How does the wealth feat work?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

Hmmm.... I'm not completely sure that it's impossible to make a balanced wealth feat. While it does come down more to PC background than something like weapon focus does, so do lots of other feats too (reincarnated, cold one, hollow) and there are feats that alter just about every other number on a character sheet, so why not gp?

What about something as simple as:
Benefit: You receive double normal starting wealth if you take this feat at 1st level. When you reach a new level, you receive 10% of the average wealth of a character of your new level, based on the Character Wealth by Level chart in the DMG. The money arrives via a method of the DM's choosing. (This feat takes effect immediately when you take it, so a character taking the wealth feat as their 3rd level feat immediately receives 270gp, 10% of a 3rd level character's average wealth.)

You may take this feat multiple times. If you do, you receive 10%*(number of wealth feats) of the average wealth of your new level, and if you take it multiple times at 1st level, you receive total starting wealth of (1+number of wealth feats)*(normal starting wealth.)



So on average, someone taking this feat is about 10% wealthier than normal, early on. But assuming you don't lose wealth anywhere, by 20th level all those extra bumps add up to about 50% more wealth. (The rich get richer...) I'm not sure if that's really fair. Seems to be worth more than 1 feat.... what about something like this more complicated, but fair version:

Benefit: You receive double normal starting wealth if you take this feat at 1st level. When you reach a new level, you receive 10% of the difference between the average wealth of a character of your new level and your old level, based on the Character Wealth by Level chart in the DMG. The money arrives via a method of the DM's choosing. (This feat takes effect immediately when you take it, so a character taking the wealth feat as their 3rd level feat immediately receives 180gp, 10% of a 3rd level character's average wealth - a 2nd level character's average wealth.)

You may take this feat multiple times. If you do, you receive 10%*(number of wealth feats) of the difference, and if you take it multiple times at 1st level, you receive total starting wealth of (1+number of wealth feats)*(normal starting wealth.)


This should keep you roughly 10% richer all the time, which seems fair.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
The Giamarga
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2313
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
Location: wandering

Post by The Giamarga »

Mangrum wrote:When I went through and created a master feat document for myself, I fixed a number of feats from CoD and HoL -- sometimes by rewriting them from scratch -- but in the case of this one, I simply left it out entirely. Dubious concept, bad execution.
But what do you do with the Dilettante PrC, which has Wealth as a prerequisite?
User avatar
Mangrum
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 811
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2003 1:29 am

Post by Mangrum »

Eric the Light Bringer wrote:The D&D PH and DMG allot how much wealth a player should receive per encounter level (and so in general how much wealth in equipment the character should have), and the encounter level is usually dependent on the challenge rating of the monster/threat the character needs to overcome
Got it in one. In 3E D&D, equipment (wealth) is a critical component of a PC's power level. A PC who lacks the standard amount of gear for his level generally isn't up to challenges that, by the letter of the rules, should pose a fair challenge. This isn't generally a big deal at the lowest levels (since PCs generally don't have much equipment then), but wealth becomes increasingly vital at higher levels.

(Too much wealth is equally unbalancing. If you give a 2nd-level fighter +3 full plate and a +2 vorpal sword, don't expect that 3rd-level orc barbarian to pose a threat.)

That's not really the crucial problem with the Wealth feat, however -- there's nothing wrong with an equipment boost vs. boosting any other resource. Having the feat be more valuable at some levels than at others isn't wrong either. (Toughness being a prime example -- a feat that's great for 1st-level wizards and sorcerers, but which actively should not be taken by any PC who will be played past starting levels.)

Yet the Wealth feat has written has numerous flaws. First of all, as has been oft noted, the mechanics don't mean anything as written (a common problem in CoH and HoL), so you end up having to write your own feat right off the bat. Second, tying the wealth gained to game months leaves the feat utterly at the mercy of the campaign. Most 3E campaigns tend to last less then a year in "game time," so you might only get a few hundred gp out of it over the course of the character's life. At the same time, the feat actively encourages PCs to not go out and adventure. You're much better off sitting at home collecting wealth for months at a stretch before venturing off to your next challenge.

Ancestral Relic, from Book of Exalted Deeds, is a much better way of handling this sort of thing.
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

Mangrum wrote:Second, tying the wealth gained to game months leaves the feat utterly at the mercy of the campaign.
Exactly. This same issue showed up multiple times in both HoL and CoD. One example, IIRC, was most of the Propagandist's abilities. That's why I think the money should come when you go up a level, not based on time.

BTW, as an experiment, I went into excel and figured out how much money you'd get if you took the 2nd version I posted above for all 8 of your feats (assume a human). The total is only 172% of normal for a 20th level character, which seems like a waste of 8 feats. I kind of like the idea of someone devoting all their feats to wealth and buying a bunch of spiffy gear, Batman style, instead of getting innate abilities. So I might want to up the numbers a bit.

