I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Bluebomber4evr
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 450
Joined: Wed Mar 17, 2004 9:08 pm
Location: United States of Whatever
Contact:

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by Bluebomber4evr »

brilliantlight wrote:
Bluebomber4evr wrote:Also, this:
First it took worshipers of Venus from a world where she is well known and they started a sex cult dedicated to her.
C'mon, man. I'm hardly a prude, but this seems inappropriate. :|
Read about the Temple of Aphrodite at Corinth. It was basically a giant brothel. Sex cults were fairly common in the ancient world. It isn't like I gave a lurid description or anything.
And? Reality is no excuse. All sorts of lurid things have occurred in history, that doesn't make them appropriate for a D&D game. That kind of prurience seems rather unnecessary.

Besides, why all the Greco-Roman stuff in a domain based on feudal Japan? It makes no sense, especially when the canon details of the domain says that they dislike foreigners and foreign customs.
Bluebomber4evr: The Justice, not you, since 2002.
Ravenloft: Prisoners of the Mist Persistent World for Neverwinter Nights: www.nwnravenloft.com
User avatar
brilliantlight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1003
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by brilliantlight »

MichaelTumey wrote:
brilliantlight wrote:[Read about the Temple of Aphrodite at Corinth. It was basically a giant brothel. Sex cults were fairly common in the ancient world. It isn't like I gave a lurid description or anything.
While Japan definitely has a reputation for deviant sexual aspects to their culture, really the prevalence of brothels in feudal Japan is derived from the equally European concept that men require sexual release, as part of healthy living, it's not ever been a 'cult' of sex, at least not before 20th century. Brothels for the lessers and courtesans for the more affluent (and kabuki actors for the alternative lifestyle persons) is a part of normal society, and not any exclusive 'cult of sex' per se.
I didn't mean it as a comment on real life Japan past or present. Prostitution is hardly unknown in the US either nor sexual deviancy. The ONLY thing it was based on was the fact that the ruler in question had a weakness for sex. Nothing more, nothing less. The dark powers are actively playing on the sons weaknesses.
Last edited by brilliantlight on Tue Dec 11, 2012 4:54 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
brilliantlight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1003
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by brilliantlight »

And? Reality is no excuse. All sorts of lurid things have occurred in history, that doesn't make them appropriate for a D&D game. That kind of prurience seems rather unnecessary.

Besides, why all the Greco-Roman stuff in a domain based on feudal Japan? It makes no sense, especially when the canon details of the domain says that they dislike foreigners and foreign customs.
The Temple at Corinth is only an example. Most polytheisitic religions have at least one goddess of beauty and sex and many have more. This wasn't a Greco-Roman thing but a human thing. From what I have read the Persians, the Eygptians and others had their own sex goddess and sex cults. It was hardly rare. It only became rare after the rise of Christianity.
Last edited by brilliantlight on Tue Dec 11, 2012 4:56 pm, edited 1 time in total.
MichaelTumey
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 451
Joined: Sat Jun 11, 2011 3:23 pm

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by MichaelTumey »

brilliantlight wrote: I didn't mean it as a comment on real life Japan past or present. Prostitution is hardly unknown in the US either nor sexual deviancy. The ONLY thing it was based on was the fact that the ruler in question had a weakness for sex. Nothing more, nothing less. The dark powers are actively playing on the sons weaknesses.
I don't mean to be overly critical, just comparing my knowledge, with what I'm reading plus a total lack of this domain's canon aspects mixed to draw conclusions from.
User avatar
brilliantlight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1003
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by brilliantlight »

MichaelTumey wrote:
brilliantlight wrote: I didn't mean it as a comment on real life Japan past or present. Prostitution is hardly unknown in the US either nor sexual deviancy. The ONLY thing it was based on was the fact that the ruler in question had a weakness for sex. Nothing more, nothing less. The dark powers are actively playing on the sons weaknesses.
I don't mean to be overly critical, just comparing my knowledge, with what I'm reading plus a total lack of this domain's canon aspects mixed to draw conclusions from.
What canon? There is practically no canon at all which is why I picked it. No description of the dark lord outside he was an aristocrat that is now a powerless gheist nor of his sons besides their names and little of the islands themselves outside of the idea they are based on Japan. I will change them from fiends to oni though as that makes sense and I will change the names.
MichaelTumey
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 451
Joined: Sat Jun 11, 2011 3:23 pm

