Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
Sure, that'd be great.
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
Before we go on, my version of Bluebeard. Mine has as little interpretation from the Darklords version as possible, except I think I gave him an extra level for the passing of time, and did a bit of fluffing around his wives.
Bluebeard (Blaustein)
Timeline
c600 BC Born in Prime Material Blaustein.
c622 BC Inherits Castle Blaustein and great wealth. Marries his first wife.
c625 BC Suspecting her of infidelity with a bard, Bluebeard kills her.
c627 BC Remarries.
c629 BC Strangles her in her sleep. Later that year, remarries.
c630 BC Leaves her to starve to death in the base of the Castle.
c631 BC Marries Marcella. She lasts about 2 months before he slits her throat. Over the next few years, does away with 3 more women in increasingly cruel ways as they prove themselves disloyal to him.
c637 BC Murders his eighth (somewhere between 6 and 8 ) wife. Becomes darklord of Blaustein (probably as an Island of Terror, but possibly not). Kills 2 (or 2-4) more wives over the next century; the most recent of which is Lorel, who he blinds and rips out the tongue of her brother before killing them both.
c741 BC Blaustein joins the Sea of Sorrows (if it hasn’t already).
760 BC Present day.
Powers Checks
Caress (Betrayal and Violence: murdering his first wife: 32%; c625 BC): Sense Motive becomes a class skill.
Enticement (Betrayal and Violence: murders his third wife increasingly sadistically: 16%; c630 BC): Discern lies.
Invitation (Betrayal and Violence: murders his fourth wife Marcella: 8%; c631 BC): Charm person.
Embrace (Betrayal and Violence: murders his sixth wife sadistically with the ghosts of his previous wives: 4%; c636 BC): Immune to negative levels.
Creature (Betrayal and Violence: murders his eighth wife: 2%; c637 BC): Becomes darklord of Blaustein. Utter loyalty, master of the castle, murderous charisma.
Base stats
S 16 D 16 C 13 I 12 W 9 Ch 7 (high fantasy)
Racial: Str +2 (caliban)
Levelling: Str +1, Dex +1
Favoured class: skills
CR 10 (8 [levels] + 1 [PC-level treasure] + 1 [darklord abilities])
760 BC (Current day stats)
CR 10 XP 9,600
Male Caliban Fighter 9
LE Medium Humanoid (Crossbreed)
Init: +3 (Dex) Senses: Lowlight vision, Perception +10
Defense
AC 22 Touch 14 Flat-footed 19 (+3 Dex, +8 armour, +1 deflection)
hp 63 (10 + 8d10 + 9)
Fort +8, Ref +7, Will +3 (+2 vs charm, sleep)
Bravery +2
SR 15
Immune to negative levels
Offense
Spd 30 ft
Melee +3 mithral straight razor +20/+15 (1d4+12, crit 19+)
+3 mithral straight razor +17/+12 (1d4+18, crit 19+ with Power Attack)
+3 mithral straight razor +15/+10 (1d4+12 plus 1d4 bleed, crit 19+ with Bloody Assault)
Unarmed strike +15/+10 (1d3+6 plus Intimidate)
Space/Reach: 5’/5’
S 19 (21) D 17 C 13 I 12 W 9 Ch 12
BAB +9 CMB +14 CMD 28 (25)
Feats
Alertness, Betrayer, Bloody Assault, Enforcer, Persuasive, Power Attack, Quick Draw, Uncanny Alertness, Weapon Focus (dagger), Weapon Specialisation (dagger)
Skills
Bluff +10 (6), Climb +6 (0), Diplomacy +13 (7), Intimidate +14 (3), Knowledge (local) +5 (4), Perception +10 (8), Sense Motive +13 (8)
Languages
Blausteiner*, Mordentish
Treasure
(34,000 gp/45,000 gp)
Belt of giant strength +2, circlet of persuasion, ring of protection +1, cloak of resistance +1, +2 agile breastplate, +3 mithral straight razor.
Special
Ferocity
Intimidating
Weapon Training (light blades +2, close +1)
Armour Training 2
Bravery
Discern lies, charm person at will
Utter loyalty
Master of the castle
Murderous Charisma
Sinkhole of evil
Bluebeard (Blaustein)
Timeline
c600 BC Born in Prime Material Blaustein.
c622 BC Inherits Castle Blaustein and great wealth. Marries his first wife.
c625 BC Suspecting her of infidelity with a bard, Bluebeard kills her.
c627 BC Remarries.
c629 BC Strangles her in her sleep. Later that year, remarries.
c630 BC Leaves her to starve to death in the base of the Castle.
c631 BC Marries Marcella. She lasts about 2 months before he slits her throat. Over the next few years, does away with 3 more women in increasingly cruel ways as they prove themselves disloyal to him.
c637 BC Murders his eighth (somewhere between 6 and 8 ) wife. Becomes darklord of Blaustein (probably as an Island of Terror, but possibly not). Kills 2 (or 2-4) more wives over the next century; the most recent of which is Lorel, who he blinds and rips out the tongue of her brother before killing them both.
c741 BC Blaustein joins the Sea of Sorrows (if it hasn’t already).
