Hi, old time D&D player (20+ years) and Ravenloft fan (didn’t play it enough, hard to find the players that “understood” Ravenloft...in the past couple months myself and some of my players decided to try Ravenloft 3E (we have only started using the 3E rules in the past 1 1/2 years)
I own all the old RL products (except for Carnival and House on Gryphon Hill, which I have as PDFs) and thankfully I’ve been able to buy or download all of White Wolf’s 3E Ravenloft products and now face the daunting task of assimilating all the new information.
I am/was also a big fan of the Secrets of the Kargatane web site, I have always thought that the “Books of S” were possibly the finest D&D netbooks you could ever find online.
So as I am once again stepping into the Domains of Dread and due to simple curiosity I do have a few questions (probably the first of many and the fact I don’t have a whole lot of time to deduce these answers on my own doesn’t help)
1) Is the Fraternity of Shadows web site the unofficial successor of the Secrets of the Kargatane web site? Are some of the SotK people involved in running the FoS? Has the FoS ever attempted to become “official”?
2) I got the impression that some of the authors/contributors of the Ravenloft 3E White Wolf products were the Kargatane/FoS authors, is this true?
3) I think I know this answer but as a stupid question: In 3E Ravenloft is Ravenloft still an actual demiplane, or some sort of “alternate plane” like “the Far Realm”?
4) I did remember the reference to “The Time of Unparalleled Darkness” from Bleak House but I was a bit shocked when I read around the FoS Site and got the impression that the outlined plan of the ToUD was to be the “end-game” of the demiplane...whose idea was it to plan that? Is it the general consensus in the FoS that the “end-game” is the standard result of the ToUD? I read the notes on how the future/lost Gazetteers would develop with S and Azlan and it seems that “end-game” idea was to become canon
5) I have understand (and agreed with) the reasoning behind the restriction on detecting alignments in Ravenloft and reading over the 3E rules on detect evil and other alignment spells it appeared to me nothing has changed...then I (just) get the Heroes of Light book and read over the new (to me) virtue rules and how you can (through deduction) detect good by way of feats and prestige classes...and I wonder why, if you can sense great virtue why you can’t sense great corruption (like a darklord or a 5th magnitude anything for example)...I always thought if a paladin is such an anathema to the Dark Lords and the demiplane then the paladin should feel the same to any one/place/thing that is greatly connected to the DLs and demiplane...has anyone ever addressed this, or adapted a house rule?
6) What happened to the Knowledge: Ravenloft and Knowledge: Monster skills...I see references to those skills in the 3.0 products but as I have only the RL 3.5 PH and DMG I am assuming that they were removed in the 3.0-3.5 conversion? I have always used a house rule of “knowledge: monster”, was knowledge: Ravenloft used to replace the rarer knowledge: the planes?
Thanks so very much!
Eric
Questions from a Old Player/Newbie FoS member
- Eric the Light Bringer
- Agent of the Fraternity

- Posts: 67
- Joined: Wed Jan 03, 2007 2:06 pm
- Location: Ontario, Canada
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7107
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
Welcome back to the mists,
Since RL’s license is back to WotC, we have tried, but the status of Ravenloft (again in some limbo as a setting) isn’t making them move. Also, they told me they are rethinking their link with fan sites. May be someday they’ll ask us …
Anyway, the FoS is now by far the largest website about Ravenloft, and we also enjoy the independence from WotC. So if they asked us to be official web site, I’m now not sure of the answer, for me at least.

Joël
The FoS web site started about a month after the surprise SotK closing. We (the FoS) were first grouped to be netbook editors, but after the closing, we wanted to fill the e-void on Ravenloft left by the great SotK site. For more info on the FoS, you should read our FAQ.Eric the Light Bringer wrote:1) Is the Fraternity of Shadows web site the unofficial successor of the Secrets of the Kargatane web site?