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by MichaelTumey »

brilliantlight wrote: The ONLY thing it was based on was the fact that the ruler in question had a weakness for sex. Nothing more, nothing less. The dark powers are actively playing on the sons weaknesses.
In that case, the direction I'd go is that the ruler frequents the courtesan's district way too much, sometimes missing meetings of state pursuing acts in bed, also regularly escorted by different courtesans at public events. If possibilities of sexual expression outside of hetero tendencies, perhaps private kabuki plays are shown in a prepared theater built within his estate for promiscous liaisons with the actors involved. Since sexual release is normal for I'Cath society, having these points mentioned at all infers to this ruler's propensity for sex extends beyond the normal ken of society.
User avatar
brothersale
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 367
Joined: Thu Mar 25, 2004 9:02 am

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by brothersale »

brilliantlight wrote: The Temple at Corinth is only an example. Most polytheisitic religions have at least one goddess of beauty and sex and many have more. This wasn't a Greco-Roman thing but a human thing. From what I have read the Persians, the Eygptians and others had their own sex goddess and sex cults. It was hardly rare. It only became rare after the rise of Christianity.
All the examples you are giving are from the wrong part of the world, if, and it is a big If, you want to continue down this root look at the right cultures for a basis i.e. Japan, China etc. not western cultures.
All great movements require a few martyrs... -Moebius (soulreaver 2)
User avatar
brilliantlight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1003
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by brilliantlight »

brothersale wrote:
brilliantlight wrote: The Temple at Corinth is only an example. Most polytheisitic religions have at least one goddess of beauty and sex and many have more. This wasn't a Greco-Roman thing but a human thing. From what I have read the Persians, the Eygptians and others had their own sex goddess and sex cults. It was hardly rare. It only became rare after the rise of Christianity.
All the examples you are giving are from the wrong part of the world, if, and it is a big If, you want to continue down this root look at the right cultures for a basis i.e. Japan, China etc. not western cultures.
Since when was Persia "Western"? India had its share as well from what I have read and so have others. Besides the domain is based on Japan it isn't Japan and it makes sense that it would have some differences. After all real magic actually exists in Ravenloft, unlike the real world.
User avatar
brilliantlight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1003
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by brilliantlight »

MichaelTumey wrote:
brilliantlight wrote: The ONLY thing it was based on was the fact that the ruler in question had a weakness for sex. Nothing more, nothing less. The dark powers are actively playing on the sons weaknesses.
In that case, the direction I'd go is that the ruler frequents the courtesan's district way too much, sometimes missing meetings of state pursuing acts in bed, also regularly escorted by different courtesans at public events. If possibilities of sexual expression outside of hetero tendencies, perhaps private kabuki plays are shown in a prepared theater built within his estate for promiscous liaisons with the actors involved. Since sexual release is normal for I'Cath society, having these points mentioned at all infers to this ruler's propensity for sex extends beyond the normal ken of society.
I also want to have the land reflecting the rulers in some way. I see them as long on the way to becoming dark lords in their own right, which is why the really belicose son commands a really militaristic regime, the wizard a strong magic one and the hedonist one has a lot of drug parlors and gambling halls. If they (or even just some of them) were granted their own domains than their sons would take over. The father would still be punished as he doesn't really give a damn about the sons, what he cares about is that the work of his lifetime is falling apart.
MichaelTumey
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 451
Joined: Sat Jun 11, 2011 3:23 pm

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by MichaelTumey »

brilliantlight wrote:After all real magic actually exists in Ravenloft, unlike the real world.
Well.... the Japanese believed magic was real. The Ministry of Onmyodo was an actual branch of the Imperial government as a means to academically train onmyoji wizards, and to control/license legal practioners of the arcane arts within Japan. The onmyoji were responsible for dictating the cycle of unlucky days, determining the calendar year and placement of all official meetings of state based on astrological projections and for protecting the Imperial court from evil spirits. Only the imperial court, office of the shogunate and the varying provincial noble houses were allowed to submit and receive members of the Ministry of Onmyodo. Non-nobles, meaning samurai, commoners and the lower social castes weren't allowed to be nor deal with wizards. Breaking down the word, onmyodo - on = honorable or nobleman, myo = magic, do = study of...

