If YOU designed Ravenloft
- Igor the Henchman
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 832
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 6:50 pm
If YOU designed Ravenloft
Remember the "To Retcon or not to Retcon" thread? Here's a fun concept: suppose a retcon of the setting really was coming. Let's imagine some hypothetical RPG business officials get a hold on the rights and decide to launch a whole new version of Ravenloft, and ask you to help, basically saying "Hey, we think this setting's pretty good. So we want YOU to make it better!"
I stress it from the start: this is a whacky, imaginary scenario. I'm just taking advantage of the fact no one's publishing Ravenloft right now to get wild with ideas. These imaginary guys are asking you to make a complete overhaul of the setting. Make it new and exciting. Make it work better and more smoothly than ever before. Fix any flaws you might see in the original design. Keep everything you think works great and re-imagine everything that could work better. You can change anything.
What would you do and why?
I stress it from the start: this is a whacky, imaginary scenario. I'm just taking advantage of the fact no one's publishing Ravenloft right now to get wild with ideas. These imaginary guys are asking you to make a complete overhaul of the setting. Make it new and exciting. Make it work better and more smoothly than ever before. Fix any flaws you might see in the original design. Keep everything you think works great and re-imagine everything that could work better. You can change anything.
What would you do and why?
- Igor the Henchman
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 832
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 6:50 pm
I'll start.
Stuff to Keep
Here's my personal "Keep it at all costs" list. This is the stuff the setting has right now that I think is a stroke of pure game design genius.
The atmosphere
My favorite part of the setting. Not only does Ravenloft's distinct gothic horror feel make it memorable and distinct from other settings, its also the part that draws the players' interest in giving it a whirl. And in my opinion, the unique atmosphere is much responsible for the setting's decade-long celebrity status among D&D fans.
The Domains and the Darklords
Seriously, this part of the setting is a masterstroke. I cannot imagine a more elegant way of blending the needs of a D&D game world with the delicate requirements of gothic horror mystique. Dividing the landmass into definite "domains", each with a clearly defined flavor and theme helps a lot with the campaign planning, while the tragic history of the darklords is a very efficient demonstration of the setting's main selling points.
The cultural levels
What can I say? The image of your D&D character shooting from a pistol at the charging werewolf is very compelling. Also, having different cultural levels existing side-by-side allows to explore various flavors of gothic horror in the same campaign, from the fighting of cursed knights to Sherlock Holmes urban intrigues.
Clusters, Islands, Pocket domains
I like the idea of making some domains isolated from the rest by making them Islands. Doing so allows for exploration and mystery moments whenever the PCs explore an unfamiliar land, and lets the DM try new things without worrying as to how it could affect the world structure. Also, arranging similar domains into clusters is a great way of enriching the setting in terms of cultures and foreign politics. Ultimately, making a domain into an island grants the DM perfect control as to when or if the PCs get to visit such or such place, which is very convenient for adventure building. The Pocket domains, on the other hand, make it easy to drop a "short and sweet" horror adventure on the PCs wherever they might be. Last but not least, the idea that there's always more unexplored Islands out there gives the DM total freedom to create his own unique lands and denizens. This is a major strength of the setting compared to many others.
The Heroes, villains and other NPCs
What's really great about Ravenloft? Its a world where NPCs matter. Its choke-full of interesting NPCs, many of which feel like characters from a novel. As a setting where the villains get to have a moment in the spotlight, the abundance of unique and interesting adversaries with rich personalities is a great DM-helper. This goes for the darklords as well as for the non-darklords.
Links to other worlds and Weekends in Hell
I said it once, and I say it again: I'm a big fan of the Weekend in Hell adventures. It allows you to get any character from any campaign world into Ravenloft for a short visit of terror whenever you like. Don't take it as an objection against the "coherent world" feel that has taken so long to be achieved. I just find that the Weekend in Hell tradition opens up the Dread Domains to fans of other settings, which is an excellent thing. In this light, Ravenloft isn't actually "competing" with other campaign worlds for attention. You can have Ravenloft and Eberron in the same campaign and make it work. Hell, I heard of some pretty interesting attempts to bring bits of Ravenloft into non-D&D worlds (such as 7th Sea), with some exciting results.
Stuff to reconsider
This is obviously a touchy subject to breach on a Ravenloft fan forum, but as much as I love the setting, I do believe it has its weak points - stuff that, had it been designed differently from the start, could have led to an even better creation. When I say "weak points", I not so much mean stuff that doesn't work, but rather things that (in my eyes) could have been designed with a better consideration for the "larger picture". I will try, to the best of my ability, to explain my reasons for finding fault with each element and explain how exactly changing it might make for a smoother and more attractive game for the DM and his group.
A little lexicon:
To make my explanations less tedious, I'll use these home-made terms as a time-saver.
Rich: this term applies to domains. It describes those domains that seem to offer especially diverse adventure possibilities and are especially attractive for DMs to plan adventures in. Rich domains tend to see more play in most campaigns. Darkon is an example of a really Rich domain. The term can be used comparatively, as in Souragne is Richer than l'Ile de la Tempete. Most often, domains that are hospitable to PCs tend to be Richer than those that don't, but there are exceptions: The Nightmare Lands are Richer than Staunton Bluffs.
Clunky: the opposite of Rich. Clunky domains are inflexible, and tend to resist the DM's attempts to customize adventures set inside them, or to run scenarios that don't involve one or more key elements of a domain. I'Cath is one of the Clunkiest domains in Ravenloft: there's nothing whatsoever you can do there, other than to confront the darklord and her minions the moment you enter the place. The term can also be used as a comparative, as in the Shadowborn Manor is Clunkier than Odiare, which is Clunkier than Zherisia. Clunkiness isn't necessarily a bad trait for a domain to have - but if a domain is Clunky, it better justify this by being really interesting and making for an exciting adventure. A perfect example of this is the House of Lament: Clunky, but really, really cool.
Attractive: This qualifier applies to choices the players can make in the campaign, but usually during character creation. It concerns the selection of classes, races, feats and background possibilities. Attractive choices are those the setting tends to encourage, usually by being especially appropriate flavor-wise, and offering rich possibilities of background and role-play. Choices that limit the PC's potential, background ideas, the places he can visit safely, or that are likely to get him involved into trouble are Unattractive. For example: in Ravenloft, playing a human cleric of Ezra is an Attractive choice. Playing a goblin cleric of Wee Jas is not.
Obtrusiveness: This term applies to setting-specific elements that pop in the way of adventure or campaign creation whether the DM wishes to profit from them or not. An Obtrusive element might be really cool, but compensates by being really difficult to ignore (short of Rule 0) if you don't plan to make use of it in your game. Darkon's memory drain is one example of an Obtrusive element. The ring of choking fog around the Village of Barovia is another: if the PCs are to go there, dealing with the fog *will* become a major issue, whether its useful for the adventure or not.
Now, I present the list of elements of Ravenloft that I would be tempted to tinker with if offered the occasion.
Augment the map scale size
This is an easy one to start with. Many Ravenloft fans during both editions of the game have admitted adjusting the size of the Core in their games to increase travel times and make the domains feel like small countries, instead of small plots of land. I'll go as far as say that the Core's small size has led to a few continuity contradictions in the past. The official 2nd edition adventure "Death Ascendant" has a big part of the action happening on the PCs' trip from Stangengrad to Nartok - but because traveling this distance takes such a ridiculously short amount of time according to official scale, the author had to "fake it", by making it five times longer. Likewise, even the Gazetteers prove guilty of inflating the travel distances from time to time, the biggest example I remember being in the Mordent chapter: "Head on past the old Whitby estate and then turn south for two days" (Gaz III p. 36).
