Dragon 351 – Campaign classics : World Serpent Inn

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Le Noir Faineant
Rafe, Agent of the Fraternity
Rafe, Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 4592
Joined: Thu Jan 06, 2005 12:25 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Barovia

Post by Le Noir Faineant »

Jester of the FoS wrote:I believe it was Mangrum who described the Sithicus entry in GazIV as one long set-up for a novel that will (likely) never be published.
:shock: Very interesting. Are there any more details available on this? - Personally, while preparing my own small Sithicus campaign, I keep wondering how fragmentaric the post-Soth-Sithican articles really are. I mean, so much, including the person of Inza is left blank. (At least to me, who didn't read the novels. ) I wonder what the Kargatane and/or Lowder had in mind for the domain as the next step.

FTR, my campaign will indeed build on that mirror shard hook described in the Dragon article. I might as well run *The Baron's Eyrie* from Dungeon some time next year. Sithicus on all sides... :)
User avatar
Catman Jim
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 859
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 12:58 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Sunny Florida

Post by Catman Jim »

Rafael wrote:
Jester of the FoS wrote:I believe it was Mangrum who described the Sithicus entry in GazIV as one long set-up for a novel that will (likely) never be published.
Very interesting. Are there any more details available on this?
If it's the same "novel-in-the-works" in question, J.L posted about it in this thread last month;

http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/foru ... php?t=3822
I only wish I had retired sooner!
User avatar
Le Noir Faineant
Rafe, Agent of the Fraternity
Rafe, Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 4592
Joined: Thu Jan 06, 2005 12:25 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Barovia

Post by Le Noir Faineant »

Thank you, Jim. :) I posted at that other thread, so maybe Mr Lowder will be friendly enough to answer. (Not sure if this expresses what I wanted to say in English, though. Darn semantics...)
JamesLowder
Scribe of the Black Rose
Scribe of the Black Rose
Posts: 95
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2004 2:21 pm
Contact:

Re: Dragon 351 – Campaign classics : World Serpent Inn

Post by JamesLowder »

Joël of the FoS wrote: - the Western most forest is now called “Giant’s Cloak”, for it hides a stone giant and his allies working against King Azrael
- there is a new village called “Iron Warden”, just east of the Chasm
The forest is where the Wanderers often hide from Inza, and the Iron Warden isn't a village, it's the inn/tavern from the short story "The Rigor of the Game."

Cheers,
Jim Lowder
JamesLowder
Scribe of the Black Rose
Scribe of the Black Rose
Posts: 95
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2004 2:21 pm
Contact:

Post by JamesLowder »

ChrisNichols wrote:Color me unimpressed. This article is just Lowder's "Waaah! Mangrum edited my perfect and deathless prose!" reposte. It's got a token sop to the issue's theme, and then regurgitates most of the errors of the original manuscript, with just a couple of new ideas.

Chris Nichols
The most polite way to put this is: You don't know what you're talking about, Chris.

What I said at the time, and now, was that I was asked to write the Gaz material on Sithicus because I was the one who had created the domain and knew it best. John tinkered with the text I submitted when he was not authorized to do so and did not have the professional courtesy to talk to me as author after making these unauthorized changes, before they saw print. I work with editors all the time and do not consider my prose either perfect or deathless. I do, however, expect my work to be treated in a professional fashion. If WW had wanted John to write or even rewrite the material, they would have hired him to do so. They were, in fact, very upset when they found out how he had inserted himself in the book the way he did. They apologized to me about what happened--more than once.

That said, the current Dragon article is most certainly not a reset. The changes in Inza's level show a progression of time. In fact, I pushed for the Inza stats and write up to reflect the Gaz material as published even more--including things John changed from my original manuscript. Because this was a work-for-hire project, I did not win all these battles. However, the Dragon editors were professional and worked with me at every step, so I've got no gripe with the final product. Even where they changed my perfect and deathless prose.

I would have liked the article to cover more new ground, but there simply wasn't space with the World Serpent Inn material. I worked with the editors to make the article the best it could be, given the project restrictions. Sorry you don't like it, but there's plenty of other things in the magazine to read.

Cheers,
Jim Lowder
JamesLowder
Scribe of the Black Rose
Scribe of the Black Rose
Posts: 95
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2004 2:21 pm
Contact:

Post by JamesLowder »

Jester of the FoS wrote:
Besides, even before the end of the line the two have taken umbridge with Lowder. I believe it was Mangrum who described the Sithicus entry in GazIV as one long set-up for a novel that will (likely) never be published.

I'm all for new content in Dragon and Dungeon, I'd just prefer it less recycled.
There's nothing "recycled" in the article. The WSI material is all new and the material on Sithicus is intended to update the Gaz material as published (and none of this is update material is from my original Gaz turnover).

