Seas about Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"?!?
Seas about Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"?!?
d20 SRD basically divides water temperatures into warm, temperate, and cold. The Nocturnal Sea Gaz with its map of Nocturnal Sea water temperatures went further and essentially divided temperatures into tropic, warm, temperate (warm), temperate (cold), cold, and artic.
Given the seasonal ice bridge from the mainland to the Finger, I would peg the waters about Lamordia as being cold under the d20 system and as being cold in parts and artic in other parts under the Nocturnal sea system. Yet Gaz 2 describes the seas about Lamordia as being "temperate aquatic". I have trouble squaring that with sea water freezing to form an ice bridge. Equally, there is the miserable winter climate of Lamordia in general.
Thoughts?
Given the seasonal ice bridge from the mainland to the Finger, I would peg the waters about Lamordia as being cold under the d20 system and as being cold in parts and artic in other parts under the Nocturnal sea system. Yet Gaz 2 describes the seas about Lamordia as being "temperate aquatic". I have trouble squaring that with sea water freezing to form an ice bridge. Equally, there is the miserable winter climate of Lamordia in general.
Thoughts?
Last edited by cure on Wed Nov 20, 2013 2:58 am, edited 1 time in total.
The cure for what ails you
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: Seas Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"?!?
The sea of Lamordia is not in Lamordia, it's another different domain so it has different weather. HOWEVER, since it freezes, I would say that it should be "cold"
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- High Priest Mikhal
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1642
- Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.
Re: Seas Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"?!?
Remember that the Finger is part of Lamordia as a domain, but the Nocturnal Sea is a domain unto itself. And Lamordia's paradox of distinctly unnatural things existing in a land ruled by logic and science is in effect as well.
Or it could be a typo in Gaz II. Occam's razor.
Or it could be a typo in Gaz II. Occam's razor.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
Re: Seas Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"?!?
Lamordia has exaggerated seasonal weather. The waters surrounding the Finger may be frozen during the winter, but they aren't during the warmer months. Seasonal changes between bitter cold winters and muggy summers = temperate climate.
Re: Seas about Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"
The climate entry for Lamordia from Gaz 2 reads as follows: "Temperate aquatic, forest, hill, plains, and swamp." For my money, the waters about Lamordia belong to the domain, but be that as it may, their temperature is described as temperate. There is reason to believe that these waters, at least between the mainland and the Finger, are shallow. And that would at least square with extreme seasonal variation as suggested by Mangrum.
I am putting together monster summoning lists for the different core domains, including land and sea creature in the case of domains such as Lamordia. I had been leaning towards classifying the waters of Lamordia as being from temperate to cold and the land as being from temperate to cold, with Death's Glacier and the upper reaches of the Finger being cold in particular. That would have squared nicely with the presence of wolverines, frost worms, and orca, and would have licensed the inclusion of dire bears and polar bears, all being cold environment creatures. Then again, there are also lizards and baleen whales, both being warm environment creatures. So perhaps 'anything' goes in Lamordia. Still, the "any dire animal, giant vermin, or monstrous vermin" description from Gaz 2 should at least be limited to creatures able to survive the extreme changes of weather. Dire lions and dire tigers hardly seem to fit the place. Equally, in Gaz 4, similar "any" descriptions were qualified by the stipulation that the creatures be of sizes up to but not beyond large. And that seems tempting to me lest there be colossal giant spiders and monstrous centipedes running about Lamordia.
I am putting together monster summoning lists for the different core domains, including land and sea creature in the case of domains such as Lamordia. I had been leaning towards classifying the waters of Lamordia as being from temperate to cold and the land as being from temperate to cold, with Death's Glacier and the upper reaches of the Finger being cold in particular. That would have squared nicely with the presence of wolverines, frost worms, and orca, and would have licensed the inclusion of dire bears and polar bears, all being cold environment creatures. Then again, there are also lizards and baleen whales, both being warm environment creatures. So perhaps 'anything' goes in Lamordia. Still, the "any dire animal, giant vermin, or monstrous vermin" description from Gaz 2 should at least be limited to creatures able to survive the extreme changes of weather. Dire lions and dire tigers hardly seem to fit the place. Equally, in Gaz 4, similar "any" descriptions were qualified by the stipulation that the creatures be of sizes up to but not beyond large. And that seems tempting to me lest there be colossal giant spiders and monstrous centipedes running about Lamordia.