While you could simply blame the authors for not knowing the setting well enough, I can't help but agree that greater distances do a better job at making the campaign world more, well, "worldly". When the word "campaign setting" is used, most players expect at least the size of a small continent. Likewise, making towns so close leaves little to no place for the wilderness: place to hide for all sorts of beasties you want the PCs to fight, place to get lost in in the middle of a storm, so they seek shelter in that harmless-looking old house on the hill. Now, granted, 3E already addresses the issue by doing away with the scale, and its a good move. Myself, I'd just drop all pretense and officially make Ravenloft a big place, and I don't think this would harm any existing setting fans (feel free to contradict me on this if I'm wrong).
Make non-human races more Attractive
Playing a non-human race is a less Attractive choice in Ravenloft than in other worlds. Outcast Ratings aside, the main reason for this is the lack of coverage and options. Consider: when you choose to make a human PC, the setting gives you tons of background concepts. Are you an Abber nomad hunter, a Dementlieuse noble or a Raji priest? If you want to play a dwarf… you’re probably a darkonian, meaning you share your unique flavor and culture with your human, elvish and gnomish neighbors. A creative player can easily make a memorable dwarf PC background, but that supposes he’s dead set on playing a dwarf in the first place. If you’re not sure which race to choose… probably human. And that’s not good, from my point of view. Why? A simple observation from playing a variety of great games: if you’re giving a player a choice, make different options roughly equally interesting. If, in a game, one important option (play a human, say) is clearly more Attractive than all rival choices (play any other race), the choice becomes less fun to make, no matter which option you pick in the end.
To be Attractive, non-human races of Ravenloft should have a unique, powerful appeal. To help this, I would propose to make non-human races more prominent in the greater scheme of things. Give them unique cultures, put them in the spotlight. Have, for example, an elvish embassy be prominent in one of the setting’s major cities. Give the setting a few elvish, dwarven and gnomish darklords. Make up domains where they can feel at home. Would it make the setting less Ravenloft-like? I heard very little complaints regarding Sithicus’ presence in the Core. How bad would it be to give dwarves and gnomes their own “Sithicus’es”? All these things would contribute to make the choice to play a non-human more Attractive, which makes the setting (and thus the game) more diverse and exciting.
Make the setting more Player-friendly
From the very beginning, Ravenloft has been something of a DM's toy. A review of my Ravenloft product collection reveals a total of forty books, only three of which can be read by players. The darklords' identities, the new monster rules, the secret societies, the domain lore, and so on, have to be carefully hidden from your players, lest you spoil all the setting's surprises. What makes this situation difficult, in my opinion, is that a great part of the "top secret" stuff is usually also very Obtrusive stuff, meaning its very difficult to separate from the stuff players *are* allowed to know. You can't really describe most domains in great detail to players, because the darklord's nature becomes too obvious. Markovia? Its that place where people go and are kinda never seen again and nobody knows why. And not many people ever returned from Forlorn, so I can't tell you what's there either. And Keening's kinda mysterious like that too. And Isle of Demise. And the Isle of Agony. And the Wildlands. And Todstein. And that L'Ile de la Tempete place. And Avonleigh. And Bluetspur. Does the pattern become tired? The reason I find this problematic is that it makes it kinda difficult for the players themselves to become immersed in the setting's lore. Since most of the most interesting, most juicy bits are constantly hidden from the players, they have less incentive to become fans of the setting themselves. I'm pretty certain that most of the setting's fans today come from the DM crowd.
The best way to avoid this pitfall is to make the "DM-only" material of the setting less Obtrusive than it is now. Remodel some domains so that they make for interesting play even when the players know most of its secrets. Make the domains bigger, more diverse, and less darklord-centric. By keeping the darklords, but removing them from the centre of things, you actually make it less dramatic if the players happen to know the darklord's true nature and history (which, most of the time, is really enjoyable stuff to read). So what if the players know that Renier chick is a wererat queen with a torn past? If they never meet her, that'll never matter. If they DO meet her, the knowledge of her origins makes it easier for the players to enjoy their interaction with that character. I don't say the setting should have absolutely no surprises for the players, but MOST game material should be as enjoyable for players as for the guy behind the screen. Once they get interested in Ravenloft's inner wheels, the players might become more invested in the setting, which would then have a better chance of flourishing.
Encourage Rich domains, avoid theme redundancy
In general, I believe that Richer domains are more valuable to the setting than the Clunkier ones. The latter can be loads of fun for an adventure or two, but don't offer a lot of long-term play. Rich domains, on the other hand, can be used over and over again without ever depleting their play value. Mordent is a Rich domain: you can play countless adventures within it, featuring ghost haunts, murder mysteries, werewolf attacks, ancestral curses, meddling fey and lots of other stuff. Doing the same in a domain like Saragoss proves more difficult, because the domain eventually stops being "fresh" and the players wish to move on to something new. As things are now, most non-Core domains seem to have been designed with the "short visit" mentality. 2nd edition accessories like Darklords and Islands of Terror (the primary sources of new domains back in the day), felt as if, in many cases, the author first got a cool idea for a darklord, then built a domain around it (think I'Cath). While this is not necessarily bad design, I feel a little more fore-thought as to what role that domain might play in the bigger portrait of the setting could be useful to make the world into a more cohesive place, suitable for long-term campaigns.
So, if I had to supervise a complete overhaul of the setting, my motto would be: "Make domains bigger, make domains Richer". I would also be careful with Theme Redundancy. Here's an example of Theme Redundancy in existing domains. Take Dementlieu and Richemulot. Both are based off of French culture. Both are very advanced and human-centric. Both are remarkably appropriate for urban adventures. Both feature vast quantities of political intrigue and class conflict. The main difference is actually a rather subtle variation in tone: Dementlieu is supposed to represent the light-hearted theme of an advanced urban society, while Richemulot represents are darker one, what with cutthroat blackmail intrigues and creepy things in the sewers. So, acknowledging the importance of these themes, but also seeking to make domains Richer and more unique identity-wise, I'm tempted to combine both realms in one: a big domain of urban intrigue featuring both the light and dark sides of the same coin. The domain could be vast, with a big Paris-like capital in the middle surrounded by surrogate urban centers, each with its own personal flavor and free Sherlock Holmes hats distributed at the gates.
Likewise, I see a strong similitude of theme in the domains of Vechor and the Nightmare Lands: both are chaotic places with a scary, ever-changing landscape. Unite them in one domain, call it "The Really Weird Place" and make it a gigantic Island of Terror. The "strangeness" of that land would increase the further one moves into it, so the land's borders could have more-or-less normal settlements, but further inside, only the Abber nomads dare dwell, and even they stay clear of the domain's deeper reaches. The place could have spots for mad wizards like Easan, and a spot for the City of Nod and the Nightmare Court. The deepest recesses of the land would stay undefined, so the DM is free to make it as creepy-crazy as needed for his game.
------
There, that's pretty much all for me. How about the rest of you? If you have ideas of what you'd do differently if you had to re-design Ravenloft from ground up, please share them so we have fun comparing. Its all imaginary. Get crazy.
Stuff to Keep
Here's my personal "Keep it at all costs" list. This is the stuff the setting has right now that I think is a stroke of pure game design genius.
The atmosphere
My favorite part of the setting. Not only does Ravenloft's distinct gothic horror feel make it memorable and distinct from other settings, its also the part that draws the players' interest in giving it a whirl. And in my opinion, the unique atmosphere is much responsible for the setting's decade-long celebrity status among D&D fans.
