QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
As I check through the various nice articles of QtR, I would like to ask a couple of questions and offer my thoughts on them.
About the 101 mishaps, I believe that's a very nice touch. Of course, I consider some mishaps better than others, but I was looking for something similar for mild curse effects, broken mirror etc. It ties very well with the "Cursed charms" article and counter-measures that were in another QtR.
Does anyone remember what it was? It had things that could help preventing bad luck. Like a lock of hair of someone that loved you to protect from bad luck etc. Superstitions and the like.
The three of them I believe tie nicely to create a more vibrant, immersive and believable world.
While the whole QtR was very good, I consider those two (three with the superstitions of the older one) articles something that would enrich my game.
The Sea wolf is well detailed and thought of. Personally, I don't use were-creature variants often but they would make a nice addition in a sea adventure I think. I also liked the regional variant parts and I would like something like that in other monster entries.
I liked the idea and background behind Prince Doon, but ... I wish there was more in it. It feels somewhat incomplete, like the prologue of a story.
The magic weapons are also nice and immediately usable. I would tone them down a notch probably though. They are also an inspiration to make similar items for my campaign.
So far, I've reached there.
About the 101 mishaps, I believe that's a very nice touch. Of course, I consider some mishaps better than others, but I was looking for something similar for mild curse effects, broken mirror etc. It ties very well with the "Cursed charms" article and counter-measures that were in another QtR.
Does anyone remember what it was? It had things that could help preventing bad luck. Like a lock of hair of someone that loved you to protect from bad luck etc. Superstitions and the like.
The three of them I believe tie nicely to create a more vibrant, immersive and believable world.
While the whole QtR was very good, I consider those two (three with the superstitions of the older one) articles something that would enrich my game.
The Sea wolf is well detailed and thought of. Personally, I don't use were-creature variants often but they would make a nice addition in a sea adventure I think. I also liked the regional variant parts and I would like something like that in other monster entries.
I liked the idea and background behind Prince Doon, but ... I wish there was more in it. It feels somewhat incomplete, like the prologue of a story.
The magic weapons are also nice and immediately usable. I would tone them down a notch probably though. They are also an inspiration to make similar items for my campaign.
So far, I've reached there.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Re: QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
@ alhoon:
Erm, about Prince Doon. I'm not really able to think clearly at the moment (thanks to, again, real life (tm) ).
thx for your comment,
kadarin
hmm, guess you're right, but real life (tm) tends to interfere with the things I really want to do. But I'll try & let you know as soon as I have terminated some other things (and, possibly, beings).I liked the idea and background behind Prince Doon, but ... I wish there was more in it. It feels somewhat incomplete, like the prologue of a story.
Erm, about Prince Doon. I'm not really able to think clearly at the moment (thanks to, again, real life (tm) ).
thx for your comment,
kadarin
Morn came and went – and came, and brought no day
– George Gordon, Darkness
– George Gordon, Darkness
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
I hope it clears up for you soon and that you took my comment as constructive criticism. I liked the story but it seemed more like a teaser you see. A preview.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Re: QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
@ alhoon:
Yes, I did take your comment as constructive criticism. But the story was not meant as a teaser, it was only written (very) late at night as a consequence of a dream (or rather, a nightmare). As I said, although, as a result of your commentary - coming from you, a much respected member of this forum - I will review the article and expand it.
Any suggestions are always welcome.
kadarin
Yes, I did take your comment as constructive criticism. But the story was not meant as a teaser, it was only written (very) late at night as a consequence of a dream (or rather, a nightmare). As I said, although, as a result of your commentary - coming from you, a much respected member of this forum - I will review the article and expand it.
Any suggestions are always welcome.
kadarin
Morn came and went – and came, and brought no day
– George Gordon, Darkness
– George Gordon, Darkness
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Re: QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
So... Ghastria. No comments on that yet.
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
I plan on having a much closer look at it later.
However, on my cursory reading, the Mistway to Sithicus exists 130 years before Sithicus does.
There's a hard return that shouldn't be there at the bottom of page 36.
All of this patience and calm and planning makes d'Polarno sound LE to me, rather than NE.
You've said that his soullessness makes him emotionless. Darklords makes it sound to me like he is charisma-less, not emotionless. Is the change intentional?
However, on my cursory reading, the Mistway to Sithicus exists 130 years before Sithicus does.
There's a hard return that shouldn't be there at the bottom of page 36.