The cure for what ails you
- High Priest Mikhal
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1642
- Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.
Re: Seas Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"?!?
Meteorological explanations had occured to me as well. Only after I'd posted. And, admittedly, I'm not well versed in meteorological terminology. I would guess several of us here are the same.Mangrum wrote:Lamordia has exaggerated seasonal weather. The waters surrounding the Finger may be frozen during the winter, but they aren't during the warmer months. Seasonal changes between bitter cold winters and muggy summers = temperate climate.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
Re: Seas about Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"
Personally, I don't subscribe to the "it's a different domain" theory. The lands of the Core should have a unified climate with only specific exceptions.
For example, you don't go from Har'Akir desert conditions to Sri Rajian jungles just because you crossed a border between the domains.
That's one of the things I like about the Core. The changes are gradual, like the real world. Domains with similar foliage and temperature border each other, and often changes are throughout the domain, rather than just "at the border." It's also like how the Clusters have formed with domains of similar climate; the Amber Wastes, the Verderous Lands, etc.
The only real exceptions I see to this are possible Vechor, because of the ever-changing nature of the land, and then of course the Islands of Terror are separated by the Mists which allow for such drastic changes.
So long story short, I agree, that just because the seas around Lamordia are a different domain, does not mean they should be drastically different in climate compared to Lamordia.
For example, you don't go from Har'Akir desert conditions to Sri Rajian jungles just because you crossed a border between the domains.
That's one of the things I like about the Core. The changes are gradual, like the real world. Domains with similar foliage and temperature border each other, and often changes are throughout the domain, rather than just "at the border." It's also like how the Clusters have formed with domains of similar climate; the Amber Wastes, the Verderous Lands, etc.
The only real exceptions I see to this are possible Vechor, because of the ever-changing nature of the land, and then of course the Islands of Terror are separated by the Mists which allow for such drastic changes.
So long story short, I agree, that just because the seas around Lamordia are a different domain, does not mean they should be drastically different in climate compared to Lamordia.
- High Priest Mikhal
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1642
- Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.
Re: Seas about Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"
Clusters are related by a symbolism uniting them and not their climates. The Amber Wastes, for example, are unified by the fact all three have past and current ties to the Egyptian Pantheon. The Verdant Lands, the Shadowlands, and Zherisia are the same story. The four Clusters may have drawn their domains from the same Material World but that's the only reason they may share any kind of similar climate.Mortavius wrote:Personally, I don't subscribe to the "it's a different domain" theory. The lands of the Core should have a unified climate with only specific exceptions.
For example, you don't go from Har'Akir desert conditions to Sri Rajian jungles just because you crossed a border between the domains.
The same idea of symbolism applies to the Core. Namely, there is no unifying symbolism from one domain to another. They may share cultures, Cultural Levels, and religions, but each is its own unique little plane of existence. It says as much in the setting book and the RPH. They're expressions of the darklords that rule them. Dementlieu is a place of moderate weather and climate because of d'Honaire. Its neighbors reflect this as well. Mordent is a bleak, haunted land because Godefroy himself is bleak and haunted. Falkovnia is as repressive in terms of weather and climate as Drakov is. And Lamordia is ruled by the dueling personalities of Mordenheim's own cold and logical approach to life and Adam's raging fury. The Sea of Sorrows is its own domain as well and is reflective of Captain Pieter van Riese.
Climate is symbolic of the darklord(s) who rule a given domain, nothing more. Consider Markovia, a tropical domain, in the northernmost waters of the Sea of Sorrows. How else can such an abnormality be explained except by the fact that Ravenloft doesn't follow the "normal" rules?
As always, Rule Zero: It's your game, do what you want. I'm just stating my own observations.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: Seas about Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"
Pharazia doesn't.High Priest Mikhal wrote:The Amber Wastes, for example, are unified by the fact all three have past and current ties to the Egyptian Pantheon.
- High Priest Mikhal
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1642
- Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.