The Domains and the Darklords
Seriously, this part of the setting is a masterstroke. I cannot imagine a more elegant way of blending the needs of a D&D game world with the delicate requirements of gothic horror mystique. Dividing the landmass into definite "domains", each with a clearly defined flavor and theme helps a lot with the campaign planning, while the tragic history of the darklords is a very efficient demonstration of the setting's main selling points.
The cultural levels
What can I say? The image of your D&D character shooting from a pistol at the charging werewolf is very compelling. Also, having different cultural levels existing side-by-side allows to explore various flavors of gothic horror in the same campaign, from the fighting of cursed knights to Sherlock Holmes urban intrigues.
Clusters, Islands, Pocket domains
I like the idea of making some domains isolated from the rest by making them Islands. Doing so allows for exploration and mystery moments whenever the PCs explore an unfamiliar land, and lets the DM try new things without worrying as to how it could affect the world structure. Also, arranging similar domains into clusters is a great way of enriching the setting in terms of cultures and foreign politics. Ultimately, making a domain into an island grants the DM perfect control as to when or if the PCs get to visit such or such place, which is very convenient for adventure building. The Pocket domains, on the other hand, make it easy to drop a "short and sweet" horror adventure on the PCs wherever they might be. Last but not least, the idea that there's always more unexplored Islands out there gives the DM total freedom to create his own unique lands and denizens. This is a major strength of the setting compared to many others.
The Heroes, villains and other NPCs
What's really great about Ravenloft? Its a world where NPCs matter. Its choke-full of interesting NPCs, many of which feel like characters from a novel. As a setting where the villains get to have a moment in the spotlight, the abundance of unique and interesting adversaries with rich personalities is a great DM-helper. This goes for the darklords as well as for the non-darklords.
Links to other worlds and Weekends in Hell
I said it once, and I say it again: I'm a big fan of the Weekend in Hell adventures. It allows you to get any character from any campaign world into Ravenloft for a short visit of terror whenever you like. Don't take it as an objection against the "coherent world" feel that has taken so long to be achieved. I just find that the Weekend in Hell tradition opens up the Dread Domains to fans of other settings, which is an excellent thing. In this light, Ravenloft isn't actually "competing" with other campaign worlds for attention. You can have Ravenloft and Eberron in the same campaign and make it work. Hell, I heard of some pretty interesting attempts to bring bits of Ravenloft into non-D&D worlds (such as 7th Sea), with some exciting results.
Stuff to reconsider
This is obviously a touchy subject to breach on a Ravenloft fan forum, but as much as I love the setting, I do believe it has its weak points - stuff that, had it been designed differently from the start, could have led to an even better creation. When I say "weak points", I not so much mean stuff that doesn't work, but rather things that (in my eyes) could have been designed with a better consideration for the "larger picture". I will try, to the best of my ability, to explain my reasons for finding fault with each element and explain how exactly changing it might make for a smoother and more attractive game for the DM and his group.
A little lexicon:
To make my explanations less tedious, I'll use these home-made terms as a time-saver.
Rich: this term applies to domains. It describes those domains that seem to offer especially diverse adventure possibilities and are especially attractive for DMs to plan adventures in. Rich domains tend to see more play in most campaigns. Darkon is an example of a really Rich domain. The term can be used comparatively, as in Souragne is Richer than l'Ile de la Tempete. Most often, domains that are hospitable to PCs tend to be Richer than those that don't, but there are exceptions: The Nightmare Lands are Richer than Staunton Bluffs.
Clunky: the opposite of Rich. Clunky domains are inflexible, and tend to resist the DM's attempts to customize adventures set inside them, or to run scenarios that don't involve one or more key elements of a domain. I'Cath is one of the Clunkiest domains in Ravenloft: there's nothing whatsoever you can do there, other than to confront the darklord and her minions the moment you enter the place. The term can also be used as a comparative, as in the Shadowborn Manor is Clunkier than Odiare, which is Clunkier than Zherisia. Clunkiness isn't necessarily a bad trait for a domain to have - but if a domain is Clunky, it better justify this by being really interesting and making for an exciting adventure. A perfect example of this is the House of Lament: Clunky, but really, really cool.
Attractive: This qualifier applies to choices the players can make in the campaign, but usually during character creation. It concerns the selection of classes, races, feats and background possibilities. Attractive choices are those the setting tends to encourage, usually by being especially appropriate flavor-wise, and offering rich possibilities of background and role-play. Choices that limit the PC's potential, background ideas, the places he can visit safely, or that are likely to get him involved into trouble are Unattractive. For example: in Ravenloft, playing a human cleric of Ezra is an Attractive choice. Playing a goblin cleric of Wee Jas is not.
Obtrusiveness: This term applies to setting-specific elements that pop in the way of adventure or campaign creation whether the DM wishes to profit from them or not. An Obtrusive element might be really cool, but compensates by being really difficult to ignore (short of Rule 0) if you don't plan to make use of it in your game. Darkon's memory drain is one example of an Obtrusive element. The ring of choking fog around the Village of Barovia is another: if the PCs are to go there, dealing with the fog *will* become a major issue, whether its useful for the adventure or not.
Now, I present the list of elements of Ravenloft that I would be tempted to tinker with if offered the occasion.
Augment the map scale size
This is an easy one to start with. Many Ravenloft fans during both editions of the game have admitted adjusting the size of the Core in their games to increase travel times and make the domains feel like small countries, instead of small plots of land. I'll go as far as say that the Core's small size has led to a few continuity contradictions in the past. The official 2nd edition adventure "Death Ascendant" has a big part of the action happening on the PCs' trip from Stangengrad to Nartok - but because traveling this distance takes such a ridiculously short amount of time according to official scale, the author had to "fake it", by making it five times longer. Likewise, even the Gazetteers prove guilty of inflating the travel distances from time to time, the biggest example I remember being in the Mordent chapter: "Head on past the old Whitby estate and then turn south for two days" (Gaz III p. 36).
While you could simply blame the authors for not knowing the setting well enough, I can't help but agree that greater distances do a better job at making the campaign world more, well, "worldly". When the word "campaign setting" is used, most players expect at least the size of a small continent. Likewise, making towns so close leaves little to no place for the wilderness: place to hide for all sorts of beasties you want the PCs to fight, place to get lost in in the middle of a storm, so they seek shelter in that harmless-looking old house on the hill. Now, granted, 3E already addresses the issue by doing away with the scale, and its a good move. Myself, I'd just drop all pretense and officially make Ravenloft a big place, and I don't think this would harm any existing setting fans (feel free to contradict me on this if I'm wrong).
Make non-human races more Attractive
Playing a non-human race is a less Attractive choice in Ravenloft than in other worlds. Outcast Ratings aside, the main reason for this is the lack of coverage and options. Consider: when you choose to make a human PC, the setting gives you tons of background concepts. Are you an Abber nomad hunter, a Dementlieuse noble or a Raji priest? If you want to play a dwarf… you’re probably a darkonian, meaning you share your unique flavor and culture with your human, elvish and gnomish neighbors. A creative player can easily make a memorable dwarf PC background, but that supposes he’s dead set on playing a dwarf in the first place. If you’re not sure which race to choose… probably human. And that’s not good, from my point of view. Why? A simple observation from playing a variety of great games: if you’re giving a player a choice, make different options roughly equally interesting. If, in a game, one important option (play a human, say) is clearly more Attractive than all rival choices (play any other race), the choice becomes less fun to make, no matter which option you pick in the end.
