Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
- Bluebomber4evr
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 450
- Joined: Wed Mar 17, 2004 9:08 pm
- Location: United States of Whatever
- Contact:
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
The moral standpoint is really what makes Ravenloft what it is; what makes it tick and stand out from other settings. Removing it is like removing space travel from Spelljammer or environmental themes from Dark Sun. Without it, you're just left with a generic horror setting. Some people may find the morality overbearing, but in that case, you're probably better off finding a setting they'd enjoy instead of radically altering the key component of the setting.
But as Ryan said, it's your campaign, nobody's forcing you to run it the traditional way. I just think you and your players might just be happier playing something other than Ravenloft if that's how you want to run the world.
But as Ryan said, it's your campaign, nobody's forcing you to run it the traditional way. I just think you and your players might just be happier playing something other than Ravenloft if that's how you want to run the world.
Bluebomber4evr: The Justice, not you, since 2002.
Ravenloft: Prisoners of the Mist Persistent World for Neverwinter Nights: www.nwnravenloft.com
Ravenloft: Prisoners of the Mist Persistent World for Neverwinter Nights: www.nwnravenloft.com
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
I reread your posts, and I am still a little confused. If I understand correctly, the main point here is that you have tried to remove good and evil from your game as concepts, especially when it comes to motivating the PCs. Is that right? Instead, you are endeavoring to give your PCs subtle, nuanced reasons to go after the villains, as well as giving complexity to the motivations and interactions of said villains. You want your players to go after the villain for a better reason than "well, he's evil." (Instead, replacing that with "he's a tyrant," "he's a murderer," or "he eats people!")
If so, I think you are doing a great service to your players by adding depth and complexity to your villains and the stories you're creating.
On the flip side of the coin, I think that choosing to eliminate good and evil as considerations in their entirety does a disservice to your plots as well as your players. It's like being a painter who doesn't use a specific color at all. I'm not saying you can't create a good painting without the color green. In fact, you could create some damn good paintings like that. However, it gets mighty boring looking at paintings that never have any green in them at all. And it's certainly makes your job more difficult, since in this case the setting of most of your paintings is a traditionally agrarian one. (Not impossible, mind, just difficult.)
Sorry, I know you said you were going to reply to people individually when you got more time, I just wanted to toss that out there so you didn't think I was telling you off or anything. (Like I said earlier, it sounds like you're putting a lot of work into your game, and it can only benefit from that.)
If so, I think you are doing a great service to your players by adding depth and complexity to your villains and the stories you're creating.
On the flip side of the coin, I think that choosing to eliminate good and evil as considerations in their entirety does a disservice to your plots as well as your players. It's like being a painter who doesn't use a specific color at all. I'm not saying you can't create a good painting without the color green. In fact, you could create some damn good paintings like that. However, it gets mighty boring looking at paintings that never have any green in them at all. And it's certainly makes your job more difficult, since in this case the setting of most of your paintings is a traditionally agrarian one. (Not impossible, mind, just difficult.)
Sorry, I know you said you were going to reply to people individually when you got more time, I just wanted to toss that out there so you didn't think I was telling you off or anything. (Like I said earlier, it sounds like you're putting a lot of work into your game, and it can only benefit from that.)
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
Lunch break note: the feedback in this thread is amazing, and I'm very happy to see all these views. My work schedule for the rest of this month well be 8 to 8, Mon through Sat, so that may delay my responses. Rest assured that I will read and ponder and respond to each post as best I can, albeit very slowly.
If I'm slow to respond, it's a time issue, and definitely not a shortfall in interest or merit of this thread's contents.
If I manage one post per day I think I may be doing all right...
If I'm slow to respond, it's a time issue, and definitely not a shortfall in interest or merit of this thread's contents.
- ewancummins
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 28523
- Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
I could see replacing the alignment system with something else, but any order of the game universe (and I don't simply mean rules--I am going deeper and dealing with the underlying moral assumptions you are making) that pretends Good and Evil don't exist independent of personal judgments is failure mode for Ravenloft, IMO. The conflict of Good and Evil that is so central to the gothics is rooted in the Christian view of an objective moral order. It simply falls apart without some reasonably similar view of a higher moral order that transcends merely human beliefs and whims.
If players are wasting game time with a silly metagame debate about alignment, that's an easy thing to fix. Alignment is a rules matter, and thus it's up to the DM. Just make a ruling. The players will accept it. If you wish to listen to their opinions, go ahead, but the ruling is yours.
If the PCs are arguing about morality—that might be great stuff.
If you really want to discourage meta-gaming debates about alignment:
• Know/detect alignment spells don’t work. Not just detect evil.
• No alignment languages exist (not the same thing as 3E’s Celestial, Abyssal, and Infernal, BTW.)
• Few people think or speak in terms of ‘alignment.’ That is, not many people would say “I am Lawful Good.’ Lots of people would say ‘I follow the laws and I am a good person.’
Some, likely many, of the people who call themselves ‘good’ will be evil-aligned. Evil is not what you say or think or feel you are—it is what you really are.
• The nine point (or three, or five) alignment system is understood and discussed IC only by metaphysicians, theologians, and so on and so forth. And they don’t all agree on how it works or what it means. They are groping at the structure of reality.
• The Outer Planes are distant, mythical realms and ‘alignment exemplar’ creatures like fiends or celestials are rarely encountered.
Note that ditching Law and Chaos simplifies things and does not, IMO, change Ravenloft much.
As ever, YMMV
If players are wasting game time with a silly metagame debate about alignment, that's an easy thing to fix. Alignment is a rules matter, and thus it's up to the DM. Just make a ruling. The players will accept it. If you wish to listen to their opinions, go ahead, but the ruling is yours.
If the PCs are arguing about morality—that might be great stuff.
If you really want to discourage meta-gaming debates about alignment:
• Know/detect alignment spells don’t work. Not just detect evil.
• No alignment languages exist (not the same thing as 3E’s Celestial, Abyssal, and Infernal, BTW.)
• Few people think or speak in terms of ‘alignment.’ That is, not many people would say “I am Lawful Good.’ Lots of people would say ‘I follow the laws and I am a good person.’
Some, likely many, of the people who call themselves ‘good’ will be evil-aligned. Evil is not what you say or think or feel you are—it is what you really are.
• The nine point (or three, or five) alignment system is understood and discussed IC only by metaphysicians, theologians, and so on and so forth. And they don’t all agree on how it works or what it means. They are groping at the structure of reality.
• The Outer Planes are distant, mythical realms and ‘alignment exemplar’ creatures like fiends or celestials are rarely encountered.
Note that ditching Law and Chaos simplifies things and does not, IMO, change Ravenloft much.
As ever, YMMV
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.
-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
- ewancummins
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 28523
- Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
Taint or Corruption mechanics could be a nice replacement for alignment, related to the Powers Check system.
This approach replaces 'alignment' as a set of philosphies/codes/ value systems aligned to metaphyical forces with 'alignment' as a scale ranging from sublime Good to fiendish Evil. Movement along the scale is based on the actions and intentions of the character in question, over time, and as interpreted by the DM on the basis of existing rules/his own best judgement.
Again, YMMV
This approach replaces 'alignment' as a set of philosphies/codes/ value systems aligned to metaphyical forces with 'alignment' as a scale ranging from sublime Good to fiendish Evil. Movement along the scale is based on the actions and intentions of the character in question, over time, and as interpreted by the DM on the basis of existing rules/his own best judgement.
Again, YMMV
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.
-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
- The Lesser Evil
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1552
- Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 3:17 am
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
The problem here though is that most of the arguments that come up in game with alignment and proper behavior come from OOC mismatches in understandings and expectations. A player goes into the game expecting reality to be one way and the dm has it another way (whether it be objective morality orHuManBing wrote: Morals, however, are much more personal to the PCs and their players. Your stated viewpoint equates the two factors, and I think that's simply not accurate. An ethical mismatch comes out as "you made a social misjudgment", which typically implies a mismatch in understanding and expectations.
If you act in what you expect is what your society expects and then the dm declares otherwise and has you hunted down for it, then that to me isn't a whole lot different from objective morality.
