover the clone. Adam, already prepared by Ivy, has set up a number of ambushes along the way designed to play on the worst fears of the PCs. When they fight their way in, they will finally confront Adam, who will give them HIS version of the story between him and Victor, as well as tell them that he stole the clone because he believes Mordenheim was going to use the body for Elise's brain rather than Sasha's. As a final blow from the monster, should they choose to defeat him (and they probably will) they will discover that he has awoken the clone, who is now a fully aware (although amnesic) person.
Act 3 is the act of betrayal. Just off the Isle of Agony, they come under fire from a concealed sniper position. Horg, Victor's assistant, has been lying in wait to kill the injured PCs returning with the clone. Adam's suspicions were correct, you see, and Mordenheim really did plan on using Sasha's body for Elise. Should the PCs confront the doctor he will fess up to his actions, and if threatened will volunteer to perform the brain transfer surgery under PC supervision. The final conflict in this story will probably be the PCs trying to decide whether or not to kill the clone in order to resurrect Sasha.
What do you guys think?
So here's the plan for upcoming days: A chance meeting will put Franky (who is unaware that he is harboring a slow burning case of mummy rot) in contact with Dr. Mordenheim. The good doctor will offer to heal his mummy rot, since he has heard of Franky's recent loss and can sympathize, as someone who also understands "the pain of losing the woman that anchors us." He will take Franky back to Schloss Mordenheim and indeed cure the mummy rot. (I don't think that's too out of the question for Mordenheim.) While there, he will offer a sympathetic ear for Franky and relay his own sob story, which he presents entirely from his own point of view. Should the PCs bring up the island of gypsies with the cages on their legs, he will point out that he couldn't have possibly done that, since it happened over fifty years ago. Eventually, he will offer Franky the chance to get his sister back, via cloning. All he asks for is the brain of the mature clone when they transfer Sasha's old brain into the new body. (They have her body preserved with Gentle Repose, which I reason will keep her brain viable.) If they object on moral grounds, Victor consoles them by telling them that he'll never even wake the clone.
So then I will have them piddlefart around for a bit. Primarily during the winter, say, while the clone is growing. I have a plot all prepared for that, I'll tell you all about it later on.
When they return, they will find that Schloss Mordenheim had been broken into. The clone, fully matured, has been stolen by Adam. The PCs will go to Adam's hideout to recover the clone. Adam, already prepared by Ivy, has set up a number of ambushes along the way designed to play on the worst fears of the PCs. When they fight their way in, they will finally confront Adam, who will give them HIS version of the story between him and Victor, as well as tell them that he stole the clone because he believes Mordenheim was going to use the body for Elise's brain rather than Sasha's. As a final blow from the monster, should they choose to defeat him (and they probably will) they will discover that he has awoken the clone, who is now a fully aware (although amnesic) person.
Act 3 is the act of betrayal. Just off the Isle of Agony, they come under fire from a concealed sniper position. Horg, Victor's assistant, has been lying in wait to kill the injured PCs returning with the clone. Adam's suspicions were correct, you see, and Mordenheim really did plan on using Sasha's body for Elise. Should the PCs confront the doctor he will fess up to his actions, and if threatened will volunteer to perform the brain transfer surgery under PC supervision. The final conflict in this story will probably be the PCs trying to decide whether or not to kill the clone in order to resurrect Sasha.
What do you guys think?
- A G Thing
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1216
- Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
- Gender: Female
- Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign - Question about book statist
Sounds great... Just make sure to avoid too much hint dropping or railroading and it should strike beautifully and leave them some good choices to make!
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign - Question about book statist
So, with my tenth game finished, I have begun a trial program for a new mechanic in my game. I call it star points. After every game, each of my players receives an XP receipt.

Here's a breakdown:
A - Game number. It's presented like a periodical, with each 'season' running in ten episode arcs.
B - Character name. This is a character that doesn't actually exist in my game. Fritz is level 5.
C - Combat XP. I just lump it all together. They know what they fought. It's the other areas where they
may not know what they earned XP for.
D - Bucking the script XP. I tend to script out my games, with backups and contingencies to keep my PCs
'on-plot.' That being said, I am not going to plot-hammer them. If they legitimately find a way
around my script, then more power to them, and I will reward them appropriately.
E - Contact XP. The PCs earn a small amount of XP for making positive contact with NPCs.
F - Non combat challenges. They also earn XP for overcoming challenges without resorting to violence.
G - Plot completion. When the PCs wrap up a story, they earn a bonus for completing it. This gives
them an impetus to wrap up the current storyline before taking downtime.
