Tome of Battle and Ravenloft. What are your thoughts?
- Spiteful Crow
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 472
- Joined: Sat Feb 25, 2006 8:46 pm
- Location: Illinois
- Contact:
And there we have it! All this time, Hollywood thought they had something, but it turns out we've been ripping off of Japanese animation even before they started making cartoons! All the great action classics of our time are now anime!Archedius wrote:second wind still seems more like 'charging up' to me.
Should I start spewing profanity, make disparaging comments about your parentage, and compare you to fascist dictators?Archedius wrote:Regardless, you're not being very civil about this.
it's all in the tone- also stop assuming what people are thinking. Everyone else can disagree in a non-beligerent manner- I believe in you and think you can as well! I don't care if you don't like my ToB=feels anime to me vibe, you can disagree without making 'biased' assumptions about me as you did before and without making yourself a hypocrit by calling me biased.
Asides many of the stances don't sit well with me either. I recall a stance that boosted your speed as well as ac or DR, don't remember. I don't have a problem with some of the maneuvers but the 'stances' effects often seem mystical to me- though I wish I provided a better example of that to make my point.
And no kid sorry, getting your second wind is far different than charging up. Stop being a child about this and discuss the mechanics at the very least.
I definately think the system in ToB was heavily influenced by popularized anime 'powers' and such. Some people don't agree with me- I respect that; Crow I know that you aren't able to and it's a shame. You live up to your name.
Asides many of the stances don't sit well with me either. I recall a stance that boosted your speed as well as ac or DR, don't remember. I don't have a problem with some of the maneuvers but the 'stances' effects often seem mystical to me- though I wish I provided a better example of that to make my point.
And no kid sorry, getting your second wind is far different than charging up. Stop being a child about this and discuss the mechanics at the very least.
I definately think the system in ToB was heavily influenced by popularized anime 'powers' and such. Some people don't agree with me- I respect that; Crow I know that you aren't able to and it's a shame. You live up to your name.
Technically, if you look at his picture, he should be "Spiteful Demilich"... which is almost a tautology in terms. </pedantry>Archedius wrote:Crow I know that you aren't able to and it's a shame. You live up to your name.
Seriously fellas, play nice, huh? Sure people get heated and passionate about the game - that's a good sign that the game still engenders a lot of interest. But let's keep a healthy respect for each other's opinions, especially when they are so subjective as personal viewpoints, or homebrew campaign suggestions (as opposed to more objective things like actual core rules - but even so you should STILL play nice when discussing those).
As a final note, Fraternity is pretty good about this. The people you meet here who may be assertive are usually so because they genuinely care about the game. If you want a good example of a board going bad, check out the Wizards boards, especially the D&D Core Rules threads.
There you've got people who are very belligerent and who seem more focussed on proving their own authoritative grasp of the rules and also on stamping out all contrary viewpoints.
We don't have that here. Fraternity's a good place with good people. Let's appreciate what we've got and keep it friendly, okay?
- Spiteful Crow
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 472
- Joined: Sat Feb 25, 2006 8:46 pm
- Location: Illinois
- Contact:
Since the forum won't let me upload my Spiteful Crow image. ¬_¬HuManBing wrote:Technically, if you look at his picture, he should be "Spiteful Demilich"... which is almost a tautology in terms. </pedantry>
Sorry about the sarcasm. I usually only use it if I'm offended, but in this case, I'm not quite sure exactly why I'm riled up. I've already made my case, I'll drop it now.
Well, anime or not, the ToB is meant to be epic, so a DM might not want to use it for Ravenloft. But compared to the crazy builds my friends have done to stay relevant to the game, I consider it a small price to pay.
(I mean it, too. The most obvious example was the guy who, in order to dish out as much damage as the wizards, had to jump twenty feat in the air for a single massive attack, and once that was done his AC dropped to -3. And I'm not talking Second Ed. here. I don't think anything in the ToB can really match that in sillyness.)
(I mean it, too. The most obvious example was the guy who, in order to dish out as much damage as the wizards, had to jump twenty feat in the air for a single massive attack, and once that was done his AC dropped to -3. And I'm not talking Second Ed. here. I don't think anything in the ToB can really match that in sillyness.)
Erm?HuManBing wrote:Okay, now I'm going to stop that right now, as it's not going to help me convince my mom that I'm not gay.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
- tec-goblin
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 397
- Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2003 5:22 am
- Location: Paris, France
- Contact:
We use the book in a quite noir Eberron campaign a lot. Some comments:
1) slightly nerf Warblade. He's taking too high hd, feats/saves, etc for the maneuvers he takes in addition to what fighter takes.
2) you can keep a low magic feeling to the book (for Ravenloft purposes) by disallowing Desert Wind. Yes, shadow hand has supernatural abilities, but they feel much more ravenloft (but some of them should require power checks). And there are so many things you can do with 8 paths anyway.
3) Read the book very very carefully. A lot of the maneuvers are much less broken than they seem.
I think that, with some discretion in its use, Tome of Battle could actually enhance instead of damage the Ravenloft feeling. Compare the Falkovnian ex-soldier hero fighter/paladin to the Sitchican elf who has been so burdened by the shadows of his lands that it reflects in its combat moves, combining natural elf fluidity with shadow hand techniques.
When you introduce Tome of Battle in your game, you have to think of how rare or how well-known the maneuvers are. The basic options are:
1) Keeping it rare. Limited to a handful of secret organizations or cultures (Shadow Fey of course!). The PCs might be able to learn some techniques (with the appropriate feats), but at best one of them will have one of the martial adept classes. Uncovering the history behind the weird and unpredictable tricks of a villain is certainly Ravenloftish - you could even link the creation of some paths to corrupted individuals (learning them as a gift from the Mists) or major events.
2) Using it in place of some of the standard classes. Do you think that paladin's nerfing (detect evil etc), aura and abilities are quite tiresome? Use crusader, who can be used without nerfing as it is in Ravenloft. Do you think that anything more than 4 fighter levels is boring? Use some warblade levels for high level fighting types. You can also swap divinity of mankind monks for appropriate builds of swordsage (what dark gifts this "divinity" gives?).
For ready NPCs, swapping a feat for the feat that gives you a maneuver might give them an appropriate (for their style, theme, origin) maneuver.
This option makes combat much more unpredictable and interesting but it's not worth the effort if your Ravenloft campaign does not involve a respectable deal of combat. You'll find that Tome of Battle tends to lead towards a game with an average of one good, interesting combat per session, and less random encounters (battle between martial adepts gets this dark "Exalted" feeling and is often rewarding).
It also has a lot to do with whether your campaign turns around hunting half-sentient monsters, full-fledged political intrigue or battles between secret organizations and intelligent NPCs.
1) slightly nerf Warblade. He's taking too high hd, feats/saves, etc for the maneuvers he takes in addition to what fighter takes.
2) you can keep a low magic feeling to the book (for Ravenloft purposes) by disallowing Desert Wind. Yes, shadow hand has supernatural abilities, but they feel much more ravenloft (but some of them should require power checks). And there are so many things you can do with 8 paths anyway.
3) Read the book very very carefully. A lot of the maneuvers are much less broken than they seem.
I think that, with some discretion in its use, Tome of Battle could actually enhance instead of damage the Ravenloft feeling. Compare the Falkovnian ex-soldier hero fighter/paladin to the Sitchican elf who has been so burdened by the shadows of his lands that it reflects in its combat moves, combining natural elf fluidity with shadow hand techniques.
When you introduce Tome of Battle in your game, you have to think of how rare or how well-known the maneuvers are. The basic options are:
1) Keeping it rare. Limited to a handful of secret organizations or cultures (Shadow Fey of course!). The PCs might be able to learn some techniques (with the appropriate feats), but at best one of them will have one of the martial adept classes. Uncovering the history behind the weird and unpredictable tricks of a villain is certainly Ravenloftish - you could even link the creation of some paths to corrupted individuals (learning them as a gift from the Mists) or major events.
2) Using it in place of some of the standard classes. Do you think that paladin's nerfing (detect evil etc), aura and abilities are quite tiresome? Use crusader, who can be used without nerfing as it is in Ravenloft. Do you think that anything more than 4 fighter levels is boring? Use some warblade levels for high level fighting types. You can also swap divinity of mankind monks for appropriate builds of swordsage (what dark gifts this "divinity" gives?).
For ready NPCs, swapping a feat for the feat that gives you a maneuver might give them an appropriate (for their style, theme, origin) maneuver.
This option makes combat much more unpredictable and interesting but it's not worth the effort if your Ravenloft campaign does not involve a respectable deal of combat. You'll find that Tome of Battle tends to lead towards a game with an average of one good, interesting combat per session, and less random encounters (battle between martial adepts gets this dark "Exalted" feeling and is often rewarding).
It also has a lot to do with whether your campaign turns around hunting half-sentient monsters, full-fledged political intrigue or battles between secret organizations and intelligent NPCs.
BEAUTIFUL IS!
CHAOS
too DIM MJLTIVERSE
IS TO NOTICE
MOST THE OF.
CHAOS
too DIM MJLTIVERSE
IS TO NOTICE
MOST THE OF.
-
AlltheMyriadWays
- Conspirator