Who makes the call? Depends from group to group. DM/player consensus on what's fair, just as with any social decision. A morality system in a roleplaying game doesn't have to totally represent the philosophical complexities of the real world. The important thing is that the players and DM have an agreed upon consensus for issues like this and good enough rapport that it allows for some understandings when disagreements occur.I personally love the "shades of grey" mentality with regards to characters, so the idea of gradients is perfectly familiar to me (and much supported!). But the main problem I have with your model is that it presumes at some point that somebody crossed a threshold, going from good into evil. Who makes that call? And what can they do to him? My response is that each PC may have a different response (some might shoot him between the eyes and sleep like a baby afterwards, others might be compelled to provide a fair trial or even to help him escape capture). And then there's the GM's responsibility of determining how society in general would have dealt with him - which again can vary from authority to authority.
[/quote]No, but it does require that every player essentially submit to the GM's objective definition of such. For simple reasons of psychology and more complex reasons of philosophy, I maintain that a GM is going to get a lot more traction and much less resistance, if they limit themselves to dictating the fictitious society around them, than trying to do the same with a moral code. (Now, you may get players who are completely fine with that. Experienced players may very well relish the chance to expand their role-playing experience to include play-acting a different moral code, in addition to the usual suite of acting a different persona and laws of nature, etc.)
Except that, in choosing not to define an objective morality, you have still made a choice (that it is nonexistent.) The gm's still enforcing an outlook on morality, namely that all morality is subjective and relative. Since Ravenloft is as a both D&D setting and setting with gothic roots, objective good/evil are common buyins to the setting, so I would submit having *no* objective morality will throw off just as many as to those you would be thrown off by some other morality definition as imposed by the DM.
- Zettaijin
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 670
- Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 2:30 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: Himeji, Japan
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
Instead of the morality/ethics dualism, how about boiling it down to values and paradigms?
First, we start with a paradigm, a meta theory if you will. Humans are born to survive, for example. From this, we establish that people will create values based around that prime notion which in turn generate ever more precise prescriptive and/or normative sub values (survival is optimal --> cooperation is optimal to survival --> helping others is optimal for cooperation etc.). Values are attitudes that seek to further/fulfill its core paradigm. Other paradigms get added on and bring their own share of values. A complex system is thus formed as humans try to balance these values and paradigms, either seeking a unified and "smooth" system that seems as internally coherent and cogent as possible or merely "go with the flow" accepting the incoherence (possibly a paradigm in of itself).
Might be less scandalous or at least scandal prone than terms like morality which come loaded with a historical baggage comparable to that of civilization and evolution (not in a biological but more normative sense).
This said, to get back to the game itself, the first real step is determine what the players and GM are looking for.
Do they seek a game of right vs. wrong where a universal and irrefutable notions of right and wrong exists and some manner of entity/cosmic conscience/natural law of causality will either bring reward or punishment for enforcement or transgression? (i.e. most of the known canonical Ravenloft based on TSR/WotC/D20 etc. products with natural incoherence due to the plethora of hands that manipulated the setting's canon)
If so, there are game play options available, but none will entirely remove alignments as absolute notions of right/wrong with the punishment/reward system are key to the game being sought.
Removing all traces of universally accepted ideals and behaviour is in fact impossible within the confines of the prison model. The existence of a prison model assumes that crimes have been committed and punishment required for these transgressions (punishment itself being a value). AFAWK, the Dark Powers remain the most important if not sole arbitrator in these matters (again, vaguely defined as they are, they may simply be the figurative executive side of the equation).
Actually, that's not true, the real arbitrators were the Gods of Ravenloft - its creators. As in the authors who worked on the product. Their values (or those they chose to infuse their creations with) were those, obvious or not, of the the fictional powers that be of the demiplane.
Even HMB's "consequences of corruption" suggests that corruption is not optimal for some set of values or paradigm hence does not do away with "morality" just renames it and changes the parameters from those set out by classic high fantasy/LotR geekdom to something more akin to what contemporary thinkers/political or social commentators might devise or articulate. Less brimstone and Hellfire and more actions/reactions with consequences, nuances and, yes, contradictory values all propped up by more down to earth stuff like popular opinion and sheer power.
Changes are cosmetic yet possibly deeper than say whether dragons should be ok or not. Plastic surgery as opposed to tarting yourself up?
Myself I have a different option, but I'll reserve it for my next post...
First, we start with a paradigm, a meta theory if you will. Humans are born to survive, for example. From this, we establish that people will create values based around that prime notion which in turn generate ever more precise prescriptive and/or normative sub values (survival is optimal --> cooperation is optimal to survival --> helping others is optimal for cooperation etc.). Values are attitudes that seek to further/fulfill its core paradigm. Other paradigms get added on and bring their own share of values. A complex system is thus formed as humans try to balance these values and paradigms, either seeking a unified and "smooth" system that seems as internally coherent and cogent as possible or merely "go with the flow" accepting the incoherence (possibly a paradigm in of itself).
Might be less scandalous or at least scandal prone than terms like morality which come loaded with a historical baggage comparable to that of civilization and evolution (not in a biological but more normative sense).
This said, to get back to the game itself, the first real step is determine what the players and GM are looking for.
Do they seek a game of right vs. wrong where a universal and irrefutable notions of right and wrong exists and some manner of entity/cosmic conscience/natural law of causality will either bring reward or punishment for enforcement or transgression? (i.e. most of the known canonical Ravenloft based on TSR/WotC/D20 etc. products with natural incoherence due to the plethora of hands that manipulated the setting's canon)
If so, there are game play options available, but none will entirely remove alignments as absolute notions of right/wrong with the punishment/reward system are key to the game being sought.
Removing all traces of universally accepted ideals and behaviour is in fact impossible within the confines of the prison model. The existence of a prison model assumes that crimes have been committed and punishment required for these transgressions (punishment itself being a value). AFAWK, the Dark Powers remain the most important if not sole arbitrator in these matters (again, vaguely defined as they are, they may simply be the figurative executive side of the equation).
Actually, that's not true, the real arbitrators were the Gods of Ravenloft - its creators. As in the authors who worked on the product. Their values (or those they chose to infuse their creations with) were those, obvious or not, of the the fictional powers that be of the demiplane.
Even HMB's "consequences of corruption" suggests that corruption is not optimal for some set of values or paradigm hence does not do away with "morality" just renames it and changes the parameters from those set out by classic high fantasy/LotR geekdom to something more akin to what contemporary thinkers/political or social commentators might devise or articulate. Less brimstone and Hellfire and more actions/reactions with consequences, nuances and, yes, contradictory values all propped up by more down to earth stuff like popular opinion and sheer power.
Changes are cosmetic yet possibly deeper than say whether dragons should be ok or not. Plastic surgery as opposed to tarting yourself up?
Myself I have a different option, but I'll reserve it for my next post...
- Zettaijin
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 670
- Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 2:30 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: Himeji, Japan
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
Ravenloft is still a prison and holds "bad people", those who have transgressed certain rules in a certain number or a certain degree or with a certain intent in a given context. The jailers are still mysterious in their decisions, some might say erratic and incoherent.
There is, upon closer inspection, a lack of a clear pattern. Values are encouraged/discouraged differently in different lands and some punished for doing what others were given ample reward for.
The truth is the DPs are bickering, malcontent and supremely powerful yet limited.
In keeping with Planescape's established rule of shared belief as source of universal power over reality, the populations of a domain are in a sense either fighting or validating their own keepers/makers through the ebbs and flows of their beliefs. Darklords are precious pets whose own quirks and values shape their unseen masters much like the masters shape their life in turn through constant deux ex machina, carefully thrown wrenches and foiled plans.
In simpler terms, the DPs jail an individual they find guilty yet interesting as a pet or sorts. They poke, prod and "play" with the pet yet the pet gives them a raison d'être. The DPs feel a certain sense of justice being served, validating their work. The populace of a domain, much like the lord, remain capable of changing the land through their shared beliefs.
In fact, concurrent complex systems of values and paradigms co-exist within fairly well defined borders. The DPs have final say on the more exotic and extraordinary magical punishments (save for a particularly creative and powerful non DP power player such as an ancient Lich or Vistana seer) yet individual populations may punish as per their own complex system of values and paradigms made into usable codes of law and their own forms of punishment. A DP could punish someone for a transgression not considered much of a transgression by the populations, hence a power play wherein the DP and population perhaps unwittingly battle for the values of the land with the darklord as a possibly powerful free agent.
Competing DP could try to interfere, meddle or takeover during these troubled times of "moral crisis".
Players are simply there. Individuals who may be outsiders, or not, and whose values may or may not match those of a majority of individuals. They are most certainly going to encounter situations where individuals are punished for transgressions they, the players, feel unwarranted and at times see the opposite - injustices and "wanton criminals" being left unpunished or given free rein.