760 BC Present day.
Powers Checks
Caress (Betrayal and Violence: murdering his first wife: 32%; c625 BC): Sense Motive becomes a class skill.
Enticement (Betrayal and Violence: murders his third wife increasingly sadistically: 16%; c630 BC): Discern lies.
Invitation (Betrayal and Violence: murders his fourth wife Marcella: 8%; c631 BC): Charm person.
Embrace (Betrayal and Violence: murders his sixth wife sadistically with the ghosts of his previous wives: 4%; c636 BC): Immune to negative levels.
Creature (Betrayal and Violence: murders his eighth wife: 2%; c637 BC): Becomes darklord of Blaustein. Utter loyalty, master of the castle, murderous charisma.
Base stats
S 16 D 16 C 13 I 12 W 9 Ch 7 (high fantasy)
Racial: Str +2 (caliban)
Levelling: Str +1, Dex +1
Favoured class: skills
CR 10 (8 [levels] + 1 [PC-level treasure] + 1 [darklord abilities])
760 BC (Current day stats)
CR 10 XP 9,600
Male Caliban Fighter 9
LE Medium Humanoid (Crossbreed)
Init: +3 (Dex) Senses: Lowlight vision, Perception +10
Defense
AC 22 Touch 14 Flat-footed 19 (+3 Dex, +8 armour, +1 deflection)
hp 63 (10 + 8d10 + 9)
Fort +8, Ref +7, Will +3 (+2 vs charm, sleep)
Bravery +2
SR 15
Immune to negative levels
Offense
Spd 30 ft
Melee +3 mithral straight razor +20/+15 (1d4+12, crit 19+)
+3 mithral straight razor +17/+12 (1d4+18, crit 19+ with Power Attack)
+3 mithral straight razor +15/+10 (1d4+12 plus 1d4 bleed, crit 19+ with Bloody Assault)
Unarmed strike +15/+10 (1d3+6 plus Intimidate)
Space/Reach: 5’/5’
S 19 (21) D 17 C 13 I 12 W 9 Ch 12
BAB +9 CMB +14 CMD 28 (25)
Feats
Alertness, Betrayer, Bloody Assault, Enforcer, Persuasive, Power Attack, Quick Draw, Uncanny Alertness, Weapon Focus (dagger), Weapon Specialisation (dagger)
Skills
Bluff +10 (6), Climb +6 (0), Diplomacy +13 (7), Intimidate +14 (3), Knowledge (local) +5 (4), Perception +10 (8), Sense Motive +13 (8)
Languages
Blausteiner*, Mordentish
Treasure
(34,000 gp/45,000 gp)
Belt of giant strength +2, circlet of persuasion, ring of protection +1, cloak of resistance +1, +2 agile breastplate, +3 mithral straight razor.
Special
Ferocity
Intimidating
Weapon Training (light blades +2, close +1)
Armour Training 2
Bravery
Discern lies, charm person at will
Utter loyalty
Master of the castle
Murderous Charisma
Sinkhole of evil
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
You didn't give him a modify memory ability? You made the people loyal with Utter loyalty?
What is Ferocity and Murderous Charisma?
What is Ferocity and Murderous Charisma?
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
In retrospect, I shouldn't have changed the methods of his wives' deaths. You are correct there. I'm not sure what I was thinking. Also, where you've added extra wives over and above the ones mentioned by Darklords is good too.
Ferocity is a Pathfinder half-orc trait where you get to remain conscious for 1 round at negative hit points, because you're too bad tempered to die. I think it suits him.
He gets SR from being a caliban too, which was on the Darklords stats but you seem to have forgotten. You've also forgotten he's immune to death effects. Unless you left them out rather than forgot them.
Utter loyalty includes the modify memory ability. The problem is, modify memory as a spell-like ability affects 1 person at a time, so the scene where they lynch the tavern wench and are all convinced she's a stranger doesn't make sense unless Bluebeard was up all night, modifying everyone's memory individually.