All of this patience and calm and planning makes d'Polarno sound LE to me, rather than NE.
You've said that his soullessness makes him emotionless. Darklords makes it sound to me like he is charisma-less, not emotionless. Is the change intentional?
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
I haven't checked Ghastria yet. A lot of things are going wrong right now unfortunately...
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Re: QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
I pulled that from d'Polarno's Bio in Book of Souls IIRC. Although the date error was likely mine.Ryan Naylor wrote:However, on my cursory reading, the Mistway to Sithicus exists 130 years before Sithicus does.
Agreed, but those were the alignments from Darklords.Ryan Naylor wrote:All of this patience and calm and planning makes d'Polarno sound LE to me, rather than NE.
His curse was the inability to feel joy. I always read that as emotionless. Could just be me.Ryan Naylor wrote:You've said that his soullessness makes him emotionless. Darklords makes it sound to me like he is charisma-less, not emotionless. Is the change intentional?
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
Not just you. That's the way I read it too. But not quite completely emotionless. He can feel emotions, just not positive ones.Jester of the FoS wrote:His curse was the inability to feel joy. I always read that as emotionless. Could just be me.
Some quotes from Darklords:
"..his great sorrow at the ... loss of his soul"
"...he sat emotionless...his victims sprawled around him..." (not pleased at his success)
"...was rocked by a surge of emotion and energy. For the first time in many monts, the marquis felt alive again."
"once a season, Ravenloft allows Stezen to regain his love of life"
"he often appears... listless, depressed, tactless"
His Cha is listed there as 17, no matter which state he's in.
Granted, it might make sense to have his Cha fluctuate with his state. That would seem to be fitting with the results of Cha drain/damage.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
You do have to remember though that the definition of Cha changed between 2e and 3e: in 2e, it was almost purely how attractive you were to look at.
More on Ghastria (some more trivial than others):
Will there be a map of the island in the gazetteer? Because I for one would find it really useful.
p. 7 - "Assorted coins" as currency struck me as odd phrasing. Is there a different way to describe the fact that gold is gold and they don't mint their own coins? "Foreign currency" perhaps?
p. 8 - From deck, we can see meadows and orchards. Orchards particularly would be unlikely to be growing that close to the sea, and the island is meant to be surrounded by rocky beaches and cliffs. A potential inconsistency.
The Docks is an uncharacteristically unlikely name for a town. A city district, sure. A town, no. Even if they're only 20 years old, they would surely have been named after someone or something or some local feature. The Marquis is trying to keep his underlings in check; he might have named it in honour of one of them. Villafane is trying to buy a title; he might have extorted people into naming the town to his satisfaction. Even if everyone calls it the docks, it'll still have some other name.
Examples include xxsea, xx-on-sea, xx's leap/folly/cove/bight/end, xx-ton, xx-borough, etc.
For that matter, what's the name of the Marquis' estate?
p. 10 - Is the high harvest related to d'Polarno's curse? Because if you didn't already know that, there's nothing anywhere that would tell you so that I can see.
p. 12 - "latest scandal in the core" should have a capital C. This bit made me smile - you'd think the Core had no cursed artists left!
p. 13 - The description of d'Marasso's history in the second paragraph of the box doesn't match the description in the Notes, most in when d'Polarno ousted the ghast from power.
p. 14 - With 125 people, how many "various criminal organisations" can there be in The Docks?
I'm not sure about the whispering to the aboleth. Is that a reference to Virundus, or is it just an open hook?
p. 15 - Why are the fishermen of Norshore unable to sail around the island?
p. 17 - It says here Annelise can only move between the picture of the gallery, but elsewhere she can move into an art on the island (e.g. the chapel). She can also "turn off a light" which is odd phrasing for a non-electrical light.
p. 20 - I know a lot of people who drink vodka, and that's basically flavourless. I think you're underestimating the pleasures of being drunk by saying that because the alcohol is flavourless no one drinks it.
Is the revenant whale a reference to something?
p. 21 - I may be wrong, but don't shellfisheries exist in shallow water, so all the shellfish would be flavourless?
p. 24 - If the painting was sold in Chateaufaux, the ghost has only been there since 707 at the earliest, and probably not before 742. Did you intend her to be that recent?
p. 28- The Home Faith is the LN Borcan sect, and they were the first to get there and start converting. But most of the priests are from Dementlieu, and therefore of the TN sect. Is that intentional, because it doesn't seem so from that description?
p. 29 - Jayde Rothwelle is not a Lamordian name to my ear, even assuming Rothwelle is her married name. Is there a more Germanic first name? I really like her dread possibility though.
p. 30 - Holding the first Marquis up as an icon struck me as a little odd too - perhaps a cultural icon, or something like that? Rather than a plain generic icon.
p. 31 - The first Baron d'Marosso wrote the biography a little over 2 decades ago. Obviously his his pretence at mortality is completely transparent.