The ideas of punishment, sin, transgression and imprisonment remain mostly intact save for the extra helping of utter madness and lack of coherence usually NOT associated with AD&D. Players are to be unaware of the invisible three-way tug of war, but quite clear of the fact that while it seems that some things seem fairly universal they remain so only until put into practice.
For players, rewards and punishments should be as rarely as possible attributed by the DP, rather, their boons and curses come from the populace or DL. The DP are too concerned with their own agenda and the DL to micromanage every single thing (unless a DM wishes to have an insanely powerful micro manager which somehow doles out rewards punishments openly, clearly, and generously just to mess with the PC).
The experience is disorienting, difficult, heart wrenching and often frustrating.
There is, upon closer inspection, a lack of a clear pattern. Values are encouraged/discouraged differently in different lands and some punished for doing what others were given ample reward for.
The truth is the DPs are bickering, malcontent and supremely powerful yet limited.
In keeping with Planescape's established rule of shared belief as source of universal power over reality, the populations of a domain are in a sense either fighting or validating their own keepers/makers through the ebbs and flows of their beliefs. Darklords are precious pets whose own quirks and values shape their unseen masters much like the masters shape their life in turn through constant deux ex machina, carefully thrown wrenches and foiled plans.
In simpler terms, the DPs jail an individual they find guilty yet interesting as a pet or sorts. They poke, prod and "play" with the pet yet the pet gives them a raison d'être. The DPs feel a certain sense of justice being served, validating their work. The populace of a domain, much like the lord, remain capable of changing the land through their shared beliefs.
In fact, concurrent complex systems of values and paradigms co-exist within fairly well defined borders. The DPs have final say on the more exotic and extraordinary magical punishments (save for a particularly creative and powerful non DP power player such as an ancient Lich or Vistana seer) yet individual populations may punish as per their own complex system of values and paradigms made into usable codes of law and their own forms of punishment. A DP could punish someone for a transgression not considered much of a transgression by the populations, hence a power play wherein the DP and population perhaps unwittingly battle for the values of the land with the darklord as a possibly powerful free agent.
Competing DP could try to interfere, meddle or takeover during these troubled times of "moral crisis".
Players are simply there. Individuals who may be outsiders, or not, and whose values may or may not match those of a majority of individuals. They are most certainly going to encounter situations where individuals are punished for transgressions they, the players, feel unwarranted and at times see the opposite - injustices and "wanton criminals" being left unpunished or given free rein.
The ideas of punishment, sin, transgression and imprisonment remain mostly intact save for the extra helping of utter madness and lack of coherence usually NOT associated with AD&D. Players are to be unaware of the invisible three-way tug of war, but quite clear of the fact that while it seems that some things seem fairly universal they remain so only until put into practice.
For players, rewards and punishments should be as rarely as possible attributed by the DP, rather, their boons and curses come from the populace or DL. The DP are too concerned with their own agenda and the DL to micromanage every single thing (unless a DM wishes to have an insanely powerful micro manager which somehow doles out rewards punishments openly, clearly, and generously just to mess with the PC).
The experience is disorienting, difficult, heart wrenching and often frustrating.
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
Sorry about the delay, everybody. Work continues to be a bugbear on my back.
To address points, hopefully in fullness and one by one...
1. Vipera Aspis raises the question of "what happens when an NPC labeled as 'evil' is seen to be engaged in an arguably neutral act?". (My paraphrase.)
If a PC has to choose sides based on politics, social philosophy, or simple adherence to the law, they can do so with a fairly clear conscience. To use Vipera Aspis' example above, a wanted criminal is still a wanted criminal regardless of whether he's shopping for pants at the time of arrest. Or a member of a terrorist organization is still fair game to a military sniper even when he's not actively planting explosives or what-have-you.
However, running a moral judgment is much murkier and more open to debate. "Punish evil people" becomes a much less clear-cut directive if you trail the highwayman to the forest... and find out he's also running a bandit camp that redistributes his wealth to the poor. Is he evil now? What if he were feeding hungry orphans? Or supporting injured soldiers abandoned by their lord?
If the issue is an ethical one, then the PC can at least look at it in the context of a social external guideline. "Yes, as a policeman, I am charged with arresting this felon. The fact that I found him unarmed at home surrounded by his wife and children (who are begging me not to arrest him) is irrelevant."
But once you bring in the moral dimension, which I'm taking to mean where Good and Evil are objective absolutes, then when does a defendant "cross over the line" of redemption or violation? How much (or how little) context may the player take into consideration and still be within the scope of the objective absolute?
If a PC applies a social judgment to somebody's actions, but then gets it wrong, then their penalty will likely come about in a social setting. Vengeful relatives, angry business partners, even the law enforcement - could realistically show up and take action. But if a PC screws up a moral call, then who puts it right? A divine being? An avatar of good or evil? And if it's the player's own moral code being applied, who gets to tell him it's "wrong"? The GM?
To address points, hopefully in fullness and one by one...
1. Vipera Aspis raises the question of "what happens when an NPC labeled as 'evil' is seen to be engaged in an arguably neutral act?". (My paraphrase.)
I'd go even further and ask "what happens when an NPC labeled as 'evil' is seen to be engaged in an arguably good act?" Study any civil war and you're likely to find that both sides have redeeming features - study any terrorist organization and you're likely to find they have at least some qualities which people consider "good" and which may be enough to draw sufficiently fanatical people to their cause. (Many organizations deemed to be terrorists by many developed nations nevertheless do provide social welfare amenities for otherwise unsupported demographics, such as water, electricity, and education.)vipera aspis wrote:This is kinda like the paladin doing a detect evil on a cleric of an "evil" god/goddess(we'll say vecna). Would the cleric always radiate "evil"?
Or is it only during the act? What if he's buying some pants at 2pm and is in the middle of getting sized by a local tailor, when the paladin struts in.
If a PC has to choose sides based on politics, social philosophy, or simple adherence to the law, they can do so with a fairly clear conscience. To use Vipera Aspis' example above, a wanted criminal is still a wanted criminal regardless of whether he's shopping for pants at the time of arrest. Or a member of a terrorist organization is still fair game to a military sniper even when he's not actively planting explosives or what-have-you.
However, running a moral judgment is much murkier and more open to debate. "Punish evil people" becomes a much less clear-cut directive if you trail the highwayman to the forest... and find out he's also running a bandit camp that redistributes his wealth to the poor. Is he evil now? What if he were feeding hungry orphans? Or supporting injured soldiers abandoned by their lord?
If the issue is an ethical one, then the PC can at least look at it in the context of a social external guideline. "Yes, as a policeman, I am charged with arresting this felon. The fact that I found him unarmed at home surrounded by his wife and children (who are begging me not to arrest him) is irrelevant."
But once you bring in the moral dimension, which I'm taking to mean where Good and Evil are objective absolutes, then when does a defendant "cross over the line" of redemption or violation? How much (or how little) context may the player take into consideration and still be within the scope of the objective absolute?
If a PC applies a social judgment to somebody's actions, but then gets it wrong, then their penalty will likely come about in a social setting. Vengeful relatives, angry business partners, even the law enforcement - could realistically show up and take action. But if a PC screws up a moral call, then who puts it right? A divine being? An avatar of good or evil? And if it's the player's own moral code being applied, who gets to tell him it's "wrong"? The GM?
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
2. Some posters have pointed to the Dark Powers (and their relationship with the Dark Lords) to support a viewpoint that objective good and objective evil must exist in Ravenloft.
So, the Dark Powers are an unpersuasive authority to support... well, anything, actually. In them, the GM can vest whatever game mechanics they see fit. Through them, the GM can shape the demiplane to whatever goal or outcome they want.
The next step of analysis is the Dark Lords, and once again I run into trouble with the idea of a fixed objective yardstick by which their crimes have been measured.
I believe looking at the Dark Lords individually, you'll find such a broad range of violations and punishments that it's not possible to formulate any objective measure that adequately explains any sort of "fitting the punishment to the crime" type of cosmic justice. Hazlik's actual crimes amount to two murders; Strahd von Zarovich killed dozens or hundreds of enemy soldiers before the wedding murders condemned him. Even Azalin is a fairly tame despot by Greyhawk's standards, in ruling over a single city-state for a generation or two and oppressing a few backward tribes - he's certainly no Iuz the Old. Why would the Dark Powers go after these and punish them, if the plan is to remove the greatest amount of evil from otherworld lands?
