If YOU designed Ravenloft

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Jasper
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 562
Joined: Thu Dec 18, 2003 7:10 pm
Location: A cultural wasteland known as WV.

Post by Jasper »

wolfgang_fener wrote:
Jakob wrote: For sure, whatever the effect, the drawback would be that from then on, all beverage would taste stale, bland or plainly disgusting to them. Or they would get the effective charisma of 3 with all waitress and servive clercks, never getting decent service anywhere...
A good Ravenloft player would take that and run with it but some of the players I've had to deal with would just see the +2 to dex and go on ordering the 'Orc piss ale' like they normaly do anyway.
Even the charisma thing wouldn't faze them as they either normaly play battle scarred weapon freaks with negitive charisma or are allready use to paying for compainionship and sadly havn't grasped that No means No for there characters. And if I stoped doing the power checks they would just b**ch and moan untill I put it back in.

Now don't get me wrong, I've had some excelent players over the years but with the recent rush of junior munchkins being bred on Eberon and powergamer articles on Wizards.com they are rarer then platinum.
"Love never dies a natural death. It dies because we don't know how to replenish it's source. It dies of blindness and errors and betrayals. It dies of illness and wounds; it dies of weariness, of witherings, of tarnishings."
Anais Nin
User avatar
wolfgang_fener
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 93
Joined: Mon Jul 10, 2006 10:32 am
Location: Quebec/Canada

Post by wolfgang_fener »

Ho well, I guess I'm lucky with the players I have ;-).

I wish you will find at least one great role player. Sometimes good roleplaying is contagious. good luck.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Jasper wrote:The only problem I see with removing domain borders is that in some cases it ruins a darklords curse. For example if Harkon is able to just walk out of Kartakass and have his wolves take over lets say Hazlan it competly ruins Harkons curse of never ruling a civilised domain. And if you keep the curse saying that every domain he takes over fades into a uncivilised mess you will quickly ruin the feel of those domains.
Well, in the revised world he certinly could leave. Although he'd be much more vulnerable away from his seat of power (fewer wolves and ones not under his influence, death would be permanent). And I think the rulers of neighbouring lands would frown on his trying to take over.
Meanwhile, Harkon would/could travel to civilized domains and find that, to them, he's an uncivilized hick
Jasper wrote:A good Ravenloft player would take that and run with it but some of the players I've had to deal with would just see the +2 to dex and go on ordering the 'Orc piss ale' like they normaly do anyway.
Even the charisma thing wouldn't faze them as they either normaly play battle scarred weapon freaks with negitive charisma or are allready use to paying for compainionship and sadly havn't grasped that No means No for there characters. And if I stoped doing the power checks they would just b**ch and moan untill I put it back in.

Now don't get me wrong, I've had some excelent players over the years but with the recent rush of junior munchkins being bred on Eberon and powergamer articles on Wizards.com they are rarer then platinum.
There's nothing inherently bad about Eberron and there's nothing inferior about powergaming.
Garudos Celestar
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 279
Joined: Sat Jun 10, 2006 1:51 pm
Location: United States

Post by Garudos Celestar »

Igor the Henchman wrote:
Make non-human races more Attractive
I would actually go the completely opposite route on this and make playing demihumans far more restrictive. One of the problems with Darkon is that it ended up being designed as the "high fantasy" domain where all the stuff from other DnD campaign settings can be found - with the demihuman races being the most notable example. However, they don't mesh well with the setting, at least in pretty much any domain except Darkon, Sithicus, and perhaps Hazlan and Nova Vaasa. To put it quite bluntly, Jander Sunstar should be the only elf in Barovia; there shouldn't be large numbers of demihuman slaves in Falkovnia because there shouldn't be more than about half a dozen demihumans in the entire domain, etc.

I think the 3E crew had the right idea when they nixed the orcs and half-orcs in favor of the caliban. I'd say halflings would have been the next easiest race to pull (well, at least before the kender of Sithicus became halflings), and dwarves and gnomes wouldn't be too hard either. The caliban and half-Vistani represent examples of demihumans that truly mesh well with this setting, not just carry-overs that are only around so the PCs can play the same characters they had in the previous game.

At the very least, I would make playing demihumans very keyed to particular backgrounds - if you are an elf, you come from Sithicus... period. I think the best way to go about arranging this is in the structure of the game material - instead of listing every demihuman race in one chapter at the beginning of the book, have their information incorporated into the description of the domain. I this example, humans, calibans, and half-Vistani might appear in the character creation chapters at the beginning of the setting sourcebook, while stats and details on elves would appear in the Sithicus description.