To be Attractive, non-human races of Ravenloft should have a unique, powerful appeal. To help this, I would propose to make non-human races more prominent in the greater scheme of things. Give them unique cultures, put them in the spotlight. Have, for example, an elvish embassy be prominent in one of the setting’s major cities. Give the setting a few elvish, dwarven and gnomish darklords. Make up domains where they can feel at home. Would it make the setting less Ravenloft-like? I heard very little complaints regarding Sithicus’ presence in the Core. How bad would it be to give dwarves and gnomes their own “Sithicus’es”? All these things would contribute to make the choice to play a non-human more Attractive, which makes the setting (and thus the game) more diverse and exciting.
Make the setting more Player-friendly
From the very beginning, Ravenloft has been something of a DM's toy. A review of my Ravenloft product collection reveals a total of forty books, only three of which can be read by players. The darklords' identities, the new monster rules, the secret societies, the domain lore, and so on, have to be carefully hidden from your players, lest you spoil all the setting's surprises. What makes this situation difficult, in my opinion, is that a great part of the "top secret" stuff is usually also very Obtrusive stuff, meaning its very difficult to separate from the stuff players *are* allowed to know. You can't really describe most domains in great detail to players, because the darklord's nature becomes too obvious. Markovia? Its that place where people go and are kinda never seen again and nobody knows why. And not many people ever returned from Forlorn, so I can't tell you what's there either. And Keening's kinda mysterious like that too. And Isle of Demise. And the Isle of Agony. And the Wildlands. And Todstein. And that L'Ile de la Tempete place. And Avonleigh. And Bluetspur. Does the pattern become tired? The reason I find this problematic is that it makes it kinda difficult for the players themselves to become immersed in the setting's lore. Since most of the most interesting, most juicy bits are constantly hidden from the players, they have less incentive to become fans of the setting themselves. I'm pretty certain that most of the setting's fans today come from the DM crowd.
The best way to avoid this pitfall is to make the "DM-only" material of the setting less Obtrusive than it is now. Remodel some domains so that they make for interesting play even when the players know most of its secrets. Make the domains bigger, more diverse, and less darklord-centric. By keeping the darklords, but removing them from the centre of things, you actually make it less dramatic if the players happen to know the darklord's true nature and history (which, most of the time, is really enjoyable stuff to read). So what if the players know that Renier chick is a wererat queen with a torn past? If they never meet her, that'll never matter. If they DO meet her, the knowledge of her origins makes it easier for the players to enjoy their interaction with that character. I don't say the setting should have absolutely no surprises for the players, but MOST game material should be as enjoyable for players as for the guy behind the screen. Once they get interested in Ravenloft's inner wheels, the players might become more invested in the setting, which would then have a better chance of flourishing.
Encourage Rich domains, avoid theme redundancy
In general, I believe that Richer domains are more valuable to the setting than the Clunkier ones. The latter can be loads of fun for an adventure or two, but don't offer a lot of long-term play. Rich domains, on the other hand, can be used over and over again without ever depleting their play value. Mordent is a Rich domain: you can play countless adventures within it, featuring ghost haunts, murder mysteries, werewolf attacks, ancestral curses, meddling fey and lots of other stuff. Doing the same in a domain like Saragoss proves more difficult, because the domain eventually stops being "fresh" and the players wish to move on to something new. As things are now, most non-Core domains seem to have been designed with the "short visit" mentality. 2nd edition accessories like Darklords and Islands of Terror (the primary sources of new domains back in the day), felt as if, in many cases, the author first got a cool idea for a darklord, then built a domain around it (think I'Cath). While this is not necessarily bad design, I feel a little more fore-thought as to what role that domain might play in the bigger portrait of the setting could be useful to make the world into a more cohesive place, suitable for long-term campaigns.
So, if I had to supervise a complete overhaul of the setting, my motto would be: "Make domains bigger, make domains Richer". I would also be careful with Theme Redundancy. Here's an example of Theme Redundancy in existing domains. Take Dementlieu and Richemulot. Both are based off of French culture. Both are very advanced and human-centric. Both are remarkably appropriate for urban adventures. Both feature vast quantities of political intrigue and class conflict. The main difference is actually a rather subtle variation in tone: Dementlieu is supposed to represent the light-hearted theme of an advanced urban society, while Richemulot represents are darker one, what with cutthroat blackmail intrigues and creepy things in the sewers. So, acknowledging the importance of these themes, but also seeking to make domains Richer and more unique identity-wise, I'm tempted to combine both realms in one: a big domain of urban intrigue featuring both the light and dark sides of the same coin. The domain could be vast, with a big Paris-like capital in the middle surrounded by surrogate urban centers, each with its own personal flavor and free Sherlock Holmes hats distributed at the gates.
Likewise, I see a strong similitude of theme in the domains of Vechor and the Nightmare Lands: both are chaotic places with a scary, ever-changing landscape. Unite them in one domain, call it "The Really Weird Place" and make it a gigantic Island of Terror. The "strangeness" of that land would increase the further one moves into it, so the land's borders could have more-or-less normal settlements, but further inside, only the Abber nomads dare dwell, and even they stay clear of the domain's deeper reaches. The place could have spots for mad wizards like Easan, and a spot for the City of Nod and the Nightmare Court. The deepest recesses of the land would stay undefined, so the DM is free to make it as creepy-crazy as needed for his game.
------
There, that's pretty much all for me. How about the rest of you? If you have ideas of what you'd do differently if you had to re-design Ravenloft from ground up, please share them so we have fun comparing. Its all imaginary. Get crazy.
- NeoTiamat
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4119
- Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 5:00 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Boston, Massachusetts, USA
You have thought a GREAT deal on this, haven't you?
I would agree with most agree with most of the things you state (Though I doubt I could do it anywhere near as eloquently). I would make two more Addendums.
Time Scale: One of the larger stumbling blocks when creating an adventure in Ravenloft with a long history (such as virtually any adventure involving Ancient Dead, or perhaps ancient curses), is that the entire setting is perhaps 400 years old, and few Domains older then a century and a half. SOme are as young as seventy years or less. Verbrek is 30 years old. How, pray tell, do you do an ancient curse in Verbrek? Hazlan and Dementlieu are barely older.
Now I suspect that most people handle this by ignoring it, which is fine. But expanding the setting's time line by a few centuries or so would make placing all kinds of long-lived undead easier. (If the setting is only 400 years or so old, how do you have Vampires of Eminent or Patriarch statues?). Not a big change, and one many people would not notice at all, but it would remove one of my pet peeves about the setting. You can still have the Darklords be more or less recent, but having long chains of history would be interesting. Falkovnia would gain a fair bit if you saw Drakov's rise to power as gaining power from an ancient line of kings and turning it into a Fascist state.
A Dynamic Political Situation. One of the other irritating things about Ravenloft is that the political situation is stable almost by definition. Between the fact that Darklords are locked to their domains, and that most Darklords can close their domain borders at will, inter-domain politics are largely moot. Drakov's Dead Mans' Campaigns are not unusual. That is what'd happen virtually any time someone tries to invade a Domain, with a few exceptions.
The Barovian occupation of Gundarak is probably one of the high points of the setting. It spawns numerous character backgrounds, and is in general very well done. More of that sort of thing should be encouraged. I for one like the idea of having say, Mallochio try and invade and occupy Verbrek, and have soldiers try and take over the domain, while Werewolves prove just how futile that is. OR perhaps unify the political machinations of Borca, Richumelot, and Dementlieu, and have plots for power stretch from land to land.
As to how to do this? Well, to begin with, I would remove entirely, or limit the strength of Closed Domain Borders. Perhaps make it that another Darklord can forcibly open the Domain? Or just make the few classic examples of closed domains salient abilities of the Darklords (such as Barovia's Fog could be a spell of Strahds, and Azalin could still have vast undead armies on the borders).
