Firstly, let me say that I really like Jester's "4efication" of the Caliban race. I never really saw any difference between them and Half-Orcs in 3.5, but the variant Jester came up with truly feels different to the Half-Orc, both the past version and the present version.
Secondly, I'm also a fan of Uri "Shadowking" Barak's "Brutes and Banshees" article in Quoth the Raven #8, which gives 5 sub-races of Caliban (Brutes, Bestials, Banshees, Cannibals, Witch-Spawn) to better customize the player's species, as well as distinct mutations.
So, with those facts out of the way, I come before you all to ask for advice: would it be possible to resurrect the concept of Caliban Breeds, or at least the idea of specific mutations, in 4th edition? If yes, how?
I'm aware of three possibilities, but I'm not certain which would work best.
Firstly, there's the possibility of, well, I call them "variable features"- see the Shifter in the Player's Handbook 2, or the Genasi in the Forgotten Realms Player's Guide.
Secondly, Shifters also resurrect some of the old edition variants (Gorehide, for example) through usage of racial feats.
The third and final option is to use Racial Paragon Paths. Speaking of which, are there any plans in general to make a Racial Paragon Path for the 4e Caliban and the Giomorgo?
Caliban Breeds in 4e
Caliban Breeds in 4e
"Is there any word more meaningless than 'hope'? Besides 'blarfurgsnarg,' of course."
"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
Re: Caliban Breeds in 4e
Because there are now quite a lot of racial variants for 4e races - I can think of Blightseer Tieflings, Dragonfear Dragonborn, Bozaak and Kapak Draconians being handled as ability-tradeouts of Dragonborn, Winterkin Eladrin, Dusk Elves, and Forgeborn Dwarves off the top of my head - I thought I'd give this topic one last shot at getting off the ground.
As I said in my opening post, I really like the customization of the Caliban presented in Brutes and Banshees - it made a big difference towards them feeling like something other than half-orcs with the serial numbers removed in 3.5. And while I accept that a perfect translation of all the deformities is unworkable, I do think that at least the general ideas of the five breeds - Banshee, Bestial, Brute, Cannibal and Witchspawn - could be used as fully-fledged racial variant options.
Indeed, the Draconian article I mentioned above particularly gives me hope for this, because of how it's handled. In essence, each of the two draconian breeds is handled as a set of three racial features; a dragonborn can swap any number of their default racial features for those from the article. This not only allows for a pretty accurate depiction of a 4e draconian, but allows for great customization of a dragonborn; there is, after all, absolutely no rules against trading Draconic Heritage and Dragon Breath for Instinctive Flight (Bozak variation) and Caustic Heritage (Kapak variation).
I'm just not a very good homebrewer, so I would really appreciate if I could get some help; at the very least, some folks to criticise my efforts would be appreciated.
Edit:
Well, I figured I might as well try my hand at some brainstorming, instead of just pleading for others to come along and help. First up, a hopefully not problematic basic outline of the "common" 4e Caliban:
4e Caliban
+2 Strength, +2 Constitution
Speed 6 Squares
Low-light Vision
+2 Endurance, +2 Intimidate
Cursed Lineage (+5 racial bonus to death saving throws)
Man Or Monster (can use Second Wind to Regenerate instead of heal)
Relentless Rage Racial Encounter Power
Stubborn Mind (+1 Will)
And next, the unique traits of the 3.5 Breeds.
3.5 Banshee Caliban
+2 Charisma, -2 Constitution
Deformities: Witch Fingers, Gaunt, Material Vulnerability, Pale, Twisted Organs, Witch Nipple, Backwards Eye, Double Irises, Eyes of Darkness, Swirling Eyes, Angelic Visage, Large Ears, Backwards Feet, Deranged, Magical Affinity (Any Bard or Necromancy), Eerie Whisper, Forked Tongue, Voice of the Many
3.5 Bestial Caliban
+2 Strength, -2 Intelligence, -2 Charisma
Deformities: Claws, Extra Arms, Multi-Segmented Limbs, Suckers, Bones of Steel, Fur, Giant, Gills, Increased Metabolism, Membrane Wings, Rough Skin, Shedding, Spinnerets, Tail, Bulbous Eyes, Bloodshot Eyes, Horns, Great Nose, Large Ears, Frogs Legs, Gorilla Feet, Hooves, Quadrepad, Webbed Limbs, Magical Affinity (Any Druid), Forked Tongue, Frog Tongue, Projectile Vomit, Sharp Teeth, Unusual Appetite.
3.5 Brute Caliban
+2 Strength, +2 Constitution, -2 Intelligence, -2 Wisdom, -2 Charisma
Deformities: Extra Arms, Multi-Segmented Limbs, Witch Fingers, Aberrant, Bones of Steel, Giant, Hunchback, Increased Metabolism, Material Vulnerability, Obesity, Rough Skin, Rubbery, Short Neck, Skulk, Slimy, Toxic Blood, Twisted Organs, Witch Nipple, Backwards Eye, Bulbous Eyes, Bloodshot Eyes, Cyclops, Face of Nightmare, Great Nose, Large Ears, No Nose, Backwards Feet, Gorilla Feet, Webbed Limbs, Deranged, Magical Affinity (Any), Malformed Twin, Frog Tongue, Projectile Vomit, Sharp Teeth, Unusual Appetite
3.5 Cannibal Caliban
+2 Dexterity, -2 Charisma
Deformities: Claws, Extra Arms, Multi-Segmented Limbs, Suckers, Aberrant, Dwarfism, Gaunt, Hunchback, Increased Metabolism, Material Vulnerability, Membrane Wings, Obesity, Pale, Rough Skin, Rubbery, Skulk, Slimy, Spinnerets, Toxic Blood, Twisted Organs, Bulbous Eyes, Bloodshot Eyes, Eyes of Darkness, Face of Nightmare, Great Nose, Frogs Legs, Gorilla Feet, Quadruped, Webbed Limbs, Deranged, Malformed Twin, Eerie Whisper, Forked Tongue, Frog Tongue, Sharp Teeth, Unusual Appetite
3.5 Witchspawn Caliban
+2 Intelligence, +2 Charisma, -2 Strength, -2 Constitution
Deformities: Witch Fingers, Aberrant, Dwarfism, Gaunt, Hunchback, Material Vulnerability, Membrane Wings, Pale, Tail, Touch of Unease, Twisted Organs, Witch Nipple, Backwards Eye, Double Irises, Eyes of Darkness, Swirling Eyes, Angelic Visage, Face of Nightmare, Horns, Large Ears, Backwards Feet, Hooves, Deranged, Magical Affinity (Any), Malformed Twin, Mark of the Warlock, Forked Tongue, Unusual Appetite, Voice of Many
Hmm... looking at them like this, it seems to me that the Breeds might actually be better handled as separate races in their own right, similar to how Elves, Eladrin, Half-Elves and Drow are all their own kind of race. Perhaps some/many of the deformities can be turned into racial feats that can be taken by all forms of Caliban?
Preceeding under this logic... a draft of the Banshee Caliban for 4e:
+2 Strength, +2 Charisma
- 4e no longer uses ability penalties, Strength is a bonus from the existing 4e Caliban, and it feels wrong to include Con bonus when it suffered a Con penalty in the last edition.
Speed: 6 squares
- The only Deformity of the Feet that Banshees could suffer was Backwards Feet, which neither aided nor impaired their movement.
Lowlight Vision
- While Banshees could receive Eyes of Darkness, its effect is to reverse light and darkness, so I was leery of giving the 4e Banshee Darkvision, because it doesn't quite match up.
+2 Arcana, +2 Diplomacy
- Banshees in 3.5 had a natural affinity for the Wizard class (specifically the Necromancy specialist) and were described as "hauntingly beautiful and charismatic"; these seemed the best fit from 4e's list of skills.
Racial Features:
Haunting Performance: Banshee Calibans receive a +5 racial bonus to any skill tests based on performing via song or musical instrument.
Of The Dead: Banshee Calibans receive a +2 racial bonus to any Arcana or Religion check made to discover information about the undead or necromantic spells, rituals or artifacts.
Wail of the Banshee: Banshee Calibans have the Chilling Scream racial power.
[No idea how to write this up, though a Burst of Cold? Necrotic + Cold? damage with possible subsequent Fear effect Push seems the most logical to me.]
As I said in my opening post, I really like the customization of the Caliban presented in Brutes and Banshees - it made a big difference towards them feeling like something other than half-orcs with the serial numbers removed in 3.5. And while I accept that a perfect translation of all the deformities is unworkable, I do think that at least the general ideas of the five breeds - Banshee, Bestial, Brute, Cannibal and Witchspawn - could be used as fully-fledged racial variant options.
Indeed, the Draconian article I mentioned above particularly gives me hope for this, because of how it's handled. In essence, each of the two draconian breeds is handled as a set of three racial features; a dragonborn can swap any number of their default racial features for those from the article. This not only allows for a pretty accurate depiction of a 4e draconian, but allows for great customization of a dragonborn; there is, after all, absolutely no rules against trading Draconic Heritage and Dragon Breath for Instinctive Flight (Bozak variation) and Caustic Heritage (Kapak variation).
I'm just not a very good homebrewer, so I would really appreciate if I could get some help; at the very least, some folks to criticise my efforts would be appreciated.
Edit:
Well, I figured I might as well try my hand at some brainstorming, instead of just pleading for others to come along and help. First up, a hopefully not problematic basic outline of the "common" 4e Caliban:
4e Caliban
+2 Strength, +2 Constitution
Speed 6 Squares
Low-light Vision
+2 Endurance, +2 Intimidate
Cursed Lineage (+5 racial bonus to death saving throws)
Man Or Monster (can use Second Wind to Regenerate instead of heal)
Relentless Rage Racial Encounter Power
Stubborn Mind (+1 Will)
And next, the unique traits of the 3.5 Breeds.
3.5 Banshee Caliban
+2 Charisma, -2 Constitution
Deformities: Witch Fingers, Gaunt, Material Vulnerability, Pale, Twisted Organs, Witch Nipple, Backwards Eye, Double Irises, Eyes of Darkness, Swirling Eyes, Angelic Visage, Large Ears, Backwards Feet, Deranged, Magical Affinity (Any Bard or Necromancy), Eerie Whisper, Forked Tongue, Voice of the Many
3.5 Bestial Caliban
+2 Strength, -2 Intelligence, -2 Charisma
Deformities: Claws, Extra Arms, Multi-Segmented Limbs, Suckers, Bones of Steel, Fur, Giant, Gills, Increased Metabolism, Membrane Wings, Rough Skin, Shedding, Spinnerets, Tail, Bulbous Eyes, Bloodshot Eyes, Horns, Great Nose, Large Ears, Frogs Legs, Gorilla Feet, Hooves, Quadrepad, Webbed Limbs, Magical Affinity (Any Druid), Forked Tongue, Frog Tongue, Projectile Vomit, Sharp Teeth, Unusual Appetite.
3.5 Brute Caliban
+2 Strength, +2 Constitution, -2 Intelligence, -2 Wisdom, -2 Charisma
Deformities: Extra Arms, Multi-Segmented Limbs, Witch Fingers, Aberrant, Bones of Steel, Giant, Hunchback, Increased Metabolism, Material Vulnerability, Obesity, Rough Skin, Rubbery, Short Neck, Skulk, Slimy, Toxic Blood, Twisted Organs, Witch Nipple, Backwards Eye, Bulbous Eyes, Bloodshot Eyes, Cyclops, Face of Nightmare, Great Nose, Large Ears, No Nose, Backwards Feet, Gorilla Feet, Webbed Limbs, Deranged, Magical Affinity (Any), Malformed Twin, Frog Tongue, Projectile Vomit, Sharp Teeth, Unusual Appetite
3.5 Cannibal Caliban
+2 Dexterity, -2 Charisma
Deformities: Claws, Extra Arms, Multi-Segmented Limbs, Suckers, Aberrant, Dwarfism, Gaunt, Hunchback, Increased Metabolism, Material Vulnerability, Membrane Wings, Obesity, Pale, Rough Skin, Rubbery, Skulk, Slimy, Spinnerets, Toxic Blood, Twisted Organs, Bulbous Eyes, Bloodshot Eyes, Eyes of Darkness, Face of Nightmare, Great Nose, Frogs Legs, Gorilla Feet, Quadruped, Webbed Limbs, Deranged, Malformed Twin, Eerie Whisper, Forked Tongue, Frog Tongue, Sharp Teeth, Unusual Appetite
3.5 Witchspawn Caliban
+2 Intelligence, +2 Charisma, -2 Strength, -2 Constitution
Deformities: Witch Fingers, Aberrant, Dwarfism, Gaunt, Hunchback, Material Vulnerability, Membrane Wings, Pale, Tail, Touch of Unease, Twisted Organs, Witch Nipple, Backwards Eye, Double Irises, Eyes of Darkness, Swirling Eyes, Angelic Visage, Face of Nightmare, Horns, Large Ears, Backwards Feet, Hooves, Deranged, Magical Affinity (Any), Malformed Twin, Mark of the Warlock, Forked Tongue, Unusual Appetite, Voice of Many
Hmm... looking at them like this, it seems to me that the Breeds might actually be better handled as separate races in their own right, similar to how Elves, Eladrin, Half-Elves and Drow are all their own kind of race. Perhaps some/many of the deformities can be turned into racial feats that can be taken by all forms of Caliban?
Preceeding under this logic... a draft of the Banshee Caliban for 4e:
+2 Strength, +2 Charisma
- 4e no longer uses ability penalties, Strength is a bonus from the existing 4e Caliban, and it feels wrong to include Con bonus when it suffered a Con penalty in the last edition.
Speed: 6 squares
- The only Deformity of the Feet that Banshees could suffer was Backwards Feet, which neither aided nor impaired their movement.
Lowlight Vision
- While Banshees could receive Eyes of Darkness, its effect is to reverse light and darkness, so I was leery of giving the 4e Banshee Darkvision, because it doesn't quite match up.
+2 Arcana, +2 Diplomacy
- Banshees in 3.5 had a natural affinity for the Wizard class (specifically the Necromancy specialist) and were described as "hauntingly beautiful and charismatic"; these seemed the best fit from 4e's list of skills.
Racial Features:
Haunting Performance: Banshee Calibans receive a +5 racial bonus to any skill tests based on performing via song or musical instrument.
Of The Dead: Banshee Calibans receive a +2 racial bonus to any Arcana or Religion check made to discover information about the undead or necromantic spells, rituals or artifacts.
Wail of the Banshee: Banshee Calibans have the Chilling Scream racial power.
[No idea how to write this up, though a Burst of Cold? Necrotic + Cold? damage with possible subsequent Fear effect Push seems the most logical to me.]
"Is there any word more meaningless than 'hope'? Besides 'blarfurgsnarg,' of course."
"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
Re: Caliban Breeds in 4e
Honestly, I really liked the idea of calibans filling the role of half-orcs. I didn't think they really needed a whole lot of fleshing out, if I'm being totally honest. I think that racial variants have a bad tendency towards making players build their characters based around their statistics, instead of constructing their statistics based around the character's personality. It's something that you can work with in a Forgotten Realms or Greyhawk, (or Eberron, if you're into that newfangled business
) but in a Ravenloft game I think they are best left at the door.
That being said, I game with a group that has a tendency to deviate towards the hack-n-slash, so I need to construct my game in such a way as to discourage that. If that isn't a problem for you, then you might be able to allow such temptations in your game without fear.
That being said, I game with a group that has a tendency to deviate towards the hack-n-slash, so I need to construct my game in such a way as to discourage that. If that isn't a problem for you, then you might be able to allow such temptations in your game without fear.
- The Pickled Punk
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 155
- Joined: Tue Jan 06, 2004 11:21 am
- Location: New York City
Re: Caliban Breeds in 4e
Amen. The whole point of Calibans was to allow players to use one of the races in the 3.X Player's Handbook, namely the only Core race to get a +2 bonus to their STR score. They did this by changing the flavor text, not the core mechanics. I see no reason to do the same for 4E Calibans. However, if you really do want to have variant breeds of Calibans, here is my suggestion:Jimsolo wrote:Honestly, I really liked the idea of calibans filling the role of half-orcs. I didn't think they really needed a whole lot of fleshing out, if I'm being totally honest. I think that racial variants have a bad tendency towards making players build their characters based around their statistics, instead of constructing their statistics based around the character's personality. It's something that you can work with in a Forgotten Realms or Greyhawk, (or Eberron, if you're into that newfangled business) but in a Ravenloft game I think they are best left at the door.
Brutes: Use the game mechanics for Goliaths (PHB2). Most Brutes would choose CON as their secondary stat modifier, indicating that they are tall, muscular and tough, while a small minority would choose WIS, being gentle giants, strong, but insightful.
Bestials: You have lots of choices for this one. Use could use the game mechanics for Shifters (PHB2), Minotaurs (PHB3), Gnolls and Kenku (Dragon Magazine). Shifter Calibans could mostly come from Kartakass and Verbrek (Longtooth) or Valachan (Razorclaw). Minotaurs Calibans would proabably be from Tepest or other areas associated with Hags, Gnoll Calibans could be from the Amber Wastes or from Farelle, and Kenku Caliban might be born in the shadow of Castle Ravenloft.
Banshees: Use the game mechanics for Shades (Heroes of Shadow) or for Shadar-Kai (Dragon Magazine).
Cannibals: Use the game mechanics for Half-Orcs (PHB2).
Witch-spawn: Here's where you get to be creative. There are lots of races to choose from: Tieflings, Githzerai (PHB3), Satyrs (Heroes of the Feywild, especially good for Calibans born near the Shadow Rift), Foulborn Humans (a heritage feat in Psionic Power, could represent Calibans exposed to Bluetspur or the Nightmare Lands in utero), and Genasi (Forgotten Realms Player's Guide).
This way you get to stay true to the real intent for Calibans: not having to say no to your players if they want to play a Race that doesn't seem to fit into the Gothic nature of Ravenloft. You could also allow other races by saying they are Calibans of the non-Human races: Drow could be Eladrin Caliban (indicating Lolth's taint made manifest), Wilden (PHB3) could be Elven Caliban, Duergar (Monster Manual 2) could be Dwarven Caliban, and Swirvneblin could be Gnomish Caliban.
There are several races that should not be used for Caliban: Devas (PHB2) and any other race with the Immortal origin; Warforged (Eberron Player's Guide) since they are Living Constructs; and Dragonborn, because they are way too cool to be mere Calibans.
The Kosher Pickled Punk of the Carnival

