Night of The Living Newbie

Discussing all things Ravenloft
Post Reply
User avatar
LordGodefroi
Criminal Mastermind
Criminal Mastermind
Posts: 144
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2007 11:19 pm
Location: Wichita, KS, USA

Night of The Living Newbie

Post by LordGodefroi »

Greetings.

I'm LordGodefroi, (the same LordGodefroi that's made a few posts over at the WOTC boards). I'm also known as Desdinova over at DreadCentral.com forums.

I discovered The Black Box in the shadowy corner of a favorite used book store one grey, rainy, depressing, unemployed day well over 15 years ago. I bought it with the rest of my store credit and devoured it over a meager lunch. I've been a Ravenloft devotee ever since.

I recently acquired Van Richten's Guide To The Walking Dead and Van Richten's Guide To The Shadow Fey in a large lot of new Ravenloft 3.5 books from a liquidated game store. ( I don't need the other books in the lot, so I'll post a link when I eBay them soon (if forum rules allow it.)) The only thing I need to complete my RL 3.5 collection is Dark Tales & Disturbing Legends.

Anyway, I'm getting ready to start a modified RL game and am looking forward to discussing how folks incorporate rules from books like Libris Mortis, Book of Vile Darkness, Heroes of Horror, and Legends & Lore: Darkness & Dread into their games.

Until then, see ya in the Mists. . . .
User avatar
vipera aspis
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 351
Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2005 8:38 pm
Location: Chicago

Post by vipera aspis »

welcome Godefroi. What do you mean by modified?
my bones among the rocks and roots
User avatar
LordGodefroi
Criminal Mastermind
Criminal Mastermind
Posts: 144
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2007 11:19 pm
Location: Wichita, KS, USA

Post by LordGodefroi »

vipera aspis wrote:welcome Godefroi. What do you mean by modified?
By 'modified', I mean in terms of setting. In my version of Ravenloft:

-there's no Shadow Rift (There's a great forest, instead.)
-there are no 'outworlders'. Everyone and everything is native to RL.
-the piece-meal nature of the lands of RL is abandoned.

Other than that, everything else is the same; In terms of rules, I intend to add things from Heroes of Horror and especially Legends & Lore: Darkness and Dread.

Thanks for the welcome.
User avatar
tec-goblin
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 397
Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2003 5:22 am
Location: Paris, France
Contact:

Post by tec-goblin »

What do you mean by "piece meal"?

(btw, shadow fey ruuule, it's sad you threw out the rift, aaah :P)

Well, most of HoH can be used. All the advice and tips can be used, including of course some of its monsters. My submission for Player's Guide to the Land of Mists contains some info on how Archivists fit into the game, too.
Regarding taint and the other rules about nausea etc... it's a completely different take to horror and derangement.
IF Ravenloft material was consistent on the use of Fear and Horror rules, changing them for the HoH rules would be painful, but, unfortunately, much of Denizens of Darkness and most of the other books ignore Fear checks etc (for example, you save against fear, instead of rolling a Fear check).
Taint is tricky: it is slow and progressive, and high level characters can get rid of it at its early stages too easily. It is more play-balanced, but it loses the sudden element of a player realizing he got corrupted in some way, suddenly, and trying to see why (when in fact it was a botched 2% check for looting the dead or smth like that). With the WW system, the Dark Powers are more capricious - I think (and I tell you from experience, as I've used both systems) that this system is better for higher level play, more difficult and gives hints on the nature of Dark Powers, while taint as in HoH is good for low-level play, where the Dark Powers seem like a constant law of nature.

Libris Mortis has nice rules for undead hunger. It has also some great stuff for necromancers etc. As for the monsters, I suggest you don't use it too often, as it is so gruesome that it could make the players and PCs jaded.

Book of Vile Darkness... As there are no otherworlders in your game, most devil and demon stuff is too overt. I suggest using pact magic from Tome of Magic instead to contact these outer beings (and there is a good chance I'll submit some things on that for PGtR, too). But you could certainly use vile damage and some of the spells (ensure you check the updated versions in Spell Compendium) when you need something horrific and evil. You could also used sadism, masochism, but in a more grey light, or as a result of a failed power check. Rules for sacrifices are very very interesting.

