ETCR author chat log
ETCR author chat log
In case anyone missed it, WotC is holding a chat with the authors of EtCR tonight at 5 PM PDT.
Link to information: http://wizo.wizards.com/uncon/pages/events.php?e=211
Link to information: http://wizo.wizards.com/uncon/pages/events.php?e=211
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7107
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
It was so so informative, but here's a transcript of it (Thanks to Chris, who send me the whole thing - I arrived half an hour late to the event, and that is why I asked a question already asked by Chris. Oh well, that will put emphasis on the setting
)
<WizO_Unicorn> Evening, James!
<WizO_Unicorn> Evening, Bruce!
<WizO_Unicorn> Thank you for coming to the Expedition to Castle Ravenloft chat with Bruce Cordell and James Wyatt. Do you have any opening remarks for us before we get to questions?
<Bruce> I'm happy to see so many people interested in the module. It was fun working with James writing this thing, or as we like to say, reimagining it for 3.5
<James> Well, just thanks for being here, thanks for your interest in this adventure.
<zerotkatama> There's no concluding the adventure section, which I assume is due to book space. Do you have any advice as to what a Concluding the adventure should contain?
<James> The tricky thing is that there are so many variables in how the adventure plays out, that it's hard to tell you how to end it.
<Bruce> Well, the adventure is finally concluded when Strahd is definitively dealt with. There are many partial victories, but the true victory comes in defeating Strahd, I'd say.
<James> Our hope is that, after playing the adventure for weeks or months, you'll know better than we do where to go with it next!
<James> Particularly in light of the adventure hooks you used to start the adventure, what's happened along the way, and what you want to do next in your campaign.
<silentkiller> so what level we looking at starting
<Bruce> 5th or 6th is probably the lowest you'd want to go
<Bruce> But you can start higher if you want to move right to the castle
<James> The adventure says 6th to 10th on the cover, but there's more specific advice inside for starting at higher level if you're going to do less of the adventure.
<WizO_Shadow> I'm ecstatic Ravenloft is being updated to 3.5!! How many of the Ravenloft books/modules are you going to update for 3.5?
<James> At this point, Expedition to Castle Ravenloft is a standalone adventure / minicampaign. We have more Expedition adventures planned, but no more Ravenloft products announced at this time.
<Bruce> Being the iconic Ravenloft adventure, this is the only one we have plans to give such treatment to at present. How'd you like that for market-speak?
<JulesLetters> I heard that the 'original' Sunblade (Legacy Weapon) upon which all others were based is in Ravenloft. What's the inspiration for making an 'original' of a classic weapon? Does it play an integral part in any of the paths the adventure can take?
<Bruce> The inspiration is that the sunblade in Ravenloft actually IS the original from which later versions were copied. Or at least, so we believe.
<James> Speaking from the perspective of the history of D&D, the original Sunsword did appear in the module I6.
<ChrisNichols> What led to the change in Strahd's look from the classic Clyde Caldwell design to the long-haired elf design?
<James> By "long-haired elf," I assume you mean the picture on page 7, as opposed to the cover image?
<Bruce> I prefer the Strahd on the cover. The interior is one artist's interpretation (as is the new cover) of course.
<James> Artistic inspiration is all I can say.
<ChrisNichols> Right, I did mean the page 7 illo. It seems to be the one more heavily used in WotC's promotional art.
<gratzu> Whose idea was it to do the rewrite and what all did it take to pull it together?
<James> It's the one we're using to promote D&D game day, at least, yes.
<James> Boy, I don't know whose idea it was originally.
<James> It took several months of writing from both me and Bruce...
<Bruce> I think there is a general idea that every so often it is cool to do a sequel of an old classic. Not sure whose idea it was to make this the original but with new 'racing stripes' so to speak. as far as working on it...
<James> Followed by the usual process of editing, typesetting, art and cartography, etc., etc....
<Bruce> that was a lot of work in a short period of time--shorter than the time we were given, because James and I were new to the new format, which was evolving as we wrote it.
<James> Yes, boy howdy!
<Bruce> But in the end, I'm exceptionally happy with how the format turned out.
