Is it Epic? Is it Ravenloft?
- Nathan of the FoS
- Fiendish Enforcer

- Posts: 5247
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
- Location: San Francisco CA
I would have to say that feeling responsible for people (heck, being responsible for people) was probably the key challenge for most of the party. In a sense Peregrine actually had an advantage over, say, Cortez, because he had relatively little to be responsible for in terms of "people actually on the scene".
Also, his coming was relatively obscured by the advent of Cortez' fleet, and therefore attracted rather less attention than it might otherwise have done.
His personal problems more than made up for that, though. In a way I guess I made it easy on DeepShadow; Peregrine was designed to be his own worst enemy, which gave DS lots of options for ways to challenge him (me?).
Also, his coming was relatively obscured by the advent of Cortez' fleet, and therefore attracted rather less attention than it might otherwise have done.
His personal problems more than made up for that, though. In a way I guess I made it easy on DeepShadow; Peregrine was designed to be his own worst enemy, which gave DS lots of options for ways to challenge him (me?).
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
- Undead Cabbage
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 623
- Joined: Wed Oct 19, 2005 7:39 pm
- Location: In one of Neil Gaiman's books, or at least I wish I was.
- Contact:
I'll say this:
I'm sorry, but I haven't really had time to seriously read Reckonings.
I am not a fan of epic level adventures, and I don't think I'd ever personally run an epic level Ravenloft myself.
However: I absolutely support the idea of your experimenting like this. I think its awesome that you're trying something new. Just because it's different from conventional Ravenloft, it doesn't mean it's automatically wrong. It really takes a lot to go out on a limb and try something new with the setting, so I can really respect what you're doing
.
Just think what D&D would be like now, if nobody tried anything new or experimented?
I'm curious to see how the experiment turns out, and again I'm really sorry that I haven't had the time to give Reckonings a serious read.
I'm sorry, but I haven't really had time to seriously read Reckonings.
I am not a fan of epic level adventures, and I don't think I'd ever personally run an epic level Ravenloft myself.
However: I absolutely support the idea of your experimenting like this. I think its awesome that you're trying something new. Just because it's different from conventional Ravenloft, it doesn't mean it's automatically wrong. It really takes a lot to go out on a limb and try something new with the setting, so I can really respect what you're doing
Just think what D&D would be like now, if nobody tried anything new or experimented?
I'm curious to see how the experiment turns out, and again I'm really sorry that I haven't had the time to give Reckonings a serious read.
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
Of course. This is but one example; I was merely trying to demonstrate that it was possible, therefore I didn't need a large number of scenarios.alhoon wrote:Actually I think it depend how you play the Epics and how you play the Ravenloft.
Excellent question! Part of how I enforced the information asymmetry when it came to divination was by engaging the players: they had to know ask the right questions in order to get the right answers, and they had to know how to interpret the answers in order to get the crucial information out of them. For example, when Ciera cast legend lore, she got this:You say that they didn't have enough info and were 99% blind. How is that possible at such a level?
Like bloodhounds for a scent they came
As arrows were their speed
We did not fight, but raised the flag,
And begged the Vengeance heed
Heedless they came and slaughtered all
No mercy in their wake,
Till finally the Dragon came
And chose us two to take.
"Mercy at last," the bosun said.
"Some kindness from your court?"
"No, I've saved the girl to warm my bed,"
"And you to give my sport!"
The sharks had come to feed their fill
On the corpses of my friends
Among their frenzied, foaming jaws
The bosun found his end.
I warmed his bed and body, too,
Though my own blood was cold.
I dared not ponder on my fate
When he found my pleasure old.
Listen well and listen long
To a story I must tell
I bend these words and forge this song
From weeks adrift in Hell
He set me free to bare this tale
And spread his legend wide
This task is done, but one thing more
Rests with me to decide
For in my belly grows his whelp
A Dragon yet to be
Let gods forgive who've scorned me help
They'll chart no course for me
Now, this verse contains clues about the Sea Dragon's methods, his curse, and his relationship to the ghost Kiraslee Malnano, but the players don't get that for free. Being epic, their spells do indeed give them a ton of information, but they still have to sift and interpret it.
To extend the "blind" analogy, there are many, many ways in which one can be blind. In some cases, people who were blind from birth have been granted sight by surgery later in life, only to discover that they can't function as seeing people, because their brains--while technically undamaged--have not learned the schemas by which they can sort and interpret visual information.
Ravenloft, in this case, was a blind spot in many ways. Many divinations didn't work there, and those that did gave information that lacked a frame of reference. Ciera's discern location, for example, told the name of the ship, Saragossan faction, domain and cluster that the queen was in, but these were not the same as directions.
I get your point, and if that's how you want to play high-level gaming, go for it. Me, OTOH, I'd point out that any spell that puts a 9th level spell to shame must be at least 10th level, and therefor uncastable by an 18th level character.When you're a 18th lvl wizard/cleric you devise the ultimate infogathering/warning spell that puts legend lore to shame (and discern location, and divination etc) and you research it/pray for it.
Part of how I kept the challenge up was by being a stickler for rules.