The Mistway to Sithicus again - I know the BoS article has the connection there, but Sithicus doesn't form until until 720 BC. (i.e. not in this part of Ghastria's history). I'm fine with the Mistway though. Perhaps it goes to eastern Darkon (elves), another elven domain, somewhere else entirely instead, and shift to Sithicus later?
More on Ghastria (some more trivial than others):
Will there be a map of the island in the gazetteer? Because I for one would find it really useful.
p. 7 - "Assorted coins" as currency struck me as odd phrasing. Is there a different way to describe the fact that gold is gold and they don't mint their own coins? "Foreign currency" perhaps?
p. 8 - From deck, we can see meadows and orchards. Orchards particularly would be unlikely to be growing that close to the sea, and the island is meant to be surrounded by rocky beaches and cliffs. A potential inconsistency.
The Docks is an uncharacteristically unlikely name for a town. A city district, sure. A town, no. Even if they're only 20 years old, they would surely have been named after someone or something or some local feature. The Marquis is trying to keep his underlings in check; he might have named it in honour of one of them. Villafane is trying to buy a title; he might have extorted people into naming the town to his satisfaction. Even if everyone calls it the docks, it'll still have some other name.
Examples include xxsea, xx-on-sea, xx's leap/folly/cove/bight/end, xx-ton, xx-borough, etc.
For that matter, what's the name of the Marquis' estate?
p. 10 - Is the high harvest related to d'Polarno's curse? Because if you didn't already know that, there's nothing anywhere that would tell you so that I can see.
p. 12 - "latest scandal in the core" should have a capital C. This bit made me smile - you'd think the Core had no cursed artists left!
p. 13 - The description of d'Marasso's history in the second paragraph of the box doesn't match the description in the Notes, most in when d'Polarno ousted the ghast from power.
p. 14 - With 125 people, how many "various criminal organisations" can there be in The Docks?
I'm not sure about the whispering to the aboleth. Is that a reference to Virundus, or is it just an open hook?
p. 15 - Why are the fishermen of Norshore unable to sail around the island?
p. 17 - It says here Annelise can only move between the picture of the gallery, but elsewhere she can move into an art on the island (e.g. the chapel). She can also "turn off a light" which is odd phrasing for a non-electrical light.
p. 20 - I know a lot of people who drink vodka, and that's basically flavourless. I think you're underestimating the pleasures of being drunk by saying that because the alcohol is flavourless no one drinks it.
Is the revenant whale a reference to something?
p. 21 - I may be wrong, but don't shellfisheries exist in shallow water, so all the shellfish would be flavourless?
p. 24 - If the painting was sold in Chateaufaux, the ghost has only been there since 707 at the earliest, and probably not before 742. Did you intend her to be that recent?
p. 28- The Home Faith is the LN Borcan sect, and they were the first to get there and start converting. But most of the priests are from Dementlieu, and therefore of the TN sect. Is that intentional, because it doesn't seem so from that description?
p. 29 - Jayde Rothwelle is not a Lamordian name to my ear, even assuming Rothwelle is her married name. Is there a more Germanic first name? I really like her dread possibility though.
p. 30 - Holding the first Marquis up as an icon struck me as a little odd too - perhaps a cultural icon, or something like that? Rather than a plain generic icon.
p. 31 - The first Baron d'Marosso wrote the biography a little over 2 decades ago. Obviously his his pretence at mortality is completely transparent.
The Mistway to Sithicus again - I know the BoS article has the connection there, but Sithicus doesn't form until until 720 BC. (i.e. not in this part of Ghastria's history). I'm fine with the Mistway though. Perhaps it goes to eastern Darkon (elves), another elven domain, somewhere else entirely instead, and shift to Sithicus later?
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
p. 36 - King Oderic sounds like a bit of a twit. He could not stand to see someone else given more respect? Why not "he saw him (rightly) as a dangerous political adversary"?
p. 37 - Why did the Vistani steal the painting and keep it hidden, moving around the island with it? Why not just dump it and go?
