Ravenloft = D&D + gothic horror, a good thing?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
Post Reply
User avatar
Scipion_Emilien
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 246
Joined: Thu Jun 23, 2005 6:54 pm

Ravenloft = D&D + gothic horror, a good thing?

Post by Scipion_Emilien »

I was reading the why DM don't like Ravenloft thread, and it help me understand my biggest gripe about Ravenloft. If I do a thread here instead of posting here, it is to have your thought about this particular thing.

My main gripe about Ravenloft is ironically what make it strengh: it is the fusion of two genre, D&D and gothic horror.

I like D&D and I m a fan of historical gothic horror. I like to read the Ravenloft book and own all the collection (even CoD and HoL). On paper, all seem well and good.

The problem arise when I start to DM a game, try to write a novel or think about making a contribution to this wonderful community here. I simply cannot execute the concept correctly. I always fall into one of the two pitfall:

1 - I go to much from a historical standpoint, which lead to great gothic horror. But I need in this case to be restrictive a lot about the magic to not destroy the feel, which lead to the fact that the corrupts guys are often the only one who have magic. I tend too to not have a lot of imagination about the dungeon crawl in this mode and go more with political intrigue than really crawling.It tend to make dull game for players who seem to expect magic even if you say before the game this Ravenloft and why magic isn't widely available. And while the roleplaying aspect is fun, the rules seem to cause trouble in this mode with the 4 encounter by day format who lead to easy nova from the part of the players.

2- I try to avoid the error of 1, and then fall into the pitfall of having a fantasy mentality. The gothic horror aspect then to take the side and I then go like it was a Greyhawk or FR game. While it make good game for the players, the feel of breaking the internal consistency (by having a more fantastic game with more magic and more classical vilains), which is what I like from the setting in the first place, make the game dull for me.

So, how to strike a balance without having to adapt to the setting a whole new rule system? What did I don't exactly understand from the setting that make me alway fall into a pitfall? What are your thougt on the question?
User avatar
Jack of Tears
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 306
Joined: Fri Mar 11, 2005 4:25 pm

re

Post by Jack of Tears »

>>I tend too to not have a lot of imagination about the dungeon crawl in this mode and go more with political intrigue than really crawling.<<

Ravenloft really isn't a setting in which one should be striving to create dungeon crawls. The nature of the world lends itself toward solving mysteries and dealing with the political aspects of scenarios. The evils in RL are real people more often than monsters - and looking at our own history one can certainly see how men are the most vile of evils. (men as a general term, woman certainly fit the bill as well) In fact, one could argue that men are the worst kind of evil because it is in the nature of many monsters to behave as they do, but wickedness in mankind is a wholy voluntary thing.

As to how one can blend the two aspects of the game - there are always, as I've said, mysteries; which often have both political and classic adventure elements. There are the "dreaded crypts and forgotten labyrinths" which are so prevelant in gothic horror; Haunted houses which will involve, not only squaring off against powerful spirits, but investigation, discussion, and research; sewers and alleyways in any large city can provide for dangerous and frightening interludes between social encounters ....

My strongest piece of advice, though, would be to wean your players away from assumptions about the game. My group first began their careers coming from combat heavy, classic dungeon-crawl style adventures and had to be taught to see the value of intrigue, thought, research and discovery. A good way to do this is demonstrate that there are layers of meaning behind even your "typical dungeon" and then leave clues by which these meanings may be discovered and brought to light. In my experience players like to feel as though they are occomplishing something, and the reason they prefer combat is because this provides quick evidence of their success - but, being the people to solve a generations-old mystery or discover the secret which brings down a force of superstitious terror in a region is even more rewarding. Try replacing combat successes with research successes, revelations, social success, etc. - small victories interspersed throughout the larger story.

Hope this helps.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Re: Ravenloft = D&D + gothic horror, a good thing?

Post by alhoon »

Scipion_Emilien wrote:I was reading the why DM don't like Ravenloft thread, and it help me understand my biggest gripe about Ravenloft. If I do a thread here instead of posting here, it is to have your thought about this particular thing.

My main gripe about Ravenloft is ironically what make it strengh: it is the fusion of two genre, D&D and gothic horror.

I like D&D and I m a fan of historical gothic horror. I like to read the Ravenloft book and own all the collection (even CoD and HoL). On paper, all seem well and good.

The problem arise when I start to DM a game, try to write a novel or think about making a contribution to this wonderful community here. I simply cannot execute the concept correctly. I always fall into one of the two pitfall:

1 - I go to much from a historical standpoint, which lead to great gothic horror. But I need in this case to be restrictive a lot about the magic to not destroy the feel, which lead to the fact that the corrupts guys are often the only one who have magic. I tend too to not have a lot of imagination about the dungeon crawl in this mode and go more with political intrigue than really crawling.It tend to make dull game for players who seem to expect magic even if you say before the game this Ravenloft and why magic isn't widely available. And while the roleplaying aspect is fun, the rules seem to cause trouble in this mode with the 4 encounter by day format who lead to easy nova from the part of the players.

