Rule systems.
Rule systems.
Just wondering which rule system all you guys generally use. I'm currently still playing 2nd Ed (as it's all I know).
What version do Ravenloft accessories go up to?
Is it hard to learn new editions? Would I be better off waiting until later this year when 5th comes out before learning another?
What version do Ravenloft accessories go up to?
Is it hard to learn new editions? Would I be better off waiting until later this year when 5th comes out before learning another?
Re: Rule systems.
1. What system do I use? GURPS by Steve Jackson Games. I like the increased customizability of the rules.
2. How important are the rules? If you're new to role playing, you may want to stick close to the path of least resistance. Changing a setting to fit a different set of rules can be a bit of work. But if you know what you like and what rules best support it, then by all means go for it.
3. Which set of rules offers the most published material for the setting? The 2nd ed materials straddle the "Great Upheaval", when the setting had a major geographical and personnel overhaul. You can tell the difference in the Ravenloft logo: if it has a "tail" extending down underneath, it's pre-upheaval. Also noteworthy are the 2nd edition supplement books, such as the Villains guidebook and the Arms and Equipment Guide, which often have a fascinating (and well researched) take on a subject with GM tips. (One reason I like GURPS is that almost ALL their non-core books have this same academician's attitude to the literary background to the materials). Specific to Ravenloft, 2nd ed also vested the most adventure publications by number - though in terms of quality they were a mixed bag.
The 3rd ed materials have more volume than all prior editions, as will as a concerted effort to make the setting more holistic and organic. These are generally believed to be the setting's heyday (although I personally prefer 2nd ed events and 3rd ed personalities). One compilation of adventures was released - critical response was mixed.
I do not believe the Ravenloft setting itself had any support in 4th ed, although they did release a stand alone adventure focussing on Castle Ravenloft. There may have been a board game, too. I know nothing about the 5th edition plans, unfortunately.
2. How important are the rules? If you're new to role playing, you may want to stick close to the path of least resistance. Changing a setting to fit a different set of rules can be a bit of work. But if you know what you like and what rules best support it, then by all means go for it.
3. Which set of rules offers the most published material for the setting? The 2nd ed materials straddle the "Great Upheaval", when the setting had a major geographical and personnel overhaul. You can tell the difference in the Ravenloft logo: if it has a "tail" extending down underneath, it's pre-upheaval. Also noteworthy are the 2nd edition supplement books, such as the Villains guidebook and the Arms and Equipment Guide, which often have a fascinating (and well researched) take on a subject with GM tips. (One reason I like GURPS is that almost ALL their non-core books have this same academician's attitude to the literary background to the materials). Specific to Ravenloft, 2nd ed also vested the most adventure publications by number - though in terms of quality they were a mixed bag.
The 3rd ed materials have more volume than all prior editions, as will as a concerted effort to make the setting more holistic and organic. These are generally believed to be the setting's heyday (although I personally prefer 2nd ed events and 3rd ed personalities). One compilation of adventures was released - critical response was mixed.
I do not believe the Ravenloft setting itself had any support in 4th ed, although they did release a stand alone adventure focussing on Castle Ravenloft. There may have been a board game, too. I know nothing about the 5th edition plans, unfortunately.
Re: Rule systems.
Generally I stick with a Pathfinder version, which is based off 3.5 Edition.Epically wrote:Just wondering which rule system all you guys generally use. I'm currently still playing 2nd Ed (as it's all I know).
What version do Ravenloft accessories go up to?
Is it hard to learn new editions? Would I be better off waiting until later this year when 5th comes out before learning another?
Ravenloft accessories go up to 3.5 D&D.
Whether it's hard or not to learn a new edition I think depends on your own mindset. If you go into it with a really open mind, then I think it's a lot easier than if you go into it with a skeptical mindset, or one that you're not going to like what you're reading.
You could wait till 5E comes out, but you're assuming it'll be later this year. I haven't actually seen a release date for the system.
Personally, I would recommend you check out Pathfinder. First reason, it's free online. You can learn how to play for nothing more than some of your time. Secondly, a lot of stuff in 5E is based off of, or very similar to 3.5E. If you learn that beforehand, it will make learning 5E even easier. And you'll have the benefit of knowing two systems so you can choose what you like best. You can even mix/match pieces to make an ideal system that works for you.