There's a circular logic to that that I could have a field day with. Ever seen Minority Report?So when you're 25th level for example you say "I cast my "Superhero's warning" spell and I learn in a full round action who will attack me today, why and where he/she/it/they hide at."
I'd have no problem with this combo. I'd give the PC's a vision of the most important fight they'd have--probably with Draga or some uber-fiend--but that vision can't cover everything. It should give them some major pieces of advice for that fight, but some of those pieces of advice should be open to interpretation.Actually with a simple divination spell (the 4th level version) you have a 90% chance to read correctly when you'll be attacked (within the week) or who will attack you. Then you throw in a vision spell and a discern location.
For example, if someone cast that at this point in the game, they'd get a vision of what appeared to be one of the PC's killing one of the others. In fact, one of the people in the vision would be an imposter, and if the PC's figure that out at the critical moment, they might make very different choices on how to react than if they thought that both characters in the vision were genuine.
"Misinformation" is so gauche.All those spells work in Ravenloft (OK you have a 10% of missinformation with the divination, but it isn't too much.)
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
Thanks! Yeah, it's really pushed me to the limits, but then it's been very rewarding, too. I can't wait to move the story ahead; maybe this thread will increase attention and get me more feedback!Funk wrote:I am eagerly awaiting results, DeepShadow
As someone who's always pushed the limits of my Ravenloft games, I really can't wait to read what you've found out!
That said, I'd like to hear others judge before I give my full results. The links I posted above in the original thread were so you all can evaluate and see how I did. I'll try to refrain from swaying the discussion either way before I reveal my own conclusions.
Of course, I seem to have already come to the defense of my game from Lost Heretic, so let me be clear: I was speaking there about the EL of darklords and other encounters, not about the actual ability to make an epic game out of non-epic foes. Inflating EL's is a number crunch, and as such can be demonstrated as a fact, especially as high as EL 15. Stringing a bunch of drastically inflated encounters into an adventure is a whole different ball of wax.
For those of you who would like to help me evaluate, let me tell you my chief concern when inflating the EL's this high. As you can infer from my response to alhoon above, challenging epic-level characters in this way usually means exercising a level of DM nastiness that treads dangerously close to...being a jerk. My biggest concern with this game was not that it wasn't possible to challenge the PC's statistically, but that they only way to do so would be to stack everything against them in such a way as to suck all the fun out of the game. I mean, one of my flagship concepts was to throw real-life problems at them that can't be solved by violence...but many people play the game to get away from those kinds of problems!
So click the links in the opening post, and ask questions about what you see there. How would you feel about a DM who skewed the world against you this way? Would it impair your enjoyment of the game?
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
And on that note, let's look at another technique that played a role in this game:
* Divide and Conquer--There is, unfortunately, much more of this than I originally intended to use! PC's started leaving the party when the first entered RL, and the party has remained split in one form or another ever since. Well over half the party divisions were imposed by the DM because one player or another had dropped out for a time. Some of the more notable encounters while PC's were alone included: Cortez ambushed by sahuagin, Anders fighting with Ashkar, (and conversely, the ships get attacked in their absence), Peregrine decimating the Raveners, Tessius fleeing Blaustein, Ciera's conflict with Draga (FoS Posted: Sat Mar 18, 2006 10:28 pm), and Balin getting ambushed and robbed (FoS, Posted: Wed Aug 02, 2006 2:09 am).
* Divide and Conquer--There is, unfortunately, much more of this than I originally intended to use! PC's started leaving the party when the first entered RL, and the party has remained split in one form or another ever since. Well over half the party divisions were imposed by the DM because one player or another had dropped out for a time. Some of the more notable encounters while PC's were alone included: Cortez ambushed by sahuagin, Anders fighting with Ashkar, (and conversely, the ships get attacked in their absence), Peregrine decimating the Raveners, Tessius fleeing Blaustein, Ciera's conflict with Draga (FoS Posted: Sat Mar 18, 2006 10:28 pm), and Balin getting ambushed and robbed (FoS, Posted: Wed Aug 02, 2006 2:09 am).
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
For anyone finding reading the whole experiment (or even the summary threads) daunting, (which is completely understandable, it's a LOT of text), here's a brief, brief, brief summary.
Ciera, the ancient sorceress in a child's body, her monk bodyguard Kinketsu, and shadow asp familiar Nephys, Saint Balin and his dragon steed Sariel, Tessius the shadowdancing spymaster with his Shadow Companion Invictus, and Cortez, the pirate-hunting paladin, along with his cohort, the swashbuckling elf Shadross, and Mount Cutter, set out from Impiltur aboard Cortez's four ships full of followers in search of the missing royal family and the wizard Arcadius, who were lost at sea and encountered something called The Red Foam.
They are soon joined by the psion Anders and his psicrystal Cal, and recieve word that the flotilla may be infiltrated by a doppleganger who is sabotaging the mission. Along the way, they fend off a Kraken and an army of Sahaugin with servant beasts, and deal with suspicion and conflict among the crew. The investigation leads to bleeding ghost, Kiraslee Milano, victim of the Sea Dragon, Draga Salt-Biter, whose blood creates the Red Foam, a mistway to Ravenloft. Within the Mistway, they face mist ferrymen and a will o' sea in the form of a ghostly ship, and learn a bit about Ravenloft though divination and deduction.
