No, I mean that Strahd can *open* it. Before Soth kills Medraut, where is he going to get blood from Gundar's bloodline from to open it to send assassins through? After Soth kills Medraut, where is he going to get the blood to open it? After 736, why would he bother?
Secondly, there is no reason Strahd would know it was there. None of the people Gundar and Medraut sent through the portal would have arrived in Barovia if they'd been alive or tried to leave the path or fought the guardian. Given the sorts of people they employed, chances are they would have done one of those. And then, rather than rushing up to Strahd screaming that they'd come through a portal in Vallaki, if anyone did survive, they are surely more likely to slip quietly away from Gundar and his psychotic son.
In the book, none of Strahd, Gundar or Medraut seem to know where the portal goes to until Soth survives the trip.
Medraut from KotBR
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
Re: Medraut from KotBR
Yes, but I'm referring to the previous time the portal was opened, not with Medraut's blood, but that of his sister. That time, it was open for several years (596 to 608, according to the RL timeline). During those twelve years, whoever was on the other end of the portal would have been able to enter without using any blood at all.
So it's my proposal that, during those twelve years, the portal was NOT pointed to Vallaki. If it was, Strahd would have picked up on it, and used it somehow.
I'm not sure what you're trying to say here.
As for the people they sent through, I don't have the book, so I can't comment on what they were like. I'd find it suspicious, however, if neither of them sent a ghost through it, invisible and incorporeal, to bypass the guardians. IMC, I'm going to say that BOTH of them did this after the first round of exploring failed. Thus, both of them actually know a lot about where it leads (not Vallaki) but have hid it from each other so long that it's easy to bluff Soth on the matter.
So it's my proposal that, during those twelve years, the portal was NOT pointed to Vallaki. If it was, Strahd would have picked up on it, and used it somehow.
Secondly, there is no reason Strahd would know it was there. None of the people Gundar and Medraut sent through the portal would have arrived in Barovia if they'd been alive or tried to leave the path or fought the guardian.
I'm not sure what you're trying to say here.
True, but how many years would it take to reach Strahd that there was this strange portal? Even if it was invisible, people can blunder into it. How many people go down that alleyway in a year? How many of them have to vanish before Strahd took it upon himself to investigate?Given the sorts of people they employed, chances are they would have done one of those. And then, rather than rushing up to Strahd screaming that they'd come through a portal in Vallaki, if anyone did survive, they are surely more likely to slip quietly away from Gundar and his psychotic son.
That could be evidence that they had not investigated...or that they had investigated and were pretending not to know...or (in Strahd's case) that the portal didn't originally go to Vallaki. I'm in favor of the latter two. I'm especially disbelieving that Medraut and Gundar would not care to know where it goes. For Gundar, it's a tactical issue: hello, it bypasses all my defenses! For Medraut, we don't know a lot about him, but he did take steps to keep the portal open for twelve years. Why do this if he had no plan to study it?In the book, none of Strahd, Gundar or Medraut seem to know where the portal goes to until Soth survives the trip.
As for the people they sent through, I don't have the book, so I can't comment on what they were like. I'd find it suspicious, however, if neither of them sent a ghost through it, invisible and incorporeal, to bypass the guardians. IMC, I'm going to say that BOTH of them did this after the first round of exploring failed. Thus, both of them actually know a lot about where it leads (not Vallaki) but have hid it from each other so long that it's easy to bluff Soth on the matter.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: Medraut from KotBR
You really need to read the book.
The portal is guarded so that anything that tries to get through that has a soul is killed. Anything that wanders off the path between the portals or tries to evade the guardians is killed.
Furthermore, the guardian actually says nothing has ever gotten past her/survived her price.
No one of Gundar's bloodline can get through.
So any living creatures would die trying to get through. Vampires still have a soul in their body, so they can't get through. It crosses planar boundaries, so very little magic could be sent through (assuming that the guardian lets any through at all). From the description of the guardian, I don't think being invisible and incorporeal would help - she's clearly semicorporeal as well, and she collects souls, so a ghost isn't going to be able to get around her.
So no matter how important tactically it is to Gundar (and Strahd, from his end) to find out where the portal goes, they *can't find out*. If you can't pass the portal, you can't find out where it goes.
From Strahd's point of view, he's just had experience with another portal that is broken and nearly kills him. So, if he learns of the portal, I'd imagine he thinks its similar: all the old portals have broken during the transition to Ravenloft.
Maybe he just never finds out the portal is there. People vanish from Barovia all the time. Maybe he does know it's there, but assumes anyone who falls into it is being killed by the broken portal.