The idea behind utter loyalty was that it affects all Blaustein's natives at once: they are so loyal to him, they all forget what he wants them forget immediately. Or if he tells them he was part of the daring raid on Martira Bay, they believe him. It also includes the slavish devotion his wives have. It just smooths out the spell - everyone responds at once.
Murderous charisma is drawn from the idea that he's getting more handsome over time. I added a mechanic, whereas you left it narratively. He gains half a point of Charisma each time he kills a wife (although he doesn't really understand that's what's going on - he just behaves the way he behaves, and gets better looking over time). With 8 wives, that's 4 points of Cha (taking him to 12 - OK, but nothing really special). With your higher number of wives, I'd change it to 1 point per 4 wives (Cha 13 from the 20) or 1 point per 3, for those he marries after becoming a darklord (Cha 12 again from the 12 post-darklord wives).
Ferocity is a Pathfinder half-orc trait where you get to remain conscious for 1 round at negative hit points, because you're too bad tempered to die. I think it suits him.
He gets SR from being a caliban too, which was on the Darklords stats but you seem to have forgotten. You've also forgotten he's immune to death effects. Unless you left them out rather than forgot them.
Utter loyalty includes the modify memory ability. The problem is, modify memory as a spell-like ability affects 1 person at a time, so the scene where they lynch the tavern wench and are all convinced she's a stranger doesn't make sense unless Bluebeard was up all night, modifying everyone's memory individually.
The idea behind utter loyalty was that it affects all Blaustein's natives at once: they are so loyal to him, they all forget what he wants them forget immediately. Or if he tells them he was part of the daring raid on Martira Bay, they believe him. It also includes the slavish devotion his wives have. It just smooths out the spell - everyone responds at once.
Murderous charisma is drawn from the idea that he's getting more handsome over time. I added a mechanic, whereas you left it narratively. He gains half a point of Charisma each time he kills a wife (although he doesn't really understand that's what's going on - he just behaves the way he behaves, and gets better looking over time). With 8 wives, that's 4 points of Cha (taking him to 12 - OK, but nothing really special). With your higher number of wives, I'd change it to 1 point per 4 wives (Cha 13 from the 20) or 1 point per 3, for those he marries after becoming a darklord (Cha 12 again from the 12 post-darklord wives).
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
My feedback on Bluebeard himself (Blaustein will come later):
As I said before, generally, I think it's quite good. There's a few things I would change, but overall I think it's a pretty good cut.
In no particular order:
Mordentish and Dementlieuese are the same language, Mordentish (or High and Low dialects). Why speak Falkovnian? It's not like they have a large pirate contingent. Surely Darkonese would be more likely if Blausten's been in Darkon's neighbourhood for 150 years?
I've already commented on modify memory above, but again, it needs a broader scope than an individual touch. While on the spell-like abilities, I really like the dream, but I would cut suggestion. I think it's important (both thematically and to Bluebeard himself) that the girl should damn herself (by answering his call), not being compelled to do it. As Darklords says, it's girls who are greedy or foolish, not girls who rolled a 5 on their Will saves. Essentially, he wants them to prove themselves "Worthy." I also like him being immune to all the abilities of his wives.
I'm curious why you include mechanics for mutilating touch and know inner desire. The latter seems redundant when you can detect thoughts, Sense Motive and charm; the former is mechanically weak (if I rip off half of your hand, you lose 1d6 hit points? Really?) and... odd. Henredon, after all, was willing. It also put him out of action for hours. Personally, I'd cut it, but if you want to keep it, bulk it up. Make it so he can do Con damage on a critical hit or a coup de grace or something.
I'm also not really fond of Key to Freedom. Realistically, he might as well just hang around Blausteiner waters waiting for his wife to fail rather than sight seeing in Dementlieu. And then modify memory if he feels like it. It's getting at one of the fundamental laws of Ravenloft, which makes me a bit uneasy, as well as thinking it's redundant.
However, I do love the ideas of the the key, the gems and the mirror as magic items. Very elegantly done.
On his personality, I like that he likes getting his hands dirty (as it were) in combat.
My impression from Darklords and Tales of Ravenloft (particularly ToR) is that he really is ill bred as suspected, he just hides it behind a veneer of respectability. He's bourgeoisie, with no "true breeding" - hence the gauche display of wealth and odd taste in clothes. It also fits well with his character themes, I think. Finally, we've got quite a lot of actual aristocrats running around; I like the idea he's a tasteless, pretentious, moneyed social climber.
In his history, I'm not sure that killing someone who's trying to poison you is evil. Even killing someone who is trying to steal your possessions seems neutral rather than evil.
