Lycantropes and Silver. 3E (DR) or 4E (regen)?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
Post Reply
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Lycantropes and Silver. 3E (DR) or 4E (regen)?

Post by alhoon »

So I was thinking on Lycanthropes and silver.
3rd edition had it as DR; you hit a werewolf without a silver weapon and a large chunk of the damage is ignored.
4e though had an approached that thematically I prefered: Lycanthropes had regeneration and by hiting them with silver, you took that away.

So, while I try to make up my mind on what version I prefer most for my 3rd edition campaigns, what do you guys think on the following options?

- DR!
The way 3rd approaches it. A single hit by a raging barbarian's with non-silver axe could kill a werewolf (with power attack) while 50 slashes from goblins would leave him unscathed. For most cases a DM and player would encounter, it would fall somewhere in the middle of these extremes; a werewolf with 25 hit points and DR 10/silver would need like 5-6 solid hits with 2H weapons yielded by strong people to take down while it would need 4-5 hits with a silver dagger or short-sword.

- Regeneration!
The way 4th edition approaches it. You need to be creative to kill a werecreature without silver. In this case for 3rd edition natural werecreatures could have a very rapid regeneration while afflicted an impressive, but slower one. Like regen 10 for natural and 5 for afflicted. Only silver does damage that doesn't regenerate the way fire works on trolls.
This makes the werecreatures seem weaker, since they can be felled easier, but considerably harder to kill, since even beheading them would cause them to regenerate their heads like trolls. It also works against magic.
In our example above, the werewolf with the 25hp would have regeneration 10. 2 good hits and he's out of the fight. Good. He would probably rise in a few rounds though. You just can't get rid of him. Chop off his head? OK, that buys you 3d6 mins to run away.

- Fast healing!
Similar to the above but if the werewolf dies, the werewolf is dead. So, I believe a Fast healing of 15 for natural and 10 for afflicted is fine. You can stop this insanely fast healing by hitting the werecreature with silver. A hit with silver blocks fast healing for the round.

(This makes werecreatures kinda weaker, but if they flee, they'll be back in 3-4 rounds FULLY healed)

- Fast healing AND damage reduction.
Well, now, unless you have some silver, you're in trouble. Fast healing 5 for natural and 2 for afflicted along with DR 5/silver for both. A hit with silver blocks fast healing for the round for natural werewolves and for 3 rounds for afflicted werewolves.

(this makes natural werecreatures a bit weaker and afflicted werecreatures a bit stronger)

- Damage reduction and (slow) regeneration.
Similar to the above case, but unless you have some silver, you're in serious trouble. DR 10/silver for natural and 5/silver for afflicted along with regeneration 2 for both. Silver deals real damage.

(This makes werecreatures stronger unless everyone is armed with silver in which case, they're like they were).

****

So? What do you think?
I personally seem to gravitate towards regeneration or DR/regeneration. I like the idea that all this meat the werecreature has to eat is used by their metabolism and that you have to have silver to kill a werewolf, even if it is plunging a silver piece into his brain through his eye.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: Lycantropes and Silver. 3E (DR) or 4E (regen)?

Post by Zilfer »

DR is supposed to prepresent either A) very tough to damage things or B) Regenerative abilities of the race. I believe it is fluff somewhere in 3.5 saying that not to think of DR as just straight immunity.

So you hit a blow for 15 damage! the blow is good and the werewolf heals but he still is feeling it for 5. Meanwhile the stab for 8 it heals. It hurt the werewolf sure but it's had worse!

Silver or Mithril just makes killing the werewolf a whole lot easier. Personally i've played with DR monsters and I don't see it being too big of an assest down the road.

You don't even need to be strong but have the right feats as well.

Take for example my Rogue 14 str with only a +2 to str rolling 1d6. (If I two hand +3)

Max damage is going to be 8-9 right? Well I opt to take power attack and subtract -2 for +4 (if two handing)damage increasing the maximum to 13-14. Which means i'll be hitting it at least. XD (in reality my rogue actually is much more powerful than this but i decided revert back to level 3 area where werewolves might be encountered)



Edit: I will say that I had a 'level 0' almost take out a lycanthrope by himself.

Playing a mordent game where I had the player start out as an Aristocrate with 3 HP. Lycanthrope business began to happen as he's working to be a guard to make some money on his own instead of relying on the family money from being a noble.

He gets the drop on the Lycanthrope while it's distracted coming after a woman, and he's deduced they are weak to silver through researching with an old herbalist. (3 guesses who) Well first thing this level 0 aristocrate does is criticals the damn thing, and rolls damage. Guess what with that silver kitchen knife he rolled max on 2d4's making 8 damage plus str twice. Nearly killing the creature in surprise round. xD

He got taken down next turn but he still remembers that, over coming the DR with a kitchen knife. xD He got his first level from that battle after surviving and now is offically a guard. (I have another topic on this so don't want to clutter it up here just saying from players view what they remember)
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Re: Lycantropes and Silver. 3E (DR) or 4E (regen)?

Post by Jester of the FoS »

No option is perfect but I like DR best.

I find the regeneration problematic as you stab the werewolf with a silver dagger and then the non-silver weapons hurt it normally. As long as one person carries a silvered weapon (super cheap) everyone can fight normally. There's no swapping to an unoptimal weapon that does better damage because it goes through the DR.

DR does the job of encouraging special weapons without preventing other weapons from even working. Like in 1e-2e where non-silver weapons did nothing.

Fast healing works as well. And it might be neat to merge the two. Lowest DR and middling regeneration but silver stops the regen. Or even does a little extra damage, so they're not just hurt by silver but vulnerable to silver.
This might work best with a doubling of resistance. Say something being resistant to non-silver or magic weapons. Either works but if it's silver and magic they're vulnerable.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Re: Lycantropes and Silver. 3E (DR) or 4E (regen)?