I really like the adventurers and their effects though.
On the Marquis' personality again - Are you sure I can't convince you? Darklords leads me to believe that he is joyless, not emotionless, and not a psychopath. Oderic cursed him to control him and make him suffer, not to make him calculating and logical. There's a lot of psychopaths running around Ravenloft (Inza, for example); there are comparatively few charmless curmudgeons who are patrons of the arts.
I do like the errors of judgement when he's CE though, and the conversion of other paintings into his own if the original is destroyed.
Why does he speak Vaasi, and not Darkonese or Sithican?
I really like Annelise and d'Marosso. I think d'Marosso's shift into "untrustworthy vassal" (Starscream?) is a really nice touch and very believable too.
Just so we're clear, despite the questions and comments, I really enjoyed your article.
p. 37 - Why did the Vistani steal the painting and keep it hidden, moving around the island with it? Why not just dump it and go?
I really like the adventurers and their effects though.
On the Marquis' personality again - Are you sure I can't convince you? Darklords leads me to believe that he is joyless, not emotionless, and not a psychopath. Oderic cursed him to control him and make him suffer, not to make him calculating and logical. There's a lot of psychopaths running around Ravenloft (Inza, for example); there are comparatively few charmless curmudgeons who are patrons of the arts.
I do like the errors of judgement when he's CE though, and the conversion of other paintings into his own if the original is destroyed.
Why does he speak Vaasi, and not Darkonese or Sithican?
I really like Annelise and d'Marosso. I think d'Marosso's shift into "untrustworthy vassal" (Starscream?) is a really nice touch and very believable too.
Just so we're clear, despite the questions and comments, I really enjoyed your article.
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Re: QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
Thanks for the feedback Ryan.
Some of the errors really crept on due to the long time this article sat around. The first draft was finished some time ago before other concerns delayed the other author's elements of the Sorrows Gaz. Having to relearn Ghastrian lore and edit in a short period likely led to my making a few small errors.
Did want to draw attention to this:
A fairly obscure bit of lore but I wanted to reference the events and make them (FoS) canon.
Some of the errors really crept on due to the long time this article sat around. The first draft was finished some time ago before other concerns delayed the other author's elements of the Sorrows Gaz. Having to relearn Ghastrian lore and edit in a short period likely led to my making a few small errors.
Did want to draw attention to this:
This was a direct reference to the second RPGA Ghastrian adventure. So I can't take full credit for getting adventures involved.Ryan Naylor wrote: p. 37 - Why did the Vistani steal the painting and keep it hidden, moving around the island with it? Why not just dump it and go?
A fairly obscure bit of lore but I wanted to reference the events and make them (FoS) canon.
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
Ah! Apart from the Heart's Final Beat, I've never seen any of the RPGA adventures.
Can you explain why they take the painting anyway?
Can you explain why they take the painting anyway?
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Re: QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
I believe the adventure were discussed here:
http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/foru ... f=1&t=4247
http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/foru ... f=1&t=4247
Re: QtR Reviews, suggestions & Questions
Glad you liked them. I've only previously seen Intelligent Items get used to either A) be completely secretive about their sentience, or B) a total distraction to the party. I liked the idea of some variety. Toning them down in power level can definitely work, but if I'm going to design a sentient item, I want there to be the potential for an ego conflict. With a simple +1 weapon of middling mental stats, the Will save will be so low that a player character might just ignore the item's wishes freely. I designed them to both be roughly in line with the rules as well as having the potential to exert their own influence if they feel like they're being sidelined.alhoon wrote: The magic weapons are also nice and immediately usable. I would tone them down a notch probably though. They are also an inspiration to make similar items for my campaign.
Reducing the power level can definitely make them fit more with a low-magic campaign (or low-level campaign), I just thought I would point out that it also reduces their Ego, and thus the potential for the item exerting its own will.
Although I didn't mention it in the article, Roselynne's Cameo has shown up twice in my games (and was the inspiration for this article). Originally, it was designed for a first-time player who wanted to be a druid, but had no experience with gaming of any sort. The Cameo was a way to offer a limited ability to influence her spell selection without overtly telling her what she "should be" doing. It has proved helpful in that role not once now, but twice. If anyone has a spellcaster who frequently takes weird things, or wishes they could hint to a PC that they should or should not take a certain spell (say, Bless Weapon if there is a fight with a band of Rakshasi) then the Cameo is a wonderful tool to influence your PCs from within the game.