H - Teamwork bonus. Can be awarded more than once per game. Always equal to the average party
level times five.
I - Roleplaying bonus. Usually awarded more than once per game. Always equal to the average party
level times three. I calculated Fritz's XP incorrectly here. It should be 15.
J - Alignment XP. Equal to the party level times the number of adherent alignment ticks. (See below.)
K - Total, including overall place in the group, since two players rarely have the same total.
L - Alignment drift. I use a system of alignment ticks along a numeric graph to track alignment. While
players are not privy to their exact score, they are told each week which direction their net
drift for that week inclined. If they drift five or more ticks in one direction, the alignment will
be underlined, and if they have drifted far enough to be into a different alignment, then it will
be circled. They have to end three games in the zone of the new alignment to actually change
alignments.
M - Powers checks. They don't get to know what they were for (they should be able to figure it out) but
they do get to know how many, how severe, and whether or not they failed them. It hasn't ever
come out, but I do reserve the right to conceal a failed powers check if I have a reason to do so.
Star Points: Star points are earned for successful adventuring. First place gets three points, second place gets two, and third place gets one. An additional star point is given for the highest total of the roleplaying and alignment bonuses and one is given for the highest teamwork bonus. Thus, a single player can earn a maximum of five per game, although the average will be one or two per player.
Star points can be spent in a similar way to Action Points from some of the d20 systems. As it is proposed now, there are a variety of ways to spend them.
1 - Add +1d6 to a d20 roll.
1 - Automatically stabilize if below zero hit points.
1 - Reroll a damage roll.
1 - Automatically confirm a critical hit.
1 - Convert a fumble into a normal failure.
2 - Give a party member a Star Point.
5 - Permanently gain a hit point, up to the maximum that your character could possibly have.
10 - Retroactively change a permanent selection, such as a spell known for a sorcerer, a chosen domain,
or a feat selection. This cannot be used to change a selection which is a prerequisite for a later
selection.
20 - Gain a permanent skill point.
25 - Gain a permanent feat.
30 - Raise one ability score by +1.
What do you all think of this system? Do you foresee any complications you think that I've blithely ignored? Can you think of any alternative uses for Star Points that I haven't come up with? One of my players has expressed interest in seeing more ways to spend them. Next Friday, they will finally receive and be able to use their points from the last season, so I would love some feedback between here and then.

Here's a breakdown:
A - Game number. It's presented like a periodical, with each 'season' running in ten episode arcs.
B - Character name. This is a character that doesn't actually exist in my game. Fritz is level 5.
C - Combat XP. I just lump it all together. They know what they fought. It's the other areas where they
may not know what they earned XP for.
D - Bucking the script XP. I tend to script out my games, with backups and contingencies to keep my PCs
'on-plot.' That being said, I am not going to plot-hammer them. If they legitimately find a way
around my script, then more power to them, and I will reward them appropriately.
E - Contact XP. The PCs earn a small amount of XP for making positive contact with NPCs.
F - Non combat challenges. They also earn XP for overcoming challenges without resorting to violence.
G - Plot completion. When the PCs wrap up a story, they earn a bonus for completing it. This gives
them an impetus to wrap up the current storyline before taking downtime.
H - Teamwork bonus. Can be awarded more than once per game. Always equal to the average party
level times five.
I - Roleplaying bonus. Usually awarded more than once per game. Always equal to the average party
level times three. I calculated Fritz's XP incorrectly here. It should be 15.
J - Alignment XP. Equal to the party level times the number of adherent alignment ticks. (See below.)
K - Total, including overall place in the group, since two players rarely have the same total.
L - Alignment drift. I use a system of alignment ticks along a numeric graph to track alignment. While
players are not privy to their exact score, they are told each week which direction their net
drift for that week inclined. If they drift five or more ticks in one direction, the alignment will
be underlined, and if they have drifted far enough to be into a different alignment, then it will
be circled. They have to end three games in the zone of the new alignment to actually change
alignments.
M - Powers checks. They don't get to know what they were for (they should be able to figure it out) but
they do get to know how many, how severe, and whether or not they failed them. It hasn't ever
come out, but I do reserve the right to conceal a failed powers check if I have a reason to do so.
Star Points: Star points are earned for successful adventuring. First place gets three points, second place gets two, and third place gets one. An additional star point is given for the highest total of the roleplaying and alignment bonuses and one is given for the highest teamwork bonus. Thus, a single player can earn a maximum of five per game, although the average will be one or two per player.
Star points can be spent in a similar way to Action Points from some of the d20 systems. As it is proposed now, there are a variety of ways to spend them.
1 - Add +1d6 to a d20 roll.
