LordGodefroi wrote:Yes, but that doesn't mean they have to keep selling the same type of product every time there's a new release. Even Burger King sells chicken.
Agreed, but after 16 years of Ravenloft (off and on), and another 17 years of D&D before that, there really aren't that many new types left. Also, new people come into the hobby (especially with a new edition) and need to be brought up to speed on what's come before without resorting to ebay.
So yeah, I'll grumble a bit upon buying my 6th version of the RL campaign setting if it ever comes, but I'd grumble even more so if it doesn't give me more detail than the previous versions.
I started my rant with "Generally speaking." What I meant was: "In the gaming industry in general." I was being broader in scope. That is to say: There are more highly detailed campaign-world-specific fill-in-the-blanks products being published than there aren't. . . which means more details are being filled in by designers. . . which, for me, means less freedom for creative game masters.
Design gaps MUST exist because that is where players and game masters get their "play space." The only thing necessary is finding a balance between needed detail and "play space." For me, as it is now, I think that designers include fewer intentional design gaps than has been in the past.
I see your point, I'm just not sure that the design gaps you see were intentional. The only intentional gap I've ever seen acknowledged is the nature of the Dark Powers. Even back in the Black box, when the Nightmare Lands, Arak, and Forlorn were all but blank spaces, I always got the feeling that they were leaving themselves spots to fill in rather than leaving blanks for DM's to use. A friend and I worked up a whole drow-based Arak story with a drider darklord back then, but I wasn't disappointed when the "real" story was revealed later and turned out worlds better than ours.
If we still didn't know the darklord of the Nightmare Lands by now, I'd be very surprised (and disappointed).
And I happen to see unintentional gaps everywhere in Ravenloft. There's a whole black splotch at the edges of the map to fill in. There are big spaces between towns where more towns could go. No town has every single inhabitant detailed. (I doubt even FR can boast that). (And no, I'm not counting the Mordentshire of I10. That's Mordentshire of the past). Even if it did, who says someone else can't move in? Even Strahd, arguably the most detailed character of the setting, has whole centuries of his life that are unexplored.
I don't see many places where you can say "my idea doesn't fit here" from a detail perspective. (from a flavor perspective, maybe, but not because there's an irreparable contradiction.)
One thing I hate even more are "living" game worlds where a product advances a meta-plot and assumes you're playing along with it.
I will agree with you there. One thing that crops up from time to time around here is "Advance the timeline!" Which I don't really get. things are happening all throughout Ravenloft, just nothing as earth shattering as the Requiem or Grand Conjunction, and that's as it should be. Let the world exist as a place to play without drastic alterations that have to be incorporated or worked around.
In any case, the more that there are products which do my thinking for me, rather than inspire me to think for myself, the less I'll buy them.
Well, it's good for your bank account at least.

The trouble is, I just don't see much new ground being broken in the "DM tools" type of books. Heroes of Horror was quite good IMHO, but a lot of it was ideas we RL fans have seen already, and a lot of it was filler to pad out the page count (do we need to know the DC to jump on a tombstone?). I'm reading Libris Mortis now and while there are some gems in there, a lot of it is old hat to anyone who's read a Van Richten's Guide. (The best idea you have for a variant vampire is one who is hurt by moonlight?)
The honest truth is that every single RPG company could go belly-up today and never publish a thing again, and we'd all survive and continue to play. There's enough material out there to inspire 10 lifetimes of campaigns. But I'd still be first in line to buy Gazetteer, volume VI.

"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."