As for the Darklords being limited to their domain, I would make this a more fluid stricture, based on their political power and presence. Under this reasoning, Drakov could in fact be in Karina, could he but get there (He makes a good example, for some reason). Or if Hazlik bought an estate on the Barovian side of their mutual border, he could visit.
In this line of reasoning, Domains become seperated from political borders. It also allows for Domains to overlap, as in Karina where Falkovnian and Invidian domains would overlap. One of the more interesting things would be to have the Darklords have more interaction with one another.
Well, these are my ideas of the moment.
I would agree with most agree with most of the things you state (Though I doubt I could do it anywhere near as eloquently). I would make two more Addendums.
Time Scale: One of the larger stumbling blocks when creating an adventure in Ravenloft with a long history (such as virtually any adventure involving Ancient Dead, or perhaps ancient curses), is that the entire setting is perhaps 400 years old, and few Domains older then a century and a half. SOme are as young as seventy years or less. Verbrek is 30 years old. How, pray tell, do you do an ancient curse in Verbrek? Hazlan and Dementlieu are barely older.
Now I suspect that most people handle this by ignoring it, which is fine. But expanding the setting's time line by a few centuries or so would make placing all kinds of long-lived undead easier. (If the setting is only 400 years or so old, how do you have Vampires of Eminent or Patriarch statues?). Not a big change, and one many people would not notice at all, but it would remove one of my pet peeves about the setting. You can still have the Darklords be more or less recent, but having long chains of history would be interesting. Falkovnia would gain a fair bit if you saw Drakov's rise to power as gaining power from an ancient line of kings and turning it into a Fascist state.
A Dynamic Political Situation. One of the other irritating things about Ravenloft is that the political situation is stable almost by definition. Between the fact that Darklords are locked to their domains, and that most Darklords can close their domain borders at will, inter-domain politics are largely moot. Drakov's Dead Mans' Campaigns are not unusual. That is what'd happen virtually any time someone tries to invade a Domain, with a few exceptions.
The Barovian occupation of Gundarak is probably one of the high points of the setting. It spawns numerous character backgrounds, and is in general very well done. More of that sort of thing should be encouraged. I for one like the idea of having say, Mallochio try and invade and occupy Verbrek, and have soldiers try and take over the domain, while Werewolves prove just how futile that is. OR perhaps unify the political machinations of Borca, Richumelot, and Dementlieu, and have plots for power stretch from land to land.
As to how to do this? Well, to begin with, I would remove entirely, or limit the strength of Closed Domain Borders. Perhaps make it that another Darklord can forcibly open the Domain? Or just make the few classic examples of closed domains salient abilities of the Darklords (such as Barovia's Fog could be a spell of Strahds, and Azalin could still have vast undead armies on the borders).
As for the Darklords being limited to their domain, I would make this a more fluid stricture, based on their political power and presence. Under this reasoning, Drakov could in fact be in Karina, could he but get there (He makes a good example, for some reason). Or if Hazlik bought an estate on the Barovian side of their mutual border, he could visit.
In this line of reasoning, Domains become seperated from political borders. It also allows for Domains to overlap, as in Karina where Falkovnian and Invidian domains would overlap. One of the more interesting things would be to have the Darklords have more interaction with one another.
Well, these are my ideas of the moment.
Ravenloft GM: Eye of Anubis, Shattered City, and Prof. Lupescu's Traveling Ghost Show
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
- Drinnik Shoehorn
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1847
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 6:28 pm
- Location: Tiptree, Home of Jam
I think the Gaz's make it clear that the Core is not politically stable. Invidia is in the midst of a civil war and the Treaty of Five Towers is crumbling around the edges.
"Blood once flowed, a choice was made
Travel by night the smallest one bade" The Ballad of the Taverners.
The Galen Saga: 2000-2005
Travel by night the smallest one bade" The Ballad of the Taverners.
The Galen Saga: 2000-2005
- Jasper
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 562
- Joined: Thu Dec 18, 2003 7:10 pm
- Location: A cultural wasteland known as WV.
Things I would change:
First I would add a sort of anti-power check to the setting. As it is now other then the right to say your untainted there is no good reason rules wise to stay good. Speaking from the experiance of a DM with VERY muchkin prone players the terror tracks are like candy to them. I know players who would knife a serving wench in alley for giving them stale ale just for the chance they would get some 'Kick arse powers!" Now if they made doing good just as inviting it would help to counter this.
Secondly I would make it so the darklords had to work for thier possition.The transfer of power in Verbek was a perfect example of this. If you are constantly evil like Vlad or Azalin your power will never be checked but if you havn't done anything realy evil since you gained power you should be replaced. As much as I like Strahd, Dr M and the three hags what have they done in the past decade that makes them stand out as evil?
Lasty in realtion with my second point I would completely get rid of any darklord that only seems to be there to fill a nitch. Malken took the idea of a Jekel/Hyde and gave it a working gothic background. The three hags on the other hand seem to be the result of someone making up an excuse to have a hag darklord. Same with Keenings banshee, Halan's evil wizard, Vechor madman and Ghastria's dorian grey knockoff. Unless some author can remake these darklords with more character and feeling Id rather they just disappear into the mists.
First I would add a sort of anti-power check to the setting. As it is now other then the right to say your untainted there is no good reason rules wise to stay good. Speaking from the experiance of a DM with VERY muchkin prone players the terror tracks are like candy to them. I know players who would knife a serving wench in alley for giving them stale ale just for the chance they would get some 'Kick arse powers!" Now if they made doing good just as inviting it would help to counter this.
Secondly I would make it so the darklords had to work for thier possition.The transfer of power in Verbek was a perfect example of this. If you are constantly evil like Vlad or Azalin your power will never be checked but if you havn't done anything realy evil since you gained power you should be replaced. As much as I like Strahd, Dr M and the three hags what have they done in the past decade that makes them stand out as evil?
Lasty in realtion with my second point I would completely get rid of any darklord that only seems to be there to fill a nitch. Malken took the idea of a Jekel/Hyde and gave it a working gothic background. The three hags on the other hand seem to be the result of someone making up an excuse to have a hag darklord. Same with Keenings banshee, Halan's evil wizard, Vechor madman and Ghastria's dorian grey knockoff. Unless some author can remake these darklords with more character and feeling Id rather they just disappear into the mists.
"Love never dies a natural death. It dies because we don't know how to replenish it's source. It dies of blindness and errors and betrayals. It dies of illness and wounds; it dies of weariness, of witherings, of tarnishings."
Anais Nin
Anais Nin
-
Jonathan Winters
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 435
- Joined: Mon Jul 05, 2004 8:23 pm
- Location: Montreal, Quebec
- Jakob
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 472
- Joined: Thu Aug 05, 2004 3:43 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: Near Milano, Italy.
- Contact:
Then their powers would simply be lame: you NEVER get what you want, from the Dark Powers!I know players who would knife a serving wench in alley for giving them stale ale just for the chance they would get some 'Kick arse powers!"
I coloni rovinavano la foresta costruendo il capolavoro dell'uomo civilizzato: il deserto.
- Luis Sepúlveda
- Luis Sepúlveda
As for politics in current Ravenloft: yes, Gazetteers hint at coming inter-domain war, but never say HOW it is to be done.
So, if you want to create a New World of Ravenloft, or Ravenloft post-Time of Ultimate Darkness, I have a few suggestions:
1. Time, Distance, and secrets: My solution is simple. Never say outright what the distances between towns are, how many people dwell in town etc. That is more realistic, in any case - when you go to some town, do you SEE how many people live there? You can see that a town is small, or big, that it is surrounded by wall with wilderness outside, or has widespread suburbs etc. Descriptive sizes, as in DMG - thorp, hamlet to metropolis are okay, but there is no need to use numbers with them. Large City can have 20 thousand dwellers, but also 5 thousands or 100 thousands - there is no need to specify it. Don't say how many soldiers is in the army - it is a secret, anyway.