<WizO_Shadow> What sentimental attachment and/or what did you enjoy about doing this project the most? ( I think it was partially answered above)
<James> I have a long history with Ravenloft. My first published game material was for the Masque of the Red Death setting. So it was really exciting for me to get this chance to revisit where it all began.
<Bruce> My sentimental attachment were to the maps, which I used to pull out all the time of the original I6, looking at and imagining a fully 3D castle for the first time.
<Bruce> ok, not quite...
<James> There are a lot of things I'm really proud of: all of Chapter 3, the legacy items, and the fundamental structure of the adventure.
<Bruce> In the podcast I discussed how my DM killed me so cruelly with Strahd. I also very strongly remember the organ music my DM played when we as players first came into the castle. Very effective on our 14 year old brains. Thanks Monte.
<gstommylee> So you wanted to bring the great experience of Ravenloft since most of the newer players where like you said around when it originally came out to have the same fun as you guys orginally did.
<James> Right.
<Bruce> Yes, but we also wanted original I6 players to get excited about doing Ravenloft all over again!
<ChrisNichols> Why did you choose not to include any references to or materials from the larger Ravenloft campaign setting as developed in both 2nd edition (from TSR) and 3.0/3.5E (from S&S/Arthaus)? And was there anything from those that you would like to have added if you could?
<Bruce> The decision was to focus solely on I6,because it had more than enough information, obviously, to fill a 200+ page book with the new format and other information we included.
<James> The idea was to revisit, reimagine, whatever... the original, classic adventure. It's been 20some years since that adventure shook up the D&D universe, which is longer than much of our audience has been alive. (Gasp!) We wanted to pass that experience on to the next generation!
<James> So much of the focus of the later Ravenloft material was on lands beyond Barovia, I don't think there's a whole lot I would have looted. We were very tightly focused on Castle Ravenloft.
<James> I did look at the House of Strahd adventure and the various implementations of Strahd's stat block as we went along, though.
<Bruce> I know there was a lot of good stuff in the expanded Ravenloft setting, but it just wasn't our focus.
<gratzu> Were you worried about the older fans' reactions to your changes?
<James> I wasn't. Perhaps I should have been, but no. I think we stayed remarkably faithful to the original, while enriching it for a new play environment.
<Bruce> A little I guess, but I think we stayed so close to the original vision that I'm only proud of what we accomplished in showcasing all that was great about the original using 3.5 rules and writing styles.
<warghoul> What time are you guys coming over to run some Ravenloft for me?
but seriously, any good pointers for running a Ravenloft/horror type game?
<James> First, I highly recommend checking out the D&D Podcast. Dave Noonan and Mike Mearls led off their interview of us with a really interesting discussion of horror games.
<Bruce> James can pump Heroes of Horror
<James> To that, I'd add that the most important thing is that everyone agree to help build the atmosphere. It doesn't work as well if your players sit down expecting the usual game and you try to surprise them into a horror game.
<James> Make sure they know to expect creepiness, and get their buy-in so they'll play along and at least act scared... until they really are scared.
<Bruce> The best horror game I was involved with was one were I co-DMed. we split the players into two groups and only allowed them to talk via walki-talkies. They were supposedly in submarines exploring a sunken city.
<zerotkatama> Chiming in with the advice for horror mood setting, aside from organ music, is there any music in particular you use when running Ravenloft, or horror in general?
<Bruce> Many. one good one: Soundtrack to the Ninth Gate.
<James> Heh. I have a "horror gaming" playlist on my iPod. It covers a range... let's see...
<James> Cortege Macabre from Grohg, Shostakovich's 5th symphony, Lord of the Rings music, some Beethoven, some Eberron music from the Sharn CD, some Pirates of the Caribbean, some Mozart Requiem. I want more!
<ChrisNichols> Is the Dawnheart (artifact) intended as a replacement for or reinterpretation of the Heart of Midnight (a giant living heart that animated the highest tower of Castle Ravenloft) in House of Strahd (the 2nd edition remake of I6)?
<Bruce> The Dayheart is indeed what becomes of the living tower with its heart showing in the original I6
<LordDiggori> For Bruce, How did the DM kill you with Strahd so "cruelly"? Was it THE Monte Cook that DMed?
