Considering a new Monk class for RL
Considering a new Monk class for RL
Hi all,
I'm doing a Monk class substitute for Ravenloft, thought first for Souragne but with probably more applications. The idea, though, is rooted not in anything Haitian or voodoo-ish but rather on the Brazilian Capoeirista and perhaps its association to Iemanjá and Candomblê cults, which seem to have enough of a relation to voodoo to make them fairly usable in Souragne.
I have the concept almost ready and a fair number of ideas on how to replace the monk skills, but I know very little about Capoeira and would like to know if anyone around here could tell me of some powers that mythic Capoeiristas might have. I'm not interested in reality, but on the myths, really. For instance, I found that a famous capoierista was said to have Corpo Fechado, that is, 'closed body': he was invulnerable to bullets or blades.
Do you know any others like these? What kind of powers do you think a Capoeirista might have?
Thank you all.
Alex
I'm doing a Monk class substitute for Ravenloft, thought first for Souragne but with probably more applications. The idea, though, is rooted not in anything Haitian or voodoo-ish but rather on the Brazilian Capoeirista and perhaps its association to Iemanjá and Candomblê cults, which seem to have enough of a relation to voodoo to make them fairly usable in Souragne.
I have the concept almost ready and a fair number of ideas on how to replace the monk skills, but I know very little about Capoeira and would like to know if anyone around here could tell me of some powers that mythic Capoeiristas might have. I'm not interested in reality, but on the myths, really. For instance, I found that a famous capoierista was said to have Corpo Fechado, that is, 'closed body': he was invulnerable to bullets or blades.
Do you know any others like these? What kind of powers do you think a Capoeirista might have?
Thank you all.
Alex
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
There was an article way back in Dragon Magazine about Capoeira dancers. I think the title was Battle Dancers or something of the sort. I'll check for more, but off the top of my head, how are you going to deal with the slavery element in Capoeira?
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- vipera aspis
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 351
- Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2005 8:38 pm
- Location: Chicago
That is not completely essential, but I remember from the Souragne Gazetteer that a large part of the population are ex-slaves. The same theme of slavery exists there, so no problem with thatDeepShadow wrote:There was an article way back in Dragon Magazine about Capoeira dancers. I think the title was Battle Dancers or something of the sort. I'll check for more, but off the top of my head, how are you going to deal with the slavery element in Capoeira?
This if I recall correctly.
Alex
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
I'd have to say the Defender base class from the Midnight campaign setting is the best replacement for the monk in a low-magic setting. It's not even pidgeonholed into being from a specific region. It's from the book Midnight Second Edition by Fantasy Flight Games and has so much content that is useful and in some cases more appropriate to RL than standard DnD.
The book even has a replacement for the DnD ranger called the Wildlander that is able to better specialize in recon, hunting, survival etc. Considering I don't expect you to go out and buy the book, I don't know what to tell you. The defender really is the best replacement for the monk; it is not restricted to a region- as it's based on both western and eastern martial arts (yes there are both), allows you to specialize against weapons/grappling/fistfighting etc. Best of all it doesn't have mystical abilities- it is human potential.
P.S. No offense to capoiera but having practiced martial arts myself as well as fought; watching that art, as beautiful as it is will not win a fight against a human that knows what they're doing- let alone the creatures of darkness. As for why- it's predictable in movement and often places you off-balance: that makes it difficult to respond to your enemy.
The book even has a replacement for the DnD ranger called the Wildlander that is able to better specialize in recon, hunting, survival etc. Considering I don't expect you to go out and buy the book, I don't know what to tell you. The defender really is the best replacement for the monk; it is not restricted to a region- as it's based on both western and eastern martial arts (yes there are both), allows you to specialize against weapons/grappling/fistfighting etc. Best of all it doesn't have mystical abilities- it is human potential.
P.S. No offense to capoiera but having practiced martial arts myself as well as fought; watching that art, as beautiful as it is will not win a fight against a human that knows what they're doing- let alone the creatures of darkness. As for why- it's predictable in movement and often places you off-balance: that makes it difficult to respond to your enemy.
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
The Battle Dancer is a core class that was included in the Dragon Compendium. I found an online version here: http://dnd.virtualsean.com/classes/battleDancer.htmlDeepShadow wrote:There was an article way back in Dragon Magazine about Capoeira dancers. I think the title was Battle Dancers or something of the sort. I'll check for more, but off the top of my head, how are you going to deal with the slavery element in Capoeira?