So while you can say magic doesn't really exist in the real world - the Japanese thought it did.

In my treatment of the Kaidan (Japanese horror) setting for PFRPG, I strove to cleave very closely to Japanese culture, history, language, folklore beliefs, even religion (with only slight deviation to apply to a fantasy game mechanic - I don't officially state Buddhism and Shinto, however the precepts presented are directly derived from those philosophical directions.) I deviate to the setting away from history only where it's most appropriate. I see no reason to fictionalize overmuch, just because the domain isn't really Japan, doesn't mean it can't very closely resemble the source. I mean, why not stick with actual Japanese concepts?
Last edited by MichaelTumey on Tue Dec 11, 2012 6:07 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
brothersale
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 367
Joined: Thu Mar 25, 2004 9:02 am

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by brothersale »

brilliantlight wrote: Since when was Persia "Western"? India had its share as well from what I have read and so have others. Besides the domain is based on Japan it isn't Japan and it makes sense that it would have some differences. After all real magic actually exists in Ravenloft, unlike the real world.
Since it is generally refer to as such in some books on ancient cultures due to the fact that the culture was radically altered from its original state when Alexander of Macedonia conquered the area and started to merge the cultures, that or middle-eastern, but NEVER oriental [please note that I have not used the term Eastern as that covers a larger area]. And please I did not say India, I stated China and Japan, two nations that have had a tradition of Isolation that prevented widespread cultural contamination from even neighbouring areas case and point not too much Indian culture in China is there, so why would a greek goddess be acceptable in such a culture. Answer it would not be, so why put it in a domain based on oriental culture.

And while there is little cannon on the domain there is some so stop ignoring it in favour of your own view if you don't people to object to it. Instead just create your own domain and then you will have complete control of whatever you want in the domain and no one will complain.
All great movements require a few martyrs... -Moebius (soulreaver 2)
User avatar
brilliantlight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1003
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by brilliantlight »

brothersale wrote:
brilliantlight wrote: Since when was Persia "Western"? India had its share as well from what I have read and so have others. Besides the domain is based on Japan it isn't Japan and it makes sense that it would have some differences. After all real magic actually exists in Ravenloft, unlike the real world.
Since it is generally refer to as such in some books on ancient cultures due to the fact that the culture was radically altered from its original state when Alexander of Macedonia conquered the area and started to merge the cultures, that or middle-eastern, but NEVER oriental [please note that I have not used the term Eastern as that covers a larger area]. And please I did not say India, I stated China and Japan, two nations that have had a tradition of Isolation that prevented widespread cultural contamination from even neighbouring areas case and point not too much Indian culture in China is there, so why would a greek goddess be acceptable in such a culture. Answer it would not be, so why put it in a domain based on oriental culture.

And while there is little cannon on the domain there is some so stop ignoring it in favour of your own view if you don't people to object to it. Instead just create your own domain and then you will have complete control of whatever you want in the domain and no one will complain.
I have never heard Persia or Iran called Western and I have always heard it called Middle Eastern. Like I said I was going to change the brother's names, I did miss that I admit. What other canon is there that I ignored? Also, although Aphrodite is "Greek" in the real world she also doesn't really exist but she does exist in canon D&D but clearly she isn't from our Greece. Changing it to Sune might work as well unless you know an oriental goddess of beauty that will work . I also said I was changing the fiends to oni.
User avatar
Bluebomber4evr
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 450
Joined: Wed Mar 17, 2004 9:08 pm
Location: United States of Whatever
Contact:

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by Bluebomber4evr »

brilliantlight wrote:
MichaelTumey wrote:
brilliantlight wrote: I didn't mean it as a comment on real life Japan past or present. Prostitution is hardly unknown in the US either nor sexual deviancy. The ONLY thing it was based on was the fact that the ruler in question had a weakness for sex. Nothing more, nothing less. The dark powers are actively playing on the sons weaknesses.
I don't mean to be overly critical, just comparing my knowledge, with what I'm reading plus a total lack of this domain's canon aspects mixed to draw conclusions from.
What canon? There is practically no canon at all which is why I picked it. No description of the dark lord outside he was an aristocrat that is now a powerless gheist nor of his sons besides their names and little of the islands themselves outside of the idea they are based on Japan. I will change them from fiends to oni though as that makes sense and I will change the names.
There's more canon info than that:

"Red Box" Domains & Denizens book, pages 39-40
Ravenloft 3.0 Campaign Setting, pages 170-172
Ravenloft Dungeon Master's Guide, page 19

While they're all brief, there's enough info that you've contradicted (like the names of the darklord's sons, and the fact that their culture is conservative and strongly dislikes foreigners). I don't mean to pile on or have you feel that I'm picking on you, so please don't take this as a personal attack because it's not... but you did ask us what we thought of your changes. To me, the changes you've made to to Rokushima Taiyoo are like the changes Champions of Darkness made to Barovia: out-of-synch with established canon, wildly inconsistent, and tonally inappropriate. If that floats your boat for your own game, go for it. But as far as I'm concerned, that means that it should not be on the main Mistipedia page for Rokushima Taiyoo.
Bluebomber4evr: The Justice, not you, since 2002.
Ravenloft: Prisoners of the Mist Persistent World for Neverwinter Nights: www.nwnravenloft.com
MichaelTumey
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 451
Joined: Sat Jun 11, 2011 3:23 pm

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by MichaelTumey »

Bluebomber4evr wrote:...and the fact that their culture is conservative and strongly dislikes foreigners).
I'd done the same with the Kaidan setting. You're familiar with the term 'gaijin'? It basically means 'long nose' and applies to how the Japanese viewed Europeans, and really any outsider/foreigner (in very negative light). In the first adventure the PCs are essentially called gaijin by everyone they meet. There is a very strong antipathy to outsiders to most of the Kaidan population - it works against the PCs throughout the adventure trilogy, as the PCs are intentionally outsiders in the setup of the modules. Even the island port the PCs land in the start of the first adventure, which is currently held and operated by the yakuza only is called Gaijinoshima, because Kaidan government considers it a 'dirty place'; a place of foreigners. Most visiting foreigners are not allowed into Kaidan beyond this port itself. Much of the first third of the first module is trying to acquire traveling papers for movement into one of the main islands of Kaidan, involving acts of diplomacy, getting in good with the local yakuza boss, and doing some favors, just to get permission to move within the setting.

While all this could certainly help in a deeper development of Rokushima Taiyoo, I'm too involved in Kaidan itself, needing to expand that setting for me to look at a similar Ravenloft domain with similar precepts. I'm willing to help if anyone asks, but I have many time constraints - a business to run, cartography to create, projects to develop, page-layouts to do for an upcoming one-shot module. I even put an entry into Paizo's RPG Superstar 2013 contest, which if I win the first round, means lots of development just for that. Though I wish I had the time, I couldn't try to lead development on any Ravenloft domain...
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: I finished my changes to Rokushima Táiyoo

Post by HuManBing »

I agree. The additions to the wiki are too far off of canon (and culturally too tangential for the feel of the domain) to warrant inclusion as an official site entry.

If they work for individual GMs in their private games, that's fine. But we would need a broader consensus of site-wide support before the wiki should include it.

Think of it this way: FoS is now the largest Ravenloft site on the net, so it's entirely feasible that a newcomer to Ravenloft might scan the wiki for the "official word" on domains, NPCs, and plot points. For this reason, it's important to keep things relatively close to canon - and to make sure any new fan-made introductions (aka "fanon") are compliant with canon and clearly pointed out as fan-additions.


Brilliantlight, I remember you were open about expressing skepticism about other posters' fanon in older threads. (E.g. "Personal canon" thread, "How do you see Drakov" thread.) Please understand that others also will scrutinize your fan work, and this goes all the moreso if it's actually placed on the site's public reference services, like the wiki. It's not personal against you, but some quality control is necessary, especially if it carries the imprimatur of the site's "this is canon" endorsement.
Post Reply