In almost every case, I think it's the passion and mental state of the Dark Lord that justifies their status as such. My answer to the choice of Dark Lords is that they're selected for the tragic nature of their stories. And this depends in large part on their internalized psychological states. In Milton's Paradise Lost Book IV, Satan says that even though he has escaped from Hell, he carries the Hell within him wherever he goes - a sentiment which Frankenstein's Creature later echoes. I think this is the key characteristic for the Dark Lords. Strahd's wedding body count pales in comparison to the millions killed by homeworld dictators and tyrants and dragon goddess queens... but it's the emotionally charged nature of the act that fixes his iconic status as a Dark Lord in Ravenloft.
This also ties in well to the meta-function of the Dark Lords and the characteristic traits of Ravenloft as a campaign setting, which is that they exist for the purpose of storytelling, and for the GM to present interesting villains far beyond the usual ethical scope of most sword-and-sorcery campaign settings. This, to me, is the strength of the Ravenloft setting, and it goes back all the way to the I6 adventure - you're fighting a fully psychologically realized villain, with their own agendas and specifically with their own shortcomings, rather than some stat block from a Monstrous Compendium. This is independent of whether the villain is being punished by a hard-and-fast external judicatory entity (as the classic "Dark Powers as Tribunal" model would have it) or by their own internal conflicts and mental state.
Note that this also ties in with my definition of morality as an internalized code of right and wrong. A Dark Lord may be the most powerful rank of character in Ravenloft, so the ethical punishment (i.e. externally from law, society, one's peers, etc.) is unlikely to be much of a deterrent - after all, if Azalin is the law, why would he fear it? (Some Dark Lords do not have this level of immunity - some such as Dominic d'Honaire and Victor Mordenheim are merely low-powered normal people within their social structures without the authority to define ethics. Others, such as Yagno Petrovna and other theocratic Dark Lords, exercise great authority within a strict social structure, so long as they comply with it, but they risk losing everything if they attempt to go against it - this can be especially dramatic where they themselves were initially responsible for setting up a rigid social structure in which they are now trapped!)
Given this reduced ethical pressure, I would submit that a Dark Lord's punishment comes largely from within. Azalin is tormented by his failure as a protector figure because of the death of Irik the Brother, and the later death (at his own hands) of Irik the Son. Strahd is tormented by his jealousy for his brother and his "thou shalt love me and none other" possessiveness over Tatyana. These are the things that torment and trouble them, and they're part of who the character was in the first place (or at least, part of what they ultimately became). They're less an externalized punishment meted out ("the Hell around me") and more a symbol of their own internal limitations, weaknesses, and unhappiness ("the Hell I carry within").
This implementation of "morality as internal limitations" is fully in keeping with GURPS, TriStat dX, and Hero system rules. I understand it's a bit more difficult for d20.
I understand that this view may be deeply unsatisfactory to those who seek a purist, objective view of good and evil, and of a final metric by which a person may be judged. It does give rise to the philosophical question of "Is something evil only if the person feels remorse?" Does it incentivize a person to harden himself to "evil" deeds and, in so doing, become invulnerable to the label? I understand this troubles people who attach value and meaning to the label. As a person who does not, I am not competent to, or in fact much interested in, enforcing such a label in my games.
Although my structure allows for ethics-based externalized punishment, it leaves the morality entirely up to the individual to ponder or ignore as they see fit. A violator who breaks laws in their nation but evades detection and capture could conceivably get away scot-free. This strikes me as an acceptably close approximation to the laws of physics and society as I understand them that I'm okay with it in my campaigns. If the PCs don't like it, a good GM works with them to give them a chance to change it. But that doesn't necessitate a judgment of whether they're being good or evil in doing so.
I offer no comment on good or evil, because I cannot meaningfully define those. Instead, I define morality more as a set of psychological internalized behaviors, and I reserve for ethics the question of external punishments. Ethics determine society's reaction to your actions, and I'm sure we've all seen society all too willing to punish a person for something even if he doesn't personally think it's wrong. (As this very forum's own discussions on copyright laws will show...) Whereas almost by definition, morals are what control your behavior in situation where you "could get away with it".
A soldier may kill ten thousand enemies and not feel remorse. But he can kill one unfaithful lover and feel emotional turmoil. And it's likely the emotional turmoil which will draw the eye of the Dark Powers (or, more honestly, "the GM") to bring him into Ravenloft - a campaign setting where each villain has a story to tell. After all, we don't discuss Strahd's crimes of the battlefield overthrows of Count Dorian or the Tergs.
In-universe from a PC's viewpoint, I am inclining towards a worldview that omits any sense of cosmic justice or retribution upon the Dark Lords. Ravenloft's own inhabitants are generally clueless about the Dark Powers (justifiably, since even the GM usually is) and very few of them have much inkling about the Dark Lords, either. Thus, the question about a Dark Lord's relationship with the Dark Powers, and his punishment by them, is of very minor immediate relevance to the PC's experience. I find greater mileage out of focusing on a Dark Lord's realworld stability concerns, in that much of their attention is focused upon merely staying in power against the many societal challenges to their rule. And for those that do clamp down and secure their position, they must still wrestle with the frustrations and insecurities of their internal demons and emotional uncertainties. Those are far more interesting and compelling to me than a heavy-handed curse thrown in by a deus ex machina in all but name. (See my revisions to Azalin's curse to remove the most overt external meddling - he is no longer constrained by an inability to learn new magic, for example.) Macbeth may have seen the Witches, but the majority of the play deals with his desperate measures to stay in power, and the psychological toll of doing so for him and his wife - and that's the part of the tragedy that most interests me. Othello is even closer to my model: the flawed hero's downfall is orchestrated completely and undeniably by human hands, without even the suggestion of the supernatural (unlike Macbeth, where the supernatural is at best deniable and at worst essential).
Accordingly:
Zilfer wrote:I think you should leave Good Evil spectrum in your game Bing but remember it's not always your morals that your upholding in the game. The Dark Powers say it's bad to it's bad according to them.
The Dark Powers, to me, are a very tenuous pin to anchor arguments of good and evil morality. They are held up as the lynchpin for all that transpires in Ravenloft, but the official canonical definition of them is more noteworthy by what it leaves out rather than what it actually explains. In every edition's rule books, they largely amount to "they are whatever you want them to be". They could be "good" beings that sequester and punish evil creatures. They could be "evil" beings that toy with and torment sinners. Essentially, the canonical explanation is they are the GM's plot devices - and any attempt to define them any clearer than that must remain non-canonical (see "Lord of the Necropolis" for what fate befalls an author who tries to pin them down too clearly).Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:Here's the thing though, I haven't called them evil, the Dark Powers have called them evil. [...] In a Ravenloft without good and evil, what are the Dark Powers doing? Why are they choosing Azalin and Strahd et al to form domains around and not Van Richten and Gondegal, or Symbuk Torul and Joan Secousse? Or do you dump the whole shebang of darklords, domains and Dark Powers and make Ravenloft just a naturally formed world? And here's what I meant by "what's the point": If you go that far, why play Ravenloft and not some other setting? (one that doesn't have such a mishmash of history and geography, etc.)
So, the Dark Powers are an unpersuasive authority to support... well, anything, actually. In them, the GM can vest whatever game mechanics they see fit. Through them, the GM can shape the demiplane to whatever goal or outcome they want.
The next step of analysis is the Dark Lords, and once again I run into trouble with the idea of a fixed objective yardstick by which their crimes have been measured.
I believe looking at the Dark Lords individually, you'll find such a broad range of violations and punishments that it's not possible to formulate any objective measure that adequately explains any sort of "fitting the punishment to the crime" type of cosmic justice. Hazlik's actual crimes amount to two murders; Strahd von Zarovich killed dozens or hundreds of enemy soldiers before the wedding murders condemned him. Even Azalin is a fairly tame despot by Greyhawk's standards, in ruling over a single city-state for a generation or two and oppressing a few backward tribes - he's certainly no Iuz the Old. Why would the Dark Powers go after these and punish them, if the plan is to remove the greatest amount of evil from otherworld lands?