As a final note, there are no actual Ravenloft accessories for 4E, but I still hold that the system has it's strong points. If you ever get a chance to look over the rules, even if you choose not to go with them, I would say that you would not be any worse off for spending some time looking them over. Can't hurt you any, at the very least.
-
MichaelTumey
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 451
- Joined: Sat Jun 11, 2011 3:23 pm
Re: Rule systems.
I use Pathfinder, although I've played Ravenloft with AD&D 1e, 2e, 3x and now Pathfinder. 4e and D&DNext/5e are systems I won't touch - not for me. As HumanBing states, nothing for Ravenloft was created for 4e, and though I have no real idea, I doubt it will show up in 5e, but we won't know until that time comes.
I develop and design RPG materials using Pathfinder, while I have hands-on skills with all the systems up to PF, I've never done it professionally until PF, which makes PF ideal fo me. Since I develop and create products for Kaidan setting of Japanese horror for PF, including adventures, supplements and maps - it's what I know best. (Also I pretty much play Kaidan, instead of Ravenloft, but Ravenloft's influence to my game, makes it a similar activitiy and I get my horror 'fix' doing so.)
Switching editions may or may not be your best choice, if you're already very familiar with 2x - you'd have to want to try a new system to make it work anyway. It's been a while since I've played 2e, but from my experience with 3x/PF, I wouldn't go back, but that's just me. Every edition took some time to learn, but they have similarities and the move proved easy enough.
I develop and design RPG materials using Pathfinder, while I have hands-on skills with all the systems up to PF, I've never done it professionally until PF, which makes PF ideal fo me. Since I develop and create products for Kaidan setting of Japanese horror for PF, including adventures, supplements and maps - it's what I know best. (Also I pretty much play Kaidan, instead of Ravenloft, but Ravenloft's influence to my game, makes it a similar activitiy and I get my horror 'fix' doing so.)
Switching editions may or may not be your best choice, if you're already very familiar with 2x - you'd have to want to try a new system to make it work anyway. It's been a while since I've played 2e, but from my experience with 3x/PF, I wouldn't go back, but that's just me. Every edition took some time to learn, but they have similarities and the move proved easy enough.
Re: Rule systems.
One of the problems I'm having is because I only know one rule system, I'm sure sure how to differentiate between all the source (canon/non) material i read here. I don't know which is 3, or 3.5, or whether there is a veritable difference lol.
Re: Rule systems.
Well Epically, it might help if you have some examples. I'm not sure what you mean when you say you're not sure what's which edition and such; most of the actual books say what edition they are for.
If the whole 3E vs 3.5E is confusing you, it's actually very simple. 3.5E is just a slightly tweaked version of 3E. They are almost the same for most things, and usually you can interchange the books with very little problems.
As to what is canon and what is not...well I believe 95% of everything actually published as a book for Ravenloft is canon. There are some exceptions, but they are rare. It's easier if you have certain books in mind to just ask about those ones and we'd be happy to let you know.
Even in the books deemed "non-canon" you can find good information however. I have yet to see a Ravenloft supplement (and I have them all) that didn't have some good ideas in it, even if the majority was not so stellar.
If the whole 3E vs 3.5E is confusing you, it's actually very simple. 3.5E is just a slightly tweaked version of 3E. They are almost the same for most things, and usually you can interchange the books with very little problems.
As to what is canon and what is not...well I believe 95% of everything actually published as a book for Ravenloft is canon. There are some exceptions, but they are rare. It's easier if you have certain books in mind to just ask about those ones and we'd be happy to let you know.
Even in the books deemed "non-canon" you can find good information however. I have yet to see a Ravenloft supplement (and I have them all) that didn't have some good ideas in it, even if the majority was not so stellar.
Re: Rule systems.
Gazetteer II is one example.
- Zilfer
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4231
- Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
- Contact:
Re: Rule systems.
Good on fluff
.
3.x isn’t that bad of a system. It’s the one I was introduced too, and I’m comfortable with. Pathfinder isn’t a stretch from 3.x either. Some people have nick named pathfinder e3.75 saying it should have been the next step. *shrugs*
I’m just on the fence on whether to change everything to pathfinder or not….
3.x isn’t that bad of a system. It’s the one I was introduced too, and I’m comfortable with. Pathfinder isn’t a stretch from 3.x either. Some people have nick named pathfinder e3.75 saying it should have been the next step. *shrugs*
I’m just on the fence on whether to change everything to pathfinder or not….