On the other hand, if you went with my first idea, and took it 8 times, you'd have 400% of starting wealth, which seems broken, but then, you've spent 8 feats to get it, and the wealthiest people in the real world have far more than 4x the money of an average person. So I'm actually thinking that my original version wasn't too bad. Maybe just adjust it to 5% instead of 10%.


I don't think the Wealthy character handing out weapons to his friends is an insurmountable issue either. After all, a cleric hands out hit points to his friends. It's just a matter of playtesting and getting the numbers to make sense, I think.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
Eric the Light Bringer
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 67
Joined: Wed Jan 03, 2007 2:06 pm
Location: Ontario, Canada

Post by Eric the Light Bringer »

gonzoron wrote:It's just a matter of playtesting and getting the numbers to make sense, I think.
I like your ideas, but is the feat really worth allowing in your campaign if you need that much work to make it "work"? :wink:
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7107
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

Mangrum wrote: Got it in one. In 3E D&D, equipment (wealth) is a critical component of a PC's power level. A PC who lacks the standard amount of gear for his level generally isn't up to challenges that, by the letter of the rules, should pose a fair challenge. This isn't generally a big deal at the lowest levels (since PCs generally don't have much equipment then), but wealth becomes increasingly vital at higher levels.
I see what you meant. But FYI in my campaign, what the PC can't buy because they lack cash, they usually can get through an exchange of service, with say the Ezra Church of Mordent.

I prefer to do it this way, it's funnier RP IMHO, and makes more future adventure hooks in the campaign. And it does mean they do not lack gold platted weapons or standard alchemical stuff when needs be.

Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

Eric the Light Bringer wrote:I like your ideas, but is the feat really worth allowing in your campaign if you need that much work to make it "work"? :wink:
Hey, what else have I got to do? ;)

My mindset is: if the player has a cool idea, find a way to make it work. In this case, I think the book did have a cool idea, and if a player wanted the feat, I'd make it work. The above was just some random musings during a slow day at work.

Joel, remember that the money comes in a method the DM sees fit. If the cash bothers you, make it unearthed family heirlooms, or objects of art that the PC must then unload, and put in the roleplaying there. :azalin:

For an Aristocrat born into wealth:
"Dearest Son, your mother redecorated the foyer again and she found no good place to put this marble statue of a wolf that used to sit on the mantle. I seem to recall you were quite fond of it as a child, so I had Jeeves deliver it to you. Do with it as you will. - Father."

For a self-made merchant:
"Boss, I found a great deal on molasses and snapped up 20 barrels. Unfortunately, I didn't realize we can't possibly make enough tarts to use up 20 barrels anytime soon. The shop is quite crowded with all these barrels, and the clutter is driving the customers away. Can you find a buyer up North where you are that we could ship them to?" - your faithful assistant, Bob."

etc....
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Joel: I humbly disagree with you. As a player I would like my 12th level hero live in some luxury at least. Also most players I know also like their characters (once they reach higher levels) live in luxury. I.e you have saved the world a couple of times and you have saved more villages from threats than you care to count... and you have to think twice before buying a couple of beers?

And I see nothing wrong with strongholds BTW. You defeat the bad guy and his army... why not take his stronghold?
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7107
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

gonzoron wrote:Joel, remember that the money comes in a method the DM sees fit. If the cash bothers you, make it unearthed family heirlooms, or objects of art that the PC must then unload, and put in the roleplaying there. :azalin:

For an Aristocrat born into wealth:
"Dearest Son, your mother redecorated the foyer again and she found no good place to put this marble statue of a wolf that used to sit on the mantle. I seem to recall you were quite fond of it as a child, so I had Jeeves deliver it to you. Do with it as you will. - Father."

For a self-made merchant:
"Boss, I found a great deal on molasses and snapped up 20 barrels. Unfortunately, I didn't realize we can't possibly make enough tarts to use up 20 barrels anytime soon. The shop is quite crowded with all these barrels, and the clutter is driving the customers away. Can you find a buyer up North where you are that we could ship them to?" - your faithful assistant, Bob."

etc....
Sure, that would be a fun way to do it :) With this feat, that PC should concentrate on his business or family matters a fair number of hours per month to get the money. Sounds fair if the money level is high.
As a player I would like my 12th level hero live in some luxury at least. Also most players I know also like their characters (once they reach higher levels) live in luxury. I.e you have saved the world a couple of times and you have saved more villages from threats than you care to count... and you have to think twice before buying a couple of beers?
Hey, I never said they should be poor and living as beggars :) I just said higher level should of course be much richer than commoners, and able to live very comfortably should they decide to stop adventuring.