1 - Automatically stabilize if below zero hit points.
1 - Reroll a damage roll.
1 - Automatically confirm a critical hit.
1 - Convert a fumble into a normal failure.
2 - Give a party member a Star Point.
5 - Permanently gain a hit point, up to the maximum that your character could possibly have.
10 - Retroactively change a permanent selection, such as a spell known for a sorcerer, a chosen domain,
or a feat selection. This cannot be used to change a selection which is a prerequisite for a later
selection.
20 - Gain a permanent skill point.
25 - Gain a permanent feat.
30 - Raise one ability score by +1.
What do you all think of this system? Do you foresee any complications you think that I've blithely ignored? Can you think of any alternative uses for Star Points that I haven't come up with? One of my players has expressed interest in seeing more ways to spend them. Next Friday, they will finally receive and be able to use their points from the last season, so I would love some feedback between here and then.
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign ...and it is always Stars...
So Friday's game is in the bag. It was a fairly slow night.
Scottmeister Vartzog gave the party the opportunity to kill the NPC who had screwed them over in the last game session, but they declined. So, Lucinde goes into the 'recurring villains' catalogue. They realized that Franky had come down with a nasty case of mummy rot, and then fell into the plotline with Dr. Mordenheim. Shockingly, Ulrich was the one who was the most opposed, with Joram (the usual source for moral outrage) being bang alongside letting Franky go under the knife. Mordenheim's surgery successfully cured the disease. They've left Sasha with him for cloning.
As a side note, I ran into an unexpected difficulty. While RPing Mordenheim, I had to fight the urge to burst into maniacal villain laughter every single second. I dunno what it is about him, but I managed to keep it under control.
Then, back to Lagenhaven. Franky surprised me by purchasing property in town. They are debating what to do with the little girl (the junky that Joram rescued) and Ulrich has begun to get the impression that she harbors a distinct darkness within her. They took their downtime to level up, and are currently debating what to do.
Scottmeister Vartzog gave the party the opportunity to kill the NPC who had screwed them over in the last game session, but they declined. So, Lucinde goes into the 'recurring villains' catalogue. They realized that Franky had come down with a nasty case of mummy rot, and then fell into the plotline with Dr. Mordenheim. Shockingly, Ulrich was the one who was the most opposed, with Joram (the usual source for moral outrage) being bang alongside letting Franky go under the knife. Mordenheim's surgery successfully cured the disease. They've left Sasha with him for cloning.
As a side note, I ran into an unexpected difficulty. While RPing Mordenheim, I had to fight the urge to burst into maniacal villain laughter every single second. I dunno what it is about him, but I managed to keep it under control.
Then, back to Lagenhaven. Franky surprised me by purchasing property in town. They are debating what to do with the little girl (the junky that Joram rescued) and Ulrich has begun to get the impression that she harbors a distinct darkness within her. They took their downtime to level up, and are currently debating what to do.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign ...and it is always Stars...
When giving the PCs XP from fights AND from other things, beware the rate they gain XP. I would suggest halving the XP from combat and increasing the XP from other things to compensate. Of course, it's all up to how fast you want your PCs to level.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign ...and it is always Stars...
I'm always wary of making XP into a competition. It doesn't go over well in some groups, with people trying to outdo each other to the detriment of the game. RPGs are collaborative IMHO, and not Player vs. DM or even Player vs. Player. But if works for your players, go ahead. (Personally, I would allow the "change a permanent choice" for most things for free if there's a good reason for it.)
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign ...and it is always Stars...
I totally agree with you alhoon, that has been my experience. I don't quite halve the XP from combat, but it is reduced.
And Gonzoron, so far the variable XP hasn't turned into a competition. I've never had a problem with it up to now, but I can always change it if things start to get too out of control. Since a large part of the XP awards are based around successful teamwork and a good group dynamic, I think it helps balance out any competition related problems. I appreciate the feedback, though, especially since I get the impression that you've had more experience (especially in Ravenloft) than I have.
And Gonzoron, so far the variable XP hasn't turned into a competition. I've never had a problem with it up to now, but I can always change it if things start to get too out of control. Since a large part of the XP awards are based around successful teamwork and a good group dynamic, I think it helps balance out any competition related problems. I appreciate the feedback, though, especially since I get the impression that you've had more experience (especially in Ravenloft) than I have.
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign ...and it is always Stars...
So, with the first ten game sessions now behind me, I feel like my game is running at a steady clip.
