Of course the players must be aware about this rule before anything bad happen to their pc. For sure it makes them a lot more affraid of death. I actually used that rule with a much higher level group and it worked fine, of course I was playing with experienced players who where more interested in role play than power play.See this would torment or get on my player's nerves..... They'd be quite weak, compared to the other PCS (the campain is @ 6 at the moment, actually.) And I myself would have one hell of a time keeping balance...
What usually happen is the new 1st or low level pc is forced to follow the humble path of "apprenticeship" playing henchmen/squires/apprentice to the higher level pcs. With the help from the higher level PC, the gap quickly narrows and you end up with a low level pc raising up in level every 2-3 game sessions (if you give xp at the end of each session), which is fun for the player while still providing the feeling of becoming a hero.
Personally as a player I would actually PREFER to start from step one. Otehrwise I would feel like I'm cheating.
PS.: I never let a pc raise more than 1 level per game session (yes it could happen when a first level begins with a few high level friends to help him !). I top the xp to the next level minus 1 when that happen.
Anyway, this is just how we do it and I understand that some groups may prefer to do otherwise. After all, the goal is to have fun so do whatever you and your players prefer
pps.:
You can even start them as non-adventurer level 0 starting at something like minus 1000XP, the amount needed to gain their first level... I did it for hirelings npcs once, they went up to warriors level 2 and then they where lucky to be sent to carry a message to another town right on the day before the "moons conjunction" which sent the whole daggerdale area into RL in my game. The PCs lost two nice hirelings (about to become henchmen) but the lucky boys where not trapped in RL and can now enjoy their new skills (and equipment) wherever they wish in FR . Of course I would not be so mean as to start a PC at level 0 unless the player ask for it.
I know at least one player who would jump right away in my game even if I told him "ok you can get in my new campaign but you'll have to start with a crippled blind hunchback level 0 orphan with horrible stats (except maybe only one above 10) with a group of average level 6-7. I'm not sending my offer yet only because I know he would end up overwelming my actual group of newbie players soon. This guy could make an interesting hero out of anything !
Sorry for the rant