But my point is, I think that in Ravenloft, an equivalent level character would be less wealthy than in FR or Greyhawk. A lich you defeat in Ravenloft isn’t sitting on the same pile of magical items and gold pieces as elsewhere. He won’t be naked of course, but his list of items will be lower than in FR (in number of items and in power), and so logically the number of gold pieces in his coffers should be lower too.

It's simply that monsters in RL are not as big loot as in other world - in the adventures well made, the number of gold pieces found is not that high. And it's because of the specificity of the RL setting. With monster character development in RL, the monsters often have other types of craving in Ravenloft than just power and greed as it is often the case in other setting. The same logic we apply to magic items being rare should also apply for gold pieces, while in a less dramatic decrease than magical item.

So that 265 gp we were talking of is a lot of money in Ravenloft, even if you are high level.
And I see nothing wrong with strongholds BTW. You defeat the bad guy and his army... why not take his stronghold?
Sure, that's an easy and fun way to get it :)

However, still I do not see a 12 level fighter accumulating gold pieces in Ravenloft, without the convenience of magic items for stocking, to build a stronghold. Putting it in the bank? Perhaps. The idea of stronghold in Ravenloft doesn't fit IMHO - somewhat too fantasy I guess, and not down to earth as Ravenloft people would be, that is IMHO.

A nice house in a great neighbourhood in Levkarest, sure. It might have traps and other devices to sleep without fear. But a stronghold per se, in the medieval castle sense, it seems out of place.

And none of the mid-high level adventuring NPCs in canon books do have one anyway, IIRC. They are wanderers or have normal houses AFAIK.

Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Well, if it suits you and your players, then that's fine Gotten. :) BTW I have a far more fantasy theme in my Ravenloft campaigns than what is considered "usual". I use dragons, giants etc. OK, flying castles and cities on the skies are out as well as pegasus riding elf lancers but I have no problem with castles etc. Just my opinion though.

On the equipment/CR thing: Yeah, if you give less equipment the characters are less prepared to fight the big monsters out there... So, where's the problem?
11th level char with half the equipment is the equivalent of an 9th level character... so you drop onto such a party CR 9 monsters and award a bit more XP. :)
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7107
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

Joël of the FoS wrote:
As a player I would like my 12th level hero live in some luxury at least. Also most players I know also like their characters (once they reach higher levels) live in luxury. I.e you have saved the world a couple of times and you have saved more villages from threats than you care to count... and you have to think twice before buying a couple of beers?
Hey, I never said they should be poor and living as beggars :) I just said higher level should of course be much richer than commoners, and able to live very comfortably should they decide to stop adventuring.

But my point is, I think that in Ravenloft, an equivalent level character would be less wealthy than in FR or Greyhawk. A lich you defeat in Ravenloft isn’t sitting on the same pile of magical items and gold pieces as elsewhere. He won’t be naked of course, but his list of items will be lower than in FR (in number of items and in power), and so logically the number of gold pieces in his coffers should be lower too.

It's simply that monsters in RL are not as big loot as in other world - in the adventures well made, the number of gold pieces found is not that high. And it's because of the specificity of the RL setting. With monster character development in RL, the monsters often have other types of craving in Ravenloft than just power and greed as it is often the case in other setting. The same logic we apply to magic items being rare should also apply for gold pieces, while in a less dramatic decrease than magical item.

So that 265 gp we were talking of is a lot of money in Ravenloft, even if you are high level.
Am I the only one with this view? Am I too cheap ;) ?

For those with on going campaign, how many gp does your PC have?

IMC, they are 5th level caracter, and a collective wealth of about 1 000 gp (plus a ex noble PC has a hidden stash, unknown from the other players).

Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
Undead Cabbage
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 623
Joined: Wed Oct 19, 2005 7:39 pm
Location: In one of Neil Gaiman's books, or at least I wish I was.
Contact:

Post by Undead Cabbage »

I do things similarily Joel, limiting the amount of gp the players get.

I'm always aiming for sort of a 'right amount'. Not so little that they feel its hopeless, but enough that if they aren't careful they'll go backrupt.

I also keep their sources of income from areas that make sense. Mainly rewards from the rich, often given under certain conditions. My players will also soon have to open a back account, which means lots and lots of Borcan fun! :twisted:
User avatar
Mangrum
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 811
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2003 1:29 am

Post by Mangrum »

Joël of the FoS wrote:IMC, they are 5th level caracter, and a collective wealth of about 1 000 gp (plus a ex noble PC has a hidden stash, unknown from the other players).
That doesn't tell us much. To know how close you are to average, we'd need to know the value of a given PC's gear. Remember, "wealth" includes magic weapons, armor, scrolls, wands, etc. Thus, add up the gp value of all of a PCs possessions. For a 5th-level PC, the baseline is that it should come out to somewhere between 9,000-13,000 gp (Table 5-1, DMG 137). If it's significantly higher or lower than that margin, you're going to encounter unexpected hiccups in the game unless you keep in mind that an encounter's listed CR/EL doesn't necessarily apply to your PCs.