<Bruce> My wizard stepped where he shouldn't and suddenly I appeared lying down in a small place, wood pressed against my face.. A coffin! I look out through the eyes of my raven familiar and see a caped man sitting on a coffin. The man says something like, "It's curtains for you," and bites the head off the raven. Then I had to roll up a new character. yes, Monte Cook
<Gotten> Has the work that S&S did on the Ravenloft 3rd ed been used in revising the adventure, or was it ignored? Why?
<Bruce> As we noted earlier, we wanted to focus only on I6, so including anything that came after I6 would have messed up that vision.
<James> Well, as we said before, our focus for this book was almost entirely on Castle Ravenloft and the immediate surroundings--what's covered in the original I6. Yeah, what Bruce said.
<ChrisNichols> It's kind of a shame that the 3E Ravenloft material got ignored. Andrew Wyatt wrote a brilliant section on Barovia in Ravenloft Gazetteer Vol. 1.
<gratzu> So what elements did you decide to change? (Aside from the rules and descriptive text that is) Why did you decide to change those elements?
<Bruce> Describing Expedition to CR as 'ignoring' material later than I6 isn't really fair to what the product we wrote represents.
<James> I think each of us added a bit of our own nightmares to the basic framework of the original adventure.
<James> There were some particularly goofy examples of bad humor in the original that didn't survive the translation. (Others did.)
<Bruce> Someone's identified the Dayheart as something that got more than an update, but an actual transformation. However, many other things are updated--and the many many empty spaces of the original castle now contain additional threats and connections.
<James> But mostly I think I'd put our changes into the category of "creative embellishment"--we took a masterpiece and added our own flourishes.
<Iddig> If there are more adventures for Ravenloft, will they all be some supernatural baddie? Or will it sometimes be just a guy who's the antagonist? Part of horror for me, is the "Not knowing for sure what's going on".
<James> Well, at this time we have no more Ravenloft adventures announced, though there are more Expedition adventures (and plenty of other adventures) on the way.
<Bruce> Yeah, hard to say until a particular adventure is concepted who will be the main threat. In this case, Strahd is too much a part of the whole package not to highlight him at the outset.
<ChrisNichols> Why did you change the Vistani from human gypsies with strange powers to mix of comparatively normal humans and halflings? Why make Madame Eva an annis hag?
<James> Well, in I6 the Vistani were "gypsies" with no strange powers. Gypsy is a real-world term that's pretty emotionally loaded for a lot of people, so we tried to avoid it.
<Bruce> I have nothing to add to whatever James notes on this topic.
<James> In 3E, we've presented halflings as having what you might call a "gypsy" lifestyle, so that's why I included them among the Vistani. Plus, we wanted to make sure the adventure still felt like D&D (and not d20 Gothic), which is why there are elves in the woods as well.
<James> And Madame Eva is a hag because her "sisters" are... It's related to the same issue--making sure the adventure feels like a part of your D&D campaign world, with recognizable D&D monsters. Hags represent that witch/seer archetype in D&D, so we ran with them.
<James> So I guess that's a pretty significant set of "creative embellishments"...
<Gotten> Question on design: How do you feel the encounter new “one page” format has really enhanced this adventure? Do you see it as an improvement or not? I’m asking because I’m not sure it’s a good idea INSIDE the Castle, since encounters that are very close are treated as having “walls” in between them and so the adventure is less dynamic / organic
(Especially in the Crypt)
<James> I'm not sure I understand. We didn't add walls--in fact, quite the contrary--the new format lets us treat multiple rooms as a single encounter area, which I think is one of its strengths.
<Bruce> Overall, I like the adventure format. You do raise an interesting point--in maps not designed originally for the format, there may be some room for dispute. However, I think it works well for me when I DM, so by that metric (the metric I always use when I design), I think it'll appeal to many other DMs.
<James> I guess I do see it as an improvement, for precisely that reason--it helps us get beyond thinking of rooms completely separate from what's just on the other side of a door. The crypts might be one place where that approach doesn't work as well, because it's such a large encounter area...
<James> ... but still better, I think, to view it as a handful of regions rather than two dozen 10x10 rooms with weird monsters inside.
<WizO_Shadow> Thank you everyone for coming tonight to the Expedition to Castle Ravenloft chat with Bruce Cordell and James Wyatt! And a special thank you to our guests for coming here and discussing their new product with us! You can find the Expedition to Castle Ravenloft adventure at your local gaming store!