The Flotilla arrives in Saragoss, but Balin, Sariel, and Tessius don't arrive with them. (Balin ends up in Ghastria, Tessius in the Nightmare Lands, and Sariel lost in the Mist until he also arrives in Saragoss). Once there, they have to deal with the local dialect so full of slang that even magical translation has difficulty, rampant disease, vengeful ghosts, a curse, sabotage, rival factions, sahaugin raiders, a traitorous vampire wizard, a witch above the water and another below, a darklord angered by their intrusion, and a royal family that has suffered greatly, not all of whom even want to be rescued.
Meanwhile, Arcadius found help back in the Core in the form of Shepherd Peregrine Wayfarer, High Inquisitor of Ezra, the only native PC, who's already got Gwydion mad at him, and may in fact be the result of Vecna's attempt to reincarnate himself. Peregrine eventually arrives in Saragoss and deals with a ship full of living and undead ghouls, including their voodan leader, The Keeper of the Raiment of Clarity. Ciera lets herself be captured in order to find Draga, and succeeds, imprisoning him in a lifeboat, infected with Cackle Fever (I think?). And right about then, Peregrine meets up with the rest of the party while they are under attack by a ghost using a nasty twist on a phantom shift along with his minions.
Meanwhile, Balin and Tessius eventually meet up through means of a slightly twisted wish, and head to Blaustein, where Tessius slays Bluebeard and Balin slays Van Riese and they then have to deal with a rescue operation due to the two domains crumbling around them as Saragoss is pulled into the void, becoming part of the Sea of Sorrows.
phew... and that's the short version. did I miss anything important?
Ciera, the ancient sorceress in a child's body, her monk bodyguard Kinketsu, and shadow asp familiar Nephys, Saint Balin and his dragon steed Sariel, Tessius the shadowdancing spymaster with his Shadow Companion Invictus, and Cortez, the pirate-hunting paladin, along with his cohort, the swashbuckling elf Shadross, and Mount Cutter, set out from Impiltur aboard Cortez's four ships full of followers in search of the missing royal family and the wizard Arcadius, who were lost at sea and encountered something called The Red Foam.
They are soon joined by the psion Anders and his psicrystal Cal, and recieve word that the flotilla may be infiltrated by a doppleganger who is sabotaging the mission. Along the way, they fend off a Kraken and an army of Sahaugin with servant beasts, and deal with suspicion and conflict among the crew. The investigation leads to bleeding ghost, Kiraslee Milano, victim of the Sea Dragon, Draga Salt-Biter, whose blood creates the Red Foam, a mistway to Ravenloft. Within the Mistway, they face mist ferrymen and a will o' sea in the form of a ghostly ship, and learn a bit about Ravenloft though divination and deduction.
The Flotilla arrives in Saragoss, but Balin, Sariel, and Tessius don't arrive with them. (Balin ends up in Ghastria, Tessius in the Nightmare Lands, and Sariel lost in the Mist until he also arrives in Saragoss). Once there, they have to deal with the local dialect so full of slang that even magical translation has difficulty, rampant disease, vengeful ghosts, a curse, sabotage, rival factions, sahaugin raiders, a traitorous vampire wizard, a witch above the water and another below, a darklord angered by their intrusion, and a royal family that has suffered greatly, not all of whom even want to be rescued.
Meanwhile, Arcadius found help back in the Core in the form of Shepherd Peregrine Wayfarer, High Inquisitor of Ezra, the only native PC, who's already got Gwydion mad at him, and may in fact be the result of Vecna's attempt to reincarnate himself. Peregrine eventually arrives in Saragoss and deals with a ship full of living and undead ghouls, including their voodan leader, The Keeper of the Raiment of Clarity. Ciera lets herself be captured in order to find Draga, and succeeds, imprisoning him in a lifeboat, infected with Cackle Fever (I think?). And right about then, Peregrine meets up with the rest of the party while they are under attack by a ghost using a nasty twist on a phantom shift along with his minions.
Meanwhile, Balin and Tessius eventually meet up through means of a slightly twisted wish, and head to Blaustein, where Tessius slays Bluebeard and Balin slays Van Riese and they then have to deal with a rescue operation due to the two domains crumbling around them as Saragoss is pulled into the void, becoming part of the Sea of Sorrows.
phew... and that's the short version. did I miss anything important?
Last edited by Gonzoron of the FoS on Fri Feb 23, 2007 11:49 am, edited 1 time in total.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Nathan of the FoS
- Fiendish Enforcer

- Posts: 5247
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
- Location: San Francisco CA
Hot dang...the doppelganger made it aboard after all.DeepShadow wrote:For example, if someone cast that at this point in the game, they'd get a vision of what appeared to be one of the PC's killing one of the others. In fact, one of the people in the vision would be an imposter, and if the PC's figure that out at the critical moment, they might make very different choices on how to react than if they thought that both characters in the vision were genuine.
Well, that's exciting. Was that to be one of Peregrine's chances to reveal his spiffy Inquisitor abilities, DS?
Man, the more we talk the more bummed I am that it's too much work to finish it up right.