- vipera aspis
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 351
- Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2005 8:38 pm
- Location: Chicago
Re: Rule systems.
I run my players with 3.5 into pathfinder. Since some of the players do not have access to the pathfinder books as of yet it's a slow conversion. Helps that we play via united states postal service and group emails though. Lots of fluff.
my bones among the rocks and roots
Re: Rule systems.
I use Basic Role Playing, using resources from cthulhu dark ages(the medieval supplement for cthulhu). This makes things 1.) simple as everything is mainly derived from a percentile die. but also 2.) it makes skills and knowledges vastly more important. This focuses ravenloft from dnd's dungeoning and hack and slash combat to a more invistgative game. Combat is extremely brutal. you can easily die if you run into a vampire's lair with no plan, however if you plan well enough you can win the day.Epically wrote:Just wondering which rule system all you guys generally use. I'm currently still playing 2nd Ed (as it's all I know).
Magic can be scaled up or down as you wish. The Basic book has several monsters a plenty to use as well, like vampires, demons and more.
All of them, from the 2nd edition to the 3rd edition. fluff is more important to me as I rely on BRP.Epically wrote:What version do Ravenloft accessories go up to?
Depends on the system. I don't like the dnd systems anyways, so BRP works for me. The fact it is a simple and intuitive system makes BRP easy to learn IMO.Epically wrote:Is it hard to learn new editions? Would I be better off waiting until later this year when 5th comes out before learning another?
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: Rule systems.
Pathfinder (as I hope everyone has noticed by now).Epically wrote:Just wondering which rule system all you guys generally use. I'm currently still playing 2nd Ed (as it's all I know).
Is it hard to learn new editions? Would I be better off waiting until later this year when 5th comes out before learning another?
I don't think it's particularly hard, although some of the subtlties might escape you at first.
For my money, Pathfinder is one of the best version of D&D to arise. The adventure paths are generally excellent, there's a huge amount of material out there to use (much of it available for free), and the community is very active and pretty friendly. Plus the game itself is well structured, quite well balanced, and easy to play.
Because it's all available for free, you could have a look and see how you feel without having to spend anything.
As for 5e, I have no idea.
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
Re: Rule systems.
I was a 2e player then started out investigating 1e and Greyhawk for D&Ds essence/roots .(I.e. who are those names from the spells chapter ?)
Later i won a 3.0. PHB and got slowly into 3e via forums and the Internet. There's a free "conversion manual" available for 2e to 3.0 which is helpful to get some of the greater changes in the rules-set (3.x or PF) if you're coming from 2e.
Since 3.x rules are open sourced you can reference them easily via the free SRD (system reference document) sites: d20srd.org being my favorite for 3.5. I learned 3.5 only via the SRD. Even while still playing 2e the 3.x rules often helped clearing up questions. But i do like 3.5 much better than 2e as it allows for far more customization has the same rules for all (NPC classes, yay!) and is generally very structured and well though out.
Now I'm actually torn between Pathfinder (best rules, nice community and excellent 3pp support) and 3.5 (best most Ravenloft specific material, official and netbooks)
Pathfinder rules are also freely available at the paizo prd site or (with some Golarion specific fluff scratched off) at d20pfsrd.com. Plus the Core Rulebook PDF costs only $ 10 and there's the introductory Beginners Box.
4th edition is not D&D anymore to me it's as someone cleverly put it literally designed to be not-D&D.And I don't hold my breath for 5e. PF is the new D&D though with the genius of open sourcing 3rd Edition all that is derived from that has the power to stay relevant. It even sparked the OSR ( old school renaissance) with retro clones of 1e, 2e, od&d and others (becmi, ...) being made from the SRD.
There are many flavours of D&D now and it's hardly necessary to use the most up to date rules set. ...If you want to use D&D at all...
You can read a bit about the differences in D&D versions here: link.
Later i won a 3.0. PHB and got slowly into 3e via forums and the Internet. There's a free "conversion manual" available for 2e to 3.0 which is helpful to get some of the greater changes in the rules-set (3.x or PF) if you're coming from 2e.