I think the twist I prefer could be described as follows: instead of "I'm from Sithicus" being a way to describe your elf character, "I'm an elf" becomes a way to describe your Sithican character.
[i]"I too have begun to wonder about the legendary wisdom of our guardian angel and his pet rock."
~ Evee Beiderbecke[/i]
User avatar
Manofevil
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1729
Joined: Sat Dec 20, 2003 11:12 pm
Location: Why should I say? No one ever visits!

Post by Manofevil »

I just finished reading this thread and feel the need to point a few things out.
Firstly, Expanding the scale of the domains of Ravenloft is all well and good but remember this: CAMPING OUT OVERNIGHT IN RAVENLOFT IS AND ALWAYS HAS BEEN A FATAL PASSTIME! Travel in RavenLoft involves getting up at the crack of dawn (Largely because that's when they pry open the doors that they nailed shut the night before the keep the werebeasts and undead out), hitting the road and eating your meals on the fly all so you'll get to the next town (or roadside inn) before sunset when they nail the doors shut again, because if the party doesn't get to it's destination before sunset, they're locked out for the night in a land crawling with werebeasts, vampires, et al. No one opens their doors after sunset (twice) because anyone pounding on the door asking for help is likely to be an undead monster or some such. I don't remember where in the Black Box I read that, but I do remember reading it. So expanding to scale of the domain is fine but remember to stick some small towns and roadside inns along the main roads so there's someplace for travelers to go at sunset.
Secondly, Expanding the history re: the point about ancient dead:
My impression of the way RavenLoft gathered beings of this sort was put forward in the novel 'Knight of the Black Rose'. In this novel, Soth is collected by the mists, does what he usually does, and earns a domain. This was, I thought, one of the two ways the DPs operated in this regard. The other being the example of Anktepot who was collected along with his entire domain as a ready-made DarkLord. You're really not going to have ancient dead that predates Strahd in the RavenLoft Timeline even if they do predate Strahd in the timeline of the greater multiverse. Perhaps what's needed is for ancient dead to have small quasi-domains created for them and attached (very carefully) to existing domains like they'd always been there. I say carefully because you probably couldn't stick one in Barovia or Falkovnia because every square inch of those domains is known to some character someplace and a change as momentous as that would raise awkward questions. One could however be placed in Darkon or Har'Akir without disturbing the continuity too much.
Lastly, Demihumans races. I know these races can be done over in a gothic horror curse style because I've SEEN them done in the Dragonlance books. There, An elven king, Lorac Caladon, attempts to use a powerful artifact to drive the Dragon armies from his kingdom. In his arrogance he fails to realize how powerful the artifact is and is imprisoned by it. The artifact calls a dragon to whisper nightmares into the kings ears and then changes the surrounding landscape to reflect those nightmares. The trees all bleed red and twist into tortured shapes (think the tree in the movie 'Sleepy Hollow') and any living animals or people were twisted in similar ways. Black clouds moved in overhead casting the land into permanent darkness and the water all runs red from the bleeding trees. Of course, the buildings were all twisted and blackened as well. I suppose it would bear a resemblance to Necropolis but I always pictured Necropolis as a dried out old skull and the elven kingdom here reminded me more of an oozing infected wound.
There was a similar cursed landscape in DragonLance following something called the DwarfGate wars. Following the Cataclysm (See Lord Soth's background) The hill and mountain dwarves grew so desparate that they turned on one another and fought against one another in hopes of bettering their lots. By the final battle, the motives had boiled down to raw hatred for the other side and dwarf slew dwarf in a conflict that would divide the peoples for centuries to come. The war ended that day with a massive magical explosion set off by a nearby human mage that leveled the plains for miles around killing the armies of both sides. The magic caused a lot of bizarre occurances. The only one which sticks in my mind is something which resembles a very still lake at a distance but when approached is shown to be actually a massive piece of crystal at beneath which are some dozen dwarves frozen in mid-combat.
So you see demihumans, dwarves and elves at least, can and have been done in ways that would fit well into RavenLoft it's just that no one's bother to DO any of them yet. We should really think about changing that. My two cents and change.
Do us a favor Luv, Stick yer 'ead in a bucket a kick it!

So, gentlemen, that's how it is. Until Grissome.... resurfaces, I'm the acting president, and I say starting with this... anniversary festival, we run this city into the ground! :D
Post Reply