Strolling through the Mordent section of Gaz. III (hm, anyone going to do the Arden Bay serpent for the new VRS guide on sea monsters?), I noticed several points in the various histories of the vanished noble families of Mordent.
Now, it's pretty well-established that Mordent came into Ravenloft in 579, what with the Alchemist and Strahd and Azalin and whatnot, so the vast majority of the backgrounds of the noble families fall into the "false history" category, making their accuracy or lack thereof questionable. Still, these raise several interesting questions concerning Mordent and its connection to the Mists of Ravenloft even before 579.
Now, we're told that the Mournesworths were the "last of the great bloodlines to pass into antiquity" (p.55) and that they vanished in 579--apparently they simply didn't get dragged along into Ravenloft along with everyone else (perhaps the DPs didn't want to burden their new toy with a whole family of honestly devout priests and scholars?--and come to think of it, how cool is the suggestion that the Mournesworth cemetery in Ravenloft keeps acquiring new tombstones to match the progression of the Mournesworth family back in the Prime Plane?).
Yet, at least two of the "false history" chapters of the destruction of the other families bear the unmistakable stamp of Ravenloft's presence, at least in their Dread Possibilities (leaving outside the suggestion that a Gauldamon was last sighted in 673, which if correct throws everything else into question--I suspect that it is a typo and that "573" was meant).
First, the Halloway family. The "Smythe's Secret" Dread Possibility states that Smythe the ferryman made a deal with a Mist Ferryman by which he brought the Ferryman victims in exchange for the Halloway family's treasure(p. 39). In addition to the statement that the Mournesworths were the last family, the Halloway entry states that the murders on the Arden occurred in 502-547 (p.54); likewise the entry talks about rumors that the Mists themselves sought the family's destruction ("Mists" being capitalized, in the sense of the Mists of Ravenloft). Yet all this matter seems to ignore the facts that while the Mists of Ravenloft were hunting the Halloway bloodline and Smythe was repeatedly delivering victims to a Mist Ferryman, Mordent was not in Ravenloft. While we know, of course, that the Mists can reach out into other lands, the fate of the Halloway family implies an extended and definite connection over a long period of time between Mordent and Ravenloft.
Similarly, there is the Dread Possibility concerning the fate of the Scottmaster family (p.52). While no date is formally given for the end of the Scottmasters, the note that the Mournesworths were the last of the nine families to pass on raises the issue that Lady Margaret was somehow able to connect to the lairs of the "dreaded shadow fey" despite Mordent being outside the Mists.
A third possibility may be raised in the fate of the Wescotes, which most of us know from "Howls in the Night." While this matter is again undated by internal sources (and even more confusingly, S somehow overlooks its existence entirely), the Mournesworth entry must put it before 579. John W. Mangrum's unofficial Ravenloft timeline (here in the FoS's Mausoleum), puts the curse that fell on Burton Wescote in 643, while noting that the bride couldn't have been Dementlieuse since Dementlieu hadn't even existed then--a suggestion that I agree with since on the one hand "Campbell" is certainly not a Dementlieuse name--though they could have been one of the Mordentish noble families that emigrated to there (Gaz. III, p.48)--and on the other hand HotN places the event as "around one hundred years ago" which is a good five decades of extra time. One might postulate that, if the tale did happen pre-579, that the details have been twisted with people's understanding (the bride, for example, would have come from a country that does not now border Mordent, resulting in the substitution of Dementlieu in the legend, creating the dating and family name errors). On the other hand, since one Wescote is still, technically, alive, it might be considered not to have been among the families that "faded into antiquity"--i.e. the Mournesworths were the last of the eight vanished noble families, not the nine, though this is contradicted by the assertion in the "Lost Families of Mordent" sidebar (Gaz. III, p.51).
Mordenshire nobility and false history...
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Re: Mordenshire nobility and false history...
Well, I guess somebody will now, because until you posted this I'd forgotten all about that one! Thanks for the reference, Sylaire.Sylaire wrote:(hm, anyone going to do the Arden Bay serpent for the new VRS guide on sea monsters?)
