de-Orientalizing Oriental classes

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Dion of the Fraternity
Lurker Maximus
Lurker Maximus
Posts: 1092
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 4:20 am
Location: Baguio City, Philippines
Contact:

de-Orientalizing Oriental classes

Post by Dion of the Fraternity »

D&D's monk character class is of course based not on the typical European cloistered monks, but on the Asian variety.

This got me to thinking: now with FOUR MORE new character classes (samurai, wu jen, ninja and shugenja), why should a samurai character for example be excusively from Ravenloft's oriental domains? If Ravenloft has Shaolin-type monasteries spread all over the place (such as Lamordia), why shouldn't there be for example a well-known dojo for samurai in the heart of Dementlieu that caters to non-Orientals? In the Complete series this de-Orientalization seems to be the common trend across all of D&D's campaign worlds.
User avatar
Lord_Pruitt
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 153
Joined: Fri May 05, 2006 3:08 am

Post by Lord_Pruitt »

The yakuza could be another form of criminal mafia, doing a little "protection" for their local neighborhoods. The ninja clans would be specialized assassins.
The wu jen would be another form of essoteric spell caster. The shugenja would be just another form of religious practice.

Course, de-orientalizing them removes some of the background flavor for the above classes. Unless, of course, a good alternative background replaces the original ones.

But it is an interesting idea ....
The Wannabe
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 37
Joined: Mon Jul 03, 2006 11:02 am
Location: classified
Contact:

Post by The Wannabe »

Of course, for the campaign's sake the class doesn't have to be de-Orientalized.....perhaps the campaign's monks come either from an Oriental domain or from an outpost temple.....perhaps way up in the Balinoks?

Alternately, while I belong to those who saw nothing but the classic Asian monk in the 3e class, is it really that hard to develop it over into a Western theme? It is campy, admittedly, but there is a scene from "The Spy Who Loved Me" (1977) James Bond movie with wester monks engaging in martial arts. While the western theme is one of contemplation and worship, why couldn't they be skilled with a club, quarterstaff or similar?

From there, one would just need to find a way to fit Western style monasteries into Ravenloft, which is as easily said as done considering the motif, and in my opinion results in an whole slew of new campaign ideas and eerie settings.

Monkwannabe
"C'mon guys, let's check it out.....what's the worst that could happen?"
User avatar
Ronia Sun
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 173
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 4:03 pm
Location: Laramie, Wyoming, gearing up for another looong winter...

Post by Ronia Sun »

There were, in fact, Western monastic orders that were also "militant" orders. Most notably, the Templars--although they became rather secularized in later years, the Templars were in fact an order of warrior-priests, trained in the arts of war and fighting.

There were also individual priests who chose to continue their military training even after taking vows, and some other orders, though not militant through-and-through, also had groups that devoted themselves to the martial disciplines. (Which only makes sense, considering that however strong one's faith may be, angels do not typically show up to defend the monastery from rampaging hordes of Vikings bent on looting.) For example, one of the generals with Henry Baudoin at the sack of Constantinople was a "warrior priest". His name escapes me at the moment, as does his specific Order, but he was a prime example of a Western monk skilled in fighting. I think, in our day and age, the romanticized vision of the zen-like Eastern monk with his amazing martial arts skills has rather overshadowed the monks of the Western tradition. Besides, not *all* orders of Asian monks studied martial arts, either... :D
Always be wary of any helpful item that weighs less than its operating manual. --Terry Pratchett
User avatar
ScS of the Fraternity
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 2409
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 10:46 pm
Location: Toronto
Contact:

Post by ScS of the Fraternity »

True enough, but I would think that the Oriental classes really only make sense in the context of an oriental setting. In truth, there's very little difference between them and their western counterparts except for class names and details regarding abilities.
Is a samuria of ancient japan really that much different than the christian knights of legend? Do wu-jen differ from wizards, except for the class abilities and restrictions?

De-orientalizing oriental classess would merely create a blurred xerox of the core classes.
Evil Reigns!!!!
User avatar
Ronia Sun
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 173
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 4:03 pm
Location: Laramie, Wyoming, gearing up for another looong winter...

Post by Ronia Sun »

I quite agree. However, why not work them in *as* oriental classes? Perhaps Rokushima Taiyoo's scholars have decided to create outposts, to further their own knowledge and to gain some new. The Celtic monastic orders did just that--the Irish monks' passion for copying down books of all countries is part of the reason why so many Greek and Roman texts survived the Dark Ages. No reason why Eastern culture monks cannot do the same, in RL. Or perhaps an entire monastery/dojo/whatever was taken by the Mists, and deposited somewhere in the Core...
Always be wary of any helpful item that weighs less than its operating manual. --Terry Pratchett
User avatar
Lord Cyclohexane
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 512
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 1:59 pm
Location: Tanelorn, OH

Post by Lord Cyclohexane »

In my opinion, ScS, your point only further supports why the classes *ought* to be de-Orientalized. If the only thing keeping a class oriental is the description, then why deny those abilities from being learned by non-oriental characters? Why not open it up so that said abilities can be learned regardless of the base culture?