2- I try to avoid the error of 1, and then fall into the pitfall of having a fantasy mentality. The gothic horror aspect then to take the side and I then go like it was a Greyhawk or FR game. While it make good game for the players, the feel of breaking the internal consistency (by having a more fantastic game with more magic and more classical vilains), which is what I like from the setting in the first place, make the game dull for me.

So, how to strike a balance without having to adapt to the setting a whole new rule system? What did I don't exactly understand from the setting that make me alway fall into a pitfall? What are your thougt on the question?
I would go with the "weekend in hell" option in your case.

Have them in Grayhawk, fighting on pegasi against the evil sorceress in the flying castle and her horde of griffons.
Have them, in the critical moment of the battle of the two armies, burst the sealed portal to the plane of fire that lies deep in the deep cave with the "riddle golem statue guards" so that the fire sweeps away the army of the evil dragon.
Heck, have them rescue the beautiful princes from the tower of the evil wizard while he is away that is guarded by a dragon.

... And then something goes wrong.
- at the moment of her death the sorceress curses them;
- the magic sealing of the portal resonates weirdly;
- The evil wizard isn't too happy they stole his bride and spends his remaining resources from his wrecked castle to cast a spell on them;

...
and they end up in Ravenloft.
Here they don't even speak the language. Their magic is corruptive. Xenophobic people look them as they bring trouble. The local villain folds them in his plans, sealing their fate in an evertwisting web of intrigue.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Le Noir Faineant
Rafe, Agent of the Fraternity
Rafe, Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 4592
Joined: Thu Jan 06, 2005 12:25 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Barovia

Post by Le Noir Faineant »

Since *certain unnamed setting for 3rd edition D&D* claims that its flavour is

Pirates of the Caribbean meets The Maltese Falcon,

I still feel myself on the winning side. :P
User avatar
Isabella
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1859
Joined: Mon May 30, 2005 12:54 am

Post by Isabella »

We once ran a game set in Dementlieu that worked pretty well. It helped that we were all low level. It seemed to be a good set-up, though - the rich nobles could afford magicians, keeping the political power as the status quo. The three main "powerblocks" in the campaign (Dominic, The Brain, and Lord Casteele) were no pushovers. Magic was not tossed about in the streets because such things were not done, and anyone who did such things would recieve a rather stern envoy from the city guard. Basically, society kept things in check.

The elven bard actually caused the Ravenloft version of the French Revolution with a ritual he designed, but it was the most gothic moment of the game. I guess it just depends on how you roll with things.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
User avatar
Mortepierre
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 182
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2004 6:20 am
Location: Belgium

Post by Mortepierre »

Personally, I think the "native campaign" from the start works best in RL.

For starter, the PC won't be used to "normal" campaign worlds where fireballs are tossed about on a daily basis and where knights in shining armor really are defenders of all that is good and holy.

By using natives, you get to explain a few things to your players about what people do and (especially) don't do over here.

The one thing a DM must keep in mind is that RL isn't designed for your average dungeon-crawl (though there can be a few of those on occasion). In a sense, it's closer to d20 modern than to "classic" D&D since RL "adventurers" usually don't go looking for trouble. Trouble finds them readily enough!

By making them start as native at 1st lvl, you'll be able to limit their access to equipment & magic (if needs be; although I try not to in my own campaign) and choose the environment where they get to cut their teeth (so to speak).

My latest campaign started in Valachan where the PC were hired to protect a small loggers community in the nearby wilderness of Verbrek. It grew from there. It has a middle-age feel. Most people are uneducated. Wild beasts are plentiful (and recognized as dangerous). And the local darklord can be portrayed as a tough yet fair nobleman that remains logical. The proximity of Sithicus means occasional contact with "feys" (read: elves). At first, the players thought that it felt like a toned-down D&D campaign but now they are enjoying the differences.

I could just as easily have started a campaign in the NW part of the Core where the PC would have been highly educated but less than adept at swinging blades.

I guess it depends a lot on what your players expect of the game and what they are ready to accept. If they are the die-hard hack-and-slash type, RL is probably not for them, apart from a short "week-end in Hell" campaign.
[b]Mortepierre Malepeste[/b]
[i]Dwarven Necro.. er .. Student of Anatomy[/i]
Jonathan Winters
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 435
Joined: Mon Jul 05, 2004 8:23 pm
Location: Montreal, Quebec

Post by Jonathan Winters »

I went through something similar to this a couple of years ago.

My advice: Ask your players what kind of game they want. Then let them know what kind of game you want. You might surprised...