<WizO_Unicorn> Evening, James!
<WizO_Unicorn> Evening, Bruce!
<WizO_Unicorn> Thank you for coming to the Expedition to Castle Ravenloft chat with Bruce Cordell and James Wyatt. Do you have any opening remarks for us before we get to questions?
<Bruce> I'm happy to see so many people interested in the module. It was fun working with James writing this thing, or as we like to say, reimagining it for 3.5
<James> Well, just thanks for being here, thanks for your interest in this adventure.
<zerotkatama> There's no concluding the adventure section, which I assume is due to book space. Do you have any advice as to what a Concluding the adventure should contain?
<James> The tricky thing is that there are so many variables in how the adventure plays out, that it's hard to tell you how to end it.
<Bruce> Well, the adventure is finally concluded when Strahd is definitively dealt with. There are many partial victories, but the true victory comes in defeating Strahd, I'd say.
<James> Our hope is that, after playing the adventure for weeks or months, you'll know better than we do where to go with it next!
<James> Particularly in light of the adventure hooks you used to start the adventure, what's happened along the way, and what you want to do next in your campaign.
<silentkiller> so what level we looking at starting
<Bruce> 5th or 6th is probably the lowest you'd want to go
<Bruce> But you can start higher if you want to move right to the castle
<James> The adventure says 6th to 10th on the cover, but there's more specific advice inside for starting at higher level if you're going to do less of the adventure.
<WizO_Shadow> I'm ecstatic Ravenloft is being updated to 3.5!! How many of the Ravenloft books/modules are you going to update for 3.5?
<James> At this point, Expedition to Castle Ravenloft is a standalone adventure / minicampaign. We have more Expedition adventures planned, but no more Ravenloft products announced at this time.
<Bruce> Being the iconic Ravenloft adventure, this is the only one we have plans to give such treatment to at present. How'd you like that for market-speak?
<JulesLetters> I heard that the 'original' Sunblade (Legacy Weapon) upon which all others were based is in Ravenloft. What's the inspiration for making an 'original' of a classic weapon? Does it play an integral part in any of the paths the adventure can take?
<Bruce> The inspiration is that the sunblade in Ravenloft actually IS the original from which later versions were copied. Or at least, so we believe.
<James> Speaking from the perspective of the history of D&D, the original Sunsword did appear in the module I6.
<ChrisNichols> What led to the change in Strahd's look from the classic Clyde Caldwell design to the long-haired elf design?
<James> By "long-haired elf," I assume you mean the picture on page 7, as opposed to the cover image?
<Bruce> I prefer the Strahd on the cover. The interior is one artist's interpretation (as is the new cover) of course.
<James> Artistic inspiration is all I can say.
<ChrisNichols> Right, I did mean the page 7 illo. It seems to be the one more heavily used in WotC's promotional art.
<gratzu> Whose idea was it to do the rewrite and what all did it take to pull it together?
<James> It's the one we're using to promote D&D game day, at least, yes.
<James> Boy, I don't know whose idea it was originally.
<James> It took several months of writing from both me and Bruce...
<Bruce> I think there is a general idea that every so often it is cool to do a sequel of an old classic. Not sure whose idea it was to make this the original but with new 'racing stripes' so to speak. as far as working on it...
<James> Followed by the usual process of editing, typesetting, art and cartography, etc., etc....
<Bruce> that was a lot of work in a short period of time--shorter than the time we were given, because James and I were new to the new format, which was evolving as we wrote it.
<James> Yes, boy howdy!
<Bruce> But in the end, I'm exceptionally happy with how the format turned out.
<WizO_Shadow> What sentimental attachment and/or what did you enjoy about doing this project the most? ( I think it was partially answered above)
<James> I have a long history with Ravenloft. My first published game material was for the Masque of the Red Death setting. So it was really exciting for me to get this chance to revisit where it all began.
<Bruce> My sentimental attachment were to the maps, which I used to pull out all the time of the original I6, looking at and imagining a fully 3D castle for the first time.
<Bruce> ok, not quite...
<James> There are a lot of things I'm really proud of: all of Chapter 3, the legacy items, and the fundamental structure of the adventure.