I disagree with this assessment of my original turn-over for the Gaz, too. Providing plot hooks or springboards is not the same as setting up an unpublished book. They suggest dynamic storylines to follow. Inasmuch as the plot hooks I might suggest for Sithicus reflect where I see the domain going from the fiction I've written and things I might write--well, of course. I set the overall storyline in motion, and that's why publishers hire me to write this material.

But I've also been doing this long enough to know that I have to treat every work-for-hire project as if it's my last on a line, so I'm not going to set up anything that needs to be resolved elsewhere by something I write on the subject.

Cheers,
Jim Lowder
JamesLowder
Scribe of the Black Rose
Scribe of the Black Rose
Posts: 95
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2004 2:21 pm
Contact:

Post by JamesLowder »

Rafael wrote:(At least to me, who didn't read the novels. ) I wonder what the Kargatane and/or Lowder had in mind for the domain as the next step.
I have some ideas where the domain is going. As I get hired to write more material, I'll continue to move things along in that direction as appropriate. If the publishers hire someone else to write about Sithicus, it'll go in another direction. That's the nature of shared worlds.

However, it is (in my opinion, anyway) a good thing that readers and players are curious about where a domain's storyline is going. That means the place is not static, that there are stories there left to be told. As a person writing game support material, I consider it my job to supply interesting springboards, to point out potential paths you can take. Where the domain ends up, though, is entirely up to you and your players.

Cheers,
Jim Lowder
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7107
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Re: Dragon 351 – Campaign classics : World Serpent Inn

Post by Joël of the FoS »

JamesLowder wrote: the Iron Warden isn't a village, it's the inn/tavern from the short story "The Rigor of the Game."

Cheers,
Jim Lowder
Ooops, I had forgotten this detail :) Thanks for the reminder!

My list was a short summary of changes and additions compared to the Gaz domain description. Was the Iron Warden in the Gaz4? I don't remember seeing it there?

Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

JamesLowder wrote:
Jester of the FoS wrote:
Besides, even before the end of the line the two have taken umbridge with Lowder. I believe it was Mangrum who described the Sithicus entry in GazIV as one long set-up for a novel that will (likely) never be published.

I'm all for new content in Dragon and Dungeon, I'd just prefer it less recycled.
There's nothing "recycled" in the article. The WSI material is all new and the material on Sithicus is intended to update the Gaz material as published (and none of this is update material is from my original Gaz turnover).

I disagree with this assessment of my original turn-over for the Gaz, too. Providing plot hooks or springboards is not the same as setting up an unpublished book. They suggest dynamic storylines to follow. Inasmuch as the plot hooks I might suggest for Sithicus reflect where I see the domain going from the fiction I've written and things I might write--well, of course. I set the overall storyline in motion, and that's why publishers hire me to write this material.

But I've also been doing this long enough to know that I have to treat every work-for-hire project as if it's my last on a line, so I'm not going to set up anything that needs to be resolved elsewhere by something I write on the subject.

Cheers,
Jim Lowder
I was repeating what I heard and what the gist of the article seemed to be (a write-up on Sithicus). I should have phrased this better.
I haven't actually read the issue in question (christmas-related poverty) so I haven't put a full review up.

But, I still maintain I'd rather see something new next time than a description of a land we've alreadys seen.
JamesLowder
Scribe of the Black Rose
Scribe of the Black Rose
Posts: 95
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2004 2:21 pm
Contact:

Post by JamesLowder »

Jester of the FoS wrote:
JamesLowder wrote:But, I still maintain I'd rather see something new next time than a description of a land we've alreadys seen.
Sure. That's understandable.

I noted to the Dragon editors that the most devoted RL audience was going to find the article less interesting because they would be familiar with the broad sweep of the domain and there wasn't enough room to do an in-depth update. But I also understand their reasons for going with a domain tied to a popular character like Soth; this allows them to reach out to their readers who are unfamiliar with RL, but know who Soth is. And Soth's "presence" in Sithicus allows them to foster the sense of connectedness between the various worlds the whole WSI idea is supposed to engender--especially since Soth shows up in the DL section, too, I believe.

So I tried to skew the descriptions to empahsize new material (like Azrael's concentration camp, the growing power of the Blessed Knight, the memory mirror quest--the things noted in the list at the start of the thread), so that the core RL audience would at least have some new plot hook to use in their campaigns. It's to be hoped the next RL article they run will cover entirely new ground.

Cheers,
Jim Lowder
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7107
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

As we wrote here, it's exciting to see a Ravenloft presence in Dragon.

But while it's not all new stuff for us, it might interest newcomers to take a look at Ravenloft.

Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
JamesLowder
Scribe of the Black Rose
Scribe of the Black Rose
Posts: 95
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2004 2:21 pm
Contact:

Post by JamesLowder »

Joël of the FoS wrote:As we wrote here, it's exciting to see a Ravenloft presence in Dragon.

But while it's not all new stuff for us, it might interest newcomers to take a look at Ravenloft.

Joël
Well said. I agree entirely, and that's the spirit in which I approached the assignment when Dragon contacted me. I think it's good news for everyone who cares about Ravenloft that the magazine decided to devote any pages to the setting. I'm honored that they asked me to write the piece. Here's hoping it will lead to more interest and, perhaps, more new material.

Cheers,
Jim
User avatar
Mangrum
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 811
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2003 1:29 am

Post by Mangrum »

JamesLowder wrote:John tinkered with the text I submitted when he was not authorized to do so and did not have the professional courtesy to talk to me as author after making these unauthorized changes, before they saw print.
Hi Jim. Since you are, obviously, the one who knows what was going on behind the scenes at the time , I was wondering if you could answer a few questions for me. These are questions to which the answers are, indeed, utter mysteries to me.

1A. If I wasn't authorized to make changes to your text, then why did the developers send it to me?

1B. In addition, why did they then use the changes? (As they had done with my edits on each of the previous Gazetteers? And Van Richten's Arsenal? And would later do again with sections of the RL DMG?)

2A. Do me a favor and check your e-mail archives. At what point did the devlopers send you a format guide for the chapter?

2B. If they did send you one, why did you consciously ignore it? For that matter, why did you not write any game material for the Attached Notes, beyond Inza and her stat block? The policy was to reserve roughly one-third of a chapter's word count for Attached Notes game material.

These are not rhetorical questions, though regardless I have no delusions that they'll be answered. While you ponder these questions, ponder this as well: The guy you're berating for not knowing what was going on was, in fact, regularly communicating with other members of the design team, unlike yourself. Or do have a mystery source of information (that you've been holding out on us all this time) other than "Jackie & Nicky said it, so it must be so"?

Hey, folks, want some fun? I'll give you a glimpse into the ravages I visited upon this chapter.

From Sites of Interest, here's S's entry on Har-Thelen (in its entirety, minus Where to Stay and stat block), as it appeared in the draft I handed back to the developers. This is what I sent out verbatim, typos and all:
Har-Thelen

Nestled in the center of the country, Har-Thelen sits on the banks of the Musarde. Nedragaard Keep and the Great Chasm sit just a day’s hard hike down a rocky road to the east, separated from the town only by the Krellin River. Due to its location, Har-Thelen has historically seen the most foreign traffic and squirmed under the firmest grip of the Lord of Nedragaard Keep. For these reasons, Har-Thelen is widely accepted as the “capital” of Sithicus, despite behind little more than half the size of Hroth.

As with the other towns, Har-Thelen is organized behind its weed-choked walls in a series of concentric circles. Unlike Mal-Erek and Hroth, however, Har-Thelen’s most active areas extend from its outermost ring. A fairly verdant plain stretches north of the town, following the banks of the Musarde for a time, and the local noble and greenshaper castes are currently cooperating to develop a vinyard that, with some management, could probably turn quite a profit.

Har-Thelen’s docks are also unusually well-kept for a Sithican community. This town has the largest mixed population by far, strongly bolstered by its river traffic. The races tolerate each other no better here than in the other elven settlements, however; the non-elves are simply more prevalent,. To avoid trouble, most non-elves congregate near the extensive docks.

Those docks exist almost exclusively thanks to the town’s former Lord Speaker, Mason of Har-Thelen. Mason was unusually ambitious for a Sithican noble, doggedly bullying the artisan caste into repairing and maintaining the city docks, and pressing for increased trade with Kartakass and Invidia. However, Mason was also known to resent Azrael’s brutal intrusions and steep taxes, while Azrael supposedly preferred his elves compliant. After the Black Rose fell from power, the two came to loggerheads, and Mason was forced to hastily vacate his post - the only time the title of Lord Speaker has changed hands within memory, in fact. Current Lady Speaker Ciyriia is new to her post, and apparently much more of the docile mold Azrael prefers.

As for Mason, his current fate is unclear. Some folk believe he is dead, or has fled into exile. Others, however, whisper that he still haunts the region, trying to organize an underground resistance to bring down the mad dwarf‘s regime.
Now, here's how that section appeared in your copies of the book, again verbatim. This is after the developers did their thing, gave it their approval, and sent it on to be printed. Compare above and below. The changes you'll find are representative of the developers' editorial presence as the Kargatane generally experienced it.
Har-Thelen

Nestled in the center of the country, Har-Thelen sits on the banks of the Musarde. Nedragaard Keep and the Great Chasm sit just a day’s hard hike down a rocky road to the east, separated from the town only by the Krellin River. Due to its location, Har-Thelen has historically seen the most foreign traffic and squirmed under the firmest grip of the Lord of Nedragaard Keep. For these reasons, Har-Thelen is widely accepted as the “capital” of Sithicus, despite being little more than half the size of Hroth.