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Wow, you really have though a lot about it! Usually when we play High-to-Epic levels around here, the characters get... diminished somehow. Example:
When you're 2nd level the average road bandit is 1st-2nd level warrior. When you're 10th level he suddenly is 2nd level fighter/ 1st level rogue. When you're 18th level the average road bandit is 3rd fighter/4 ranger/2 rogue.
I hate that.
But you didn't deny the power of the high levels. You play them as high levels, not as average levels with flashier spells and more hit points (which is moot as everyone they encounter does more damage).
The only thing I would like to press on is this:
No, that's not to just disagree and say "in three pages long answer I disagree here" but to point out that the divinations of 15th+ level characters are almost unstoppable.
Of course I agree with the technique of "giving them the clues, very useful hints but not the solution". This sets things right except one thing:
An intelligence score of 26-30.
A character that smart who is doing that for the last 10 years or so, should be able to intepret the meaning of the divination correctly and in depth. Which only leads us to another question:
How do you deal with epic-high mental ability scores?
What about Epic-high skill modifiers?
A 25th level bard could well hit a +45 to diplomacy checks, with just an item that gives +10 to diplomacy.
PS. Sorry if I strech this conversation but each answer just spawns more questions.
When you're 2nd level the average road bandit is 1st-2nd level warrior. When you're 10th level he suddenly is 2nd level fighter/ 1st level rogue. When you're 18th level the average road bandit is 3rd fighter/4 ranger/2 rogue.
I hate that.
But you didn't deny the power of the high levels. You play them as high levels, not as average levels with flashier spells and more hit points (which is moot as everyone they encounter does more damage).
The only thing I would like to press on is this:
All the spells I mentioned were 8th level or lower. The spell I proposed could very well be a 7th spell level (for clerics) divination spell without revealing so much (or penetrating so much info) as Discern location.DeepShadow wrote:I get your point, and if that's how you want to play high-level gaming, go for it. Me, OTOH, I'd point out that any spell that puts a 9th level spell to shame must be at least 10th level, and therefor uncastable by an 18th level character.When you're a 18th lvl wizard/cleric you devise the ultimate infogathering/warning spell that puts legend lore to shame (and discern location, and divination etc) and you research it/pray for it.![]()
No, that's not to just disagree and say "in three pages long answer I disagree here" but to point out that the divinations of 15th+ level characters are almost unstoppable.
Of course I agree with the technique of "giving them the clues, very useful hints but not the solution". This sets things right except one thing:
An intelligence score of 26-30.
A character that smart who is doing that for the last 10 years or so, should be able to intepret the meaning of the divination correctly and in depth. Which only leads us to another question:
How do you deal with epic-high mental ability scores?
What about Epic-high skill modifiers?
A 25th level bard could well hit a +45 to diplomacy checks, with just an item that gives +10 to diplomacy.
PS. Sorry if I strech this conversation but each answer just spawns more questions.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
Me, too! That was one of my chief points in the original debate, that D&D needn't be an arms race of classes, levels and magic items. Adapting villains does not have to mean that you scale them to within two levels of the party (or in the case you speak of above, keep their damage proportional to what they've always done).alhoon wrote:Wow, you really have though a lot about it! Usually when we play High-to-Epic levels around here, the characters get... diminished somehow. Example:
When you're 2nd level the average road bandit is 1st-2nd level warrior. When you're 10th level he suddenly is 2nd level fighter/ 1st level rogue. When you're 18th level the average road bandit is 3rd fighter/4 ranger/2 rogue.![]()
I hate that.
If the circumstances don't support the road bandit being a 9th level with PC classes, look for other ways to raise the EL of the encounter. Perhaps his family has been held hostage, and he's being forced to do what he does. Now the PC's have a different situation, that may involve their deduction, divination, diplomacy, subdual combat/grappling, or other creative means of dealing with a threat.
That is my intent.But you didn't deny the power of the high levels. You play them as high levels, not as average levels with flashier spells and more hit points (which is moot as everyone they encounter does more damage).
Sorry, I thought discern location was 9th.All the spells I mentioned were 8th level or lower.
Sure, but then, IMHO, it wouldn't be "putting discern location to shame." But then that's what I get for trying to put game stats on a figure of speech.The spell I proposed could very well be a 7th spell level (for clerics) divination spell without revealing so much (or penetrating so much info) as Discern location.
Sounds like I need to scrape up some examples of divinations and evaluate them for fairness. Thanks for keeping me intellectually honest! I really appreciate this kind of feedback!No, that's not to just disagree and say "in three pages long answer I disagree here" but to point out that the divinations of 15th+ level characters are almost unstoppable.
Excellent question. To me, the question should really be: "how do you split an in-game intellectual challenge between the player and the character?" I'm an avid fan of Dungeoncraft author Ray Winninger, especially his rule about how one needs to challenge both the players and the PC's. In Reckonings, this particular issue came into full relief because most or all of the PC's had mental ability scores in the huperhuman range. Without insulting the players, I think I can safely say that their characters are smarter than they are.Of course I agree with the technique of "giving them the clues, very useful hints but not the solution". This sets things right except one thing:
An intelligence score of 26-30.