- Posts: 7
- Joined: Sat May 26, 2007 3:28 am
We've had a 40 page debate on the WotC boards on whether or not Tome of Battle is "too anime". Needless to say it's not been particularly constructive for the most part.
However, Batshido (who is not me, I take no credit for this) took up another member's challenge to make Tome of Battle fit the Ravenloft feel, and I think he did a fine job.
Here's a direct link to the post.
Also, I'd like to go ahead and say hello to all you fine folks. I've been reading these boards for a while now, and I'm new to Ravenloft (it was unfortunately before my time) but I hope to be able to contribute!
However, Batshido (who is not me, I take no credit for this) took up another member's challenge to make Tome of Battle fit the Ravenloft feel, and I think he did a fine job.
Here's a direct link to the post.
Also, I'd like to go ahead and say hello to all you fine folks. I've been reading these boards for a while now, and I'm new to Ravenloft (it was unfortunately before my time) but I hope to be able to contribute!
- Dion of the Fraternity
- Lurker Maximus

- Posts: 1092
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 4:20 am
- Location: Baguio City, Philippines
- Contact:
I personally see good things about Tome of Battle when it comes to Ravenloft, and I--

What? you gasp? Dion loves both Tome of Battle and Ravenloft??
Why not?
I've read it and I guess it'd work well, although the whole "Nine Blades" metaplot needs to be heavily tweaked to fit into the Dread Realms. Besides, the legacy items found in it are awesome. 

What? you gasp? Dion loves both Tome of Battle and Ravenloft??
Why not?
- WolfKook
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 573
- Joined: Tue Oct 03, 2006 2:10 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Bogotá, Colombia
- Contact:
Well, I don't have it, and the legacy weapons in ToB make perfect sense to me. It might be that the rules are not essential, or that all these years of playing D&D have made me faster at grasping new concepts in the rules.HuManBing wrote:For legacy weapons, do you need to have the WoL handbook to make sense of it?
I really, really suspect it so.HuManBing wrote:Or is WoL relatively brief on rules and bigger on non-essential listings and stats?
"The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom"
William Blake
William Blake
