Seconded. All it does it take away humanity's vaulted flexibility.Jakob wrote:I really do not like the idea. Difference in nationality can be exploited trough skills, feats and good old roleplay, with no need to have "nationality modifiers".JinnTolser wrote:I proposed the idea of different statistics for different nationalities of humans once on the Kargatane board years ago, and it was almost universally rejected. I still think it's a good one, especially with demihumans playing such a small part in canon RL. I wouldn't go as far as to have different ability score adjustments, nor would I want humans' extra bonus feat to be automatic for a given nationality. But perhaps an additional benefit/drawback for each nationality would add some variety.
Even in Greyhawk's Player's Guide the different stats for human "races" were absolutely optional.
Well, look at the folklore of gnomes.Jakob wrote:I do not agree. Gnomes are really different from dwarves. They have a natural spellcasting tradition, with even small children being taught to use cantrips (they CAN use them spontaneously, after all), and the 3.5 minor change (with bard as their favored class) make them repository of knowledge, after all... Quite different from dwarves. Theirs, for example, is not a culture obsessed with leaving traces of their passage on earth.
They're shot little people who live in caves, mine, turn to stone when exposed to sunlight and horde magnificent treasures. Books on gnomes could almost be written verbatim about dwarves.
The only differences seem to be the legends that gnomes are tricksters and more goblin-ish than dwarves and that gnomes are typically a foot tall.
Now look at D&D. In 2nd Edition gnomes were almost identical with most of the same racial abilities but a desire for gems and fondness for illusions.
Ravenloft tried to make them different by making dwarves more like Vikings and gnomes like Greeks.
Dragonlance made them tinkerers.
3E made them bards while taking bits and pieces from Dragonlance.
But, at their core, they're a short subterranean people that lives in caves and has a good constitution. Like dwarves. Only they're a magical people with natural arcane talents. Like elves.