Since 3.x rules are open sourced you can reference them easily via the free SRD (system reference document) sites: d20srd.org being my favorite for 3.5. I learned 3.5 only via the SRD. Even while still playing 2e the 3.x rules often helped clearing up questions. But i do like 3.5 much better than 2e as it allows for far more customization has the same rules for all (NPC classes, yay!) and is generally very structured and well though out.
Now I'm actually torn between Pathfinder (best rules, nice community and excellent 3pp support) and 3.5 (best most Ravenloft specific material, official and netbooks)
Pathfinder rules are also freely available at the paizo prd site or (with some Golarion specific fluff scratched off) at d20pfsrd.com. Plus the Core Rulebook PDF costs only $ 10 and there's the introductory Beginners Box.
4th edition is not D&D anymore to me it's as someone cleverly put it literally designed to be not-D&D.And I don't hold my breath for 5e. PF is the new D&D though with the genius of open sourcing 3rd Edition all that is derived from that has the power to stay relevant. It even sparked the OSR ( old school renaissance) with retro clones of 1e, 2e, od&d and others (becmi, ...) being made from the SRD.
There are many flavours of D&D now and it's hardly necessary to use the most up to date rules set. ...If you want to use D&D at all...
You can read a bit about the differences in D&D versions here: link.
Last edited by The Giamarga on Wed Mar 27, 2013 2:31 pm, edited 5 times in total.
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Rule systems.
If you're referring to Expedition to Castle Ravenloft, that was the very end of 3.5, not 4th. If you're referring to Castle Ravenloft, that's a board game, not a module (though loosely based on 4e rules.) If you're referring to the module in Dragon (Fair Barovia) I haven't read it yet, but I don't think it focused on the castle.HuManBing wrote:I do not believe the Ravenloft setting itself had any support in 4th ed, although they did release a stand alone adventure focussing on Castle Ravenloft.
Anyway, I just switched to pathfinder, after using 3.0 for 10 years. I've played Ravenloft in 2e before that, and non-Ravenloft in 1e and OD&D before that. All the systems have their pros and cons. I say use what you and your players like best and are most familiar with. (Though 3.0/3.5/pathfinder is free to try, so it's worth taking a look even if you've never tried it before.)
If you're having trouble figuring out which edition a Ravenloft product was made for, look here:
http://fraternityofshadows.com/DrawingRoom.html
We didn't split up the 3.0 and 3.5 stuff, but they are so close it hardly matters. And you can usually look at the publication dates to see which is which. 2003 is the cut-off, though I think there were a few 3.0 books early in that year.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- High Priest Mikhal
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1642
- Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.
Re: Rule systems.
I still prefer 3.5, which is really just a cleaned up, better coordinated version of 3.0. I still know AD&D 2e, but I haven't got the rulebooks anymore. Then there's some homebrew rules that roll certain skills together to cut down on the redundancy, some adaptations for the psionics-magic transparency (elves are immune to magical and psionic sleep effects, they gain the usual +2 racial bonus to psionic charm effects as well, etc.) and some "nonstandard" rules for things most people don't deal with in RPGs (the BoEF, for example, and dreams and oneiromachy [dream combat]).
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
-
MichaelTumey
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 451
- Joined: Sat Jun 11, 2011 3:23 pm
Re: Rule systems.
I can even look at Pathfinder as a 'cleaned up' version of 3x, much the same as you view 3.5 to 3.0 - there are differences: basic class design (for no dead levels), combined skills, cleaned up the 'grapple' and 'turn undead' issues, and lots of fiddily little differences in feats and spells. But it's largely the same system.
The first year I played Pathfinder, we judiciously used 3.0/3.5 rules in collusion with Pathfinder - only when a rule was a major difference did we rely on Pathfinder, such as the difference between Power Attack in 3x vs. PF. Now a days, it's Pathfinder only for our group, but PF is definitely backwards compatible and mostly works hand in hand with 3x if you want it to. There's enough books released for PF now, that any reliance on old system rules is no longer necessary (for my table).
The first year I played Pathfinder, we judiciously used 3.0/3.5 rules in collusion with Pathfinder - only when a rule was a major difference did we rely on Pathfinder, such as the difference between Power Attack in 3x vs. PF. Now a days, it's Pathfinder only for our group, but PF is definitely backwards compatible and mostly works hand in hand with 3x if you want it to. There's enough books released for PF now, that any reliance on old system rules is no longer necessary (for my table).