I see the "samurai" class as being much better than the new "knight" class in terms of defending one's lord, in taking on vows to protect one's country, etc, regardless of whether that country is Western or Eastern in feel. The new "knight" class feels like it only fit "hedge knights", ones sworn to protect the people but not bound to any particular lord. So why not de-Orientalize the "samurai" class to represent any warrior specifically bound to their liege lord?

The same appears with the other classes as well. If the class works well elsewhere, why not use it? If that particular Western culture shares the particular trait that inspired that Oriental class in the Eastern culture, why not reason that, for the same reason that that culture trait generated it in an Eastern country that it could generate it in a Western country?
Last edited by Lord Cyclohexane on Mon Jul 31, 2006 12:40 pm, edited 1 time in total.
My name is lost to me
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
User avatar
Ronia Sun
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 173
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 4:03 pm
Location: Laramie, Wyoming, gearing up for another looong winter...

Post by Ronia Sun »

Again, though, the definition of a Western knight is pretty much the same as a samurai, no matter what the D&D book says. :D You couldn't *be* a knight in medieval Europe without a liege lord, not really. By definition, a knight was one who swore a vow of fealty to another, whether that man was a king, an earl, or a baron. The "hedge knight" description you reference is, I think, a means by which the game designers try to present an option for players who really don't like the idea of having to obey a liege.

That said, though, the Western and Eastern classes are not mirrors of one another. The basic goals and structure are similar, but there are very different philosophies and means of evolution. At the height of their culture, the samurai were the rulers of the country. They were cultured, refined, and placed as much emphasis on their philosophy as on their martial training. At their ebb, they were little more than hired thugs. With Western knights, there was always a certain absence of the cultured aspects. True, at the height of their era the knights were sworn defenders of the faith, defenders of king and country. However, most of them were still illiterate, unwashed barbarians. (Which, whatever the Western historians and snobs would have us believe, *most* of the so-called great civilization of the West was just that: unwashed, illiterate barbarians.) I think the key difference between "Western" and "Eastern" is philosophy. Not to say either is better (though the Eastern cultures sure clued in on the whole 'bathing' thing a lot faster), but they are very different philosophies. Western philosphy was very heavy into obedience to God (and the Church) first, and liege second. Eastern tended toward obedience to your superiors, hands down. This is part of the reason why Japan kicked the Westerners out for so long: they really disliked the Christian emphasis on obedience to the Church. They saw the political ramifications in their peasantry obeying a distant leader in Rome before their own daimyos...

At any rate, de-orientalizing the Oriental classes seems to me, as ScS says, merely muddling the core, Western classes. Part of the interest in the Oriental classes is the different philosophy--perhaps the basic duties of the class are the same, but the means by which the evolution/training/etc is achieved is unique.
Always be wary of any helpful item that weighs less than its operating manual. --Terry Pratchett
User avatar
Lord Cyclohexane
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 512
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 1:59 pm
Location: Tanelorn, OH

Post by Lord Cyclohexane »

I guess that's where I see the divide. Philosophy is an "in character" thing, unrelated for the most part from the rules.

I see no issue with taking a Rokuma warrior, calling him a "samurai" in game and having every other character refer to him as a "samurai" but having his class level Ftr3. Behavior-wise, the character acts as a samurai does; but rules-wise, he follows the stats of a Fighter.

Similarly, I see no issue with taking a Richemuloise warrior, calling him a "knight" in game and having every other character refer to him as a "knight" but having his class level be Sam3. Behavior-wise, the character acts as a knight does; but rules-wise, he follows the stats of a Samurai.

I fail to see why these cannot be mixed and matched. As for the "In the West, knights followed God more strongly than their liege lord due to the effect of the Catholic Church", I ask, why should the Western Core domains follow the same? Where do you see that same super-strong religious force in the Core? The Ezran Church is the closest you've got, but it has no political authority anywhere outside of Borca; heck, if Ivana Boritsi decided to turn her back on the Ezran Church, she'd still be the political ruler of Borca, so excommunication from the Ezran Church has no teeth.

As such, there is no equivalent religious force in Western Ravenloftian culture that there is in Western realworld culture. So the Western Ravenloftian cultures are *not* the same as the Western realworld cultures. Why wouldn't Western Ravenloftian cultures share certain traits of Eastern realworld cultures? Why wouldn't Western Ravenloftian cultures share some classes as Eastern realworld cultures? Must we be bound to realworld cultural notions when dealing with a world that had different influences creatings its cultures?
Last edited by Lord Cyclohexane on Mon Jul 31, 2006 1:41 pm, edited 1 time in total.
My name is lost to me
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
User avatar
Ronia Sun
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 173
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 4:03 pm
Location: Laramie, Wyoming, gearing up for another looong winter...

