There is another extreme in this situation. As important as it is to instill a fear of the House on Griffon Hill, don't do anything that will cripple game play completely. I don't think this situation would warrant killing off one of the players. There's a point where the players no longer feel frightened so much as cheated.
As powerful as the solution is going to be, it can't be something that results in character loss.
If I might request we not include my silly spelling mistake in the title of the threadGreat ideas in these threads. I'll collect them for the adventure hooks.
Joël



