I've pretty nearly read it through, making it the second-best Ravenloft product I've read this month (after VRS: Dopplegangers, natch
1. Well, now I can finish "A Gentleman by Moonlight" without any heinous Darkon errors. Yay! Since the first draft is already done and the second nearly typed into the computer, I should get it posted before Halloween. Too bad it's more "interesting" than "scary," but hey.
2. Is there any more overpowered ability in the history of roleplaying than Azalin Rex's modify memory ability? Seriously--the guy can completely rewrite the memories of anyone in his entire domain, living or dead, at will, no saving throw? I swear, the DM's Tip on p. 137 is more an attempt by the writers to pretend it's possible to oppose Azalin in any direct way (sure, it's certainly possible to foil a plan around the fringes of his scheming which isn't worth his personal attention--but the instant he becomes personally aware of opposition within Darkon, *poof*, it's over). On the other hand, I genuinely prefer this to all the Undying Soul darklords running around Ravenloft. At least the PCs have no chance of destroying Azalin because he's too tough for them, not because the Dark Powers cheat to keep them alive eternally...
Or am I just missing something painfully obvious (like, "it doesn't work on native Darkonese the same way the false memory function does")?
3. Death. Is it possible to face the Grim Reaper and snicker. Love the wink-and-a-nudge reference to when "Necropolis" was the name of the whole domain.
4. Nice to see the Fraternity of Shadows mentioned.
5. The reference to "a small band of heroes" defeating Tavelia and restoring Azalin...was this an actual published adventure?
6. You know, it's not every day where restoring a lich-king to a position of total, unquestioned power counts as a major-league good deed! Probably gives the party's paladin a serious headache.
7. Lamordia is a very cool place, though I'm sorry about Ivan Dragonov's Dread Possibility. Come to think of it, what's up with the setting designers retconning the official fiction so often? Jander's wonderfully apposite death in Vampire of the Mists cancelled out, Dragonov's redemption from Tales of Ravenloft spoiled (at least as a Dread Possibility rather than canon), The Enemy Within's Tristen obliterated, I, Strahd treated as the highly-skewed portrayal of events from an unreliable narrator, Adam's story in Mordenheim the same...
8. Why is Adam the darklord of Lamordia and not Mordenheim? This one comes up every so often, but I really would like to know. Mordenheim is the one who commits the original sin. He's the one who actively chooses the sin of pride over a fundamental code of morality, and who visits a very personal destruction on his loved ones (Elise, Eva...even Adam, in a way, suffers from Mordenheim's evil because he gets stuck with an "evil" soul purely to punish Mordenheim). Heck, he's the one suffering from the curse (his fruitless quest to restore life to Elise). Adam...at worst, he's a side effect--and I don't see how it is that Adam should be punished by being imprisoned as darklord of Lamordia for maiming Elise (even assuming that he's really responsible for it, unlike the tale he tells in Mordenheim) when it's clearly established that he was specifically created with a corrupt, evil soul by the gods that Mordenheim rebelled against. Unlike, say, Strahd or Azalin, he was never given the choice to choose "good"--he lacked free will because of the divine curse levied against him before his "birth."
It's almost as if the original Black Box designers looked at Adam and fell into the trap of all the peasants in every Frankenstein movie ever made--they looked at the "monster" and screamed in horror. Weird.
9. I'm glad to see that Drakov-as-written is as lame as I was characterizing his Black Box version in the "Lame Darklords & Fixes" thread. I would like to say, however, that Falkovnia is very well written, and I can actually see using it as a setting or playing in it. It's a completely different kind of horror than the classic Gothic horror more suitable to Mordent, Lamordia, and Dementlieu, but it is excellent stuff. I must say, that without being able to take the step of completely rewriting Drakov from the ground up, the writers here did as much as they could ever be expected to to make Falkovnia into a viable setting.
10. I note that becoming a vassalich is listed as being an "irredeemably evil act." Is that supposed to be Ravenloft-specific, or generally applicable? 2nd Ed. liches, after all, could be of any alignment, but VRGttL points out that Ravenloft liches were universally evil (probably because the Mists don't take in outlander non-evil liches and because any way to become a lich inside Ravenloft would require various irredeemably evil acts along the way).
11. Lamordia's "rationalism" appears to be nothing of the sort. On the contrary, it more accurately resembles "rejection of the divine/supernatural as a belief system." This, to me, is too eerily reflective of Mordenheim's own belief system to be a coincidence--especially when you add in the effect of the Dakj Fe'nunft (which itself reminds me a bit of Gray Mundane from Piers Anthony's Xanth books: a Magician whose supernatural Talent is to make magic not exist). By the way, the effect that Mordenheim's personal attitudes have on both the people and the land of Lamordia seem to, once again, suggest that it's Mordenheim who is the true Darklord...