<Bruce> In the podcast I discussed how my DM killed me so cruelly with Strahd. I also very strongly remember the organ music my DM played when we as players first came into the castle. Very effective on our 14 year old brains. Thanks Monte.
<gstommylee> So you wanted to bring the great experience of Ravenloft since most of the newer players where like you said around when it originally came out to have the same fun as you guys orginally did.
<James> Right.
<Bruce> Yes, but we also wanted original I6 players to get excited about doing Ravenloft all over again!
<ChrisNichols> Why did you choose not to include any references to or materials from the larger Ravenloft campaign setting as developed in both 2nd edition (from TSR) and 3.0/3.5E (from S&S/Arthaus)? And was there anything from those that you would like to have added if you could?
<Bruce> The decision was to focus solely on I6,because it had more than enough information, obviously, to fill a 200+ page book with the new format and other information we included.
<James> The idea was to revisit, reimagine, whatever... the original, classic adventure. It's been 20some years since that adventure shook up the D&D universe, which is longer than much of our audience has been alive. (Gasp!) We wanted to pass that experience on to the next generation!
<James> So much of the focus of the later Ravenloft material was on lands beyond Barovia, I don't think there's a whole lot I would have looted. We were very tightly focused on Castle Ravenloft.
<James> I did look at the House of Strahd adventure and the various implementations of Strahd's stat block as we went along, though.
<Bruce> I know there was a lot of good stuff in the expanded Ravenloft setting, but it just wasn't our focus.
<gratzu> Were you worried about the older fans' reactions to your changes?
<James> I wasn't. Perhaps I should have been, but no. I think we stayed remarkably faithful to the original, while enriching it for a new play environment.
<Bruce> A little I guess, but I think we stayed so close to the original vision that I'm only proud of what we accomplished in showcasing all that was great about the original using 3.5 rules and writing styles.
<warghoul> What time are you guys coming over to run some Ravenloft for me?
<James> First, I highly recommend checking out the D&D Podcast. Dave Noonan and Mike Mearls led off their interview of us with a really interesting discussion of horror games.
<Bruce> James can pump Heroes of Horror
<James> To that, I'd add that the most important thing is that everyone agree to help build the atmosphere. It doesn't work as well if your players sit down expecting the usual game and you try to surprise them into a horror game.
<James> Make sure they know to expect creepiness, and get their buy-in so they'll play along and at least act scared... until they really are scared.
<Bruce> The best horror game I was involved with was one were I co-DMed. we split the players into two groups and only allowed them to talk via walki-talkies. They were supposedly in submarines exploring a sunken city.
<zerotkatama> Chiming in with the advice for horror mood setting, aside from organ music, is there any music in particular you use when running Ravenloft, or horror in general?
<Bruce> Many. one good one: Soundtrack to the Ninth Gate.
<James> Heh. I have a "horror gaming" playlist on my iPod. It covers a range... let's see...
<James> Cortege Macabre from Grohg, Shostakovich's 5th symphony, Lord of the Rings music, some Beethoven, some Eberron music from the Sharn CD, some Pirates of the Caribbean, some Mozart Requiem. I want more!
<ChrisNichols> Is the Dawnheart (artifact) intended as a replacement for or reinterpretation of the Heart of Midnight (a giant living heart that animated the highest tower of Castle Ravenloft) in House of Strahd (the 2nd edition remake of I6)?
<Bruce> The Dayheart is indeed what becomes of the living tower with its heart showing in the original I6
<LordDiggori> For Bruce, How did the DM kill you with Strahd so "cruelly"? Was it THE Monte Cook that DMed?
<Bruce> My wizard stepped where he shouldn't and suddenly I appeared lying down in a small place, wood pressed against my face.. A coffin! I look out through the eyes of my raven familiar and see a caped man sitting on a coffin. The man says something like, "It's curtains for you," and bites the head off the raven. Then I had to roll up a new character. yes, Monte Cook
<Gotten> Has the work that S&S did on the Ravenloft 3rd ed been used in revising the adventure, or was it ignored? Why?
<Bruce> As we noted earlier, we wanted to focus only on I6, so including anything that came after I6 would have messed up that vision.