Then: Find some compromise (if you have to).

My game went from "politics / mysteries" to ""mysteries / a couple of fights a session".

That was my compromise. Same storyline, but with more fights thrown in.

It might not be "pure RL", but I still have a game going. :)

And for the record, "RL is not set up for dungeon-crawls": Off the top of my head, I can think of Castles RL, Forlorn, Avernus, the prison in Falkovnia, probably some crypts or what-not's in Hazlan, spending the night in the forest in Kartakass or Valachan, an old forgotten laboratory in Lamordia found on a mountain, Necropolis (if you find a way in without dying), sewers of Richemulot & Paridon, a sealed off crypt in the Amber Wastes, survive the cold and wild beasts of the Frozen Reaches, etc.

I guess what I am trying to say is that the developpers made it so you still have a choice in what kind of game you'd like to play.

Just my two cents...

Patrick
User avatar
Mortepierre
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 182
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2004 6:20 am
Location: Belgium

Post by Mortepierre »

When I said that RL wasn't set up for traditional dungeon crawls, I meant that you'll never find a "dungeon" with monsters in it who are there for no logical reason apart from guarding an illogical amount of treasure.

All the places you described can, indeed, be considered dungeons but their inhabitants have a personal history and their own motivations for being there and not leaving. Not to mention that riches don't come easy in RL. Even if you cleared up every last room of Castle Forlorn, for instance, I doubt you would find ten chests full of gold pieces to reward you for your troubles...

In essence, letting a "normal" D&D group run through a RL dungeon will probably leave them frustrated. Monsters won't react as usual and they'll have nothing to show for it but stuff their characters probably won't deem important.
[b]Mortepierre Malepeste[/b]
[i]Dwarven Necro.. er .. Student of Anatomy[/i]
User avatar
Jakob
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 472
Joined: Thu Aug 05, 2004 3:43 am
Gender: Male
Location: Near Milano, Italy.
Contact:

Post by Jakob »

I simply think Ravenloft, even more than the "your-standard-fantasy-setting", should be dedicated to "telling a story" than "random adventures stitched together with spit" (can we say "spit" on this board? :lol:).
If you create a story, then the problem of merging gothic and D&D is nowhere to be found. :wink:

The DM has the responsability of knowing WHERE and HOW to take the story... All this while not making the PC feel restricted.
Being DM in Ravenloft is HARD. :)
I coloni rovinavano la foresta costruendo il capolavoro dell'uomo civilizzato: il deserto.
- Luis Sepúlveda
Jonathan Winters
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 435
Joined: Mon Jul 05, 2004 8:23 pm
Location: Montreal, Quebec

Post by Jonathan Winters »

Hi Mortepierre,

I apologize if I sounded like I was bashing your point of view! I didn't mean it that way.

I just meant that if you want to dungeon crawl in RL, well you can. We're in the middle of Castles Forlorn in my campaign and my players are enjoying the change of pace I think: Goblyns, wererats, powerful ghosts, etc. All this while chasing down a murderer who fled (was captured?) to Tristenoira...

Actually, my main problem right now is trying to convey the sense of Forlorn's history without ramming ghost encounters down their throat so they get it... (Advice is welcome. Even from Joël even though he might be present at the next game! That's just how desperate I am at the moment! :) )

Patrick

PS: Make RL what works best for yourself and your PCs.
User avatar
Mortepierre
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 182
Joined: Wed Aug 25, 2004 6:20 am
Location: Belgium

Post by Mortepierre »

Jonathan Winters wrote:Hi Mortepierre,

I apologize if I sounded like I was bashing your point of view! I didn't mean it that way.
No offense taken Patrick. I was actually afraid I hadn't made my first post clear enough.
Jonathan Winters wrote:I just meant that if you want to dungeon crawl in RL, well you can. We're in the middle of Castles Forlorn in my campaign and my players are enjoying the change of pace I think: Goblyns, wererats, powerful ghosts, etc. All this while chasing down a murderer who fled (was captured?) to Tristenoira...

Actually, my main problem right now is trying to convey the sense of Forlorn's history without ramming ghost encounters down their throat so they get it... (Advice is welcome. Even from Joël even though he might be present at the next game! That's just how desperate I am at the moment! :) )
Well, in my experience, Forlorn's history is best conveyed by making the PC use the time-travel properties of the castle and then having them witness key events (as was suggested in the Castle Forlorn boxed set IIRC). Works rather well, especially if they later run into the ghost of someone they met in the past. Just make sure they don't understand Tristan's story well enough (at first) to interfere with the events that shaped him to be the local darklord. If you manage to pull that stunt, your players should be screaming "If only we had known when we first met him!" by the end of the campaign :twisted:
[b]Mortepierre Malepeste[/b]
[i]Dwarven Necro.. er .. Student of Anatomy[/i]
User avatar
Scipion_Emilien
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 246
Joined: Thu Jun 23, 2005 6:54 pm

Post by Scipion_Emilien »

Jakob wrote:The DM has the responsability of knowing WHERE and HOW to take the story... All this while not making the PC feel restricted.
Being DM in Ravenloft is HARD. :)
In fact, my two problems could be resume by this phrase. Im not able to lead the story without making the PC feel restrict in their choice. I either go too far in one direction or another.