A character that smart who is doing that for the last 10 years or so, should be able to intepret the meaning of the divination correctly and in depth. Which only leads us to another question:
How do you deal with epic-high mental ability scores?
So the character scores have to be taken into account when figuring about interpretation. Some ways I handled this:
--Missing information. While some information can be inferred by a deductive character, other information cannot. As David Hume said, the inhabitants of a steaming jungle, no matter how intelligent, cannot infer the existence of snow in other places. If the PC's have not discovered such a crucial piece of information, I help them interpret the rest, but no further.
--Assumed actions. Any game has assumed actions; who roleplays out the sharpening of a sword, the staking of a tent? It's assumed that if a player is being offered a decision, the decision is significant enough that the character's intelligence isn't enough.
--Oftentimes, the crucial difference is not the player's intelligence versus the character, but either one of them versus the parameters of a spell. Spells aren't smart. To avoid repeating myself, allow me to quote from my analysis on MSD's site:
--Let them have it! Ciera's struggled to understand the nature of the plane of Ravenloft. She started with no frame of reference, and this led to some errors (missing information) before she eventually started to put things together. I'm okay with that. She's managed to put together a great deal of the rules of how the plane works within 24 hours of traveling there--which seems appropriate for a 27th level character designed as a walking encyclopedia of the planes.The PC's have gone through enough now that we can take a closer look at some ways to challenge high-level PC's with mundane effects. Right now I'm going to look specifically at a number of spells that Ciera has used to gather information (see above about information as a commodity). Please keep in mind that I hope to use these weaknesses to prevent the PC's from ruining the game, without outright ruining their fun. As I said above, I like to see effort rewarded.
Foresight-- looking in the SRD, we find:
"This spell grants you a powerful sixth sense in relation to yourself or another. Once foresight is cast, you receive instantaneous warnings of impending danger or harm to the subject of the spell. You are never surprised or flat-footed. In addition, the spell gives you a general idea of what action you might take to best protect yourself and gives you a +2 insight bonus to AC and Reflex saves."
Okay, this has two major weaknesses that Ciera has personally experienced, and both of them step from the fact that it only warns of imminent, personal danger. Remove the first of these criteria (that is, create a situation that is potentially harmful, but not right away) and the spell is hindered.
For example, imagine a creature damages the Pirate's Bane so that it begins taking on water and slowly starts to sink. Ciera would get no warning about how to prevent this attack, because the danger to her was not imminent--the ship would still be afloat.
Assuming the creature's attack is successful, we find the other edge of the razor a little while later. Ciera might get some great advice on how she, personally, might avoid drowning. There would be no advice about how to save her followers, or any of the crew, or anyone else. Matter of fact, in many cases the spell would advise her to do something that would amount to abandonment of people in need. After all, it offers the most direct course of action for avoiding harm to herself.
True Seeing--Despite its reputation as the penultimate in vision, True Seeing is a great example of a high-magic effect that is easily hampered by low- or no-magic countereffects. A quick summary of the things that True Seeing penetrates (polymorphing, illusions, ethereal, shapechanging) and doesn't (standard concealment, fog, hiding) reveals that it's mainly for undoing magical effects. The sole exception is that it conveys darkvision to 120 ft, which is useful enough in RL, but remember that the other thing RL is infamous for is fog....
Prying Eyes, Greater--again, looking in the SRD, we find a few small but significant weaknesses of these wonderful little constructs. First, though, let's look at what makes them so useful. Their versatility is laid out by two statements from the SRD, 1) "When you create the eyes, you specify instructions you want them to follow in a command of no more than twenty-five words," and 2)"Any knowledge you possess is known by the eyes as well." As I understand this, the instructions come first, but they are open to improvisation and interpretation by the knowledge of the character. Thus, the crystal eyes can be given the instruction to "look for anything suspicious" without the caster having to specify what is suspicious. If an eye sees Sean Leslie in Captain Wolff's cabin at night, for example, it's going to realize that that's extremely odd, just as Ciera would if she were present.
On the other hand, the eyes have no constant telepathic link to Ciera, and thus their understanding is limited to what she knew at the time of casting. For example, if Ciera sends out her eyes at 10 AM, and at 3 PM the PC's discover that Captain Wolffe is the doppleganger, and at 7 PM an eye reports something suspicious, Ciera might discover that the eye had several opportunities to follow Captain Wolffe, but it didn't because it lacked the information to make that judgement.
*It takes an eye 1 round to replay 1 hour of recorded images. This actually becomes a greater liability as the caster increases in levels, because the longer the eyes have been around, the longer they will take to reach whatever it is they are reporting on.
For example, Ciera's eyes are around for 27 hours--longer than a day. If, after 22 hours of watching paint dry, an eye sees something worth reporting, it will fly immediately to Ciera, but will take 22 rounds (over two minutes) to get to the single significant event that caused it to report. Also note that anything significant will almost undoubtedly be dead last in an eye's report, because if it saw something significant before that, it would have reported earlier.
*"In order to report their findings, the eyes must return to your hand." Combined with how fragile they are (1 hit point, no hardness), it's likely that a certain amount of information is lost due to destroyed orbs. Add the range limit of one mile, and the fact that the caster doesn't know why/how the eye was destroyed, and there's room for a lot of information to get lost.