Post by alhoon »

Well, regen in 3rd edition doesn't stop.
If the werewolf has regeneration, he can't be killed without silver weapons. Even when beheaded. Werecreatures have a reason to be afraid of silver (like trolls are afraid of fire) because it's one of the few ways that they can be killed.
If it's like 4th edition, that it stops, then silver works as an allergen. Werewolves have a reason to be afraid of silver because not only it can harm them, it will also make them vulnerable, taking part of their power away.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: Lycantropes and Silver. 3E (DR) or 4E (regen)?

Post by Zilfer »

alhoon wrote:Well, regen in 3rd edition doesn't stop.
If the werewolf has regeneration, he can't be killed without silver weapons. Even when beheaded. Werecreatures have a reason to be afraid of silver (like trolls are afraid of fire) because it's one of the few ways that they can be killed.
If it's like 4th edition, that it stops, then silver works as an allergen. Werewolves have a reason to be afraid of silver because not only it can harm them, it will also make them vulnerable, taking part of their power away.
Yeah but constantly pounding the lycanthrope keeps them down until someone can get silver.... <.< or just completely obliterating them with acid or fire I would rule would take them down as well.... but that's just me.
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Re: Lycantropes and Silver. 3E (DR) or 4E (regen)?

Post by alhoon »

Well, a mix of DR and FHealing or regen would deal with that.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Jimsolo
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 468
Joined: Thu Sep 06, 2012 10:34 pm

Re: Lycantropes and Silver. 3E (DR) or 4E (regen)?

Post by Jimsolo »

In 3rd edition, you could kill a creature with regeneration provided that you could put it down. Although non-silver weapons would still do subdual damage to the creature, once it was out, several sources (notably, I believe, was Skip Williams in Sage Advice) recommended that you be able to kill an unconscious creature with regeneration.

Personally, I would stick with damage reduction for most werewolves. The fact that massive damage can overcome it (a barbarian isn't going to one-shot the average lycanthrope unless he crits with that greataxe, and x3 damage with a Power Attack from Rage probably SHOULD kill most things...) is one of the things I like about it. Creative solutions should be rewarded. While silver is the most common method of werewolf disposal, a boulder shoved off a cliff should also accomplish the goal. Or a speeding semi-truck.

If you find that your werewolf NPCs need a little extra bite (ahem) then my personal feeling is that a little fast healing added to the mix is your best bet. It complements the DR nicely without overpowering the encounter, and is a little bit of a surprise for the player who thinks he knows it all.

Regeneration, while powerful, is a little TOO much for the werewolf, I think. The ability to regrow a severed head is too much. Furthermore, I think that the damage reduction of a werewolf is sufficient that the average person is largely powerless against them, which is the primary source of the fear that surrounds them.

Of course, that's just my personal opinion. You and your players may have totally different expectations and needs.
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: Lycantropes and Silver. 3E (DR) or 4E (regen)?

Post by Zilfer »

alhoon wrote:Well, a mix of DR and FHealing or regen would deal with that.

So curious in a situation where the werewolf was dwindled down to 0 HP and thus knocked unconscious on the ground.... The players then start to use Coup De Grace on the creature instantly confirming criticals. Which would allow it probably to score high enough to both pass DR and the regeneration it would have each turn and with multiple attacks it's going to go into the negatives faster than it can regenerate...

That's before considering the rule that a Coup De Grace makes the creature make a fortitude save or die.... Which to me would make sense. If you have the werewolf down regenerating stabbing through the heart or tearing it to pieces before it can get back up or do anything only makes sense.

But again DnD is imagination at work so if that's how you want the game to work that's perfectly fine. :D To each his own!
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Re: Lycantropes and Silver. 3E (DR) or 4E (regen)?

Post by alhoon »

Coup de Grace deals subdual damage to a troll unless it's fire/acid. So I would say it doesn't die. The minimum these creatures get is -10 hp from such tactics. I would go the same for the non-dying-from-anything-but-silver werewolf. An iron sword deals subdual damage. Cutting off the werewolf's head deals subdual damage.
A silver piece through the eye deals normal damage (so crit) and eventually kills the werewolf.

But I partially agree with Jimsolo; OK, The wolf-awesome lycanthrope with 8 levels that is the big villain has actually regeneration and can't be killed without silver, the way a few Lycanthropes can control their progeny or summon wolves etc.
Perhaps I'll give that to Alfred Timothy.

The rest... DR 10/silver and fast healing 2, that stops with silver is OK IMO.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: Lycantropes and Silver. 3E (DR) or 4E (regen)?

Post by Zilfer »

alhoon wrote:Coup de Grace deals subdual damage to a troll unless it's fire/acid. So I would say it doesn't die. The minimum these creatures get is -10 hp from such tactics. I would go the same for the non-dying-from-anything-but-silver werewolf. An iron sword deals subdual damage. Cutting off the werewolf's head deals subdual damage.
A silver piece through the eye deals normal damage (so crit) and eventually kills the werewolf.

But I partially agree with Jimsolo; OK, The wolf-awesome lycanthrope with 8 levels that is the big villain has actually regeneration and can't be killed without silver, the way a few Lycanthropes can control their progeny or summon wolves etc.
Perhaps I'll give that to Alfred Timothy.

The rest... DR 10/silver and fast healing 2, that stops with silver is OK IMO.

I'm not sure there's a rule saying that it stops at -10 is what I'm saying. Subdual damage could just keep piling up until it's literally so far gone that it would take quite a long time to get. Remember the Coup De Grace has x2 damage if it's an ax x3 and if they are using a Scythe like my group does sometimes x4!
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
Post Reply