Like it or nor, 3E D&D is very much a tightly integrated game of resource management, and wealth is a major resource. You have to keep an eye on it.
User avatar
Guardian of Twilight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 428
Joined: Sun Oct 02, 2005 2:34 pm
Location: Mordent

Post by Guardian of Twilight »

Joël of the FoS wrote:
Joël of the FoS wrote:
As a player I would like my 12th level hero live in some luxury at least. Also most players I know also like their characters (once they reach higher levels) live in luxury. I.e you have saved the world a couple of times and you have saved more villages from threats than you care to count... and you have to think twice before buying a couple of beers?
Hey, I never said they should be poor and living as beggars :) I just said higher level should of course be much richer than commoners, and able to live very comfortably should they decide to stop adventuring.

But my point is, I think that in Ravenloft, an equivalent level character would be less wealthy than in FR or Greyhawk. A lich you defeat in Ravenloft isn’t sitting on the same pile of magical items and gold pieces as elsewhere. He won’t be naked of course, but his list of items will be lower than in FR (in number of items and in power), and so logically the number of gold pieces in his coffers should be lower too.

It's simply that monsters in RL are not as big loot as in other world - in the adventures well made, the number of gold pieces found is not that high. And it's because of the specificity of the RL setting. With monster character development in RL, the monsters often have other types of craving in Ravenloft than just power and greed as it is often the case in other setting. The same logic we apply to magic items being rare should also apply for gold pieces, while in a less dramatic decrease than magical item.

So that 265 gp we were talking of is a lot of money in Ravenloft, even if you are high level.
Am I the only one with this view? Am I too cheap ;) ?

For those with on going campaign, how many gp does your PC have?

IMC, they are 5th level caracter, and a collective wealth of about 1 000 gp (plus a ex noble PC has a hidden stash, unknown from the other players).

Joël
I agree with you. I look at acquiring wealth in Ravenloft a bit differently than most other places... like you may get to use certain people with equipment knowledge to help build (or just build) your new weapon. Kind of like in Van Helsing, where he got the new crossbow. I also like using access to personal libraries as a way of rewarding characters. After all, isn't the old saying "Knowledge is power"?

Oh, forgot about just good old fashioned contacts. That is my personal favorite. :)
Seek not in the shadows, for there ye shall find secrets too terrible for mortal man to bear.
-Mordentish proverb
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

I do a periodic "audit" to make sure my characters have approximately the "right amount" of wealth.

At last audit, my group of 8th level characters averaged 31000gp each. That's right between the suggested 27k and 36k for 8th and 9th level characters, respectively. Now, only a small fraction of that is "cash" in the form of coins and gems. About 800gp each in cash.

The vast majority is in the form of magic items, and here's where I think things diverge in RL from your average D&D campaign. The items the group has are generally fewer but bigger. We all know the mantra that every (or nearly every) magic item in RL should have a story, and there are no simple "+1 swords." Well, the story behind an item is usually that much better if the item itself is fairly powerful, i.e. expensive. (yes, you can make a great name and story for a simple item, but it's tougher.)

So as an example, here's the list of one PC:
Staff: +1/+1 Defending, Protection - 26600gp
Rock: Casts Anesthesia and provides +2 fort on command 1/day - 1000gp
Chalice: 1/day/person Cure Light Wounds - 2400gp
Armor: +1 Studded Leather - 1175gp
Cash: 600gp
Miscellaneous nonmagical gear - approx 400gp

The prices of the Rock and Chalice were extrapolated from similar items. The armor is the only "boring" item, and the character paid to have it enchanted while visiting the Arcane Studies dept. of the University of Dementlieu. (The only opportunity to 'buy' magic items bigger than a small potion in the whole campaign, so that's a story in itself.) The rock and chalice were family heirlooms, and the Staff (which is 5/6 of the character's wealth in one object) was a gift from the spirit of a long-dead Knight of the Shadows.

A "great reward" for my PCs for saving a whole town runs in the 1000gp/player range. I don't think the players feel rich by any means. Especially when this PC's greatest wish is a boat trip to Nidala that I priced at 3000-5000gp/ticket.

There are certainly strongholds in Ravenloft. I can name a few: Ravenloft, Avernus, Pantara, Misericordia, Draccipetri, Hunadora, Faarhaven... If one of my players wanted to drop a bunch of money on one, and found a suitable lord to pay fealty to who would grant them some land, why not? But you're right, they'd probably feel more at home, and get more value out of a nice Manor House (like Gryphon Hill or Shloss Mordenheim...) :)
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
Post Reply