And there were situations in Saragoss when such a bonus would be warranted. Take Angus and the Nightwalkers, for example. Since this thread is about evaluation, let's break out a few small spoilers and make a comparison!What about Epic-high skill modifiers?
A 25th level bard could well hit a +45 to diplomacy checks, with just an item that gives +10 to diplomacy.
The Nightwalkers are the crew of the next ship over in Saragoss, the first to make contact with the epics since they came to RL. Angus was their representative, and he's a pretty typical member of their group--he's a former Mordentishman who's taken on the Neutral Evil mindset that typifies veteran Saragossans. That is, he views newcomers as disposable rubes, and his job is to "educate" them about how Saragoss works by running them through a gauntlet of con games that will get them addicted to the Saragoss equivalent of crack.
In a lower-level game, the adventure would probably call for some serendipitous accident to clue the PC's on to their newfound friend and his plans. Angus and the Nighghtwalkers would wind up as a villains, or at least typical evil NPC's, and the PC's would have to play some sort of double-cross gambit with him in order to get their supplies and repairs and escape Saragoss with their skins intact. That's fine; many perfectly good adventures revolve around merely escaping the domain.
These epics, on the other hand, are doing what other heroes might call "admirable but impossible": they are convincing Angus to actually work with them. They are even making headway with the other Nightwalkers. The psychological forces that control these people--hazing, Stockholm Syndrome, cognitive dissonance, fear, guilt--are enough to justify the use of epic diplomacy just to get them to listen seriously, but that's what's happening.
I didn't design Angus or the Nightwalkers with the epics in mind. I designed Saragoss as an interactive system that chews up newcomers and forces them to play by dog-eat-dog rules. The epics decided how they would respond when put into that system.
Not at all, I think this is a lot of what I was looking for.PS. Sorry if I strech this conversation but each answer just spawns more questions.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
Err...not ...exactly. I really don't think I want to reveal more about said vision, especially since IIRC no one has any such divination spells left. But I think it's about time to lay the doppleganger to rest, and thereby introduce one of the most debatable tactics I used:Nathan of the FoS wrote:Hot dang...the doppelganger made it aboard after all.
* Negative Serial Search--A "negative serial search" is where the PC's are put in a situation where they must search for something that isn't there--in this case, a doppleganger. The doppleganger hired to thwart the party knew that the only thing harder to find than a doppleganger is a rumor of one, so it arranged a message to the PC's claiming that they had been infiltrated. The PC's searched all the ships from top to bottom using all manner of divination, scrying, psionics, and whatnot. They discovered traps the creature had laid, but not the creature itself. Finally they satisfied themselves that the creature was not aboard, after Cortez tried unsuccessfully to bait the creature out of hiding, and Ciera finally figured out that the plane itself was blocking her from scrying outside of it.
The point of this tactic was a) to stir up paranoia and doubt among the party, b) to exhaust their divination spells and abilities, and c) to keep some of their attention divided toward an enemy that didn't exist. As far as that's concerned, there may be no tactic better suited to challenge epic PC's because no amount of divination magic may ever be sufficient to prove a negative! If a particular spell doesn't reveal a suspected creature, how can you be sure it's not because the creature didn't save, or evade the spell somehow?
This tactic may have been too perfect, as it treaded very close IMO to the prime danger of sucking the fun out of the game.
Well, now that I've spoiled that idea, I'd better be on watch for more such oportunities, to make it up to you.Well, that's exciting. Was that to be one of Peregrine's chances to reveal his spiffy Inquisitor abilities, DS?
I don't think we're at that point yet. After we've exhausted the experiment, we'll talk about the best way to wrap up the storyline. I'll give whatever spoilers I deem necessary to study things properly--like the one above about the doppelganger--but there are some that deserve to be revealed in context if at all possible.I'm thinking about revealing Peregrine's stats and as much of his backstory as I know (!)--is there any reason not to at this point?
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
He's got his share. He's now responsible for the remnants of the Raveners, and if his vision was interpreted correctly, they may yet play a role in his mission to recover the Raiment.Nathan of the FoS wrote:I would have to say that feeling responsible for people (heck, being responsible for people) was probably the key challenge for most of the party. In a sense Peregrine actually had an advantage over, say, Cortez, because he had relatively little to be responsible for in terms of "people actually on the scene".
Quite. Again, I don't try to oppose people on every level and turn. I just try to run the world the way it wants to run. Sometimes things go in your favor; I only remove the obvious serendipity from epic games because it's cheesy and unnecessary.Also, his coming was relatively obscured by the advent of Cortez' fleet, and therefore attracted rather less attention than it might otherwise have done.
I might as well confess that I took the introduction of Peregrine as an opportunity to explore a different type of epic-in-RL play. Peregrine as a native has a list of enemies, and some of them might actually be among the few legitimate epics in RL. The closest thing I could get with the rest of the party is Anders' contact with the god-brain, and--playing strictly by the book--that won't bear fruit for about a month. Thus, while Cortez's ultimate challenge is with all the nickles and dimes of keeping his men alive, Peregrine's ultimate challenge may very well be keeping himself alive....His personal problems more than made up for that, though. In a way I guess I made it easy on DeepShadow; Peregrine was designed to be his own worst enemy, which gave DS lots of options for ways to challenge him (me?).