Re: Seas about Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"
Actually it does. It comes from the same Material World as Har'Akir and Sebua, albeit centuries later in time. I've also not found any canon books stating what religion the Pharazians practiced prior to Diamabel's rise, though I do seem to remember something about part of his curse also being his inability to erase all reminders of the old gods any more than the desert could. It's even an Egyptian saying, "Man fears Time. But Time only fears the Pyramids."Ryan Naylor wrote:Pharazia doesn't.High Priest Mikhal wrote:The Amber Wastes, for example, are unified by the fact all three have past and current ties to the Egyptian Pantheon.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
-
Garudos Celestar
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 279
- Joined: Sat Jun 10, 2006 1:51 pm
- Location: United States
Re: Seas about Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"
Ryan's right about Pharazia coming from a different world than Har'Akir and Sebua. The Verdurous Lands also have no connection: Saragoss comes from the Forgotten Realms and the other 2 are from unspecified Primes Material worlds (but Aber-Toril never had a developed Indian-style setting and the Wildlands don't have a Realmsian corrolary). There's no canon reference to Paridon and Timor coming from the same Prime Material world either. The Frozen Wastes are also only unified by climate: Vorostokov had ties to Birthright, and the few details we have of Sanguinia don't match with any of the cultures from that setting.High Priest Mikhal wrote: Clusters are related by a symbolism uniting them and not their climates. The Amber Wastes, for example, are unified by the fact all three have past and current ties to the Egyptian Pantheon. The Verdant Lands, the Shadowlands, and Zherisia are the same story. The four Clusters may have drawn their domains from the same Material World but that's the only reason they may share any kind of similar climate.
The Shadowlands and the Burning Peaks were the only clusters to be tied together by the identities of the darklords themselves.
[i]"I too have begun to wonder about the legendary wisdom of our guardian angel and his pet rock."
~ Evee Beiderbecke[/i]
~ Evee Beiderbecke[/i]
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: Seas about Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"
I would like a reference please.High Priest Mikhal wrote:Actually it does. It comes from the same Material World as Har'Akir and Sebua, albeit centuries later in time.Ryan Naylor wrote:Pharazia doesn't.High Priest Mikhal wrote:The Amber Wastes, for example, are unified by the fact all three have past and current ties to the Egyptian Pantheon.
Re: Seas about Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"
I understand that there are symbolic links between the Clusters. I didn't include them in my comment because it wasn't really relevant. Whether or not Har'Akir and Sebua come from the same land (and yes, I know they do), they both have the same climate. So I considered the symbolic link irrelevant to what I was mentioning.High Priest Mikhal wrote:Clusters are related by a symbolism uniting them and not their climates. The Amber Wastes, for example, are unified by the fact all three have past and current ties to the Egyptian Pantheon. The Verdant Lands, the Shadowlands, and Zherisia are the same story. The four Clusters may have drawn their domains from the same Material World but that's the only reason they may share any kind of similar climate.
Although I think you are incorrect on some of them; as others mentioned, the Verdrous Lands have no symbolic connection to each other AFAIK. I'm also not certain about Pharazia or the Zherisia cluster.
Well, there are a few factual errors with your examples (Mordenheim is not a co-Darklord of Lamordia, he's merely tied to the Darklord) and some examples that fly in the face of what you're saying.The same idea of symbolism applies to the Core. Namely, there is no unifying symbolism from one domain to another. They may share cultures, Cultural Levels, and religions, but each is its own unique little plane of existence. It says as much in the setting book and the RPH. They're expressions of the darklords that rule them. Dementlieu is a place of moderate weather and climate because of d'Honaire. Its neighbors reflect this as well. Mordent is a bleak, haunted land because Godefroy himself is bleak and haunted. Falkovnia is as repressive in terms of weather and climate as Drakov is. And Lamordia is ruled by the dueling personalities of Mordenheim's own cold and logical approach to life and Adam's raging fury. The Sea of Sorrows is its own domain as well and is reflective of Captain Pieter van Riese.
Climate is symbolic of the darklord(s) who rule a given domain, nothing more. Consider Markovia, a tropical domain, in the northernmost waters of the Sea of Sorrows. How else can such an abnormality be explained except by the fact that Ravenloft doesn't follow the "normal" rules?.
It's true that the domain is a reflection of the Darklord but not *everything* is part of that reflection. For example, the PC's. The alien things in Hazlan that are legacies from when it bordered Bluetspur are another example.