In almost every case, I think it's the passion and mental state of the Dark Lord that justifies their status as such. My answer to the choice of Dark Lords is that they're selected for the tragic nature of their stories. And this depends in large part on their internalized psychological states. In Milton's Paradise Lost Book IV, Satan says that even though he has escaped from Hell, he carries the Hell within him wherever he goes - a sentiment which Frankenstein's Creature later echoes. I think this is the key characteristic for the Dark Lords. Strahd's wedding body count pales in comparison to the millions killed by homeworld dictators and tyrants and dragon goddess queens... but it's the emotionally charged nature of the act that fixes his iconic status as a Dark Lord in Ravenloft.
This also ties in well to the meta-function of the Dark Lords and the characteristic traits of Ravenloft as a campaign setting, which is that they exist for the purpose of storytelling, and for the GM to present interesting villains far beyond the usual ethical scope of most sword-and-sorcery campaign settings. This, to me, is the strength of the Ravenloft setting, and it goes back all the way to the I6 adventure - you're fighting a fully psychologically realized villain, with their own agendas and specifically with their own shortcomings, rather than some stat block from a Monstrous Compendium. This is independent of whether the villain is being punished by a hard-and-fast external judicatory entity (as the classic "Dark Powers as Tribunal" model would have it) or by their own internal conflicts and mental state.
Note that this also ties in with my definition of morality as an internalized code of right and wrong. A Dark Lord may be the most powerful rank of character in Ravenloft, so the ethical punishment (i.e. externally from law, society, one's peers, etc.) is unlikely to be much of a deterrent - after all, if Azalin is the law, why would he fear it? (Some Dark Lords do not have this level of immunity - some such as Dominic d'Honaire and Victor Mordenheim are merely low-powered normal people within their social structures without the authority to define ethics. Others, such as Yagno Petrovna and other theocratic Dark Lords, exercise great authority within a strict social structure, so long as they comply with it, but they risk losing everything if they attempt to go against it - this can be especially dramatic where they themselves were initially responsible for setting up a rigid social structure in which they are now trapped!)
Given this reduced ethical pressure, I would submit that a Dark Lord's punishment comes largely from within. Azalin is tormented by his failure as a protector figure because of the death of Irik the Brother, and the later death (at his own hands) of Irik the Son. Strahd is tormented by his jealousy for his brother and his "thou shalt love me and none other" possessiveness over Tatyana. These are the things that torment and trouble them, and they're part of who the character was in the first place (or at least, part of what they ultimately became). They're less an externalized punishment meted out ("the Hell around me") and more a symbol of their own internal limitations, weaknesses, and unhappiness ("the Hell I carry within").
This implementation of "morality as internal limitations" is fully in keeping with GURPS, TriStat dX, and Hero system rules. I understand it's a bit more difficult for d20.
I understand that this view may be deeply unsatisfactory to those who seek a purist, objective view of good and evil, and of a final metric by which a person may be judged. It does give rise to the philosophical question of "Is something evil only if the person feels remorse?" Does it incentivize a person to harden himself to "evil" deeds and, in so doing, become invulnerable to the label? I understand this troubles people who attach value and meaning to the label. As a person who does not, I am not competent to, or in fact much interested in, enforcing such a label in my games.
Although my structure allows for ethics-based externalized punishment, it leaves the morality entirely up to the individual to ponder or ignore as they see fit. A violator who breaks laws in their nation but evades detection and capture could conceivably get away scot-free. This strikes me as an acceptably close approximation to the laws of physics and society as I understand them that I'm okay with it in my campaigns. If the PCs don't like it, a good GM works with them to give them a chance to change it. But that doesn't necessitate a judgment of whether they're being good or evil in doing so.
I offer no comment on good or evil, because I cannot meaningfully define those. Instead, I define morality more as a set of psychological internalized behaviors, and I reserve for ethics the question of external punishments. Ethics determine society's reaction to your actions, and I'm sure we've all seen society all too willing to punish a person for something even if he doesn't personally think it's wrong. (As this very forum's own discussions on copyright laws will show...) Whereas almost by definition, morals are what control your behavior in situation where you "could get away with it".
A soldier may kill ten thousand enemies and not feel remorse. But he can kill one unfaithful lover and feel emotional turmoil. And it's likely the emotional turmoil which will draw the eye of the Dark Powers (or, more honestly, "the GM") to bring him into Ravenloft - a campaign setting where each villain has a story to tell. After all, we don't discuss Strahd's crimes of the battlefield overthrows of Count Dorian or the Tergs.
In-universe from a PC's viewpoint, I am inclining towards a worldview that omits any sense of cosmic justice or retribution upon the Dark Lords. Ravenloft's own inhabitants are generally clueless about the Dark Powers (justifiably, since even the GM usually is) and very few of them have much inkling about the Dark Lords, either. Thus, the question about a Dark Lord's relationship with the Dark Powers, and his punishment by them, is of very minor immediate relevance to the PC's experience. I find greater mileage out of focusing on a Dark Lord's realworld stability concerns, in that much of their attention is focused upon merely staying in power against the many societal challenges to their rule. And for those that do clamp down and secure their position, they must still wrestle with the frustrations and insecurities of their internal demons and emotional uncertainties. Those are far more interesting and compelling to me than a heavy-handed curse thrown in by a deus ex machina in all but name. (See my revisions to Azalin's curse to remove the most overt external meddling - he is no longer constrained by an inability to learn new magic, for example.) Macbeth may have seen the Witches, but the majority of the play deals with his desperate measures to stay in power, and the psychological toll of doing so for him and his wife - and that's the part of the tragedy that most interests me. Othello is even closer to my model: the flawed hero's downfall is orchestrated completely and undeniably by human hands, without even the suggestion of the supernatural (unlike Macbeth, where the supernatural is at best deniable and at worst essential).
Accordingly:
- arguments that require me to attribute some sort of concrete motive to the Dark Powers are unpersuasive (I choose to leave them undefined, as the core rulebooks do, because a godlike figure is still a godlike figure, regardless of alignment, and still brings up logical problems for a non-theist).
- arguments that Dark Lords require a purely good vs. evil moral struggle are problematic for the same basic reason of definitions as above. (However, I have no problems with Dark Lords requiring some sort of emotional internal struggle, and I do implement this through internalized character conflicts. Again, GURPS has a systemic structure that supports this without automatically supposing an objective external moral scale.)
- arguments that the Dark Lords by definition require a curse handed down to them by the Dark Powers, I find unpersuasive, again because of the inherent assumptions of the Dark Powers. I am fine with the idea of a Dark Lord being a creature in some form of torment, but I do not see the torment as handed down by any sort of judiciary entity - although those observers who have a poetic sense may certainly choose to interpret it as such. I also consider an internal torment to be potentially far more evocative than an obvious external punishment, because like Milton's Satan, the sufferer may evade capture and defy punishment, but still remain tormented by the troubles within.
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
That's a really long and well thought out post there, HMB. (And I expect no less, of course) It will take time for me to fully digest it, but let me pose this question to you that is my first gut reaction:
What separates Strahd from Van Richten?
Both suffered a loss of someone they loved, that emotionally scarred them for life (for Van Richten, his son and wife, and for Strahd, Tatyana)
Both performed an act in pursuit/vengeance of what they loved, (for Van Richten, killing Baron Metus and the Radanovich clan, for Strahd, killing Alek Gwylim, Sergei and the wedding guests) using forbidden magics to do so (Van Richten's borrowed zombies from Azalin, and Strahd's vampire pact)
Both were cursed for this action (Van Richten's curse by Madame Radanovich, Strahd's darklord curse)
Both have spent the years since killing people unrelated to their initial loss (The monsters Van Richten hunts, The prey that Strahd drinks)
Both suffer internalized torment from their loss and neither feel much remorse for those they've killed (until the finale of Van Richten's Guide the Vistani, at least)
Note that I'm equating Strahd's innocent victims with Van Richten's foes because in the absence of morality, what's the difference? All the monsters Van Richten killed were minding their own business and doing what monsters do before he rudely slew them, no? Sometimes he worked with law enforcement and was on the side of ethical right, but surely at other times, he was working covertly against members of the establishment. Likewise, within Barovia, Strahd IS the land, and therefore IS the law, so he's always ethical by default.
I submit that there should be a definable difference between the two. And the Dark Powers clearly see a difference because one is saddled with darklordhood and one is not. But without calling one good and the other evil, without calling Van Richten's crusade justified and noble, and calling Strahd's reign of terror depraved and selfish, how can we differentiate them?
What separates Strahd from Van Richten?
