As we all know, 4th edition made a major (and, in my personal opinion, well needed) change to the sacred cow that is alignment. In addition to trimming down the original nine into five, it also made alignment no longer an in-game mechanic in its own right. No alignment restrictions to classes, no detecting or protecting against alignment, etc.
However, I was wondering: does adopting this system to 4e Ravenloft pose any mechanical problems with, for example, Powers Checks? Elena Faithhold's curse still works, as far as I know - after all, she was never detecting "evil", just strong emotions, positive or negative, held towards her - but I'm just worried about how well 4e's lack of alignment mechanics might affect Ravenloft games.
4ed Ravenloft question: Alignment problems?
4ed Ravenloft question: Alignment problems?
"Is there any word more meaningless than 'hope'? Besides 'blarfurgsnarg,' of course."
"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
Re: 4ed Ravenloft question: Alignment problems?
If you're going to run Ravenloft with D&D 4th edition, I honestly think that the alignment mechanics may give you a little bit of difficulty on the DM side of the screen, but if you've already managed to make your peace with the other problems the edition brings to a Ravenloft setting, then I think you should be fine. In many ways, Ravenloft removes some of the difficulties from your path (since there was never alignment detection in Ravenloft to begin with) rather than adding them.
I think with the powers checks, since the severity is based off of the 'alignment' of the victim, you should just make a judgement call as a DM. It should be fairly easy to lump the victimized NPC into the 'evil,' 'neutral,' 'good,' or 'innocent' categories. I think that all of the areas where mechanical difficulties will come into play will be restricted to what the DM alone is privy to, so as long as you handle things in a manner which is consistent with fair play as well as good storycraft, I don't think your players will ever know, or object if they do somehow find out.
As a side note, I would really appreciate hearing what your beef with the old alignment system was. Since I've always loved it (the way I and my close friends run it) I am interested to see why you disliked it so. Thus far, I've only ever run into people having a problem with it when it was mismanaged (or misunderstood, but you seem smart enough, so I don't think that's the case). I'd really like an objective opportunity to make the case for a more comprehensive alignment system rather than the one that 4e uses.
I think with the powers checks, since the severity is based off of the 'alignment' of the victim, you should just make a judgement call as a DM. It should be fairly easy to lump the victimized NPC into the 'evil,' 'neutral,' 'good,' or 'innocent' categories. I think that all of the areas where mechanical difficulties will come into play will be restricted to what the DM alone is privy to, so as long as you handle things in a manner which is consistent with fair play as well as good storycraft, I don't think your players will ever know, or object if they do somehow find out.
As a side note, I would really appreciate hearing what your beef with the old alignment system was. Since I've always loved it (the way I and my close friends run it) I am interested to see why you disliked it so. Thus far, I've only ever run into people having a problem with it when it was mismanaged (or misunderstood, but you seem smart enough, so I don't think that's the case). I'd really like an objective opportunity to make the case for a more comprehensive alignment system rather than the one that 4e uses.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: 4ed Ravenloft question: Alignment problems?
I was using the old alignment system in 4th edition. 
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Re: 4ed Ravenloft question: Alignment problems?
I cannot for the life of me, see any reasons why using the 4E alignment system would give you any problems in Ravenloft.
And evil act is still an evil act, regardless of what alignment system you use. Just utilize your Dark Powers check system of choice (there's been a few over the years), and eyeball what you think should be the appropriate percentage chance based on what happened.
As another said, Ravenloft makes it even easier, as detecting alignment went out the window anyways.
And evil act is still an evil act, regardless of what alignment system you use. Just utilize your Dark Powers check system of choice (there's been a few over the years), and eyeball what you think should be the appropriate percentage chance based on what happened.
As another said, Ravenloft makes it even easier, as detecting alignment went out the window anyways.
- The Pickled Punk
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 155
- Joined: Tue Jan 06, 2004 11:21 am
- Location: New York City
Re: 4ed Ravenloft question: Alignment problems?
In terms of Lady Elena Faithhold's curse, I see no reason to change anything. In fact, because "regular" Paladins and Cavaliers can not detect anyone's alignment, she no doubt holds herself in high esteem, in her hubris assuming that she is "special". In the meantime, her curse remains the same: she detects strong emotions, love or hate, anger or remorse, jealousy or sadness, as "Evil" and reacts accordingly.
In terms of Dark Powers checks, there shouldn't be any change. The alignment of the victim's only effect was the severity of the offense (or sometimes whether to make a roll or not).
The old Alignments end up as follows: Lawful Good and Chaotic Evil are unchanged. Neutral Good and Chaotic Good were lumped together as Good (though Good is closer to the old Neutral Good in many respects). Lawful Evil and Neutral Evil were lumped together as Evil (which veers a lot closer to the old Lawful Evil). Lawful Neutral, True Neutral and Chaotic Neutral all became Unaligned. Unaligned varies between strongly True Neutral (like 1E Druids or Mordenkainen) and Apathetic. Under the 4E Alignment System, both Mordenkainen and Lord Robilar are Unaligned, but Mordenkainen is unalligned because he seeks balance between Good and Evil and Law and Chaos, while Lord Robilar is Unaligned because he is too undisciplined to obey the law, too amoral to be Good and too honorable to be Chaotic Evil. Unaligned is the real mess of the 4E Alignment System, IMO.
This will all be moot in a few months, to a degree, since D&D Next is bringing back the nine-alignment system. (Hopefully with better explanations for how to roleplay Chaotic Good, Chaotic Neutral and Neutral Evil.)
In terms of Dark Powers checks, there shouldn't be any change. The alignment of the victim's only effect was the severity of the offense (or sometimes whether to make a roll or not).
The old Alignments end up as follows: Lawful Good and Chaotic Evil are unchanged. Neutral Good and Chaotic Good were lumped together as Good (though Good is closer to the old Neutral Good in many respects). Lawful Evil and Neutral Evil were lumped together as Evil (which veers a lot closer to the old Lawful Evil). Lawful Neutral, True Neutral and Chaotic Neutral all became Unaligned. Unaligned varies between strongly True Neutral (like 1E Druids or Mordenkainen) and Apathetic. Under the 4E Alignment System, both Mordenkainen and Lord Robilar are Unaligned, but Mordenkainen is unalligned because he seeks balance between Good and Evil and Law and Chaos, while Lord Robilar is Unaligned because he is too undisciplined to obey the law, too amoral to be Good and too honorable to be Chaotic Evil. Unaligned is the real mess of the 4E Alignment System, IMO.
This will all be moot in a few months, to a degree, since D&D Next is bringing back the nine-alignment system. (Hopefully with better explanations for how to roleplay Chaotic Good, Chaotic Neutral and Neutral Evil.)
The Kosher Pickled Punk of the Carnival