Post by Ronia Sun »

Good points...but then, what is the point of bringing in the Oriental classes at all, then? If you've got a character who is a lvl3 fighter and calls himself a samurai, then what's the point? Though you might ask yourself why in the world an adventurer from the Core would call himself a samurai and not a knight? Why would they do that, when "samurai" (or "wu jen") is not a part of any of the Core languages? Knight, however, and it's variations, are. "Cavalier", "cavaler", "Ritter", and so on, I could see as being used in lieu of "knight", depending upon a character's origins...but "samurai"? Not unless they came from an Eastern tradition.

I suppose what I'm looking for is a compelling reason as to WHY the Core would have such traditions, if they are not from an "Eastern" culture. You said it yourself: the Core doesn't appear to have any strong philosophical leanings, period. Why should Eastern thought--which shares many of the same spiritual roots as Western--be any different?

(And please understand that I am not in any way bashing your idea. I just enjoy the debate. 8) )
Always be wary of any helpful item that weighs less than its operating manual. --Terry Pratchett
User avatar
Lord Cyclohexane
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 512
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 1:59 pm
Location: Tanelorn, OH

Post by Lord Cyclohexane »

Ronia Sun wrote:Good points...but then, what is the point of bringing in the Oriental classes at all, then? If you've got a character who is a lvl3 fighter and calls himself a samurai, then what's the point?
Why wouldn't I bring them in? If I have a lvl3 Fighter who calls his himself a "Blargflurter" and then WotC puts out a book with a specialty "Blargflurter" class, does that mean I now can't use it?

I fail to see why I shouldn't use a particular rule set just because a particular name is attached to it. "A rose by any other name would smell as sweet" and all of that.

I agree that a "samurai" should follow the values, behaviors, codes of conduct, etc that a realworld samurai would (with small modifications for campaign flavor). But I fail to see why a ruleset labelled as "samurai" means that I am forbidden from using it unless I follow the personality type of a "samurai" as well.

As a comparison: If I use the statistics from the Monstrous Manual for a troll, am I forced to actually use a troll for it? Can't I switch the color of the skin, the overall body look, and simply use that ruleset for this new monster I desire? Similarly, if I create my own monster and decide to name that a "troll", am I forbidden from using the MM ruleset for a troll, even if I call the canon troll by a different name?
Ronia Sun wrote:Though you might ask yourself why in the world an adventurer from the Core would call himself a samurai and not a knight? Why would they do that, when "samurai" (or "wu jen") is not a part of any of the Core languages? Knight, however, and it's variations, are. "Cavalier", "cavaler", "Ritter", and so on, I could see as being used in lieu of "knight", depending upon a character's origins...but "samurai"? Not unless they came from an Eastern tradition.
I'm going to be purposefully argumentative here... :)

But anyway, you can't back up your above statement. Unless, of course, you've been to the Demiplane of Dread recently and picked up dictionaries in Mordentish, Balok, Vaasi, Lamordian, Falkovnian, etc and checked through each and every one of them. One of those languages may indeed contain the word "samurai" referring to a warrior style.

Also, if you went to the Demiplane and picked up dictionaries in Rokuma and all of the other "Oriental" languages, you may not find the word "samurai" in any of them.

Just because "samurai" exists in the realworld language of Japanese and doesn't exist in any of the realworld European languages doesn't create any influence on how things work in Ravenloft.

Note, however: Does your above argument mean that, if I run an Oriental campaign in I'Cath (based on China), that I can't use the Samurai class, seeing as the word "samurai" doesn't exist in Chinese either???
Ronia Sun wrote:I suppose what I'm looking for is a compelling reason as to WHY the Core would have such traditions, if they are not from an "Eastern" culture. You said it yourself: the Core doesn't appear to have any strong philosophical leanings, period. Why should Eastern thought--which shares many of the same spiritual roots as Western--be any different?
And I'm trying to find a compelling reason as to WHY NOT to have such traditions. When we're creating brand new fantasy cultures, why not take elements from as many different places as we please? Why limit ourselves based on our notions of the "real world"?

(And please understand that I am not in any way bashing your idea. I just enjoy the debate 8) )

That's cool, I'm enjoying it as well. :)
My name is lost to me
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

One's philosophy isn't defined by character class, only one's quantifiable game-stats. A character's class defines what they can do, not what they think or how they dress or what sociopolitical context gave rise to them -- that's why WotC deliberately chose to make Ember the Iconic Monk resemble an African, not an Asian, in the 3E artwork -- apart from a few culturally-generic ethical constraints inherent to a profession (like druids not laying waste to the wilderness).