Interesting point! Hmmm....The "Smythe's Secret" Dread Possibility states that Smythe the ferryman made a deal with a Mist Ferryman by which he brought the Ferryman victims in exchange for the Halloway family's treasure(p. 39). In addition to the statement that the Mournesworths were the last family, the Halloway entry states that the murders on the Arden occurred in 502-547 (p.54)
Perhaps Smythe's initial murder of the young Halloway couple actually caused him to be drawn into Ravenloft, like so many other villains before and after him? When the ferryman came upon him, he'd already been taken up by the Mists, and his attempt to bargain with it caused him to become one of the Fugued. For a time, he crossed over from Ravenloft to Mordent (still on the Material Plane) and preyed on the village, much as the Phantom Lover drops in on Material Plane widows. Then, when the Halloways were all dead, the ferryman ditched him in an oubliette (the ferry crossing), where he lingered until the rest of Mordent appeared in Ravenloft, incorporating his ferry into itself.
The notion that Smythe is Fugued could explain why the old geezer is still around, centuries after his original crime: he's either unaging as a result of his altered nature, or he simply doesn't exist in the intervals of time between visitors, and is reabsorbed into the Mists when nobody else is around.
That one, I'd take with a grain of salt. S compiled the tale of the family's demise, centuries after the fact, and she said herself that official records don't go back that far. Rumors that "the Mists" were responsible could easily have been incorporated into the account of the Halloways' demise, after Mordent had been taken up by Ravenloft. Folk in the Land of Mists do tend to lay blame for anything unexplained on the Mists' malign influence, with or without cause.likewise the entry talks about rumors that the Mists themselves sought the family's destruction ("Mists" being capitalized, in the sense of the Mists of Ravenloft).
That one, we really can't explain away as anything other than an editorial error. (Not unless we assume that some of the sith who fled the Plane of Shadow didn't wind up in Ravenloft, but were scattered on their way through the Obsidian Gate and found themselves in Material Plane Mordent!) If the sidebar wasn't OOC, we could argue that the "sith" Lady Margaret witnessed was a native fey of Mordent's world of origin -- it's not as if such a capricious fey would be out of place in a rural pseudo-British setting, away from Ravenloft -- but as it stands, it explicitly names Sithington as a shadow fey. It's one that we just have to toss out the dates for.Similarly, there is the Dread Possibility concerning the fate of the Scottmaster family (p.52). While no date is formally given for the end of the Scottmasters, the note that the Mournesworths were the last of the nine families to pass on raises the issue that Lady Margaret was somehow able to connect to the lairs of the "dreaded shadow fey" despite Mordent being outside the Mists.
(FWIW, we know that the Scottmatter lineage isn't entirely gone, as Father Scott of the FoS has Scottmatter (and fir) blood. Perhaps his more obscure branch of the family hadn't been represented in Lord Andrew's painting?)
As for the Wescotes, I think the "about a hundred years" reference in HitN is probably just the NPC sheriff's shorthand for "long enough that nobody alive then is alive now". His family might've passed down the story of the Wescotes' demise for several generations, always starting it off with the same "about a hundred years ago"!
But really, if the dates make no sense, simply retconning them is likely the best solution of all. It's not as if the writers haven't done the same, in the official products: in the original Black Box bloodline, Gerard d'Honaire died at age six, yet LotB has him living to age sixteen ... long enough to reveal his immunity to Dominic's mind-control and provoke his darklord uncle into having him murdered!
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
Well, really, I don't think any of the noble famlies are completly gone. Otherwise, what's the point of putting them there? Their legacies affect the land, sure, but don't forget the mention of a lot of Mordentish nobility moving up to Dementileu the first chance they got-Mordent, as presented, definately has a "Waiting for the mysterious heir(s) to find their legacy and save the nation." feel to it, y'know?
But in regards to dates, don't forget that the Mists can alter time, too. Once Mordent was inside Ravenloft, the history of the domain became something for the Mists to screw around with-who's to say that those terrible tradgeties didn't happen because of a loop in time? That could even be made into an Adventure hook; the PCs stumble on a mistway to the death of one of the Mordentish famlies, and have a chance to try and make history turn out a little kinder.
At the very least, it's useful to have the last names and mottos for the endless numbers of otherwise anoymnous northwestern core nobility.
But in regards to dates, don't forget that the Mists can alter time, too. Once Mordent was inside Ravenloft, the history of the domain became something for the Mists to screw around with-who's to say that those terrible tradgeties didn't happen because of a loop in time? That could even be made into an Adventure hook; the PCs stumble on a mistway to the death of one of the Mordentish famlies, and have a chance to try and make history turn out a little kinder.
At the very least, it's useful to have the last names and mottos for the endless numbers of otherwise anoymnous northwestern core nobility.