I think Bluebeard's true evil is in the way he sadistically tests people - his little traps for his wives, his little trap for Henredon. It seems to me he's motivated more by his desire to control people, not by having people prove themselves worthy to him (even if it's dressed up as proving themselves worthy). He sets people up to fail rather than actually testing them - since he can read minds, he knows your flaws, and there's no real way to pass his tests to prove worthy. He's a tyrant. Or even more appropriately, a rapist - he's motivated by the same desire to have power over people (particularly women, but not exclusively) that a rapist does. Which is perhaps a consequence of growing up a reviled and ugly caliban. He's trying to prove himself superior to everyone else in the world by adopting high class manners and wealth, and humiliating and degrading people with his tests. His sympathetic character is that a lot of people feel isolated or powerless as children and dream about lashing out in revenge; he's a foil for lonely outsiders (as well as a vile mass murdering thug). I think the seeds of that are there, you just need to bring it through a bit more strongly/clearly.
As I said before, generally, I think it's quite good. There's a few things I would change, but overall I think it's a pretty good cut.
In no particular order:
Mordentish and Dementlieuese are the same language, Mordentish (or High and Low dialects). Why speak Falkovnian? It's not like they have a large pirate contingent. Surely Darkonese would be more likely if Blausten's been in Darkon's neighbourhood for 150 years?
I've already commented on modify memory above, but again, it needs a broader scope than an individual touch. While on the spell-like abilities, I really like the dream, but I would cut suggestion. I think it's important (both thematically and to Bluebeard himself) that the girl should damn herself (by answering his call), not being compelled to do it. As Darklords says, it's girls who are greedy or foolish, not girls who rolled a 5 on their Will saves. Essentially, he wants them to prove themselves "Worthy." I also like him being immune to all the abilities of his wives.
I'm curious why you include mechanics for mutilating touch and know inner desire. The latter seems redundant when you can detect thoughts, Sense Motive and charm; the former is mechanically weak (if I rip off half of your hand, you lose 1d6 hit points? Really?) and... odd. Henredon, after all, was willing. It also put him out of action for hours. Personally, I'd cut it, but if you want to keep it, bulk it up. Make it so he can do Con damage on a critical hit or a coup de grace or something.
I'm also not really fond of Key to Freedom. Realistically, he might as well just hang around Blausteiner waters waiting for his wife to fail rather than sight seeing in Dementlieu. And then modify memory if he feels like it. It's getting at one of the fundamental laws of Ravenloft, which makes me a bit uneasy, as well as thinking it's redundant.
However, I do love the ideas of the the key, the gems and the mirror as magic items. Very elegantly done.
On his personality, I like that he likes getting his hands dirty (as it were) in combat.
My impression from Darklords and Tales of Ravenloft (particularly ToR) is that he really is ill bred as suspected, he just hides it behind a veneer of respectability. He's bourgeoisie, with no "true breeding" - hence the gauche display of wealth and odd taste in clothes. It also fits well with his character themes, I think. Finally, we've got quite a lot of actual aristocrats running around; I like the idea he's a tasteless, pretentious, moneyed social climber.
In his history, I'm not sure that killing someone who's trying to poison you is evil. Even killing someone who is trying to steal your possessions seems neutral rather than evil.
I think Bluebeard's true evil is in the way he sadistically tests people - his little traps for his wives, his little trap for Henredon. It seems to me he's motivated more by his desire to control people, not by having people prove themselves worthy to him (even if it's dressed up as proving themselves worthy). He sets people up to fail rather than actually testing them - since he can read minds, he knows your flaws, and there's no real way to pass his tests to prove worthy. He's a tyrant. Or even more appropriately, a rapist - he's motivated by the same desire to have power over people (particularly women, but not exclusively) that a rapist does. Which is perhaps a consequence of growing up a reviled and ugly caliban. He's trying to prove himself superior to everyone else in the world by adopting high class manners and wealth, and humiliating and degrading people with his tests. His sympathetic character is that a lot of people feel isolated or powerless as children and dream about lashing out in revenge; he's a foil for lonely outsiders (as well as a vile mass murdering thug). I think the seeds of that are there, you just need to bring it through a bit more strongly/clearly.
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
i'm just curious. what sinkholes of evil are on the island.
Not every Angel alights the sky with feathery wings of Glory,
Nor every Demon with cloven hoof hunts unwary Quarry.
No, but evil exists in this world and in the hearts of us all,
For let us not forget even the greatest of Angels fell.
Nor every Demon with cloven hoof hunts unwary Quarry.