An urban street-gang member could be statted like a barbarian, even if he hasn't seen a deer or a mountain or a tree in his life. Alanik Ray is a 'canon' NPC statted as a rogue, who doesn't come close to fitting the dictionary's definition of 'roguish'; so was Van Richten, a 'thief' in the 2E products. Clerics in D&D are all members of the same PHB character class, yet such folk adhere to and advocate thousands of different philosophies, as disseminated by their various (often mutually-opposed) deities and belief-systems. If such disparities in origin, agenda or beliefs can all be gathered under the umbrella of a single PHB class, why should a samurai's cultural background make his class any different from a western knight's?

The one reason why the OA classes -- or non-prestige optional classes from any other product -- might be worth adding to Ravenloft, IMO, is if you feel there's a need for the mechanical aspects of such a class to be made available for characters IYC. If you think there are elements of the samurai character class that are statistically useful for your game, go ahead and add it as a class option, whether or not your PCs ever actually use the word "samurai". (Indeed, unless you assume the class's skills are popularly recognized as something imported from Rokushima, it may be best to prohibit that word's useage in-character for all non-Roku samurai, perhaps replacing it with some less anachronistic term.) But if it's just the samurai's image you're concerned with capturing -- the paired katanas, the calligraphy, etc -- then I'd recommend sticking with the PHB fighter, perhaps with a substitute-level that grants better access to the Japanese samurai's repertoire of "cultured" skills, in lieu of one of a standard fighter's perks.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

I think you should keep them largely Asian in nature. Sure, a few people from other cultures could acquire them and that's not against any rules, but it would probably require some degree of convoluted back history to justify it.

Just think: the game is already European- and American-centered as it is. The usual approach to Asian culture characters tends to lock them out from playing Paladins, Druids, and other standard classes. The idea of an unarmed fighting monk capable of doing acrobatic and martial arts stunts draws clearly from Asian cultures, but has now become ubiquitous to the point that the PHB uses an African-American character to illustrate it. (An interesting but slightly dubious case of racial diversity, illustrated by a case of racial disenfranchisement? The mind boggles.)

I'm not saying that any cross cultural pollination is bad, but if you're going to unlock the Asian style specialties for non-Asian characters to play, then at least consider opening the floodgates the other way too.

In my campaign, you'll find Chinese and Japanese characters wandering around Darkon, and putting down their burdens for a quick drink in Port-a-Lucine shipyard taverns too. An occasional Minglun jiao (think Buddhist) temple dots the landscape in areas with many such Asian style visitors.
User avatar
Jack of Tears
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 306
Joined: Fri Mar 11, 2005 4:25 pm

re

Post by Jack of Tears »

The biggest argument? To maintain diversity. By allowing the Oriental classes to remain restricted to domains which might generate such, you are creating the image of diversity between the cultures. Yes, diversity can be role played, however, players themselves do recognized the existance of mechanics and will be more impressed by a Samuria whom has powers and abilities distinct from those available to knights.

By your argument one could just as easily ask: "Why bother restricting certain spell types to specific magic users?" After all, if description and rp are the only important factors, mechanics become meaningless. I want my wizard to cast Cure Disease and Heal - go ahead, so long as he can describe them as arcane, rather than divine in nature.

There is a reason we use a class based system; so people can fill different and unique roles in the game.

By stripping every class down to mechanics and offering them to everyone you sacrifice a valuable storytelling tool - and make no mistake, in an rpg, the inner workings of the classes does tell part of the story.

Historically Samurai and Knights are trained differently, thus they should be treated differently in the game - and flavor text alone doesn't do justice to that.

That all said, I firmly support the idea of making culturally distinct classes for everyone. We should have African style warriors using a more accurate fighting style, or Indian spell casters who call upon different methods to provide their powers. (in fact there was setting material put out or an African game and Al'Qabim once provided the latter) Culteral diversity makes the world interesting, exciting and mysterious.
User avatar
Dion of the Fraternity
Lurker Maximus
Lurker Maximus
Posts: 1092
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 4:20 am
Location: Baguio City, Philippines
Contact:

Post by Dion of the Fraternity »

I'm not saying that any cross cultural pollination is bad, but if you're going to unlock the Asian style specialties for non-Asian characters to play, then at least consider opening the floodgates the other way too.
I think that's what Ravenloft d20 did (unlocking non-Oriental classes to Rokumans, I mean: assassins in Rokushima Taiyoo are called ninja, as stated in the RLPHB).

I dunno how this fits into the discussion, but here's the iconic Samurai character from Complete Warrior:

Image

As a dwarf, with the exception of his daisho he doesn't quite look Oriental. ;)
Post Reply