Both suffered a loss of someone they loved, that emotionally scarred them for life (for Van Richten, his son and wife, and for Strahd, Tatyana)
Both performed an act in pursuit/vengeance of what they loved, (for Van Richten, killing Baron Metus and the Radanovich clan, for Strahd, killing Alek Gwylim, Sergei and the wedding guests) using forbidden magics to do so (Van Richten's borrowed zombies from Azalin, and Strahd's vampire pact)
Both were cursed for this action (Van Richten's curse by Madame Radanovich, Strahd's darklord curse)
Both have spent the years since killing people unrelated to their initial loss (The monsters Van Richten hunts, The prey that Strahd drinks)
Both suffer internalized torment from their loss and neither feel much remorse for those they've killed (until the finale of Van Richten's Guide the Vistani, at least)
Note that I'm equating Strahd's innocent victims with Van Richten's foes because in the absence of morality, what's the difference? All the monsters Van Richten killed were minding their own business and doing what monsters do before he rudely slew them, no? Sometimes he worked with law enforcement and was on the side of ethical right, but surely at other times, he was working covertly against members of the establishment. Likewise, within Barovia, Strahd IS the land, and therefore IS the law, so he's always ethical by default.
I submit that there should be a definable difference between the two. And the Dark Powers clearly see a difference because one is saddled with darklordhood and one is not. But without calling one good and the other evil, without calling Van Richten's crusade justified and noble, and calling Strahd's reign of terror depraved and selfish, how can we differentiate them?
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Zilfer
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4231
- Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
- Contact:
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
Sorry, I may not have understood your above post but it seemed to boil down in the counter argument that you couldn't accept the Dark powers giving out punishment/rewards for being evil. It sounds more like they don't exist in your game if you take that view point for Strahd is the way he is just because he is. He wasn't granted his power from the Darkpowers.... where did it come from?
Again i'm sorry if I'm missing something in your post, I'm scratching my head because I think I missed something. But that seems to be your stance. Leave them undefined and out of the picture. (Well why have them at all then?)
I agree that Ron's statement about; how can you judge things without the innate Good Vs Evil that is ingrained in most people, I mean without morality it'd be so hard to judge for ourselves right or wrong. It's complicated enough with Morality in the game does taking it out make it any easier?
What do you see as the benefits of doing this. (sorry if i missed that apart above again)
Again i'm sorry if I'm missing something in your post, I'm scratching my head because I think I missed something. But that seems to be your stance. Leave them undefined and out of the picture. (Well why have them at all then?)
I agree that Ron's statement about; how can you judge things without the innate Good Vs Evil that is ingrained in most people, I mean without morality it'd be so hard to judge for ourselves right or wrong. It's complicated enough with Morality in the game does taking it out make it any easier?
What do you see as the benefits of doing this. (sorry if i missed that apart above again)
- Zettaijin
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 670
- Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 2:30 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: Himeji, Japan
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
But you're ok with Azalin and Strahd, right?arguments that require me to attribute some sort of concrete motive to the Dark Powers are unpersuasive (I choose to leave them undefined, as the core rulebooks do, because a godlike figure is still a godlike figure, regardless of alignment, and still brings up logical problems for a non-theist).
Dude, as a fairly rational atheist I find the idea of an ambulant, sentient skeleton capable of altering the very fabric of what we deem to be the "laws of nature" on little more than a whim and who seems to be able to animate massive amounts of dead bodies with a thought to be rather unpersuasive.
And a blood sucking immortal being who is technically deceased yet still fully conscious?
God-like beings ruling over a misty sandbox are easier to swallow when we have these guys running around.
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
I came back to this thread because of an Oglaf cartoon. (Warning: crude language but no nudity.) The third panel has a statement that's almost signature material.
Also, I revisit this question because there is a newer thread that's generating a fair bit of controversy about Dark Powers checks. It struck me as thematically apt.
From browsing the other posts, I have come across several repeated points.
1. Gothic horror requires evil, and Gothic horror without evil is a contradiction in terms.
Numerous posters have emphasized this point as a matter of fact. I can respect that others feel that way, and I understand if you believe Gothic horror truly requires some objectively defined evil actor, then I will state my disagreement and leave this an open question for more knowledgeable literary scholars to answer. My own readings of the story of Frankenstein and the works of Anne Radcliffe have left me with the belief that Gothic horror can exist independently of a clear-cut evil figure, and furthermore that it can allow for questions about who has the right to define something as evil, and indeed whether it exists at all. I also note that the mere presence of an antagonist (even one who must be stopped at all costs) is not, by itself, presence of evil.
2. Some of the earlier posts go one step further, and they focus on whether or not Ravenloft requires Gothic aesthetics as opposed to other horror genres. I think this is both more specific, and easier to rebut. Ravenloft's own examples indicate that it is hardly confined to the purely Gothic strain of horror. Vladimir Ludzig, Gwydion, and even Azalin himself stand as noteworthy departures from the Gothic milieu, as they hail from steampunk, Lovecraft, and modern fantasy fiction respectively - all without "breaking" the demiplane. Even if my proposals cannot possibly be defined as "Gothic" (as per point 1. above - which I am not prepared to concede), this is overridden by a larger issue: the setting does not require purely Gothic horror play. Bluetspur is about as alien as they come, and it was present from the first printing of the Black Box. It also would have formed the last domain of S.'s tour through the Gazetteers, according to the outline provided by the 3rd ed. campaign writers.
3. The question of whether Ravenloft requires an objective definition of evil (and the central discussion to this thread) is separate from both points 1. and 2. above. Again, if the concept of Ravenloft, in your definition, requires a concept of evil as well, then you and I hold fundamentally incompatible views and it's not my place to challenge them. The best I can do is to explain my position and to describe my own successes or failures in running a campaign under these parameters. I do so here.
Now, to specific points raised in discussion.
On what differentiates a good guy from a bad guy:
Let's look at functional differences. Functionally, in a campaign, the "difference" between Van Richten and Strahd is first and foremost one of subjective placement. Van Richten is much more likely to aid the PCs than to act against them, and Strahd is much more likely to oppose them. The PCs ally with VR more readily because he's somewhat more similar to them.
Imagine, conversely, if the setting was more of a Birthright setting or a Dungeon Keeper style of game, where the PCs were rulers or nobles in their own right. VR would be a quisling adventurer lurking around in the background - and Strahd would be much more relevant as an ally or a rival. The same could be said if the PCs were Vistani in the Zarovan tasque, or playing lycanthropes or servitor vampires in Strahd's employ.
In my opinion, the question of "by what measure is a villain" is worth asking. A campaign that does it well is admirable. Consider this: The general human populace may support VR's reputation as a champion against evil, whereas a coven of vampires may view him as the embodiment of murderous excess - a presumptuous mortal who, in his self-proclaimed monopoly of morality, destroys the limitless futures of immortals just to salve his own fleeting existence. (Such a point is specifically made in VRGttV in one of the descriptive texts.)
The canonical rules discourage allowing the PCs to play as the "dark" characters. To me, that does a disservice to the setting's versatility. Why not play a murderer, an assassin, a Vistani? "Because the book says so" is, to me, insufficiently compelling reason.
These questions go above and beyond the usual simplistic "humans good, nonhumans evil" crusaders' philosophy. Where you stand determines what you see. My focus is much more on asking the question "Where do you stand?" And I'm not the first to do it, either - TIE Fighter, Dungeon Keeper, Planescape Torment, and Ultima VI all asked the question of "what makes you so sure you're on the side of good?" Plenty of movies do it too - including the Dracula adaptation by Francis Ford Coppola, which specifically takes an ambivalent or even sympathetic view of the Count and demonstrates the dramatic potential for viewing "the other side of the fence".
Realworld leaders - Moammar Ghaddafy, Saddam Hussein, Osama bin Laden - all have complex histories of glories and calumnies. To me, a story that draws a simple moral tale of "they were evil, so we fought them and now they're gone" is not compelling. Much more interesting to me is a nuanced reading, such as "they filled a popular demand", or "they ruled well... at first", or even "they're our enemies now, but we were the ones who helped put them in power to begin with". (All three of which could historically be said of all three of the above figures.) I don't think Ravenloft is so fragile that it collapses when a campaign examines such complex issues in the character of its rulers. A PC group can be put in between the machinations of two utterly amoral, deceptive, and brutal leaders, and be asked "which of these do you help in their fight against the other?"