Now, since Ravenloft requires a bit more preparation to maintain proper mood, I prefer to avoid all the random tables. I dont ever do random treasure in Ravenloft, since it seems like a recipe for disaster. I do recognize that the CR system is set up with the assumption that the PCs will have a certain amount of loot at their disposal (both in financial resources and superior equipment) so I try and keep that as close to the PC wealth by level table. I keep all their accumulated (accessible) wealth totaled with a system of cards, one card for each equipment item of superior or better quality, plus an additional card for myself that notes aspects of their character that impacts their wealth that they may not be privy to.
Now, here's the question. I'm handing out the following magical item in my game, but I am not sure what the market price on it should be.
Sword of Sacrifice - A mundane falchion, the Sword of Sacrifice can easily be mistaken for a nonmagical blade, which it usually is. After the first time in a given day that the blade draws blood, however, it gains an enchantment bonus which varies based on the corruption of the person whom it struck.
+1 - Evil
+2 - The User
+3 - Neutral
+4 - Good
+5 - Innocent
The enchantment bonus lasts until the stroke of midnight, at which point the blade loses any such bonus. A minor nick is not sufficient to grant a bonus, it must be a real attack. The wielder must use their full strength; no "pulling your punch" in order to avoid damage to yourself. (Or an ally!) If the wielder inflicts a wound later in the day that would qualify the blade for a better enhancement bonus, then the higher bonus replaces the lower one for the duration of the day. Note that in order to gain the enhancement, the blade must draw blood. In other words, the attack must hit a living target, which means undead, constructs, and elementals (except for blood elementals) do not qualify.
I'm tempted to set the price around 18000 gp. It seems like the sword is going to spend most of its time with a +1 bonus, occasionally getting a +2, and rarely a +3. I don't think that I'll ever see it at a +4 or higher, certainly not in this game. So what do you guys think?
Now, since Ravenloft requires a bit more preparation to maintain proper mood, I prefer to avoid all the random tables. I dont ever do random treasure in Ravenloft, since it seems like a recipe for disaster. I do recognize that the CR system is set up with the assumption that the PCs will have a certain amount of loot at their disposal (both in financial resources and superior equipment) so I try and keep that as close to the PC wealth by level table. I keep all their accumulated (accessible) wealth totaled with a system of cards, one card for each equipment item of superior or better quality, plus an additional card for myself that notes aspects of their character that impacts their wealth that they may not be privy to.
Now, here's the question. I'm handing out the following magical item in my game, but I am not sure what the market price on it should be.
Sword of Sacrifice - A mundane falchion, the Sword of Sacrifice can easily be mistaken for a nonmagical blade, which it usually is. After the first time in a given day that the blade draws blood, however, it gains an enchantment bonus which varies based on the corruption of the person whom it struck.
+1 - Evil
+2 - The User
+3 - Neutral
+4 - Good
+5 - Innocent
The enchantment bonus lasts until the stroke of midnight, at which point the blade loses any such bonus. A minor nick is not sufficient to grant a bonus, it must be a real attack. The wielder must use their full strength; no "pulling your punch" in order to avoid damage to yourself. (Or an ally!) If the wielder inflicts a wound later in the day that would qualify the blade for a better enhancement bonus, then the higher bonus replaces the lower one for the duration of the day. Note that in order to gain the enhancement, the blade must draw blood. In other words, the attack must hit a living target, which means undead, constructs, and elementals (except for blood elementals) do not qualify.
I'm tempted to set the price around 18000 gp. It seems like the sword is going to spend most of its time with a +1 bonus, occasionally getting a +2, and rarely a +3. I don't think that I'll ever see it at a +4 or higher, certainly not in this game. So what do you guys think?
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign - How much should it cost?
I'd price it as a +2. In the hands of a good party, that's what it will be most of the time. The occasional boost up to +3 (or higher, perhaps by accident) is balanced by the likely need to whack yourself with it once a day and expend healing resources to compensate. I would assume from the "pulling your punch" clause that taking the -4 to hit to deal nonlethal damage is disallowed. But I would also assume that you aren't required to use extra sources of damage if available (power attack, sneak attack, weapon crystals, strength-enhancing magic items...) So 2d4 hp per day more than balances an occasional higher bonus.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Zilfer
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4231
- Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
- Contact:
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign - How much should it cost?
I agree, with Mr. ron above me. A +2 price seems about right, (8,000g) for what it is. Unless the party is evil in which case... they'll eventually have many more 'toy's then this from the dark powers.
Re: Ongoing Ravenloft Campaign - How much should it cost?
Thanks guys! While the party is neutral as an average, the character in question is good, so I am sure he will appreciate the price reduction (although he won't necassarily ever find out, lol) and the commensurate extra loot he will get.