Nope. But we are blessed by the presence here and work of John W Mangrum (see his many files in the library, as well as the upcoming Tiny Tales of Terror project) and Chris Nichols (working with us on the Nocturnal Sea Gaz). Other K stop once in a while and say hello.Are some of the SotK people involved in running the FoS?
Yes, of course. When WW was doing RL, nobody (WW or WotC) wanted to make this decision, as nobody wanted to sort this legal limbo over the status of Ravenloft with the licensing.Has the FoS ever attempted to become “official”?
Since RL’s license is back to WotC, we have tried, but the status of Ravenloft (again in some limbo as a setting) isn’t making them move. Also, they told me they are rethinking their link with fan sites. May be someday they’ll ask us …
Anyway, the FoS is now by far the largest website about Ravenloft, and we also enjoy the independence from WotC. So if they asked us to be official web site, I’m now not sure of the answer, for me at least.
Yep. Read the reviews and compare with the personnel of the kargatane website, you’ll find many of them authored RL 3e books. Those are among the best books of the line.2) I got the impression that some of the authors/contributors of the Ravenloft 3E White Wolf products were the Kargatane/FoS authors, is this true?
No, it’s quite similar to the 2e situation: an artificial pocket realm in the Ethereal Plane (RL PHB p8).3) I think I know this answer but as a stupid question: In 3E Ravenloft is Ravenloft still an actual demiplane, or some sort of “alternate plane” like “the Far Realm”?
From our FAQ:4) I did remember the reference to “The Time of Unparalleled Darkness” from Bleak House but I was a bit shocked when I read around the FoS Site and got the impression that the outlined plan of the ToUD was to be the “end-game” of the demiplane...whose idea was it to plan that? Is it the general consensus in the FoS that the “end-game” is the standard result of the ToUD? I read the notes on how the future/lost Gazetteers would develop with S and Azlan and it seems that “end-game” idea was to become canon
And the most important thing about it, again from our FAQ:It has been foreseen that there will come a Time of Unparalleled Darkness to Ravenloft that will reach a climax in the year 775 (on the Barovian calendar). This concept is alluded to in The Evil Eye in relation to the Gentleman Caller as well as in the introduction to Domains of Dread. It is first mentioned by name in one of the endings to Bleak House. Van Richten is clearly going to be involved, but at the moment little else is known about what might occur during this period.
It was rumoured that at one point there was a definite plan among the Kargat for the ToUD, but in reality no one expected the product line to last long enough to reach the year 775. It was always meant to be a shadowing event in the far future. A ToUD module was proposed as the final RAVENLOFT product and was to involve travel through time with the heroes journeying to the year 775 before returning with the foreknowledge and the possibility of changing things. However, this proposal was rejected. Any plans they did have ended with the line as well as the change in publishers and developers.
So you can do whatever you want it. Many fans have given their interpretation and ideas over the years.For now, the Time of Unparalleled Darkness remains a nebulous event in the far future. Like the dark powers and the Gentleman Caller's ultimate plan, the ToUD is a tool for DMs to develop as they see fit.
Oh, Heroes of Light. This book, and Champions of Darkness, are often considered to be containing many design flaws (the best polite way to say they were full of crap). Fans cherry pick what they want from them and leave the rubbish out of their game.5) I have understand (and agreed with) the reasoning behind the restriction on detecting alignments in Ravenloft and reading over the 3E rules on detect evil and other alignment spells it appeared to me nothing has changed...then I (just) get the Heroes of Light book and read over the new (to me) virtue rules and how you can (through deduction) detect good by way of feats and prestige classes...and I wonder why, if you can sense great virtue why you can’t sense great corruption (like a darklord or a 5th magnitude anything for example)...I always thought if a paladin is such an anathema to the Dark Lords and the demiplane then the paladin should feel the same to any one/place/thing that is greatly connected to the DLs and demiplane...has anyone ever addressed this, or adapted a house rule?
Still there, see the RL Players handbook p 606) What happened to the Knowledge: Ravenloft and Knowledge: Monster skills...I see references to those skills in the 3.0 products but as I have only the RL 3.5 PH and DMG I am assuming that they were removed in the 3.0-3.5 conversion? I have always used a house rule of “knowledge: monster”, was knowledge: Ravenloft used to replace the rarer knowledge: the planes?
Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
- Eric the Light Bringer
- Agent of the Fraternity

- Posts: 67
- Joined: Wed Jan 03, 2007 2:06 pm
- Location: Ontario, Canada
Thank you very much Joel!
one the topic of detecting alignment...I was considering a house rule that detect evil/good could sense extreme sources of good and evil, like true innocents, celestials, dark lords, fiends with a few power rituals (? can't remember if that is the term), etc.
or perhaps (using description of the spell) any alignment (good/evil) of overwhelming aura?
would you think that would unbalanceweaken a RL game?
oh, and would you consider a horror check/save against a creature of extreme good ?
one the topic of detecting alignment...I was considering a house rule that detect evil/good could sense extreme sources of good and evil, like true innocents, celestials, dark lords, fiends with a few power rituals (? can't remember if that is the term), etc.
or perhaps (using description of the spell) any alignment (good/evil) of overwhelming aura?
would you think that would unbalanceweaken a RL game?
oh, and would you consider a horror check/save against a creature of extreme good ?
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Keep the metagame purpose of the no-alignment-detection rule in mind, before you make such a decision. The reason the rule exists is to keep the PCs (and, by extension, the players) in the dark as to who or what their enemies are, and whom they can really trust. If allowing spells to discern strong moral alignments will undermine more of your plans than it advances (e.g. if PCs can tell that gracious, likeable Dominic d'Honaire has to be very Evil, simply because the spell works on him), then it's best not to change things.Eric the Light Bringer wrote:one the topic of detecting alignment...I was considering a house rule that detect evil/good could sense extreme sources of good and evil, like true innocents, celestials, dark lords, fiends with a few power rituals (? can't remember if that is the term), etc.
or perhaps (using description of the spell) any alignment (good/evil) of overwhelming aura?
would you think that would unbalanceweaken a RL game?
That being said, fiends' evil alignment can be detected in many people's Ravenloft campaigns. However, that's best presented more as a special weakness of fiends (i.e. their reality wrinkles disrupt it so much, the Land can't protect them from divinations per usual) than as an exception to the no-alignment-detection rule, IMHO.
The RLDMG describes how to figure OR values for creatures. Personally, if a good outsider has a sufficiently benign reputation to bring its OR value down to 3 or less, I'd skip the Horror save under any circumstance. Characters don't have to make Horror saves when they meet elves, etc.oh, and would you consider a horror check/save against a creature of extreme good ?
Even if its OR modifier is quite high, I'd only require a Horror save if A) the character who meets the outsider is either extremely fearful of anything supernatural; B) the witness is unaware that the outsider is of a benevolent variety (e.g. a lammasu looks like a big scary predator to someone who's never heard of them); or C) the character has some terrible guilt on their conscience, and assumes the outsider has come to condemn them for it.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Nathan of the FoS
- Fiendish Enforcer

- Posts: 5247
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
- Location: San Francisco CA
I dunno...if we take the Biblical appearances as a guide, the fact that the first thing the angel usually says is "Fear not!" seems to imply that most people find their appearing (and quite possibly their presence) alarming.Rotipher of the FoS wrote:The RLDMG describes how to figure OR values for creatures. Personally, if a good outsider has a sufficiently benign reputation to bring its OR value down to 3 or less, I'd skip the Horror save under any circumstance. Characters don't have to make Horror saves when they meet elves, etc.oh, and would you consider a horror check/save against a creature of extreme good ?
Even if its OR modifier is quite high, I'd only require a Horror save if A) the character who meets the outsider is either extremely fearful of anything supernatural; B) the witness is unaware that the outsider is of a benevolent variety (e.g. a lammasu looks like a big scary predator to someone who's never heard of them); or C) the character has some terrible guilt on their conscience, and assumes the outsider has come to condemn them for it.