<James> Well, as we said before, our focus for this book was almost entirely on Castle Ravenloft and the immediate surroundings--what's covered in the original I6. Yeah, what Bruce said.
<ChrisNichols> It's kind of a shame that the 3E Ravenloft material got ignored. Andrew Wyatt wrote a brilliant section on Barovia in Ravenloft Gazetteer Vol. 1.
<gratzu> So what elements did you decide to change? (Aside from the rules and descriptive text that is) Why did you decide to change those elements?
<Bruce> Describing Expedition to CR as 'ignoring' material later than I6 isn't really fair to what the product we wrote represents.
<James> I think each of us added a bit of our own nightmares to the basic framework of the original adventure.
<James> There were some particularly goofy examples of bad humor in the original that didn't survive the translation. (Others did.)
<Bruce> Someone's identified the Dayheart as something that got more than an update, but an actual transformation. However, many other things are updated--and the many many empty spaces of the original castle now contain additional threats and connections.
<James> But mostly I think I'd put our changes into the category of "creative embellishment"--we took a masterpiece and added our own flourishes.
<Iddig> If there are more adventures for Ravenloft, will they all be some supernatural baddie? Or will it sometimes be just a guy who's the antagonist? Part of horror for me, is the "Not knowing for sure what's going on".
<James> Well, at this time we have no more Ravenloft adventures announced, though there are more Expedition adventures (and plenty of other adventures) on the way.
<Bruce> Yeah, hard to say until a particular adventure is concepted who will be the main threat. In this case, Strahd is too much a part of the whole package not to highlight him at the outset.
<ChrisNichols> Why did you change the Vistani from human gypsies with strange powers to mix of comparatively normal humans and halflings? Why make Madame Eva an annis hag?
<James> Well, in I6 the Vistani were "gypsies" with no strange powers. Gypsy is a real-world term that's pretty emotionally loaded for a lot of people, so we tried to avoid it.
<Bruce> I have nothing to add to whatever James notes on this topic.
<James> In 3E, we've presented halflings as having what you might call a "gypsy" lifestyle, so that's why I included them among the Vistani. Plus, we wanted to make sure the adventure still felt like D&D (and not d20 Gothic), which is why there are elves in the woods as well.
<James> And Madame Eva is a hag because her "sisters" are... It's related to the same issue--making sure the adventure feels like a part of your D&D campaign world, with recognizable D&D monsters. Hags represent that witch/seer archetype in D&D, so we ran with them.
<James> So I guess that's a pretty significant set of "creative embellishments"...
<Gotten> Question on design: How do you feel the encounter new “one page” format has really enhanced this adventure? Do you see it as an improvement or not? I’m asking because I’m not sure it’s a good idea INSIDE the Castle, since encounters that are very close are treated as having “walls” in between them and so the adventure is less dynamic / organic
<James> I'm not sure I understand. We didn't add walls--in fact, quite the contrary--the new format lets us treat multiple rooms as a single encounter area, which I think is one of its strengths.
<Bruce> Overall, I like the adventure format. You do raise an interesting point--in maps not designed originally for the format, there may be some room for dispute. However, I think it works well for me when I DM, so by that metric (the metric I always use when I design), I think it'll appeal to many other DMs.
<James> I guess I do see it as an improvement, for precisely that reason--it helps us get beyond thinking of rooms completely separate from what's just on the other side of a door. The crypts might be one place where that approach doesn't work as well, because it's such a large encounter area...
<James> ... but still better, I think, to view it as a handful of regions rather than two dozen 10x10 rooms with weird monsters inside.
<WizO_Shadow> Thank you everyone for coming tonight to the Expedition to Castle Ravenloft chat with Bruce Cordell and James Wyatt! And a special thank you to our guests for coming here and discussing their new product with us! You can find the Expedition to Castle Ravenloft adventure at your local gaming store!
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
- tec-goblin
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 397
- Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2003 5:22 am
- Location: Paris, France
- Contact:
Very interesting points on the maps. If they just had some better info on the bordering regions, that would be perfect.
For the Vistani and Eva, they don't seem to convince me. I don't care whether Eva is a hag or there are vistani halfling. I care that they become scoundrels and more "classic" dnd characters, and lose some of their uniqueness. They could have made vistani a 1 la template, and add the sight and some other iconic abilities, at least...