The portal is guarded so that anything that tries to get through that has a soul is killed. Anything that wanders off the path between the portals or tries to evade the guardians is killed.
Furthermore, the guardian actually says nothing has ever gotten past her/survived her price.
No one of Gundar's bloodline can get through.
So any living creatures would die trying to get through. Vampires still have a soul in their body, so they can't get through. It crosses planar boundaries, so very little magic could be sent through (assuming that the guardian lets any through at all). From the description of the guardian, I don't think being invisible and incorporeal would help - she's clearly semicorporeal as well, and she collects souls, so a ghost isn't going to be able to get around her.
So no matter how important tactically it is to Gundar (and Strahd, from his end) to find out where the portal goes, they *can't find out*. If you can't pass the portal, you can't find out where it goes.
From Strahd's point of view, he's just had experience with another portal that is broken and nearly kills him. So, if he learns of the portal, I'd imagine he thinks its similar: all the old portals have broken during the transition to Ravenloft.
Maybe he just never finds out the portal is there. People vanish from Barovia all the time. Maybe he does know it's there, but assumes anyone who falls into it is being killed by the broken portal.
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
Re: Medraut from KotBR
Read and loved it. Remembering the specifics, now that's the issue.Ryan Naylor wrote:You really need to read the book.
Okay, but what about turning around and going back? Is that considered "leaving the path"?The portal is guarded so that anything that tries to get through that has a soul is killed. Anything that wanders off the path between the portals or tries to evade the guardians is killed.
Okay, that's an important quote. Still, that's only referring to what she knows of, if she's telling the truth.Furthermore, the guardian actually says nothing has ever gotten past her/survived her price.
Interesting! So it does say that Medraut was unable to go through? I wondered about that as well.No one of Gundar's bloodline can get through.
Whoah, vampires have a soul in their body? Is there an official word on that. This is new.Vampires still have a soul in their body, so they can't get through.
It crosses planar boundaries, so very little magic could be sent through (assuming that the guardian lets any through at all).
I'd still love to see the list of things that Medraut sent through over the years, though!
Okay, if she's semicorporeal, that's a problem for ghosts. Likewise the collects souls thing. That being the case, a gaseous vampire would be next on my list. If you are right about vampires having souls, then that's out, too.From the description of the guardian, I don't think being invisible and incorporeal would help - she's clearly semicorporeal as well, and she collects souls, so a ghost isn't going to be able to get around her.
Well, going through it is hardly the only way to find out where it goes. A Legend Lore ought to do the trick, and either Strahd or Medraut could cast that.So no matter how important tactically it is to Gundar (and Strahd, from his end) to find out where the portal goes, they *can't find out*. If you can't pass the portal, you can't find out where it goes.
Great point. Which portal is that, that nearly killed him? Are you referring to the one with Azalin? Or is this something else from KotBR that I forgot?From Strahd's point of view, he's just had experience with another portal that is broken and nearly kills him. So, if he learns of the portal, I'd imagine he thinks its similar: all the old portals have broken during the transition to Ravenloft.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: Medraut from KotBR
It's great isn't it?DeepShadow of FoS wrote:Read and loved it. Remembering the specifics, now that's the issue.
Yes. Once you're in, you can't leave without paying the price.Okay, but what about turning around and going back? Is that considered "leaving the path"?
She's quite up front about everything else, so I see no reason for her to lie about that. She certainly doesn't sound like she's lying. And since she's the guardian, she'd probably know.Okay, that's an important quote. Still, that's only referring to what she knows of, if she's telling the truth.Furthermore, the guardian actually says nothing has ever gotten past her/survived her price.
Yes. He's named specifically.Interesting! So it does say that Medraut was unable to go through? I wondered about that as well.
VRGtV. Staking them (or otherwise killing them permanently) frees the soul, so they often get a look of peace on their faces as you stake them.Whoah, vampires have a soul in their body? Is there an official word on that. This is new.
It crosses planar boundaries, so very little magic could be sent through (assuming that the guardian lets any through at all).
Actually, checked again, and magic doesn't seem to work in her domain at all. So that limits the options even more.
Not on Strahd's spell listWell, going through it is hardly the only way to find out where it goes. A Legend Lore ought to do the trick, and either Strahd or Medraut could cast that.
Great point. Which portal is that, that nearly killed him? Are you referring to the one with Azalin? Or is this something else from KotBR that I forgot?
No, it's in KotBR. It's guarded by a gibbering mouther, but the portal opens into an inferno rather than going anywhere. It's just after Soth meets Azrael.