Also, there are examples of an effort to unify the Core. Nova Vassa used to have five moons in previous versions, and Sithicus had three. Both have since had those references removed or changed. I can only guess that this was an effort to make things less "weird." To avoid a situation where a PC could jump back and forth across the borders of the domain and watch the night sky change.
I think it's possible to over-analyze this issue. For example, I see nothing in d'Honaire that screams "temperate climate" at me. That connection can be justified, but I think it's reaching. To make a connection between Markov and tropical climate you have to say it reflect's weirdness. But really, there's nothing about Markov that ties him to a tropical climate. He's from Barovia and presumably (by his background) never even experienced a tropical climate.
In reality, what ties Markov to a tropical climate? He's a reflection of the Island of Dr. Moreau, and that story takes place on a topical island.
- High Priest Mikhal
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1642
- Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.
Re: Seas about Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"
Okay, okay! I get it. I got my facts wrong. I'm over-analyzing things. And my brain is the consistency of mush (stress can literally change the brain's structure, I have Chronic Anxiety Disorder, you do the math). But I still maintain there is an underlying symbolism to all domains and the Clusters in particular. For the Amber Wastes, Frozen Wastes, and Verdurous Lands (with the exception of Saragoss; that was only added to the cluster in 3e) there are historical and/or mythological ties based on the real world regions that inspired them.
Vorostokov sounds more like a Baltic region where the Vikings did settle (Latvia, Lithuania, Russia) and Sanguinia is a Slavic domain akin to the kingdoms of the middle ages in Eastern Europe. Easily a country that would be a neighbor to a region the Vikings settled in.
The Wildlands are representative of Hindu beliefs in sacred animals and stories of intelligent animals, albeit twisted like everything else in Ravenloft. Sri Raji basically India where the myths originate.
The Amber Wastes are all inspired by Egypt, albeit Pharazia was inspired by the area as it was during the Islamic Conquest.
As for Markovia, I already knew Markov was based on Dr. Moreau. But why does a tropical island exist in an area where other domains are considered cold?
I think I'll quit posting in this thread. My Asperger's is showing in my posts.
Vorostokov sounds more like a Baltic region where the Vikings did settle (Latvia, Lithuania, Russia) and Sanguinia is a Slavic domain akin to the kingdoms of the middle ages in Eastern Europe. Easily a country that would be a neighbor to a region the Vikings settled in.
The Wildlands are representative of Hindu beliefs in sacred animals and stories of intelligent animals, albeit twisted like everything else in Ravenloft. Sri Raji basically India where the myths originate.
The Amber Wastes are all inspired by Egypt, albeit Pharazia was inspired by the area as it was during the Islamic Conquest.
As for Markovia, I already knew Markov was based on Dr. Moreau. But why does a tropical island exist in an area where other domains are considered cold?
I think I'll quit posting in this thread. My Asperger's is showing in my posts.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
- Dark Angel
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 815
- Joined: Tue Aug 13, 2013 10:00 am
- Location: Falentei, the Lands of Fire and Darkness
Re: Seas about Lamordia are described as "temperate aquatic"
I calls it as I sees it. I my game, Markovia is a small island, but not inherently tropical. It is like it was pulled from the Core and plopped into the ocean (which it kinda was), hence it is a temperate land among cold waters (which makes retreat into the ocean a bit more daunting). The only concern is that while Dementlieu is considered a milder climate as is Western Darkon, Lamordia is right in the middle. I account for it as the trade winds blow hard down from the Sleeping Beast Mountains and right over the waters which are then fairly cold (the water being shallow helps) from the weather. The rest if the area of the northeastern Sea of Sorrows is then a bit warmer (say a Gulf Stream up from the southern waters). This means the waters off Martina Bay are not choked with ice floes 4-6 months a year and the differences in weather and water temperature makes for a very stormy ocean around the Isle of Agony and gives Lamordia the bleak and crap weather they are used to.
"One does not stop playing when they get old, they grow old when they stop playing" George Bernard Shaw
"If you could be either God’s worst enemy or nothing, which would you choose?" Chuck Palahniuk
"If you could be either God’s worst enemy or nothing, which would you choose?" Chuck Palahniuk