No, but evil exists in this world and in the hearts of us all,
For let us not forget even the greatest of Angels fell.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
As I read, I'll comment:
Paka: I liked the article, quite detailed and all. However, it gives the impression that there are many communities of Paka in the core, making them among the numerous monsters. Personally, I would think that the Paka were less than 500 in the whole core, and I have a Core of 2Million people.
Anyway, I especially liked how the article supported multiple editions. For the 4th edition stats, I would say that the lick wounds should IMO be daily power.
Fluff wise, I liked how the paka are not the usual "serial killer in an animal's costume" but use lies, money and influence to achieve their goals.
If I may say, I would say that "what's missing" is information or actually more details on "cat&mouse" games in deadly labyrinths that I think the "playfully cruel" and "sport-loving" Paka would make. I mean something like a large labyrinth where enemies are thrown in and trapped to be led this way or that by taunting Paka with blades to be slowly worn down till they're actually killed. An abandoned mine with painful but not deadly traps would be nice. Some pools with rancid water for the quarry to be forced to drink also.
Perhaps some Paka in the labyrinth aren't in the "nudging forward" pack but ambush the quarry, force something bad on him and let him go before the others come. Like "In order to cut you down from this net so the others won't slowly chop you, I want you to cut your little finger. Else the others will come with the razors and find you trapped."
I have some things in my mind. I may put them in to a post sometime.
Paka: I liked the article, quite detailed and all. However, it gives the impression that there are many communities of Paka in the core, making them among the numerous monsters. Personally, I would think that the Paka were less than 500 in the whole core, and I have a Core of 2Million people.
Anyway, I especially liked how the article supported multiple editions. For the 4th edition stats, I would say that the lick wounds should IMO be daily power.
Fluff wise, I liked how the paka are not the usual "serial killer in an animal's costume" but use lies, money and influence to achieve their goals.
If I may say, I would say that "what's missing" is information or actually more details on "cat&mouse" games in deadly labyrinths that I think the "playfully cruel" and "sport-loving" Paka would make. I mean something like a large labyrinth where enemies are thrown in and trapped to be led this way or that by taunting Paka with blades to be slowly worn down till they're actually killed. An abandoned mine with painful but not deadly traps would be nice. Some pools with rancid water for the quarry to be forced to drink also.
Perhaps some Paka in the labyrinth aren't in the "nudging forward" pack but ambush the quarry, force something bad on him and let him go before the others come. Like "In order to cut you down from this net so the others won't slowly chop you, I want you to cut your little finger. Else the others will come with the razors and find you trapped."
I have some things in my mind. I may put them in to a post sometime.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
I remember Ron pushing to add a few extra moreRyan Naylor wrote:In retrospect, I shouldn't have changed the methods of his wives' deaths. You are correct there. I'm not sure what I was thinking. Also, where you've added extra wives over and above the ones mentioned by Darklords is good too.
Great idea indeed.Ferocity is a Pathfinder half-orc trait where you get to remain conscious for 1 round at negative hit points, because you're too bad tempered to die. I think it suits him.
Well indeed we chose to forget this, we thought his 2e 10 % magic resistance wasn’t an important feature.He gets SR from being a caliban too, which was on the Darklords stats but you seem to have forgotten.
Please remind me, where it is said that caliban get SR?
Well when 2e specters drained levels, it made sense to made him immune to level drains, but when making them ghosts, we thought i twas better suited to make him immune to the wives.You've also forgotten he's immune to death effects. Unless you left them out rather than forgot them.
The concept is better indeed. But what I had in mind is mass modify memory or somthing like that.Utter loyalty includes the modify memory ability. The problem is, modify memory as a spell-like ability affects 1 person at a time, so the scene where they lynch the tavern wench and are all convinced she's a stranger doesn't make sense unless Bluebeard was up all night, modifying everyone's memory individually.
The idea behind utter loyalty was that it affects all Blaustein's natives at once: they are so loyal to him, they all forget what he wants them forget immediately. Or if he tells them he was part of the daring raid on Martira Bay, they believe him. It also includes the slavish devotion his wives have. It just smooths out the spell - everyone responds at once.
What is the source of Utter Loyalty?
Great idea! I hade him getting more handsome with time, but that mechanic is better.Murderous charisma is drawn from the idea that he's getting more handsome over time. I added a mechanic, whereas you left it narratively. He gains half a point of Charisma each time he kills a wife (although he doesn't really understand that's what's going on - he just behaves the way he behaves, and gets better looking over time). With 8 wives, that's 4 points of Cha (taking him to 12 - OK, but nothing really special). With your higher number of wives, I'd change it to 1 point per 4 wives (Cha 13 from the 20) or 1 point per 3, for those he marries after becoming a darklord (Cha 12 again from the 12 post-darklord wives).