For the Vistani and Eva, they don't seem to convince me. I don't care whether Eva is a hag or there are vistani halfling. I care that they become scoundrels and more "classic" dnd characters, and lose some of their uniqueness. They could have made vistani a 1 la template, and add the sight and some other iconic abilities, at least...
BEAUTIFUL IS!
CHAOS
too DIM MJLTIVERSE
IS TO NOTICE
MOST THE OF.
CHAOS
too DIM MJLTIVERSE
IS TO NOTICE
MOST THE OF.
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7107
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
But they did not convince me, far from it: these info should be back in the room description, as a sidebar or whatever. Close to the room description would be a better way not to goof by forgetting the whatever monster in the next room.tec-goblin wrote:Very interesting points on the maps. If they just had some better info on the bordering regions, that would be perfect.
They are indeed casting back the halfling into petty thieves. And it makes me laugh when they say they didn't use gypsy as it might shock some people, but made them gypsy-looking-without-the-name thieves and scam peopleFor the Vistani and Eva, they don't seem to convince me. I don't care whether Eva is a hag or there are vistani halfling. I care that they become scoundrels and more "classic" dnd characters, and lose some of their uniqueness. They could have made vistani a 1 la template, and add the sight and some other iconic abilities, at least...
Exactly, they changed I6 into a fantasy adventure with undead. It has kept very few of the original gothic / horror atmosphere that made I6 the unique thing it was.Jester of the FoS wrote:Iconic abilities in the campaign setting. As pointed out, they were just people in I6.
It's a good fantasy adventure perhaps, but a so so conversion of I6.
Yep, no source indeed, and no pics either. For ex., you can wonder for a while what is a Troll stalker elemental if you do not have the mm#whatever where this monster is featured.My main gripe as I work through EtCR is the masses of unique and templated monsters where the source is missing.
Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
- NeoTiamat
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4119
- Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 5:00 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Boston, Massachusetts, USA
Troll Stalker Elemental? Tell me your making this up... (Don't have EttCR, not sure if thats bad).
I did find "I think we stayed remarkably faithful to the original, while enriching it for a new play enviroment" hilariously funny, in a somewhat melancholy way.
I did find "I think we stayed remarkably faithful to the original, while enriching it for a new play enviroment" hilariously funny, in a somewhat melancholy way.
Ravenloft GM: Eye of Anubis, Shattered City, and Prof. Lupescu's Traveling Ghost Show
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7107
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
Unfortunately, no. But I can't tell you what the thing is, because the book is incomplete thataway.NeoTiamat wrote:Troll Stalker Elemental? Tell me your making this up... (Don't have EttCR, not sure if thats bad).
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
- tec-goblin
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 397
- Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2003 5:22 am
- Location: Paris, France
- Contact:
Still, when somebody has written something very interesting, and it's not such a pain to reproduce it with 3.5 mechanics, even in a limited way, I don't see why you should just drop it out. They had 220 pages. Removing a couple of "troll stalker elemental"s would make vistani a lot more interesting and it would be a good political move to make us complain a lot lessJester of the FoS wrote:Iconic abilities in the campaign setting. As pointed out, they were just people in I6.
BEAUTIFUL IS!
CHAOS
too DIM MJLTIVERSE
IS TO NOTICE
MOST THE OF.
CHAOS
too DIM MJLTIVERSE
IS TO NOTICE
MOST THE OF.
- NeoTiamat
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4119
- Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 5:00 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Boston, Massachusetts, USA
I'm afraid this is degenerating into a EttCR bashing bit...
Still, I can't help myself (and will be righteously thwacked by the FoS soon, I don't doubt), but they do seem very confident of themselves in the chat-log. Anyone care to guess whether this was confidence in the product or simply, as one of the authors said, marketing double-speak?
Still, I can't help myself (and will be righteously thwacked by the FoS soon, I don't doubt), but they do seem very confident of themselves in the chat-log. Anyone care to guess whether this was confidence in the product or simply, as one of the authors said, marketing double-speak?
Ravenloft GM: Eye of Anubis, Shattered City, and Prof. Lupescu's Traveling Ghost Show
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
Arg!!!! All of these discussions are turning me inside out: do I get it or not? Actually the main reason would be to please my players who'd like to play through it again.