Of course, since they've met, the can share their problems. Fun for everyone.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
Perhaps an introduction of the characters is in order for the other readers of this thread:
Characters were made at 27th level, 30 point buy. All charaters are at least middle age. They got full PC wealth from the DMG but could only spend a max of 20% on a single item. With all that wealth many opted for the Complete Guide to Self Enhancement(TM), i.e. all the attribute enhancement +5 books. Cortez staffed and equipped all of his 700+ followers and purchased 3 or 4 ships and a lighthouse.
So without further ado here's a short note on each character:
Ciera the Child Witch is a Rashemen Sorceress/Loremaster specializing in Knowledge(the planes) and, I think, divinations. Her epic cohort is a 20+ level monk. She only took a few of her followers with her. Due to a mysterious spell (or curse?) she's in the body of a young girl.
Captain Cortez Vandrokar is a Rogue turned Paladin turned flotilla captain. His Diplomacy score is in the 40s and he supplied 3 full ships manned by his followers. His epic cohort is an elf Fighter/Rogue/Duelist CL 20+.
St. Balin Cormaeril is a Cormyrian Paladin/Fist of Raziel with the saint template. The epitome of the shining knight, he has young gold dragon as a mount/cohort.
Tessius is a rogue/shadowdancer spymaster in the employ of Cormyr. At first stranded in the Nightmare lands, he lost all of his equipment when he used a wish from his Luckblade to escape from there.
Anders is psion/soulknife/psion incarnate monster hunter who had a bad run in with illithids in his past. He joins the heroes as a reputed doppleganger hunter.
And last not least the only native PC, His Righteous Zeal Peregrine Wayfarer, Grand Inquisitor of the Church of Ezra, Shepherd of the Faithful. Hailing from the Burning Peaks Cluster he's a Fighter/Scourge/Cleric of Ezra "Inquisitor" who carries the Sword and Shield of Ezra and Borrowed Time. He is possibly in the late stages of possession by a fiend (Gwydion?), failed at least two powers checks and is perhaps a clone of Vecna. He also has a past connection with the Nightmare Court.
Characters were made at 27th level, 30 point buy. All charaters are at least middle age. They got full PC wealth from the DMG but could only spend a max of 20% on a single item. With all that wealth many opted for the Complete Guide to Self Enhancement(TM), i.e. all the attribute enhancement +5 books. Cortez staffed and equipped all of his 700+ followers and purchased 3 or 4 ships and a lighthouse.
So without further ado here's a short note on each character:
Ciera the Child Witch is a Rashemen Sorceress/Loremaster specializing in Knowledge(the planes) and, I think, divinations. Her epic cohort is a 20+ level monk. She only took a few of her followers with her. Due to a mysterious spell (or curse?) she's in the body of a young girl.
Captain Cortez Vandrokar is a Rogue turned Paladin turned flotilla captain. His Diplomacy score is in the 40s and he supplied 3 full ships manned by his followers. His epic cohort is an elf Fighter/Rogue/Duelist CL 20+.
St. Balin Cormaeril is a Cormyrian Paladin/Fist of Raziel with the saint template. The epitome of the shining knight, he has young gold dragon as a mount/cohort.
Tessius is a rogue/shadowdancer spymaster in the employ of Cormyr. At first stranded in the Nightmare lands, he lost all of his equipment when he used a wish from his Luckblade to escape from there.
Anders is psion/soulknife/psion incarnate monster hunter who had a bad run in with illithids in his past. He joins the heroes as a reputed doppleganger hunter.
And last not least the only native PC, His Righteous Zeal Peregrine Wayfarer, Grand Inquisitor of the Church of Ezra, Shepherd of the Faithful. Hailing from the Burning Peaks Cluster he's a Fighter/Scourge/Cleric of Ezra "Inquisitor" who carries the Sword and Shield of Ezra and Borrowed Time. He is possibly in the late stages of possession by a fiend (Gwydion?), failed at least two powers checks and is perhaps a clone of Vecna. He also has a past connection with the Nightmare Court.
Last edited by The Giamarga on Fri Mar 28, 2014 10:11 am, edited 3 times in total.
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7107
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
It's pretty hard to believe at first that those PCs are in Ravenloft, but I'm glad to be proven wrongThe Giamarga wrote:Perhaps an introduction of the characters is in order for the other readers of this thread:
Characters werde made at 27th level, 30 point buy. All charaters are at least middle age. They got full PC wealth from the DMG. (but could only spend a max of 20% on a single item). With all that wealth many opted for the Complete Guide to Self Enhancement(TM), i.e. all the attribute enhancement +5 books. Cortez staffed and eequipped all of his 700+ followers and purchased 3 or 4 ships and a lighthouse.
Cool experiment, DS. I guess all is in the balance of things. If you want to write about the principles / guidelines you followed to make this epic campaign fun, I'd surely welcome that to the DM info part of the site.
Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
- Nathan of the FoS
- Fiendish Enforcer

- Posts: 5247
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
- Location: San Francisco CA
Tru dat. One of the things about being epic level and anything like good is that you acquire people to be responsible for pretty quickly. Believe it or not, the whole Raveners thing was totally spontaneous when I first decided to do it; Peregrine originally intended to find out the lay of the land by walking around for a while, but then I thought "Well, the Boritsis are financing this thing, so Peregrine would probably check out the Liberte (the ship the Boritsis wanted to recover) first thing, and then see what's next." I didn't realize unti Peregrine arrived that the Raveners had moved in, and, of course, having made that discovery action had to be taken. (Leading to one of my favorite "epic throw-away moments", in which Peregrine (actually, the Sword of Ezra) kills scores of ghouls and ghaisties with a single blow.)DeepShadow wrote:He's got his share. He's now responsible for the remnants of the Raveners, and if his vision was interpreted correctly, they may yet play a role in his mission to recover the Raiment.
Well, and I noted some anti-serendipity entering at certain points. Having the Furies show up just as the Sword of Ezra disappeared would make the Furies much harder to deal with, and potentially much bolder.Quite. Again, I don't try to oppose people on every level and turn. I just try to run the world the way it wants to run. Sometimes things go in your favor; I only remove the obvious serendipity from epic games because it's cheesy and unnecessary.
Note that "some" of them (not one) are among Ravenloft's epics.I might as well confess that I took the introduction of Peregrine as an opportunity to explore a different type of epic-in-RL play. Peregrine as a native has a list of enemies, and some of them might actually be among the few legitimate epics in RL. The closest thing I could get with the rest of the party is Anders' contact with the god-brain, and--playing strictly by the book--that won't bear fruit for about a month. Thus, while Cortez's ultimate challenge is with all the nickles and dimes of keeping his men alive, Peregrine's ultimate challenge may very well be keeping himself alive....
Death ain't the worst that could happen to Peregrine. Not by a long chalk. Assuming you're going by the Tarokka reading from waaayyyy back at the beginning, the three outcomes predicted then were a) The Broken One. Peregrine breaks and descends into madness and despair (probably his assumption into the Nightmare Court), b) The Master of Swords, Peregrine triumphs both morally and physically (I've speculated wildly on this point, but I don't have much of an idea how DS would bring this off), or c) The Beast, which was interpreted as Peregrine destroying both his chief enemy (probably Gwydion, could be the Nightmare Man) and himself.
Of course, since they've met, the can share their problems. Fun for everyone.
Yeah, well, Peregrine probably gets the better of that deal. ("So...now that I've helped heal everybody from the six diseases they acquired before breakfast, do you wanna go fight the CR 32+ Sorcerer-Fiend with me?")
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
LOL! Believe it or not, I didn't plan that, either. I had my map; the Liberte was abandoned around the time the original Bliss (the Ravener ship) was sunk. I already had them hanging curtains before you were creating your character!Nathan of the FoS wrote:Believe it or not, the whole Raveners thing was totally spontaneous when I first decided to do it;
And that was one of the greatest tests of my philosophy to "let them be epic." Don't interfere with the glory; player had a great idea and it should go off without a hitch. I estimated how many weren't on deck at that moment (about 10%), and decided that those plus a few select would be all that survived. That meant offing the Jolly Roger first mate before he was more than a promising sketch, but them's the breaks. When you throw epics against 3-7th level characters, you should be prepared for the epics to blow straight through all your clever defenses and techniques from time to time.(Leading to one of my favorite "epic throw-away moments", in which Peregrine (actually, the Sword of Ezra) kills scores of ghouls and ghaisties with a single blow.)
FWIW, Ram Haroon was below decks because he was almost always in the brig. As the former leader of the Raveners, Ram posed a liability to the Keeper's leadership, but the Keeper wanted his advice from time to time.
...I honestly didn't plan an order for those two events. They were both so close together. Then again, if the Furies are really here because Peregrine is showing compassion for once, then shouldn't that follow the loss of his sword? Without that loss, would Peregrine have so much empathy for someone else's pain? I dunno, I guess I just saw them as cause and effect. Maybe not.Well, and I noted some anti-serendipity entering at certain points. Having the Furies show up just as the Sword of Ezra disappeared would make the Furies much harder to deal with, and potentially much bolder.
Then again, if the Furies are really here just because of Peregrine's compassion, then they came awfully fast! I might call foul on a DM who had them show up within seconds of the first glimmer of atonement. After all, they can track the penitent, not teleport!
*sigh* It's not always about you, you know.
OTOH, I'll admit to anti-seredipity in the case of the sword vanishing. It had to happen, and I wanted it to be dramatic. Guilty as charged.
I used "some" in terms of the overarching technique.Note that "some" of them (not one) are among Ravenloft's epics.Gwydion certainly, the Nightmare Court certainly...let's see...Phantom's Bane, although I doubt he'll be brought in at this point. Vecna's gone (unless he's possessing Peregrine...what a thought) so it's not him.
Peregrine, nothing. RL in general, and this game in particular, is a grand testament to the fact that there are so many things worse than death.Death ain't the worst that could happen to Peregrine.
For some people, "life" would fall into that category.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