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
True, an initial Fear check might be warranted, even if Horror isn't that appropriate. Of course, the fear could be based as much on seeing something astounding appear out of nowhere, as on what the creature in question actually looks like or does.Nathan of the FoS wrote:I dunno...if we take the Biblical appearances as a guide, the fact that the first thing the angel usually says is "Fear not!" seems to imply that most people find their appearing (and quite possibly their presence) alarming.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Re: Questions from a Old Player/Newbie FoS member
The Knowledge: Ravenloft and other monster skills were part of 3.0, back when Knowledges were like Craft and Profession and could cover all range of topics.Eric the Light Bringer wrote:6) What happened to the Knowledge: Ravenloft and Knowledge: Monster skills...I see references to those skills in the 3.0 products but as I have only the RL 3.5 PH and DMG I am assuming that they were removed in the 3.0-3.5 conversion? I have always used a house rule of “knowledge: monster”, was knowledge: Ravenloft used to replace the rarer knowledge: the planes?
They were hastily re-folded into the fewer but broader knowledge topics in 3.5 to fall in line with the new D&D PHB.
Knowledge: Ravenloft has been replaced by Knowledge: Planes which applies to any information regarding the demi-plane status of Ravenloft. The more mundane is simply Knowledge: Local.
Like 3.5, the Monster knowledges in 3.0 are now the more common knowledges with things like Outsiders covered in Knowledge: Planes, abberations in Knowledge: Dungoneering, animals in Knowledge: Nature, etc.
- Eric the Light Bringer
- Agent of the Fraternity

- Posts: 67
- Joined: Wed Jan 03, 2007 2:06 pm
- Location: Ontario, Canada
I was thinking of how celestials are discussed in the Alderac Entertainment Group (AEG) book "Good", where (as I remember) celestials, even though they are their good alignment in physical form, are so purely good they are to the point alien to mortals..thus there is "mortal good" and "celestial good"
(And logically then, the most evil mortal in known existance is still not as evil as the weakest/least fiend "mortal evil vs fiendish evil"...which is why the greatest evil mortals usually shed their mortality for undeath or fiendishness)
Anyway, my idea of a horror check when you encounter a celestial is based off of the "alienness" of the celestial..that the celestial is soooo inhuman in their virtue that it is horrific to the mortal mind?
(And logically then, the most evil mortal in known existance is still not as evil as the weakest/least fiend "mortal evil vs fiendish evil"...which is why the greatest evil mortals usually shed their mortality for undeath or fiendishness)
Anyway, my idea of a horror check when you encounter a celestial is based off of the "alienness" of the celestial..that the celestial is soooo inhuman in their virtue that it is horrific to the mortal mind?
- Eric the Light Bringer
- Agent of the Fraternity

- Posts: 67
- Joined: Wed Jan 03, 2007 2:06 pm
- Location: Ontario, Canada
Re: Questions from a Old Player/Newbie FoS member
thank you evryone for your replies!
I have never accepted you have to specialize (i.e. spend skill points) in a huge field of knowledge to know about a creature type...especially for classes (i.e. Fighters) that do not have full access to a knowledge Skill and yet should/need to know about a certain monster abilities/vulnerabilities
my house rule I (and my players) developed brought in "Knowledge: Monster" and then created synnergy bonuses with the other knowledge skills for the knowledge: monster skill check (e.g. +2 synergy bonus to a knowledge: monster check involving a plant creature if you have 5+ ranks in knowledge:nature)
ughhJester of the FoS wrote: Like 3.5, the Monster knowledges in 3.0 are now the more common knowledges with things like Outsiders covered in Knowledge: Planes, abberations in Knowledge: Dungoneering, animals in Knowledge: Nature, etc.
my house rule I (and my players) developed brought in "Knowledge: Monster" and then created synnergy bonuses with the other knowledge skills for the knowledge: monster skill check (e.g. +2 synergy bonus to a knowledge: monster check involving a plant creature if you have 5+ ranks in knowledge:nature)