Har-Thelen is organized behind its weed-choked walls in a series of concentric circles. Its most active areas extend from its outermost ring. A fairly verdant plain stretches north of the town, following the banks of the Musarde, and the local noble and greenshaper castes are currently cooperating to develop a vineyard that could probably turn quite a profit.

Har-Thelen’s docks are also unusually well-kept for a Sithican community. This town has the largest mixed population, strongly bolstered by its river traffic. The races tolerate each other no better here than in the other elven settlements, however; the non-elves are simply more prevalent. To avoid trouble, most non-elves congregate near the extensive docks.

Those docks exist thanks to the town’s former Lord Speaker, Mason of Har-Thelen. Unusually ambitious for a Sithican noble, Mason doggedly bullied the artisan caste into repairing and maintaining the city docks and pressed for increased trade with Kartakass and Invidia. Mason, though, was also known to resent Azrael’s brutal intrusions and steep taxes, while Azrael supposedly preferred his elves compliant. After the Black Rose fell from power, the two came to loggerheads, and Mason was forced to vacate his post hastily - the only time the title of Lord Speaker has changed hands within memory. Current Lady Speaker Ciyriia is new to her post, and apparently much more of the docile mold Azrael prefers.

Mason's current fate is unclear. Some believe he is dead or has fled into exile. Others whisper that he still haunts the region, trying to organize an underground resistance to bring down the mad dwarf‘s regime.
And finally, here's the same section, once again verbatim, in the original, exalted version you would have seen it had I not been, as Jim as made it so abundantly clear over the years, a megalomaniacal bastard who somehow took the developers' sainted aunties hostage in order to render them horrifically powerless before my editorial tyranny. If you're wondering how much of the text below would have changed before reaching print, well, again, compare the two samples above. Personally, I was pleased as punch on the occasions when they so much as caught my typos.
Har-Thelen

Nestled in the center of the country, the last city I came across lies east of the Nedragaard Keep ruins, north of a densely and unnamed forest that also disappears into the Mists and west of the haunted forest known as the Fumewood. With the Musarde running north of the city as well as a fairly verdant plain, the city is in the process of developing a vineyard that, with some management, will probably turn quite a profit. As with the other cities, the construction within the weed choked outer walls is a series of concentric circles separating the various families and castes. And this city, by far, has the largest mixed population. I noticed they don’t tolerate each other any better than the other cities; there are just more nonnatives here.
For the record, the versions of Where to Stay and the town's stat block in your books remain virtually unchanged from the original draft. (In the case of Where to Stay, my only changes were to insert food/room quality notes, in keeping with the standard format. In the stat block, I just fixed a little irregular terminology, fixed some numbers, and largely arbitrarily, labeled it a "village," since originally, it... well, it wasn't labeled anything.

Have fun, Jim. I'll let you get back to caressing your dusty manuscript of Wake of the Black Rose.
JamesLowder
Scribe of the Black Rose
Scribe of the Black Rose
Posts: 95
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2004 2:21 pm
Contact:

Post by JamesLowder »

Mangrum wrote:Hi Jim. Since you are, obviously, the one who knows what was going on behind the scenes at the time , I was wondering if you could answer a few questions for me. These are questions to which the answers are, indeed, utter mysteries to me.
I had a contract with WW and an agreement with the official developers, struck after they asked me to write for the Gaz. Neither involved you or any third party editing or rewriting my work. As it was explained to me after the fact, WW was allowing you to proof for continuity, but that you were not authorized to make changes to other authors' work--that it wasn't your job to rewrite people. Your changes were used because they did not realize you had made them before the book went to print. They apologized for allowing you take this unauthorized license with the work of other writers actually contracted to write the material.

As for posting the text--hey, nice job violating copyright and all the basic premises of professional conduct. Bravo.

The best part is, I didn't write that section.

Voronica Whitney-Robinson did.

The fact that you are holding this up as an example of my work explains quite clearly why so much remains a mystery to you, and will certainly remain a mystery in the years to come.

Cheers,
Jim Lowder
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7107
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

. o 0 (headache coming)

Let’s try to sort it out for once, shall we?

Before I try to do it, let it be said I respect both authors enormously, I’ve said that often to them in private and public over the years. So I have no preconceived bias.

---

John, do we have to understand you expanded VWR’s text (submitted by VWR as the third quote in your post, while your expanded text is the first quote).

And that this expanded text wasn’t changed much by the editors (the second quote)?

Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
Locked