As mentioned in an earlier post, I am working to erase or downplay the most heavy-handed game mechanics of "Dark Powers as judges". I believe that this renders the second part of your post, about the Dark Powers "rewarding" Strahd with darklordship, moot. As with any other darklord, Strahd's position as leader of Barovia is essentially a development of history. He's there now, and although the facts of how he got there may be of great interest to the PCs, any moral "lesson" they choose to draw from his ascension (including faith in some cosmic thumb on the scales, punishing him for past misdeeds) are just that - a moral they have chosen to impose on the facts. Ravenloft campaigns also function perfectly well without Strahd at all - I've set numerous campaigns in and around Darkon, where mentions of Barovia and its darklord are rare. (In fact, my mentions of Darkon's darklord are pretty uncommon as well even within Darkon.)
Again, I'm aware that this will trigger responses of "if you remove {X canonical characteristic} from Ravenloft, it ceases to be Ravenloft". You are free to hold that opinion but if that's the alpha and omega of your input, then we must conclude our discussion with a simple disagreement of assumptions. Mere canonicity by itself has never been a compelling argument for me.
On whether the choice to eliminate the concept of moral judgment is a limitation on the campaign
On whether disbelief in a godlike being is rendered logically impossible by belief in fictitious characters
(And there's nothing wrong with disagreement. Reasonable minds can certainly agree to disagree.)
Discussion follows below, in spoiler tags for tangentiality.
There are more points to cover, but I'll have to get round to them some other time. Zettaijin spent several posts delving deep into the philosophy of moral codes or ethical codes, and I owe those a much closer reading and greater study. I should have done this before replying last time, but there was too much material to get through, and I hope to do it the justice it deserves at a later date.
Also, ewancummins suggests a Corruption or Taint mechanic. I seem to recall that Taint was brought up in Heroes of Horror - although I'm blanking on which DnD sourcebook described Corruption. (I do recall there is a "corruption" path for failed Dark Powers checks in the Ravenloft rulebooks.) Both are good suggestions; GURPS does feature something very similar - it used to be called "Corruption" in older editions, but in 4th edition they call it "Spiritual Distortion" (for a more morally-neutral terminology), and the way it functions is described in my GURPS Ravenloft conversion thread.
Finally, in the Agency Campaign thread, Gonzoron brings up the question of whether a "corrupting spellbook" could truly exist in a setting where "evil" is meaningless. I maintain it certainly can. Mere danger does not equal evil. A nuclear code briefcase, or a smallpox virus test tube, or the Black Death, can all exist in an amoral universe. After all, pestilence was mankind's worst enemy long before we thought to call anything "evil".
Also, I revisit this question because there is a newer thread that's generating a fair bit of controversy about Dark Powers checks. It struck me as thematically apt.
From browsing the other posts, I have come across several repeated points.
1. Gothic horror requires evil, and Gothic horror without evil is a contradiction in terms.
Numerous posters have emphasized this point as a matter of fact. I can respect that others feel that way, and I understand if you believe Gothic horror truly requires some objectively defined evil actor, then I will state my disagreement and leave this an open question for more knowledgeable literary scholars to answer. My own readings of the story of Frankenstein and the works of Anne Radcliffe have left me with the belief that Gothic horror can exist independently of a clear-cut evil figure, and furthermore that it can allow for questions about who has the right to define something as evil, and indeed whether it exists at all. I also note that the mere presence of an antagonist (even one who must be stopped at all costs) is not, by itself, presence of evil.
2. Some of the earlier posts go one step further, and they focus on whether or not Ravenloft requires Gothic aesthetics as opposed to other horror genres. I think this is both more specific, and easier to rebut. Ravenloft's own examples indicate that it is hardly confined to the purely Gothic strain of horror. Vladimir Ludzig, Gwydion, and even Azalin himself stand as noteworthy departures from the Gothic milieu, as they hail from steampunk, Lovecraft, and modern fantasy fiction respectively - all without "breaking" the demiplane. Even if my proposals cannot possibly be defined as "Gothic" (as per point 1. above - which I am not prepared to concede), this is overridden by a larger issue: the setting does not require purely Gothic horror play. Bluetspur is about as alien as they come, and it was present from the first printing of the Black Box. It also would have formed the last domain of S.'s tour through the Gazetteers, according to the outline provided by the 3rd ed. campaign writers.
3. The question of whether Ravenloft requires an objective definition of evil (and the central discussion to this thread) is separate from both points 1. and 2. above. Again, if the concept of Ravenloft, in your definition, requires a concept of evil as well, then you and I hold fundamentally incompatible views and it's not my place to challenge them. The best I can do is to explain my position and to describe my own successes or failures in running a campaign under these parameters. I do so here.
Now, to specific points raised in discussion.
On what differentiates a good guy from a bad guy:
I strongly uphold your (rhetorically made) point, which is that from a certain point of view Van Richten and Strahd could both be seen as villainously culpable. The way you made your post suggests that you consider it absurd. As a reader with a strong aversion to any moral absolutist viewpoint, I consider it inspired.Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:What separates Strahd from Van Richten? [...] All the monsters Van Richten killed were minding their own business and doing what monsters do before he rudely slew them, no? Sometimes he worked with law enforcement and was on the side of ethical right, but surely at other times, he was working covertly against members of the establishment. Likewise, within Barovia, Strahd IS the land, and therefore IS the law, so he's always ethical by default.
I submit that there should be a definable difference between the two. And the Dark Powers clearly see a difference because one is saddled with darklordhood and one is not.
Let's look at functional differences. Functionally, in a campaign, the "difference" between Van Richten and Strahd is first and foremost one of subjective placement. Van Richten is much more likely to aid the PCs than to act against them, and Strahd is much more likely to oppose them. The PCs ally with VR more readily because he's somewhat more similar to them.
Imagine, conversely, if the setting was more of a Birthright setting or a Dungeon Keeper style of game, where the PCs were rulers or nobles in their own right. VR would be a quisling adventurer lurking around in the background - and Strahd would be much more relevant as an ally or a rival. The same could be said if the PCs were Vistani in the Zarovan tasque, or playing lycanthropes or servitor vampires in Strahd's employ.
In my opinion, the question of "by what measure is a villain" is worth asking. A campaign that does it well is admirable. Consider this: The general human populace may support VR's reputation as a champion against evil, whereas a coven of vampires may view him as the embodiment of murderous excess - a presumptuous mortal who, in his self-proclaimed monopoly of morality, destroys the limitless futures of immortals just to salve his own fleeting existence. (Such a point is specifically made in VRGttV in one of the descriptive texts.)
The canonical rules discourage allowing the PCs to play as the "dark" characters. To me, that does a disservice to the setting's versatility. Why not play a murderer, an assassin, a Vistani? "Because the book says so" is, to me, insufficiently compelling reason.
These questions go above and beyond the usual simplistic "humans good, nonhumans evil" crusaders' philosophy. Where you stand determines what you see. My focus is much more on asking the question "Where do you stand?" And I'm not the first to do it, either - TIE Fighter, Dungeon Keeper, Planescape Torment, and Ultima VI all asked the question of "what makes you so sure you're on the side of good?" Plenty of movies do it too - including the Dracula adaptation by Francis Ford Coppola, which specifically takes an ambivalent or even sympathetic view of the Count and demonstrates the dramatic potential for viewing "the other side of the fence".
Realworld leaders - Moammar Ghaddafy, Saddam Hussein, Osama bin Laden - all have complex histories of glories and calumnies. To me, a story that draws a simple moral tale of "they were evil, so we fought them and now they're gone" is not compelling. Much more interesting to me is a nuanced reading, such as "they filled a popular demand", or "they ruled well... at first", or even "they're our enemies now, but we were the ones who helped put them in power to begin with". (All three of which could historically be said of all three of the above figures.) I don't think Ravenloft is so fragile that it collapses when a campaign examines such complex issues in the character of its rulers. A PC group can be put in between the machinations of two utterly amoral, deceptive, and brutal leaders, and be asked "which of these do you help in their fight against the other?"
As mentioned in an earlier post, I am working to erase or downplay the most heavy-handed game mechanics of "Dark Powers as judges". I believe that this renders the second part of your post, about the Dark Powers "rewarding" Strahd with darklordship, moot. As with any other darklord, Strahd's position as leader of Barovia is essentially a development of history. He's there now, and although the facts of how he got there may be of great interest to the PCs, any moral "lesson" they choose to draw from his ascension (including faith in some cosmic thumb on the scales, punishing him for past misdeeds) are just that - a moral they have chosen to impose on the facts. Ravenloft campaigns also function perfectly well without Strahd at all - I've set numerous campaigns in and around Darkon, where mentions of Barovia and its darklord are rare. (In fact, my mentions of Darkon's darklord are pretty uncommon as well even within Darkon.)