Similarly with the history - as few dates as possible, and no distinguishing between false and true history. You can say what people say - who needs more?
As for secrets: do it as the Dying Earth RPG does. They don't have GM books. Instead, every monster has three different descriptions and statblocks - and stats are often relative to average attributes of PCs. Similarly with secrets - books gives popular superstitions and contradictory divagations of scholars. GM decides which one, if any, is true.
2. Domains - as for me, Darklords should be still bound to their domains, BUT domain borders shouldn't be stable. Darklords could and should battle to move domain borders. That way, they are still in prison, but can enlarge their cells - at the expanse of their neighbours. The way to do it would be two - by armed conquest, and by persuading people.
You don't need to persuade people to want to be part of your domain. If people are believing in religion popular in your domain, using your language, possess your Cultural level, follow your traditions, the border will change accordingly.
And the other way round - Darklords set the Cultural level and Magic level of their domain (at least in the center, near the borders there can be influence from the neighbouring domain), prevalent traditions and modes of behaviour of people, etc. - even weather, to an extent.
3. There should be no closing domain borders. Darklords certainly could make it DIFFICULT to enter or leave their domain - by changing weather, misdirecting travellers etc.
4. Darklords have usually a lair, or castle, or other centre of power - usually a Sinkhole of Evil. I would call it Demesne (or similar). As we have enlarged domains, this place could use some of the former domain abilities. Specifically, Darklord could close the borders of his demesne - but only if he is inside. To leave it, he has to open the borders.
That way, you can have politics, war, trade, etc. But, you can also close adventurers in with a Darklords in his castle, or inside the village of Barovia.
5. Many of the published adventures are about killing darkords. On the other hand, according to the official "history" most of the darklords were not killed. So - are the darklors to be killed, or not?
My suggestion - I would create a lesser class of villains, in contrast to Lords they could be called Vassals. They should be bound to domain, similarly to the Lord, should possess Demesnes, and certain powers over the nearby land (although subject to Lords.) They could close their Demesnes - although in this case it is possible, although difficult, to escape despite closure, and Darklord can forced their Demesne open. They should be similar in some respect to the Darklord - mostly vampires in Barovia, wizards or undead in Darkon.
In that way you can have difficult enemies to kill without great political upheaval.
6. With several Vassals in the domain, you don't have to decide who is the darklord. In most famous domains, like Barovia, it is obvious, but in others you can present several options for the GM.
If a Darlord of the Corre is slain, his domain never disappears. It is either taken over by a Vassal, or divided between neighbours.
7. It should be made clear that Darklords are immortal, and don't die of age until slain.
8. Dwarves and Elves - if there is to be a greater prominence of demihumans, they should return to their folkloric roots. There is no need for elves and dwarves in cities, where they differ from humans only with their ears or height. Dwarves should live underground, either in mines or in mountains, and elves in their own faery realms, either hidden in forest, in invisible castles, or in the strange magical "planes" accessible by sidhe mounds, or as magical isles hidden in the sea. A good source for this are Norse legends and book of Poul Anderson - "Broken Sword" and "Three Hearts and Three Lions".
So, if you want to create a New World of Ravenloft, or Ravenloft post-Time of Ultimate Darkness, I have a few suggestions:
1. Time, Distance, and secrets: My solution is simple. Never say outright what the distances between towns are, how many people dwell in town etc. That is more realistic, in any case - when you go to some town, do you SEE how many people live there? You can see that a town is small, or big, that it is surrounded by wall with wilderness outside, or has widespread suburbs etc. Descriptive sizes, as in DMG - thorp, hamlet to metropolis are okay, but there is no need to use numbers with them. Large City can have 20 thousand dwellers, but also 5 thousands or 100 thousands - there is no need to specify it. Don't say how many soldiers is in the army - it is a secret, anyway.
Similarly with the history - as few dates as possible, and no distinguishing between false and true history. You can say what people say - who needs more?
As for secrets: do it as the Dying Earth RPG does. They don't have GM books. Instead, every monster has three different descriptions and statblocks - and stats are often relative to average attributes of PCs. Similarly with secrets - books gives popular superstitions and contradictory divagations of scholars. GM decides which one, if any, is true.
2. Domains - as for me, Darklords should be still bound to their domains, BUT domain borders shouldn't be stable. Darklords could and should battle to move domain borders. That way, they are still in prison, but can enlarge their cells - at the expanse of their neighbours. The way to do it would be two - by armed conquest, and by persuading people.
You don't need to persuade people to want to be part of your domain. If people are believing in religion popular in your domain, using your language, possess your Cultural level, follow your traditions, the border will change accordingly.
And the other way round - Darklords set the Cultural level and Magic level of their domain (at least in the center, near the borders there can be influence from the neighbouring domain), prevalent traditions and modes of behaviour of people, etc. - even weather, to an extent.
3. There should be no closing domain borders. Darklords certainly could make it DIFFICULT to enter or leave their domain - by changing weather, misdirecting travellers etc.
4. Darklords have usually a lair, or castle, or other centre of power - usually a Sinkhole of Evil. I would call it Demesne (or similar). As we have enlarged domains, this place could use some of the former domain abilities. Specifically, Darklord could close the borders of his demesne - but only if he is inside. To leave it, he has to open the borders.
That way, you can have politics, war, trade, etc. But, you can also close adventurers in with a Darklords in his castle, or inside the village of Barovia.
5. Many of the published adventures are about killing darkords. On the other hand, according to the official "history" most of the darklords were not killed. So - are the darklors to be killed, or not?
My suggestion - I would create a lesser class of villains, in contrast to Lords they could be called Vassals. They should be bound to domain, similarly to the Lord, should possess Demesnes, and certain powers over the nearby land (although subject to Lords.) They could close their Demesnes - although in this case it is possible, although difficult, to escape despite closure, and Darklord can forced their Demesne open. They should be similar in some respect to the Darklord - mostly vampires in Barovia, wizards or undead in Darkon.
In that way you can have difficult enemies to kill without great political upheaval.
6. With several Vassals in the domain, you don't have to decide who is the darklord. In most famous domains, like Barovia, it is obvious, but in others you can present several options for the GM.
If a Darlord of the Corre is slain, his domain never disappears. It is either taken over by a Vassal, or divided between neighbours.
7. It should be made clear that Darklords are immortal, and don't die of age until slain.
8. Dwarves and Elves - if there is to be a greater prominence of demihumans, they should return to their folkloric roots. There is no need for elves and dwarves in cities, where they differ from humans only with their ears or height. Dwarves should live underground, either in mines or in mountains, and elves in their own faery realms, either hidden in forest, in invisible castles, or in the strange magical "planes" accessible by sidhe mounds, or as magical isles hidden in the sea. A good source for this are Norse legends and book of Poul Anderson - "Broken Sword" and "Three Hearts and Three Lions".
"Dies nostri quasi umbra super terram et nulla est mora."
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
I have to say there's not a lot I would change. Most of what I'd have done was already done in the Red Box (removing the "Clunky" and "Obstrusive" domains from Core) and the Gaz series (fleshing out the Darklords and Domains, even the ones I never cared about, into wonderful detail).
I would agree that the setting could use some larger scale and longer history. But longer history would require either changing all the canon dates that exist and pushing them further back, or leaping the setting ahead to Ravenloft: The Next Generation. And while the latter might be a tempting excercise, with proven precedent for success, it would fracture the setting into two disctinct ones. And the rich roster of NPCs, which I agree is the setting's greatest strength, would be wasted for the most part. Only the darklords and others cursed/blessed with immortality would survive, and we'd lose all or most of the "good guys". I for one, am not too interested in Bob Weathermay-Foxgrove-Mournesworth-Mousel, great-great-great-grandson of one of the Twins.