I find the Battle Dancer well done, but a bit repetitive. Almost all abilities are based on the Tumble skill, which gets boring. Still, I'm probably going to use something from there.
As for whether Capoeira is worthy or not as a martial art, I'd say history proves it is. That's what the brazilian slaves used to defend themselves from the portuguese army and they did give a fair resistance, according to some accounts.
Perhaps you only know Capoeira from today's exhibitions and I agree they are quite boring, mostly because they are always showing off acrobatic skills and very, very rarely enacting real fights. That's why one gets the impression that is not a good martial art. However, I have seen videos on youtube that showed me it can be quite impressive, if done with teh intent to hurt.
I'll try to take a look at the Defender in some shop or so, just to get a feel for it.
Thanks all
Alex
As for whether Capoeira is worthy or not as a martial art, I'd say history proves it is. That's what the brazilian slaves used to defend themselves from the portuguese army and they did give a fair resistance, according to some accounts.
Perhaps you only know Capoeira from today's exhibitions and I agree they are quite boring, mostly because they are always showing off acrobatic skills and very, very rarely enacting real fights. That's why one gets the impression that is not a good martial art. However, I have seen videos on youtube that showed me it can be quite impressive, if done with teh intent to hurt.
I'll try to take a look at the Defender in some shop or so, just to get a feel for it.
Thanks all
Alex
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
yeah, I was talking from what I've seen IRL and from a few vids (I live in America). Never been to South America so I don't know how corrupted it's gotten over here. If the movements were more direct when they were used against the Portuguese I can see how harmful it could be. Had some guy doing spinning and stuff- predicted movement and knocked him off balance then grappled w/ him (I studied Shaolin Kempo- direct aggressive action w/ little wasted motion ie. punches segway into elbows).
The thing is that in America martial arts often become commercialized and the traditional discipline and 'extraneous' parts of the art are chopped out to make it more digestable to Westerners. Luckily for me I was taught in a more traditional way but in the back of my mind that I would not be considered as good as someone say from China who was my same rank. I can easily imagine a similar scenario w/ Capioera- I apologize for not fully thinking my statement before- I forget sometimes that these boards have people from across the world on them; that my statements scope might appear incorrect.
The thing is that in America martial arts often become commercialized and the traditional discipline and 'extraneous' parts of the art are chopped out to make it more digestable to Westerners. Luckily for me I was taught in a more traditional way but in the back of my mind that I would not be considered as good as someone say from China who was my same rank. I can easily imagine a similar scenario w/ Capioera- I apologize for not fully thinking my statement before- I forget sometimes that these boards have people from across the world on them; that my statements scope might appear incorrect.
From what I heard Capoeira is so weird because it's meant to be performed in chains and it had to be disguised as dance (because if the slaves were caught practicing martial arts they'd be killed) so it probably was different when they actually tried to kill someone with it.
I also heard it could be peformed with razor blade-studded chains, which would make it a little more difficult to deal with, but this is just errant chat of unknown veracity that I picked up.
I also heard it could be peformed with razor blade-studded chains, which would make it a little more difficult to deal with, but this is just errant chat of unknown veracity that I picked up.
Well, this video
is a good example of aimless showing off of skills in Capoeira. Especially around the 15sec mark when one of the fighters is hopping on his hands oblivious to the fact that the other one could strike him directly if he wanted.
This, on the other hand, has examples of both kinds:
And these are only fighting, even if training:
The point with Capoeira is that it was developed as martial art by slaves to fight off their masters' men, but since they were forbidden to fight, they concealed the fighting within the music. That, at least, is what the myth says. During the 19th century and early 20th century, Capoeira was mostly used by thugs and criminals and being a Capoeirista was very badly seen.