I actually made my own 3.5 version a while back. It was mostly updating to the new rules. I kept everything as it was in House of Strahd (I don't have I6). The main problem was keeping the difficulty even. Strahd is way too overpowered if compared to most of the other criters in the castle (like Strahd undeads). So I had the choice of either beefing up the minions to match a high level party or lowering Strahd's level. Being in love with Strahd's sheet in the Gaz, I maximised the minions.
I actually made my own 3.5 version a while back. It was mostly updating to the new rules. I kept everything as it was in House of Strahd (I don't have I6). The main problem was keeping the difficulty even. Strahd is way too overpowered if compared to most of the other criters in the castle (like Strahd undeads). So I had the choice of either beefing up the minions to match a high level party or lowering Strahd's level. Being in love with Strahd's sheet in the Gaz, I maximised the minions.
De retour dans les Brumes, enfin!
Speaking as someone who once sat in their chairs, so to speak, having done a chat for Carnival (and having once convinced an audience of hardcore RL fans at GenCon that the cancellation of 2E Ravenloft could be a good thing), it's a combination of two elements:NeoTiamat wrote:Still, I can't help myself (and will be righteously thwacked by the FoS soon, I don't doubt), but they do seem very confident of themselves in the chat-log. Anyone care to guess whether this was confidence in the product or simply, as one of the authors said, marketing double-speak?
1. Yes, they probably are honestly happy with their work and are excited to see it reach an audience.
2. Yes, the specific purpose of this chat is to promote the product. The whole thing, regardless of whatever else it may be, is an ad, and you're not likely to want to scuttle your own promotion.
- midnightcat
- Criminal Mastermind

- Posts: 128
- Joined: Sun Feb 29, 2004 10:21 pm
- Location: Jackson
Just ignore the hag part. and use the basic stats from GAZ 1. That is what I pan to do, if I run the modules. Remember the rule, change what you don't like to fit your game.cure wrote:I just can't get over Eva as a hag. Halfing Vistani, ok, without the sight and other powers, as hanger ons. But a hag! And as to the sister stuff, please!
-
Matthew L. Martin
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 176
- Joined: Sun Dec 05, 2004 7:49 pm
- Contact:
Eva should have been a green hag, IMO.
Wait, hear me out.
The origin for the Three Hags presented in EtCR is actually fairly interesting. They weren't born hags; rather, each one was the priestess of one of the three wilderness shrines to ancient saints of Barovia. Strahd bound himself and the Land together through unholy rites at those shrines, corrupting Barovia and twisting the three priestesses into hags.
The interesting coincidence regarding this is how it ties into some of John Mangrum's ideas on witches, the Weave, and hags. As described to me one evening,
And why should Eva be a green hag? Because she's the one connected to the Forest Fane. Make her the greenhag and make Baba Zelenna, demon-worshipping keeper of the Mountain Fane, the annis.
Matthew L. Martin
Wait, hear me out.
The origin for the Three Hags presented in EtCR is actually fairly interesting. They weren't born hags; rather, each one was the priestess of one of the three wilderness shrines to ancient saints of Barovia. Strahd bound himself and the Land together through unholy rites at those shrines, corrupting Barovia and twisting the three priestesses into hags.
The interesting coincidence regarding this is how it ties into some of John Mangrum's ideas on witches, the Weave, and hags. As described to me one evening,
It would not take too much finessing to tie this into the EtCR setup. And as I've said before, I can largely take or leave the Vistani as the Mysterious All-Knowing Special People of the setting.John W. Mangrum wrote: " My concept: Halan witches use Weave magic, the oldest, most primal, and perhaps most dangerous form of magic. By manipulating at the threads of the Weave -- the "planar fabric" -- they could manipulate the cycles of nature (such as weather, night and day, aging, etc. The danger would be getting tangled in the Weave, and having one's own natural cycles pulled out of balance.
In other words, grab for too much power and you might become a hag."
And why should Eva be a green hag? Because she's the one connected to the Forest Fane. Make her the greenhag and make Baba Zelenna, demon-worshipping keeper of the Mountain Fane, the annis.
Matthew L. Martin

