DA, let me open by saying I'm not offended or angry at you personally. I have truck with a casual stance toward sexual violence, which is pervasive in many corners of gamer culture, but I do not hold you personally responsible for that. My aim here is purely to provide options and points for consideration, and if I'm coming across aggressively, I apologize. (It also has the misfortune of being related to the transition of vampires from bloodsucking corpse to sexualized object, which has been a matter of academic study on my part- I was a research assistant for several published papers on the topic, and we all know what happens when the Geek Trivia Dam bursts...). As to your concern...
Dark Angel wrote:If the part you are talking about was the serving girl anecdote...
No real issue with the serving girl angle. The part that raised my eyebrow was:
Dark Angel wrote:Yes, that angle can (and if your group can take it well enough, should) be used.
I posit that is can be equally chilling to have a vampire who runs a charity clinic and (when not actively seeking revenge on his own murderer) seems to be a rather decent sort, perform what we all agree are horrible acts (kidnapping, vampirization, etc) because he just wants a friend... honestly, as I was rereading it recently it was, at times, almost coming across as a deconstruction of the Twilight vampires. He's lonely, and because of what he is he cannot remedy this lack in a normal healthy manner; he tries to fill the void through violence and force.
Part of what gets me bristling about the "should" though... how do you know your group can handle it? Worst case scenario, can you be 100% sure that no one in your group has a history you'll be dredging up with it? It's not the sort of thing many people talk about. This is not to say it cannot be a powerful storytelling device, but it's an extremely vulnerable subject compared to most other RPG/horror topics. Real-world victims of brutal murder do not get the chance to do much role playing after, and few real people need to contend with PTSD following an orc raid or zombie outbreak. Even those on the sidelines, well, you usually know when your friend's mother was killed by a mugger in front of his eyes, and can avoid scenarios that resemble the traumatic event. However, between the lingering psychological effects, and the bizarre stigma of blame sexual assault victims often receive, it's very hard to know who's going to be triggered by having it pop up in the game... with the added complication that they probably won't tell you it's bothering them, either, since they don't want to be a wet blanket, or worse, have you seeing them as someone "weak" enough to be molested or raped.
I'm really just arguing that it's not necessarily the best, much less only, way to portray the incident, and if you're going to go that route, to be very sensitive to your players' reactions.
Unrelated technical note: Given Erasmus' age, it wouldn't actually be pedophilia, it would be ephebophilia.