Both in the Reckonings game, and again in DeepShadow's description of his Mordent adventure/campaign, I've noticed an interesting and largely unexamined question about George, Gennifer and Laurie.
They've all become monster hunters, and successful ones, but is this actually an abdication of responsibility on their part? When Jules Weathermay dies, what will happen to Mordent? I think one can make a strong case that they're ignoring their duty (the relatively dull and political work of ruling Mordent well) in favor of the exciting (monster hunting!), and that Mordent will end up suffering for it. Thoughts?
Are the WF twins choosing the right thing?
- Nathan of the FoS
- Fiendish Enforcer

- Posts: 5247
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
- Location: San Francisco CA
Are the WF twins choosing the right thing?
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
You make an interesting point... Actually everyone in the VRarsenal (except Balfour) was telling them to not become monster hunters themselves.
Yes, they should choose someone to rule in their stead and they should do that carefully.
On the other hand, I really don't thing they are dishing the boring for the exciting.
While it is exciting for us to play monster hunters, I would hardly say that I would like to do that for (a short) life. Also don't think that it is not boring to read tomes over tomes on the subject. While the kill is exciting and rewarding... it is painful.
Do you think that when a rotting corpse fell over one of the twins and smelled her hair she enjoyed it?
What about when the Glutton bit off the arm of one of their friends?
What about the SFey that killed the farmer and placed traps around their bed?
Yes, they should choose someone to rule in their stead and they should do that carefully.
On the other hand, I really don't thing they are dishing the boring for the exciting.
While it is exciting for us to play monster hunters, I would hardly say that I would like to do that for (a short) life. Also don't think that it is not boring to read tomes over tomes on the subject. While the kill is exciting and rewarding... it is painful.
Do you think that when a rotting corpse fell over one of the twins and smelled her hair she enjoyed it?
What about when the Glutton bit off the arm of one of their friends?
What about the SFey that killed the farmer and placed traps around their bed?
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- vipera aspis
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 351
- Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2005 8:38 pm
- Location: Chicago
-
Jonathan Winters
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 435
- Joined: Mon Jul 05, 2004 8:23 pm
- Location: Montreal, Quebec
That is a very interesting topic...
I wonder if any of the authors wanted to explore this in the Guides...
Or are they at liberty to tell? (Still?)
I can see a tale of sacrifice in there. Which twin would forego the Chase to be what she should be for the greater good? (or ''another'' greater good, really.) Because I don't think ruling Mordent is a lesser or demeaning task.
Patrick
I wonder if any of the authors wanted to explore this in the Guides...
Or are they at liberty to tell? (Still?)
I can see a tale of sacrifice in there. Which twin would forego the Chase to be what she should be for the greater good? (or ''another'' greater good, really.) Because I don't think ruling Mordent is a lesser or demeaning task.
Patrick
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
The twins are fine. They're farther down the line of sucession so they're free to spend their youth doing whatever. In this case helping people and seeing the world.
George, on the other hand, is ignoring his political responsibility to persue a revenge fantasy across the Core. And is doing questionable things in the process.
George, on the other hand, is ignoring his political responsibility to persue a revenge fantasy across the Core. And is doing questionable things in the process.
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
It is an interesting question. I think you dealt with it splendidly in the Reckonings game when you spoke to them. For sake of discussion (and because I admire your prose) let's hear it again:
"Miss Gennifer, Miss Laurie," Peregrine says, his voice somber. "You know that I have a great deal of respect and love for your family. I would not ordinarily interfere in any of your doings; but your grandfather has asked me to speak to you about your chosen vocation."
"I will not tell you that women are not capable of it, because I have seen some who are, and what I hear of you would lead me to believe you are among them. I will also not remind you of the price of failure; you have seen enough, and heard enough from van Richten and your uncle, to know what can happen to those who strive against darkness."
"I will, however, ask you this: have you considered the price of success?"
Laurie is halfway through a retort when she realizes what Peregrine has actually said.
"Oh, uh...."
Gennifer, on the other hand, merely swallows, then looks at Peregrine with all the daring she can muster.
"Go on," she says evenly.
"Think of the persons you aspire to emulate--van Richten, your uncle George...me, perhaps...others like Ivan Dragonov, Eia Pax, Kolmy Szestelyn...What do we have in common, other than our vocation and our relative success at it?"
The twins share a slightly confused glance; Peregrine prompts them with, "You speak Darkonese, don't you? What does my first name mean in that tongue?"
A look of dawning realization crosses Gennifer's face; slowly, she says, "It means 'wanderer'." She and Laurie look at each other again.
Peregrine nods. "That is not the name I was born with; whatever that was is lost in the Mists. But it is who I have become. It is what your Uncle George has become. It is what every monster hunter, in time, becomes. For most of us, we have lost everything that we knew before we begin our careers; we have no responsibilities to hearth and home, or we would not have set our feet on this path. But you...you are different."
The room falls silent--so quiet that the muffled tick of Borrowed Time sounds clearly between the tap of raindrops at the Dementlieuse window opening on the patio.
"Your grandfather will die soon," Peregrine says quietly. "Who will rule Mordent when he is gone? You chafe against your "aristocratic responsibilities"; who will perform them if you do not?"
The twins fall silent for a long time. Finally it is Laurie who breaks the wall of silence between the girls and the aging inquisitor.
"What are we supposed to do, with all this at our doorsteps?" she whispers, her voice resonating with emotion despite being barely audible. "I'll give you the benefit of the doubt that when you say 'rule' you mean more than feeding off the poor or becoming porcelain dolls for everyone to protect or chattel to buy Mordent a 'real ruler.' Assuming you really mean guiding the people and treating them fairly, would we not be herding so much cattle for the Legions of the Night? What good do fair taxes and peace accords do when people are dying all around us?"
Her voice has risen now to natural levels, but her whole body is quaking with rage...and something else. Still pondering the inquisitor's words, Gennifer finally speaks, seeing as her twin is finally at a loss for words.
"We'll consider your words, Shepherd, coming as they do with such love for us and all of Mordent. Did you have anything else to add?"
"Children," Peregrine says, his voice quiet with both pain and anger. "Can you be so blind? Have you learned nothing from the example of your grandfather?"
Turning, he stares out the Dementlieuse window. "When I came here, it was impossible for me to believe how happy, and how free, the people of Mordent were. Impossible. You have seen the misery of Falkovnia; but even that does not compare to the place where I grew up."
"I put it to you...why should Mordent be free and happy, and Falkovnia enchained and miserable? And I will take the liberty to answer myself: because of the quality of their rulers. It is necessary that we struggle against the Legions of Night; but it is imperative that we be ruled by justice." His voice rising, now, Peregrine turns and fixes Laurie with his gaze. "How can you dare to deride 'fair taxes and peace accords', Laurie Weathermay-Foxgrove? Have you not seen the peasants of Falkovnia and Nova Vaasa bent beneath the lash for tax default? Have you never heard of the Dead Man's Campaign? Have you any idea what war would bring to the fields of Mordent? It is your responsibility, by birth and training, to watch over these people. Who will do it if you do not?"
This last question Peregrine roars hoarsely; the twins sit, white-faced and trembling, as he falls silent, recovering his composure.
"I am sorry, Miss Laurie, Miss Gennifer," he says, at last. "You are women grown, and I should not forget myself so." Going to one knee in the traditional attitude of fealty, Peregrine whispers, "I beg of you, my ladies. Remain here and strengthen the children of Light in wisdom and duty, and leave the way of the wanderer for those of us who have no home worthy of defending."
Standing, Peregrine turns on his heel and leaves through the Dementlieuse window, walking into the gray light and gentle rain.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
