I like Ravenloft a lot, but sometimes I think it's just necessary to accept that it just doesn't appeal to everybody. I tried DM'ing in Ravenloft before with a group who just weren't "into" Gothic Terror and were more oriented towards Dungeon Crawl type adventures and the whole thing fell kinda flat. Maybe if I were a better DM it would have went over better, I don't think I can really blame RavenLoft.
That said, the thing I find awkward about RL as it stands involves the DarkLords and their relationship to adventurers in RL. My perception is that the DL's are too powerful for PCs to attack directly and it just "feels" wrong to think in terms of killing one of the darklords. After all, if a band of adventurers killed Strahd, it would completely change the nature of RL. So, IF you accept that, it make it hard, IMO, to create a compelling adventure that makes sense. Any more minor villain in a given domain would probably have to either be working FOR the darklord, or would be at odds with the darklord, in my opinion. So that makes it hard to create a really interesting villian / enemy that can reasonably be defeated by the PCs in a way that doesn't just lead back to the DL of the domain.
Maybe I'm just being too rigid in my thinking though... I suppose I could accept killing the major DLs as an eventual goal for very high-level characters, or I could create my own domains and accompanying darklords which can be defeated by the PCs without "messing up" the canonical RavenLoft. Or maybe I just need to be more creative in finding ways to create adventures within the existing domains that don't result in a showdown with the DarkLord.
What do you guys think? Does any of this make sense?