Are they?Ryan Naylor wrote: Mordentish and Dementlieuese are the same language, Mordentish (or High and Low dialects). Why speak Falkovnian? It's not like they have a large pirate contingent. Surely Darkonese would be more likely if Blausten's been in Darkon's neighbourhood for 150 years?
Indeed, delete Dementlieuse and add Darkonese.
Yes, indeed, I think this precision is important. I’ll remove the suggestion part.I've already commented on modify memory above, but again, it needs a broader scope than an individual touch. While on the spell-like abilities, I really like the dream, but I would cut suggestion. I think it's important (both thematically and to Bluebeard himself) that the girl should damn herself (by answering his call), not being compelled to do it. As Darklords says, it's girls who are greedy or foolish, not girls who rolled a 5 on their Will saves. Essentially, he wants them to prove themselves "Worthy."
Mutilating TouchI'm curious why you include mechanics for mutilating touch and know inner desire. The latter seems redundant when you can detect thoughts, Sense Motive and charm; the former is mechanically weak (if I rip off half of your hand, you lose 1d6 hit points? Really?) and... odd. Henredon, after all, was willing. It also put him out of action for hours. Personally, I'd cut it, but if you want to keep it, bulk it up. Make it so he can do Con damage on a critical hit or a coup de grace or something.
We also saw him as the physical brute that loved to mutilate people, as per ToR. Seemed the physical abuser type. Who
loved to beat the weaker ones.
Perhaps Co damage is better, indeed, and even bigger damage on willing victims.
Know Inner desire
It made him a more precise abuser, a more clever cat know knowing exactly which button to push to make people fall. I’m not sure you get this after ten minutes of discern lies and detect thoughts?
I know, but I reallly like it! Exactly because it breaks a law, making it fun and unique, I thought. And it's fairly limited in time!I'm also not really fond of Key to Freedom. Realistically, he might as well just hang around Blausteiner waters waiting for his wife to fail rather than sight seeing in Dementlieu. And then modify memory if he feels like it. It's getting at one of the fundamental laws of Ravenloft, which makes me a bit uneasy, as well as thinking it's redundant.
Mmm, but if I'm the only one liking it… Other thoughts?
The Blaustein gems were a C Nichols idea, on which I expanded a lot, trying to stay within the theme.However, I do love the ideas of the the key, the gems and the mirror as magic items. Very elegantly done.
Good idea, indeed, I’ll add that precision.My impression from Darklords and Tales of Ravenloft (particularly ToR) is that he really is ill bred as suspected, he just hides it behind a veneer of respectability. He's bourgeoisie, with no "true breeding" - hence the gauche display of wealth and odd taste in clothes. It also fits well with his character themes, I think. Finally, we've got quite a lot of actual aristocrats running around; I like the idea he's a tasteless, pretentious, moneyed social climber.
I could put emphasis on him again being the judge and executionner, in that special case. He could have turned her to justice, but he chose to kill her instead.In his history, I'm not sure that killing someone who's trying to poison you is evil. Even killing someone who is trying to steal your possessions seems neutral rather than evil.
Interesting nuance, I like it.I think Bluebeard's true evil is in the way he sadistically tests people - his little traps for his wives, his little trap for Henredon. It seems to me he's motivated more by his desire to control people, not by having people prove themselves worthy to him (even if it's dressed up as proving themselves worthy). He sets people up to fail rather than actually testing them - since he can read minds, he knows your flaws, and there's no real way to pass his tests to prove worthy. He's a tyrant. Or even more appropriately, a rapist - he's motivated by the same desire to have power over people (particularly women, but not exclusively) that a rapist does.
Excellent!Which is perhaps a consequence of growing up a reviled and ugly caliban. He's trying to prove himself superior to everyone else in the world by adopting high class manners and wealth, and humiliating and degrading people with his tests.
BB’s Castle itself of course! But I’ll precise this in the final version. Maybe the castle is rank two, and the Hanging Room is rank three ?twinwolf wrote:i'm just curious. what sinkholes of evil are on the island.
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
- A G Thing
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1216
- Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
- Gender: Female
- Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
Just to add I also like the Key to Freedom ability because it allows him to bend a seemingly cardinal rule of Ravenloft that makes him seem unique.