Again, I'm aware that this will trigger responses of "if you remove {X canonical characteristic} from Ravenloft, it ceases to be Ravenloft". You are free to hold that opinion but if that's the alpha and omega of your input, then we must conclude our discussion with a simple disagreement of assumptions. Mere canonicity by itself has never been a compelling argument for me.
On whether the choice to eliminate the concept of moral judgment is a limitation on the campaign
The way you phrase it is interesting, because it implies that I have decided to purposefully exclude a useful tool or an objective truth, and thus limit the range of the work. But consider another way of looking at it: consider that the excluded element is a hindrance rather than a tool, and that by excluding it, I am opening up different realms of inquiry and exploration. No longer does the game slap players on the wrist with a mechanic that says "naughty player, try again". Instead, the campaign's focus is on posing the question to the players themselves: "how far would your character go?" "Can you put yourself in their shoes and think as they would think?" "What do you think society around you would do, in the absence of some Ultimate Invigilator?"Jimsolo wrote:I think that choosing to eliminate good and evil as considerations in their entirety does a disservice to your plots as well as your players. It's like being a painter who doesn't use a specific color at all. I'm not saying you can't create a good painting without the color green. In fact, you could create some damn good paintings like that. However, it gets mighty boring looking at paintings that never have any green in them at all. And it's certainly makes your job more difficult, since in this case the setting of most of your paintings is a traditionally agrarian one. (Not impossible, mind, just difficult.)
On whether disbelief in a godlike being is rendered logically impossible by belief in fictitious characters
Yes. I do not consider the two examples (Azalin/Strahd on the one hand, a godlike being on the other) to be equally absurd. Put another way, I believe that the Azalin/Strahd example requires much less suspension of disbelief than the idea of a godlike being. If you personally hold them to be identical in believability, that illustrates an important fundamental difference of perception between us.Zettaijin wrote:[in response to my aversion to god-like beings because of my own atheism]
But you're ok with Azalin and Strahd, right? Dude, as a fairly rational atheist I find the idea of an ambulant, sentient skeleton capable of altering the very fabric of what we deem to be the "laws of nature" on little more than a whim and who seems to be able to animate massive amounts of dead bodies with a thought to be rather unpersuasive. And a blood sucking immortal being who is technically deceased yet still fully conscious?
(And there's nothing wrong with disagreement. Reasonable minds can certainly agree to disagree.)
Discussion follows below, in spoiler tags for tangentiality.
VIEW CONTENT:
Also, ewancummins suggests a Corruption or Taint mechanic. I seem to recall that Taint was brought up in Heroes of Horror - although I'm blanking on which DnD sourcebook described Corruption. (I do recall there is a "corruption" path for failed Dark Powers checks in the Ravenloft rulebooks.) Both are good suggestions; GURPS does feature something very similar - it used to be called "Corruption" in older editions, but in 4th edition they call it "Spiritual Distortion" (for a more morally-neutral terminology), and the way it functions is described in my GURPS Ravenloft conversion thread.
Finally, in the Agency Campaign thread, Gonzoron brings up the question of whether a "corrupting spellbook" could truly exist in a setting where "evil" is meaningless. I maintain it certainly can. Mere danger does not equal evil. A nuclear code briefcase, or a smallpox virus test tube, or the Black Death, can all exist in an amoral universe. After all, pestilence was mankind's worst enemy long before we thought to call anything "evil".
Re: Thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns
Hey hey. So...here's my thing:
1. I'm still not entirely sure what you are trying to get from this thread. (Not trying to be standoffish, just trying to get some clarification.)
Are you just wanting feedback on this theoretical idea? Are you asking whether or not people think it's a good idea? Have you already decided to do it, and are merely trying to get help predicting any possible hiccups in implementation? Or are you wanting us to argue you out of it?
2. It seems like you are trying to bring your real-world views on morality into your game. If you also serve as some kind of philosophical or spiritual leader for your players, I think that might work out for you. For most other social dynamics, I think that your players will have views on morality that are too far different from your own to make this fun for them. I think that this challenge (Ravenloft is a game where moral and ethical issues are central to the storytelling) is the greatest challenge to running an effective Ravenloft game. It's very hard to tell morality/ethics stories when the parties involved have vastly frameworks. D&D (and Ravenloft in specific) at least attempts to rectify this by providing a framework that we can all agree to treat as the 'way things work' at least for the purpose of the story we are all telling together. I think that attempting to replace the game's framework with that of any one person's real-world views is a mistake. Even among close friends, there can be vast disagreements on issues of morals and ethics, so unless everyone shares a single set of views, I wouldn't do it.
3. I think that any major change to the game should be considered heavily. If there's any doubt in my mind, I don't do it. Minor changes are one thing, but big sweeping changes can have vast impacts on our games that we can't always predict. I think that the good DM is the cautious DM when it comes to this.
How big of a role do you feel your players play in telling the story in your game? Do you feel that the players are constructing the story along with the DM, or do you feel that the DM does all the story construction, and the players are just experiencing it? I haven't really see you discuss how your players feel so far, and really, the players are the most important part of the game. (If they weren't, we'd just go write books!
) I'm assuming you AREN'T one of those really sick DMs who are just behind the screen because they want to run their campaign like their own personal video game, with everyone acting like puppets on a string, doing exactly what the DM wants. But I think you need to ask yourself if your views are more important or if their views are. If you are going to replace the conventional rules of morality in D&D with anything, it deserves the be the views your players hold, I think.
I know you haven't got a whole lot of time, and you have a whole lot of responses here, so just think of it as food for thought. I admit that I hadn't thought of the 'morality as a tool' from your point of view (as an impediment rather than a boon). After a day of consideration, I still think it's a useful tool rather than a liability, but I think that the difference there is so fundamental that neither of us will ever convince the other. I'm just going to chalk it up to artistic differences, and ask you to consider what is best for the story you are telling (and your players are helping to construct).
In any event, come what may, no matter what you decide, I hope your game only gets better. Again, if you put this much thought into one aspect of your game, I am willing to bet you are very attentive to other aspects too, and I wager that your players probably enjoy it very much. I certainly hope they appreciate the work you do on their behalf.
1. I'm still not entirely sure what you are trying to get from this thread. (Not trying to be standoffish, just trying to get some clarification.)
2. It seems like you are trying to bring your real-world views on morality into your game. If you also serve as some kind of philosophical or spiritual leader for your players, I think that might work out for you. For most other social dynamics, I think that your players will have views on morality that are too far different from your own to make this fun for them. I think that this challenge (Ravenloft is a game where moral and ethical issues are central to the storytelling) is the greatest challenge to running an effective Ravenloft game. It's very hard to tell morality/ethics stories when the parties involved have vastly frameworks. D&D (and Ravenloft in specific) at least attempts to rectify this by providing a framework that we can all agree to treat as the 'way things work' at least for the purpose of the story we are all telling together. I think that attempting to replace the game's framework with that of any one person's real-world views is a mistake. Even among close friends, there can be vast disagreements on issues of morals and ethics, so unless everyone shares a single set of views, I wouldn't do it.
3. I think that any major change to the game should be considered heavily. If there's any doubt in my mind, I don't do it. Minor changes are one thing, but big sweeping changes can have vast impacts on our games that we can't always predict. I think that the good DM is the cautious DM when it comes to this.
How big of a role do you feel your players play in telling the story in your game? Do you feel that the players are constructing the story along with the DM, or do you feel that the DM does all the story construction, and the players are just experiencing it? I haven't really see you discuss how your players feel so far, and really, the players are the most important part of the game. (If they weren't, we'd just go write books!
I know you haven't got a whole lot of time, and you have a whole lot of responses here, so just think of it as food for thought. I admit that I hadn't thought of the 'morality as a tool' from your point of view (as an impediment rather than a boon). After a day of consideration, I still think it's a useful tool rather than a liability, but I think that the difference there is so fundamental that neither of us will ever convince the other. I'm just going to chalk it up to artistic differences, and ask you to consider what is best for the story you are telling (and your players are helping to construct).
In any event, come what may, no matter what you decide, I hope your game only gets better. Again, if you put this much thought into one aspect of your game, I am willing to bet you are very attentive to other aspects too, and I wager that your players probably enjoy it very much. I certainly hope they appreciate the work you do on their behalf.