But then during the 30s, I believe, it struck the Brazilians that Capoeira was a true Brazilian invention, a strong mark of culture and then it began being promoted precisely as that: a cultural product, blending fight, music and dance, and possibly even something more. You must understand Capoeira under that light. Today, it is shown off as a nice musical exercise, but without much emphasis on the fight. It even becomes silly to watch, unless you simply want to see skills. It's like watching the Harlem Globe Trotters or, for that matter, Shaolin monks breaking spears with their necks. Most Shaolin exhibitions become rather silly also, sometimes, at least from the point of view of a Karate-ka like I was. My master used to scoff at Kung-fu simply because it wasted too much time with flourishings. But I suspect this is traditional in all martial art schools. I once talked with a practicioner of Wado-Ryu Karate, if I'm not mistaken, and he mocked of a Shotokan Kata, claiming that while I was doing my opening move he'd have struck me. I guess we can never fully understand an art when we're on the outside, and even from the inside, it takes a long time to achieve the right level of comprehension. I may well have been rightly mocked for not performing the Kata well or not knowing exactly what it meant.
Alex
is a good example of aimless showing off of skills in Capoeira. Especially around the 15sec mark when one of the fighters is hopping on his hands oblivious to the fact that the other one could strike him directly if he wanted.
This, on the other hand, has examples of both kinds:
And these are only fighting, even if training:
The point with Capoeira is that it was developed as martial art by slaves to fight off their masters' men, but since they were forbidden to fight, they concealed the fighting within the music. That, at least, is what the myth says. During the 19th century and early 20th century, Capoeira was mostly used by thugs and criminals and being a Capoeirista was very badly seen.
But then during the 30s, I believe, it struck the Brazilians that Capoeira was a true Brazilian invention, a strong mark of culture and then it began being promoted precisely as that: a cultural product, blending fight, music and dance, and possibly even something more. You must understand Capoeira under that light. Today, it is shown off as a nice musical exercise, but without much emphasis on the fight. It even becomes silly to watch, unless you simply want to see skills. It's like watching the Harlem Globe Trotters or, for that matter, Shaolin monks breaking spears with their necks. Most Shaolin exhibitions become rather silly also, sometimes, at least from the point of view of a Karate-ka like I was. My master used to scoff at Kung-fu simply because it wasted too much time with flourishings. But I suspect this is traditional in all martial art schools. I once talked with a practicioner of Wado-Ryu Karate, if I'm not mistaken, and he mocked of a Shotokan Kata, claiming that while I was doing my opening move he'd have struck me. I guess we can never fully understand an art when we're on the outside, and even from the inside, it takes a long time to achieve the right level of comprehension. I may well have been rightly mocked for not performing the Kata well or not knowing exactly what it meant.
Alex
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
Of course, the best news is that since this is for an FRPG, the in-game depiction can be as realistic or as fantastic as you like (and, for that matter, as effective)...
which I suppose you actually said way back in the first post. ^_^
I suppose if you don't want to stray too far from a perception that the actual fighting art is questionable you could say that the balance is made up by supernatural-based abilities (which would go hand-in-glove with the Souragnean background you've implied and perhaps a link to voodan, since real-life voudoun was itself a product of the culture of slavery in the Caribbean...).
which I suppose you actually said way back in the first post. ^_^
I suppose if you don't want to stray too far from a perception that the actual fighting art is questionable you could say that the balance is made up by supernatural-based abilities (which would go hand-in-glove with the Souragnean background you've implied and perhaps a link to voodan, since real-life voudoun was itself a product of the culture of slavery in the Caribbean...).
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
I've always kicked around the idea of doing a QtR article on monastic orders of the Mists, but Races of the Mists always killed my time.
It would revolve around racial substitution and alternate class features for monks based on regional techniques.
It wouldn't have been a complete re-working (too much work, too hard to balance, too awkward in play having to continually reference looseleaf notes or the like) but more a renaming and reworking of occasional abilities.
It would revolve around racial substitution and alternate class features for monks based on regional techniques.
It wouldn't have been a complete re-working (too much work, too hard to balance, too awkward in play having to continually reference looseleaf notes or the like) but more a renaming and reworking of occasional abilities.
That's a bit what I intended with this one. Unfortunately, I've had my time taken up with other things so I haven't done any more writeup with this. But it's nearly ready, anyway.Jester of the FoS wrote:I've always kicked around the idea of doing a QtR article on monastic orders of the Mists, but Races of the Mists always killed my time.
It would revolve around racial substitution and alternate class features for monks based on regional techniques.
It wouldn't have been a complete re-working (too much work, too hard to balance, too awkward in play having to continually reference looseleaf notes or the like) but more a renaming and reworking of occasional abilities.
Alex
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