Three days is not much time for any such escape from his domain as the majority of at least one or even two is spent most likely on a boat and he often races home for the third such day to avoid the consequences of staying away for too long. It is a mystery why he is so special compared to the other Darklords and lends itself well to throwing the PC's for a loop. Realistically he could use it to perhaps make some sort of inroads in the coastal domains. Perhaps other Darklords who's domains he enters are prevented from controlling that part as if his domain actually spreads while he travels making problems for them till he leaves. I also love that he does not seem to realize that he is different or even a Darklord as he thinks it is his curse only.
I once had a game where I had Hazlik make a magic using construct that imitated him outside of his domain (Nova Vaasa) when he had to perform some maneuvering politically and such. He even tried to recruit the PC's during the events to help him. The Golem allowed for Hazlik to control it for a short time but it was unstable like most constructs and if he lost control it could act as if him but often not how he wanted. Eventually I had Hazlik golem and his contingent have to leave when the story required under the excuse of ill health to cover the failing golem. My jaded PC's were surprised by it and questioned everything they thought they knew about Ravenloft for the rest of that game.
Three days is not much time for any such escape from his domain as the majority of at least one or even two is spent most likely on a boat and he often races home for the third such day to avoid the consequences of staying away for too long. It is a mystery why he is so special compared to the other Darklords and lends itself well to throwing the PC's for a loop. Realistically he could use it to perhaps make some sort of inroads in the coastal domains. Perhaps other Darklords who's domains he enters are prevented from controlling that part as if his domain actually spreads while he travels making problems for them till he leaves. I also love that he does not seem to realize that he is different or even a Darklord as he thinks it is his curse only.
I once had a game where I had Hazlik make a magic using construct that imitated him outside of his domain (Nova Vaasa) when he had to perform some maneuvering politically and such. He even tried to recruit the PC's during the events to help him. The Golem allowed for Hazlik to control it for a short time but it was unstable like most constructs and if he lost control it could act as if him but often not how he wanted. Eventually I had Hazlik golem and his contingent have to leave when the story required under the excuse of ill health to cover the failing golem. My jaded PC's were surprised by it and questioned everything they thought they knew about Ravenloft for the rest of that game.
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
I would think the Hanging Room would be rank 5, or at least 4. The castle as a whole is at least 3.
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
In my rules. It's not canon. Don't worry about it. I was just raising the issue of his vanishing 10% magic resistance.Joël of the FoS wrote:Well indeed we chose to forget this, we thought his 2e 10 % magic resistance wasn’t an important feature.
Please remind me, where it is said that caliban get SR?
Yes, I agree.Well when 2e specters drained levels, it made sense to made him immune to level drains, but when making them ghosts, we thought i twas better suited to make him immune to the wives.
Perfectly reasonable. It just needs to be clear in the stat block that that's how it works.The concept is better indeed. But what I had in mind is mass modify memory or somthing like that.
What is the source of Utter Loyalty?
I made it up.
I just think it's unnecessary, rather than fun. But it's your article, so do what you think is best.I know, but I reallly like it! Exactly because it breaks a law, making it fun and unique, I thought. And it's fairly limited in time!I'm also not really fond of Key to Freedom. Realistically, he might as well just hang around Blausteiner waters waiting for his wife to fail rather than sight seeing in Dementlieu. And then modify memory if he feels like it. It's getting at one of the fundamental laws of Ravenloft, which makes me a bit uneasy, as well as thinking it's redundant.
Mmm, but if I'm the only one liking it… Other thoughts?
A bit more on the domain itself: presumably the Blaustein flag would only be flow in Blaustein's water. You could quite easily steal the colours from captured ships, fly the stolen colours to get close to another, and then drop them to reveal the Blaustein flag when you're close enough to attack - a true narrative pirate tradition.
The empty grave is not all the unusual really. There are a lot of empty graves in the world where the body couldn't be recovered. It's less of a warning sign than you seem to think.
Finally, I really like Conomor. He's a great, very evocative character.
- Rock of the Fraternity
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 6844
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:16 pm
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
The Key to Freedom doesn't work that well for me, either. The whole basis of being a Darklord is that you are the ruler -- of your own personal hell / prison cell.
Rather than give Bluebeard the run of the oceans, why not expand the Domain borders of Blaustein a bit so its lord can go sailing, but never quite reach the mainland. You could add a little fang of rock of an island to the domain; Bluebeard can claim he stores his greatest treasures there for safe keeping, and he occasionally sails to it to do some accounting, which takes time.
In truth, Bluebeard enjoys the limited freedom of the open waves and waits for his latest wife to fail his test.