I don't know about Legends and Lore supplements, please elaborate on this.

PS: Welcome to the boards Lord! :D
BEAUTIFUL IS!
CHAOS
too DIM MJLTIVERSE
IS TO NOTICE
MOST THE OF.
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

Heroes of Horror has a good necromancer class that is far superior to the standard wizard-specializing-in-necromancy nonsense that the usual D&D rules has.

Libris Mortis has a few good monsters, but the main addition it brings is a whole load of new feats and details about how to run undead in a campaign. It's useful for the DM who knows his players will go up against undead, as well as the DM who wants to make a memorable undead enemy.

As for Dark Tales and Disturbing Legends, it seems to be a 3.5 equivalent of the Book of Crypts (which was basically a book with various adventure hooks that you could elaborate on). However, my main problem, I am ashamed to say, is that it is set out with great big blocks of text and huge amounts of backstory. Reading wise, it's fairly impenetrable... and this is for a guy who's been reading every Ravenloft item he can find with ravenous zeal.
User avatar
LordGodefroi
Criminal Mastermind
Criminal Mastermind
Posts: 144
Joined: Fri Jan 05, 2007 11:19 pm
Location: Wichita, KS, USA

Post by LordGodefroi »

tec-goblin wrote:What do you mean by "piece meal"?

(btw, shadow fey ruuule, it's sad you threw out the rift, aaah :P)
I don't know about Legends and Lore supplements, please elaborate on this.

PS: Welcome to the boards Lord! :D
1) Piece meal: The lands of canon RL are stitched together like Frankenstein's Monster. Sometimes the topography changes abruptly at domain borders. I don't like that. In my version of RL, the RL world IS the Material Plane and acts like the material plane. (This, of course, somewhat changes the 'prison-world' aspect of RL for the darklords. In my RL, the darklords are still trapped, and can still close their domain borders; However, the darklords are 'anchored' to their lands, not entombed within them. Rather than trying to escape RL, they are attempting to become 'unbound' within it.)

2) Probably going to keep the Shadow Fey, just change the nature of where they come from - the rift is now the Schwarzwalden (Black Forest).

3) Legends & Lore: Darkness & Dread was released about a year before Heroes of Horror and is probably what inspired WOTC to publish HoH. Darkness & Dread is one of my favorite D&D supplements. The book features:
  1. New replacement core character classes: In fitting with the horror genre, these character classes are weaker than the standard D&D classes. In giving the monsters the upper hand, horror is easier to maintain for the DM. For simplicity's sake, however, I don't use them in RL. These classes are really intended for a home-brew horror setting.
  2. A new Health Point system to replace the Hit Point system. Hit point progression is MUCH slower and 'tank' characters aren't able to soak up as much damage as they would in standard D&D games. Again, this makes it easier to maintain the horror feel.
  3. A new version of Fear, Terror, and Madness checks. Similar to RL.
  4. Fear rating system for the monsters of the core rules. Similar to fear checks in RL.
  5. A 'Black Magic' system that describes the negative effects (temp CON damage, die roll penalties, and Madness points) of using spells on the Black Magic spell list the DM creates. A sample spell list is included in the book. In general, all the 'big damage' spells (Fireball, for example) are relegated to the Black Magic category as are spells that involve the dead or extra-planar beings.
  6. Considering that horror involves mystery and investigation, there's an innovative new system regarding the Knowledge skill which allows characters broader coverage in their knowledge base. (Yet it isn't as broad as Bardic Knowledge.) It's very interesting and workable but I don't use it as I want to keep new rules to the minimum because I've got players that are newbies to the RL campaign setting.
  7. There's a very innovative system regarding magic books, libraries, and research that could be used in any D&D game. This is worth the price of the book by itself. I definitely use this one in my game.

4) Thanks for the welcome!
User avatar
The Giamarga
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2313
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
Location: wandering

Post by The Giamarga »

This shop has Dark Tales & Disturbing Legends for $ 12:
http://www.rpgshop.com/overstock.php?aid=152&src=DTRPG
Post Reply