There is too the problem of the players, I seem to hit two kind of players:

Poor roleplayers that are juste boring to play with. And that Im not able to teach them roleplaying to them. (More because I don't know how than really because the players are stupid).

Or good roleplayers, but who are to much use to the FR mentality. They expect magic item and a greater freedom of movement even when you told hem it's not exactly like that in this game. They are too afraid of nothing. Im currently playing servant of darkness and they take more time convincing Wyan that being ill during the girl was free is a stupid coincidence than actually trying to found proof to free the girl...
User avatar
Igor the Henchman
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 832
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 6:50 pm

Post by Igor the Henchman »

It seems to me you're asking two distinct questions, here. The one in the thread title is whether gothic horror and classic D&D make a good mix. Then, there's your concerns regarding your group and your difficulty in running memorable adventures for them.

I have a pretty strong opinion on the first question: its an adamant "YES". From day one, Ravenloft has been designed as a "variation on the genre" setting, to give jaded players and DMs an occasion for a healthy change of pace. Ravenloft is still fundamentally D&D, with classic horror fiction used for inspiration in bits and places. When you try to push the setting (as written) too much into the "pure" gothic horror territory (not that it can't be done), you end up hitting a lot of inconsistencies and contradictions, such as an abundant presence of non-human races and other fantasy stereotypes.

I think that, even with the recent trend to increase setting consistency, Ravenloft has never been any more realistic, logical or internally consistent than your old Greyhawk or Forgotten Realms. D&D gaming has a tradition of using internal logic when convenient, but also knowing to shove it away when it stands in the way of interesting adventure design. Its no different with Ravenloft. If you like Ravenloft atmosphere, but prefer a more realistic approach, I stongly recommend giving Masque of the Red Death a look. Ravenloft with less D&D is exactly what Gothic Earth is.

Now about the difficulty for designing and running Ravenloft adventures. By far the most important advice I have to give is: never forget its your game, and your world - and your players', too, by the way. So don't worry about "getting it right" - your concern is to run a fun game for yourself and the group.

You have, you say, a pretty complete collection of Ravenloft products. I imagine you might feel you've invested so much in your setting savvy, that you're not quite doing it right if your game doesn't have the exact sort of flavor your books seem to suggest. But what the books say or imply shouldn't shackle creative DM work. If you don't feel comfortable DMing your game as it is, change it so you do.

You can ditch half the canon domains, include encounters with a flock of red dragons and turn Madame Eva into a succubus, and if you see your players having a hell of a time at the table, and chat about it in between sessions, know that you're running a great Ravenloft game. Same if you've banned spellcasting and gave the game a more historical feel (though in my experience, you really should have the right kind of players to attempt it).

Also, you probably shouldn't concern yourself with "teaching" your players to roleplay. In my personal experience, its something one learns oneself at one's own personal pace. The best "compromise" I've found in dealing with the sorts of players you have is throwing them an occasional bone by including no-brainer hack-and-slash encounters or magical treasure every once in a while. After all, its all about letting the players have some fun in your world - and when they enjoy your game, that's when you start enjoying it for yourself, too.

In short: try not to overthink your game, and don't be afraid to trust your group's tastes. That's the best way to sum up my advice, I think.
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

Scipion_Emilien wrote:
Jakob wrote:The DM has the responsability of knowing WHERE and HOW to take the story... All this while not making the PC feel restricted.
Being DM in Ravenloft is HARD. :)
In fact, my two problems could be resume by this phrase. Im not able to lead the story without making the PC feel restrict in their choice. I either go too far in one direction or another.

There is too the problem of the players, I seem to hit two kind of players:

Poor roleplayers that are juste boring to play with. And that Im not able to teach them roleplaying to them. (More because I don't know how than really because the players are stupid).

Or good roleplayers, but who are to much use to the FR mentality. They expect magic item and a greater freedom of movement even when you told hem it's not exactly like that in this game. They are too afraid of nothing. Im currently playing servant of darkness and they take more time convincing Wyan that being ill during the girl was free is a stupid coincidence than actually trying to found proof to free the girl...
I've felt exactly the same, and I only began having real fun with my game when I dropped some expectations I had as DM and accepted my campaign would never be as in the books. I have to agree with most of what Igor said in reply to you.

Alex
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
Post Reply