I do like these demesne and vassal ideas of Baduin9. But I don't think that Border Closure is the be-all and end all of War in the core. Drakov needs to work smarter, not harder. Admitedly, not his strong suit, but if his allies do the thinking for him...
Consider the possibility that The Brain decides that a Falkovnian occupation is just the thing to sweep away Dominic's power base, so that he can start anew. Through proxies, he makes contact with Falkovnia and begins passing useful information their way. In the meantime, he can work on some sort of psionic research into a power or item that can temporarily incapacitate Dominic or render him unable to close the borders for just long enough for the army to get in. (Really all that might be needed is a good diversionary tactic. If the Brain can sneak some loyal "assassins" into Dominic's house, he could be kept on the run long enough to not notice what's happening.) Once inside, he uses his powers to make them all his own minions, and therefore immune to Dominic's powers. Now, of course, with a whole army that's loyal to him, and not Drakov, the Brain can overthrow Dominic, take over the domain, and then betray Drakov, ejecting the soldiers. Drakov's curse is fulfilled, since he has no real victory, but maybe it's not immediate this time. Maybe the apparent occupation goes on for years, or decades. And maybe due to the change in darklordship, the Dark Powers step in and redefine the borders like they did in Gundarak, giving Drakov some small token victory to keep him hungry for more. Chateaufaux, maybe, or some small village previously unnamed.
Similar concepts could be proposed for the other domains of the Four Towers. Richemulot has Louise Renier, who could jump sides. In Borca, Ivana could finally get fed up with Ivan, and "cede" the former Dorvinia by simply choosing not to close the borders. Or Drakov might finally be pursuaded to make use of his Ministry of the Arcane and pump out some golems that would be immune to Borca's posion. And that's not even touching the possibility of Drakov's main ally, Mallocchio, finding a way to break his own curse...
EDIT: One more thing. I think the predominance of humans is something I would like to keep, if not expand. I don't begrudge Ravenloft its D&D heritage, but I like having a mostly-human setting. It's a refreshing alternative to the half-dragon-drow and goblin wererat type stuff that populates other worlds. I myself play a goblin wererat in another campaign, and I realize that elves and dwarves are much more tame than crazy 5 template and Savage progression stuff, but I think Ravenloft makes humans just as interesting as the non-human races, if not moreso.
I would agree that the setting could use some larger scale and longer history. But longer history would require either changing all the canon dates that exist and pushing them further back, or leaping the setting ahead to Ravenloft: The Next Generation. And while the latter might be a tempting excercise, with proven precedent for success, it would fracture the setting into two disctinct ones. And the rich roster of NPCs, which I agree is the setting's greatest strength, would be wasted for the most part. Only the darklords and others cursed/blessed with immortality would survive, and we'd lose all or most of the "good guys". I for one, am not too interested in Bob Weathermay-Foxgrove-Mournesworth-Mousel, great-great-great-grandson of one of the Twins.
I do like these demesne and vassal ideas of Baduin9. But I don't think that Border Closure is the be-all and end all of War in the core. Drakov needs to work smarter, not harder. Admitedly, not his strong suit, but if his allies do the thinking for him...
Consider the possibility that The Brain decides that a Falkovnian occupation is just the thing to sweep away Dominic's power base, so that he can start anew. Through proxies, he makes contact with Falkovnia and begins passing useful information their way. In the meantime, he can work on some sort of psionic research into a power or item that can temporarily incapacitate Dominic or render him unable to close the borders for just long enough for the army to get in. (Really all that might be needed is a good diversionary tactic. If the Brain can sneak some loyal "assassins" into Dominic's house, he could be kept on the run long enough to not notice what's happening.) Once inside, he uses his powers to make them all his own minions, and therefore immune to Dominic's powers. Now, of course, with a whole army that's loyal to him, and not Drakov, the Brain can overthrow Dominic, take over the domain, and then betray Drakov, ejecting the soldiers. Drakov's curse is fulfilled, since he has no real victory, but maybe it's not immediate this time. Maybe the apparent occupation goes on for years, or decades. And maybe due to the change in darklordship, the Dark Powers step in and redefine the borders like they did in Gundarak, giving Drakov some small token victory to keep him hungry for more. Chateaufaux, maybe, or some small village previously unnamed.
Similar concepts could be proposed for the other domains of the Four Towers. Richemulot has Louise Renier, who could jump sides. In Borca, Ivana could finally get fed up with Ivan, and "cede" the former Dorvinia by simply choosing not to close the borders. Or Drakov might finally be pursuaded to make use of his Ministry of the Arcane and pump out some golems that would be immune to Borca's posion. And that's not even touching the possibility of Drakov's main ally, Mallocchio, finding a way to break his own curse...
EDIT: One more thing. I think the predominance of humans is something I would like to keep, if not expand. I don't begrudge Ravenloft its D&D heritage, but I like having a mostly-human setting. It's a refreshing alternative to the half-dragon-drow and goblin wererat type stuff that populates other worlds. I myself play a goblin wererat in another campaign, and I realize that elves and dwarves are much more tame than crazy 5 template and Savage progression stuff, but I think Ravenloft makes humans just as interesting as the non-human races, if not moreso.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- NeoTiamat
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4119
- Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 5:00 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Boston, Massachusetts, USA
When I talked about history, I only meant pushing it back, not moving ahead. Under no circumstances would I want to lose all of the excellent characters in the setting. Just do a bit of relatively light retcon, and perhaps flesh out history somemore where necesary.
Ravenloft GM: Eye of Anubis, Shattered City, and Prof. Lupescu's Traveling Ghost Show
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Okay, I'm working late in my cubicle at WotC when three men in suits approach me. They pull into an office and they sit me down at a table. "Jester,” they say, “we want you to do the RAVENLOFT Campaign Setting for this new Forth edition we have coming up.”
“But,” I protest, “it’s only 2006 and 3.5 was less than three years ago.”
“Quiet you.” They snap. “This is a dream-sequence, it’s really happening in the future. What do you have planned for us?”
Alright, it’s 773 on the Barovian calendar, over eleven years since the last published information on the setting. The Time of Unparalleled Darkness is a mere two years away and the world has changed.
There western coast is embroiled in a war started by Falkovnia and Invidia. Borca has been crushed and is occupied by Falkovnian troops. However, captured prisoners brought before the lord of Falkovnia managed to poison the King-Fuhrer. The land is currently on the brink of a civil war while the various generals fight over the crown with nobles and the few sons of Drakov.
Richemulot and Dementlieu have been flooded with Borcan nobles and refugees. In a recent move, Dementlieu absorbed Richemulot and Mordent into its borders forming a single, strong political entity. They have begun to purchase armaments from Lamordia while Falkovnia is in turmoil and slowly build defences on the border.
Over on the East, Nova Vassa is thriving through the sea trade but the cities once again fear the criminal mastermind, Malken, who has once again reasserted his claim as head of the underworld. Several rogues have recently turned up dead after seizing power when rumours suggested Malken had died.
* * *
What have I changed? Darklords no longer have immutable borders. They control and influence the area around them, much like reality wrinkles, and can seal off their lairs, but can no longer control the entire borders of their land. However, they are no longer imprisoned in a small area and can wander as long as they don’t attempt to enter someone else’s lair or sphere. When they’re in their lair their power increases dramatically, it is their seat of power.