The little island could just be a barren rock, left well alone because Bluebeard inspires such loyalty. Alternatively, the island could be home to a tribe of debased, inbred creatures that normally prey on each other, but are delighted to mob and devour any intruders in search of Bluebeard's treasures, then burn their ships. It could be anything from humans to paka, to whatever you should desire. Morlocks, perhaps?
Rather than give Bluebeard the run of the oceans, why not expand the Domain borders of Blaustein a bit so its lord can go sailing, but never quite reach the mainland. You could add a little fang of rock of an island to the domain; Bluebeard can claim he stores his greatest treasures there for safe keeping, and he occasionally sails to it to do some accounting, which takes time.
In truth, Bluebeard enjoys the limited freedom of the open waves and waits for his latest wife to fail his test.
The little island could just be a barren rock, left well alone because Bluebeard inspires such loyalty. Alternatively, the island could be home to a tribe of debased, inbred creatures that normally prey on each other, but are delighted to mob and devour any intruders in search of Bluebeard's treasures, then burn their ships. It could be anything from humans to paka, to whatever you should desire. Morlocks, perhaps?
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
OK, I see the Key ability isn't making it, and I understand why.
Thanks AG Thing. I'll keep the ability, but will put it as a short DM's option, in a separate box. Will specify the geographical limits he can reach whithin 3 days - that is Mordent to Lamordia, and all the SoS islands. A few hours spend there, and back home the wives bring him back.
Will specify too that the wives cannot bring him back from a domain with borders closed - could be a fun adventure hook - bargain with a DL to keep BB inside and hunt him.
---
Rock, indeed the domain borders over water could be a bit larger for this domain, and the barren rock is a good idea too.
Ryan, ah, OK, that is why I couldn't find Utter Loyalty. I'll modify my modify memory to make it mass modify memory, and add more from your concept in it. Also, I think it would be good if he could exclude people from it. Conomor, for example, should be spared from it. BB needs at least one safe/sane person in the know.
Yes that is how I see pirates working the the Blaustein flag. Will clarify this in the text.
Didn't know there are empty graves where the body wasn't found. But it makes sense, to have a place for relatives to mourn. OK, that can be a lead but that isn't a proof that something is wrong.
Well Conomor is really based on the ToR story. I just found a reason to make him that.
---
Rank 3 for the Castle and 5 for the Hanging room? Could be indeed. I was trying to avoid 5th rank, as they are said to be extremely rare, but if I have support for it, I can go that way without problem. Makes sense.
Thanks AG Thing. I'll keep the ability, but will put it as a short DM's option, in a separate box. Will specify the geographical limits he can reach whithin 3 days - that is Mordent to Lamordia, and all the SoS islands. A few hours spend there, and back home the wives bring him back.
Will specify too that the wives cannot bring him back from a domain with borders closed - could be a fun adventure hook - bargain with a DL to keep BB inside and hunt him.
---
Rock, indeed the domain borders over water could be a bit larger for this domain, and the barren rock is a good idea too.
Ryan, ah, OK, that is why I couldn't find Utter Loyalty. I'll modify my modify memory to make it mass modify memory, and add more from your concept in it. Also, I think it would be good if he could exclude people from it. Conomor, for example, should be spared from it. BB needs at least one safe/sane person in the know.
Yes that is how I see pirates working the the Blaustein flag. Will clarify this in the text.
Didn't know there are empty graves where the body wasn't found. But it makes sense, to have a place for relatives to mourn. OK, that can be a lead but that isn't a proof that something is wrong.
Well Conomor is really based on the ToR story. I just found a reason to make him that.
---
Rank 3 for the Castle and 5 for the Hanging room? Could be indeed. I was trying to avoid 5th rank, as they are said to be extremely rare, but if I have support for it, I can go that way without problem. Makes sense.
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
- Zilfer
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4231
- Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
- Contact:
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
Forgive me, I haven't looked at the entry yet, however i will say a classic for a pirate base is to have an enterance that is only available at a certain time of a day. (easy to post watch as well because it's only accessable about twice a day. Usually low tide)
I did this during a Pirate hunting session my group went on... it wasn't ravenloft but it took just a little while to figure out why there was an X on the map that only lead to a huge cliff!
I did this during a Pirate hunting session my group went on... it wasn't ravenloft but it took just a little while to figure out why there was an X on the map that only lead to a huge cliff!
- Nathan of the FoS
- Fiendish Enforcer

- Posts: 5247
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
- Location: San Francisco CA
Re: Quoth the Raven #19 - discussion thread
We have one planned already!Joël of the FoS wrote: And the barren rock is a good idea too.
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:

