Altering Magic Items

Discussing all things Ravenloft
Post Reply
User avatar
Jimsolo
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 468
Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2012 10:34 pm

Altering Magic Items

Post by Jimsolo »

Do you think it has a negative effect on game balance to allow PCs to alter magic items? Say, for example, to grind a +1 short sword down into a +1 dagger? I require the PC to have the relevant item creation feat, and to make appropriate craft checks, (as though they were crafting an item with a price equal to the difference between the starting product and the end product) but I do allow it. You guys think that's too out there?
MichaelTumey
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 451
Joined: Sat Jun 11, 2011 3:23 pm

Re: Altering Magic Items

Post by MichaelTumey »

Well considering it usually also requires a masterwork weapon. Now just because a given +1 magic sword was a masterwork weapon before it was enhanced, if a PC grinds it down, is that PC skilled enough to create a masterwork dagger from the body of the sword? Unless they are a master craftsman - I'd say, no (and a master craftsman wouldn't make a dagger out of a sword, he'd forge it from scratch). It requires going to a master smith to create a masterwork dagger, that can then be enchanted. That's how it usually works.
User avatar
The Giamarga
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2313
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
Location: wandering

Re: Altering Magic Items

Post by The Giamarga »

I believe game balance assumes access to reasonable magic shops, ie the possibility to swap or upgrade items and get reasonably fitting items.

Magic item crafting already give PCs a measure of control and they could always sell unwanted magic items and reinvest. Also upgrading magic items is possible though it only concerns the magical abilities and not the base item.

I like your idea of customizing/changing/reworking items though. And by requiring the crafting feat and craft skill for it it should be quite balanced. I would impose at least some gp cost for it too and of course limit it to reasonable reworkings.

Perhaps the repair rules could be used/adapted:
Magic items, unless otherwise noted, take damage as non-magical items of the same sort. A damaged magic item continues to function, but if it is destroyed, all its magical power is lost. Magic items that take damage in excess of half their total hit points, but not more than their total hit points, gain the Broken condition, and might not function properly (see the Appendix).

Repairing Magic Items

Repairing a magic item requires material components equal to half the cost to create the item, and requires half the time. The make whole spell can also repair a damaged (or even a destroyed) magic items—if the caster is high enough level.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Re: Altering Magic Items

Post by alhoon »

Game balance: I don't see any problems with altering magic items.
Thematic: Meeeh... grinding down a +1 sword to make it smaller? Seems a bit tooooo far. Yes, it doesn't break the balance. I don't like it though. Adding a good race of sentient bubblegums with very nice voices and bard spells as good monsters also doesn't break the balance. I also don't like it.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Re: Altering Magic Items

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

Game balance and fun: yeah, it's all but required. No one wants to invest a bunch of feats in the rapier, and then find an awesome magic spear you can't use as well. You've probably used your chosen weapon as part of your character concept, too. You picture Obi-wan Kenobi with a lightsaber, not the blaster he used once in EpIII. You picture Connor MacLeod with his katana sword, not the pipe he found in an alley that one time. Would Legolas drop his bow and switch to axes if he found a magical one?

realism: no, makes no sense. But whatchagonnado? It's magic to begin with, so a bit of magical fudging isn't a really big deal. I'm a player in a campaign where another player hacked the haft off a near-artifact glaive to make it into a kukri. A bit silly? maybe. But who cares, if it adds to the fun.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
Jimsolo
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 468
Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2012 10:34 pm

Re: Altering Magic Items

Post by Jimsolo »

I thought it kinda fit with the fantasy genre we're all playing in, anyway. I mean, would The 13th Warrior have been more realistic if Ahmed Ibn Fahdlan had used the greatsword he'd been given? Probably. But it's way more memorable when he grinds it down into a scimitar and proceeds to rock-n-roll with it! :D Plus, if I wanted a game with full realism, I wouldn't be playing a game with magic in it anyway. :P (I'd probably be playing Twilight 2012...) It isn't without precedent in the source material for people to turn one magic item into another, anyway. (I can think of a certain dark elf who shall remain nameless and the bracers of speed he wears on his shins...)

I've already had a player (the wizard in the group is an item-creation wizard) grind a greatspear blade down and sand the shaft thinner to turn it into a naginata. There is a plot coming up where the group will be finding a magical greatsword, and while no one in the group uses greatswords, the fighter does use a falchion. Personally, I don't see it being that big of a deal.

I think that, ultimately, I'm going to have it be a circumstantial thing. Primarily, it's going to be based on the item at the time of creation. I think I will make it so that when enchanting an item, you can determine whether or not its form can be altered later on. That way I can introduce items which are unalterable if I want.

I mean, it's not like I'm going to let someone turn a shortsword into a warhammer or anything. And of course, catastrophic failure of the crafting roll will destroy the magic item, so it's always going to be a bit of a gamble. I feel like it's almost required for me to allow this, since I don't have places where players can buy and sell magic items. In my campaign, magic is rare enough (and in the Western core, quasi-mythical enough) that there are few people who deal in enchanted items on a mercantile basis. (In the Forgotten Realms I can see walking into a store and being like "Yeah, I'll take two cloaks of resistance, a bag of holding, and the holy avenger. You guys take Visa?" but in Ravenloft, I like keeping the magic item trade a little more underground.)

Since the greatsword in question is sentient, and the whole story is revolving around the spirit which animates it uniting with the fighter in question, and how they share a common purpose in life, I figure that the re-forging will help the two characters to bond, especially if the item is reluctant at first to allow itself to be altered, and I let the PC 'convince' her.
User avatar
Jimsolo
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 468
Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2012 10:34 pm

Re: Altering Magic Items

Post by Jimsolo »

alhoon wrote:Game balance: I don't see any problems with altering magic items.
Thematic: Meeeh... grinding down a +1 sword to make it smaller? Seems a bit tooooo far. Yes, it doesn't break the balance. I don't like it though. Adding a good race of sentient bubblegums with very nice voices and bard spells as good monsters also doesn't break the balance. I also don't like it.
Do you really think turning a longsword into a shortsword is in the same vein as sentient bubblegums? Or were you just exaggerating to clarify?
User avatar
High Priest Mikhal
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1642
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
Gender: Male
Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.

Re: Altering Magic Items

Post by High Priest Mikhal »

Jimsolo wrote:
alhoon wrote:Game balance: I don't see any problems with altering magic items.
Thematic: Meeeh... grinding down a +1 sword to make it smaller? Seems a bit tooooo far. Yes, it doesn't break the balance. I don't like it though. Adding a good race of sentient bubblegums with very nice voices and bard spells as good monsters also doesn't break the balance. I also don't like it.
Do you really think turning a longsword into a shortsword is in the same vein as sentient bubblegums? Or were you just exaggerating to clarify?
I'm thinking exaggeration to clarify his view. Personally I invoke Rule Zero: It's your game. Do what you like.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Re: Altering Magic Items

Post by alhoon »

Jimsolo wrote:
alhoon wrote:Game balance: I don't see any problems with altering magic items.
Thematic: Meeeh... grinding down a +1 sword to make it smaller? Seems a bit tooooo far. Yes, it doesn't break the balance. I don't like it though. Adding a good race of sentient bubblegums with very nice voices and bard spells as good monsters also doesn't break the balance. I also don't like it.
Do you really think turning a longsword into a shortsword is in the same vein as sentient bubblegums? Or were you just exaggerating to clarify?

Take a guess! I thought it would be obvious that...
VIEW CONTENT:
I exaggerated x10 to clarify. And mostly because I like extreme exagerations. I usually don't say "that guy had arms thick as a tree!" I would say "that guy had arms thick as the Empire State Building"
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Jimsolo
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 468
Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2012 10:34 pm

Re: Altering Magic Items

Post by Jimsolo »

Well, that's good. :D I ask these questions to get the advice of other DMs on a professional level. I'd hate to think I'd made a decision that was that silly.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Re: Altering Magic Items

Post by alhoon »

Jimsolo wrote:Well, that's good. :D I ask these questions to get the advice of other DMs on a professional level. I'd hate to think I'd made a decision that was that silly.

Simple quiz to figure if your decision was silly:

Question 1: Did you and your players enjoyed the results of your decision?
A1: Yes
A2: No

Question 2: What other people not on the table think about your decision?
A1: They find it silly
A2: They find it good

Question 3: How the rules apply in your decision?
A1: There are rules for similar situations that support my decision
A2: There is a rule's gap there
A3: There are rules for similar situations that don't support my decision.


Quizz answer:
If you score 10 or more, the decision wasn't silly.
If you score -10 or less, the decision was silly.
VIEW CONTENT:
First question:
A1: +10 points
A2: -5 points

All other questions:
Don't matter. No points added or subtracted.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Post Reply