So there’ll be countries (Lamordia, Dementlieu, Falkovnia, etc) and city-states (much of Invidia will be collections of city-states and the rest lumped into the “Misted Wood” that dominates the West. There can also be lesser lords whose influence doesn’t spread beyond a single manor or village.
Mortal lords will be replaced. Sticking with old lords and having them be unnaturally old simply seems silly. As their borders and powers shift, some find themselves quickly succumbing to old age and weakened. Others, like Ivana, might delve into dark rituals and magic to preserve their magical youth (bathing in blood, drawing strength and youth from victims).
So new darklords in Dementlieu (carving that land between Dominic’s heir and the Brain) and Nova Vassa (female ‘Tristen’ but still a male Malken?!).
“But,” I protest, “it’s only 2006 and 3.5 was less than three years ago.”
“Quiet you.” They snap. “This is a dream-sequence, it’s really happening in the future. What do you have planned for us?”
Alright, it’s 773 on the Barovian calendar, over eleven years since the last published information on the setting. The Time of Unparalleled Darkness is a mere two years away and the world has changed.
There western coast is embroiled in a war started by Falkovnia and Invidia. Borca has been crushed and is occupied by Falkovnian troops. However, captured prisoners brought before the lord of Falkovnia managed to poison the King-Fuhrer. The land is currently on the brink of a civil war while the various generals fight over the crown with nobles and the few sons of Drakov.
Richemulot and Dementlieu have been flooded with Borcan nobles and refugees. In a recent move, Dementlieu absorbed Richemulot and Mordent into its borders forming a single, strong political entity. They have begun to purchase armaments from Lamordia while Falkovnia is in turmoil and slowly build defences on the border.
Over on the East, Nova Vassa is thriving through the sea trade but the cities once again fear the criminal mastermind, Malken, who has once again reasserted his claim as head of the underworld. Several rogues have recently turned up dead after seizing power when rumours suggested Malken had died.
* * *
What have I changed? Darklords no longer have immutable borders. They control and influence the area around them, much like reality wrinkles, and can seal off their lairs, but can no longer control the entire borders of their land. However, they are no longer imprisoned in a small area and can wander as long as they don’t attempt to enter someone else’s lair or sphere. When they’re in their lair their power increases dramatically, it is their seat of power.
So there’ll be countries (Lamordia, Dementlieu, Falkovnia, etc) and city-states (much of Invidia will be collections of city-states and the rest lumped into the “Misted Wood” that dominates the West. There can also be lesser lords whose influence doesn’t spread beyond a single manor or village.
Mortal lords will be replaced. Sticking with old lords and having them be unnaturally old simply seems silly. As their borders and powers shift, some find themselves quickly succumbing to old age and weakened. Others, like Ivana, might delve into dark rituals and magic to preserve their magical youth (bathing in blood, drawing strength and youth from victims).
So new darklords in Dementlieu (carving that land between Dominic’s heir and the Brain) and Nova Vassa (female ‘Tristen’ but still a male Malken?!).
- Igor the Henchman
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 832
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 6:50 pm
While I generally agree most changes brought upon by the GC were very sensible ones, some of the "domain cuts" never cease to amaze me. They decided Bluetspur didn't belong to the Core - because its nothing but a barren wasteland with no surface life whatsoever, full of hostile monsters and a Big Mountain of Evil as its main attraction. Keening, on the other hand, is a perfectly fitting Core domain, because its not at all similar to that. Likewise, the Nightmare Lands obviously had to go, because its a chaotic, ever-changing landscape ruled by an unfanthomal insane mind. But Vechor? Why, it fits right in! Like I said, the GC was a great move overall, but some aspects of it I can't stop poking fun at.gonzoron wrote:I have to say there's not a lot I would change. Most of what I'd have done was already done in the Red Box (removing the "Clunky" and "Obstrusive" domains from Core)
Don't forget that I never meant this thread to be a "Who'd like a Retcon?" debate. All of my suggested changes are nothing but harmless, imaginary fun with setting analysis. I don't at all mean to suggest there should be a Retcon, but rather to have a conversation on the setting's stronger and weaker points.gonzoron wrote:I would agree that the setting could use some larger scale and longer history. But longer history would require either changing all the canon dates that exist and pushing them further back, or leaping the setting ahead to Ravenloft: The Next Generation. And while the latter might be a tempting excercise, with proven precedent for success, it would fracture the setting into two disctinct ones. And the rich roster of NPCs, which I agree is the setting's greatest strength, would be wasted for the most part. Only the darklords and others cursed/blessed with immortality would survive, and we'd lose all or most of the "good guys". I for one, am not too interested in Bob Weathermay-Foxgrove-Mournesworth-Mousel, great-great-great-grandson of one of the Twins.
On the subject of dynamic politics and land usurpation: I think that, while Ravenloft does make them tricky, it doesn't make them impossible. Dominiani really did usurp control of Gundarak and held it up to the Grand Conjunction. The Gentleman Caller did arrange for Invidia to split between two military factions, each with its own set of allies. Spectre of the Black Rose features a desperate triple-coup of Sithicus by Mallochio, Azrael and Inza. If you think about it, conquering another domain poses only one significant problem: the darklord must be distracted or incapacitated. Whole units of Vlad Drakov's soldiers regularly slip through Borcan borders unnoticed - it wouldn't take much to assemble them into a small military unit to stage a swift but lethal attack on the state capital, especially if Ivan is distracted with some other business. By the way, Ivan did threaten Invidia with military retribution if Malocchio didn't stop his borcan incursions? Should Ivan ever choose to act on his threat, would Gabby close the borders to protect her son? Doubtful.
Oh, and NeoTiamat? I totally agree with the "history should be longer" point. Always bugged me too.
Last edited by Igor the Henchman on Mon Sep 25, 2006 11:26 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
Jonathan Winters
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 435
- Joined: Mon Jul 05, 2004 8:23 pm
- Location: Montreal, Quebec
- wolfgang_fener
- Agent of the Fraternity

- Posts: 93
- Joined: Mon Jul 10, 2006 10:32 am
- Location: Quebec/Canada
For sure, whatever the effect, the drawback would be that from then on, all beverage would taste stale, bland or plainly disgusting to them. Or they would get the effective charisma of 3 with all waitress and servive clercks, never getting decent service anywhere...Jakob wrote:Then their powers would simply be lame: you NEVER get what you want, from the Dark Powers!I know players who would knife a serving wench in alley for giving them stale ale just for the chance they would get some 'Kick arse powers!"
- Jasper
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 562
- Joined: Thu Dec 18, 2003 7:10 pm
- Location: A cultural wasteland known as WV.
The only problem I see with removing domain borders is that in some cases it ruins a darklords curse. For example if Harkon is able to just walk out of Kartakass and have his wolves take over lets say Halan it competly ruins Harkons curse of never ruling a civilised domain. And if you keep the curse saying that every domain he takes over fades into a uncivilised mess you will quickly ruin the feel of those domains.
I do however like the idea of a dynamic setting with slowly changing domains and darklords. Three domains have cannon instances of darklords being overthrown and replaced with a more worthy canidates (Invidia, Sithicus and Verbrek) and I think any next generation books should follow this trend to 'cut the fat' from the main core.
I do however like the idea of a dynamic setting with slowly changing domains and darklords. Three domains have cannon instances of darklords being overthrown and replaced with a more worthy canidates (Invidia, Sithicus and Verbrek) and I think any next generation books should follow this trend to 'cut the fat' from the main core.
"Love never dies a natural death. It dies because we don't know how to replenish it's source. It dies of blindness and errors and betrayals. It dies of illness and wounds; it dies of weariness, of witherings, of tarnishings."
Anais Nin
Anais Nin

