Darkon's Memory Drain, or Everywhere Else's?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Lord Cyclohexane
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 512
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 1:59 pm
Location: Tanelorn, OH

Darkon's Memory Drain, or Everywhere Else's?

Post by Lord Cyclohexane »

My girlfriend had an interesting idea regarding Darkon's memory drain upon leaving Darkon:

Since the victim is completely convinced that (s)he is a native Darkonian, wouldn't it be equally likely that the person thinks that his/her *real* memories are the false ones, that the person has always been a Darkonian but is receiving false memories of a life outside of Darkon?

So, to the individual going through it, does it seem like Darkon has the memory alteration or does it seem like all of the lands *outside* of Darkon are the ones with the memory alteration?

Has anyone played around with this particular possibility before? Any suggestions on running with it?
My name is lost to me
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

I have not considered it precisely from that angle.

But, if you recall the TV show Nowhere Man, I have always thought that an adventure run like that, where the truth of one's backstory and even of who one is, is bought into question as memory and evidence shifts under one's feet would be the perfect adventure for Darkon.
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
Lord Cyclohexane
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 512
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 1:59 pm
Location: Tanelorn, OH

Post by Lord Cyclohexane »

cure wrote:I have not considered it precisely from that angle.
Nor had I, until she mentioned it. But she made a darn good point, that the "false memory" problem only comes up with Darkonian natives (as they think themselves to be), and only on that first time that the native remembers having tried to leave...
cure wrote:But, if you recall the TV show Nowhere Man, I have always thought that an adventure run like that, where the truth of one's backstory and even of who one is, is bought into question as memory and evidence shifts under one's feet would be the perfect adventure for Darkon.
It'd be very difficult to pull off for an entire *group* of people going through it, but if you incorporated some elements from Final Fantasy 8's story (regarding them losing memories due to interaction with the Espers, thus them not even remembering that they'd previously known each other) then I think that combo of Nowhere Man ideas and Final Fantasy 8 (to make it group-sized) could make it work.
My name is lost to me
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

In my campaigns, I'm holding that the Darkonian memory drain is permanent, even if the victim escapes Darkon.

Once they cross the border, their false memories are shown to be false, but they do not regain their original memories.

A black market of do-gooders and exploiters has sprung up near the border to help these unfortunates out if they need it.

This has fairly interesting role playing possibilities if your players are up for a "Memento" type adventure.
User avatar
Sylaire
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 280
Joined: Thu Mar 15, 2007 10:27 pm
Location: Maine

Post by Sylaire »

One point brought to the fore by Gaz. II is that Darkonians actually are aware of the fact that their nation has the memory draining effect, and one of the shadows lurking in the back of the minds of natives is whether or not everything they remember is real.

(They don't talk about it openly, but it obviously gets whispered about or no one would know about the effect.)

Thus when one leaves Darkon and regains one's true memories, there's no reason to doubt that they're actually the true ones, presuming that the person had spent any significant amount of time in Darkon and talked to people.

An interesting idea might be, though, to have a native Darkonese (darn it, what IS the possessive form of "Darkon"?!?) who crosses the border and then is preyed on by some kind of telepathic monster which starts playing games with his/her memories for its own nefarious purposes...
User avatar
lostboy
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1795
Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2007 8:12 am
Location: Biding my time...

Post by lostboy »

An interesting idea might be, though, to have a native Darkonese (darn it, what IS the possessive form of "Darkon"?!?) who crosses the border and then is preyed on by some kind of telepathic monster which starts playing games with his/her memories for its own nefarious purposes...
At the risk of subverting this thread Id go for "Darkoniantarian"... :lol:

But I do like the idea you mention. consider it suitably "borrowed".
"I had a dream, which was not all a dream.
The bright sun was extinguish'd, and the stars
Did wander darkling in the eternal space..."
User avatar
Lord Cyclohexane
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 512
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 1:59 pm
Location: Tanelorn, OH

Post by Lord Cyclohexane »

HuManBing wrote:Once they cross the border, their false memories are shown to be false, but they do not regain their original memories.
If they do not regain their original memories, how do they know their memories are false? What would make them doubt their own memories?
HuManBing wrote:A black market of do-gooders and exploiters has sprung up near the border to help these unfortunates out if they need it.
An interesting idea, though I've never heard of any organized group actively preventing non-native native Darkonese from leaving the country.
HuManBing wrote:This has fairly interesting role playing possibilities if your players are up for a "Memento" type adventure.
Perhaps. Although, like how the main character in "Momento" puts faith in the tattoo notes he's written, I believe the PCs would trust the memories that they have, the ones that show how they grew up in Darkon, how their parents died at a relatively young age, and how the PCs then grew up in one of Darkon's great quality orphanages.

Like the main character in "Momento", I doubt the PCs would believe in anyone having tampered with their "true" memories of being Darkonians (just as the main character never considered that he could have written a false tattoo note) and would instead disbelieve the "false" memories that flood into their minds.

In any case, I'm half-thinking that a Madness check might be in order when leaving Darkon. Failure entails gaining a delusion, success means staying with the Darkonese memories, and success +10 means returning to their true memories from before entering Darkon.
My name is lost to me
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
User avatar
Lord Cyclohexane
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 512
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 1:59 pm
Location: Tanelorn, OH

Post by Lord Cyclohexane »

Sylaire wrote:One point brought to the fore by Gaz. II is that Darkonians actually are aware of the fact that their nation has the memory draining effect, and one of the shadows lurking in the back of the minds of natives is whether or not everything they remember is real.
I don't recall it being presented that way at all, but perhaps I'm remembering incorrectly. As I recall, S refers to the rare occurrence of foreigners suddenly forgetting who they are and believing that they've always lived in Darkon; natives will then politely never bring up the fact, but simply let it be.

However, S did not mention anything regarding "memory draining" or about it being linked to the Kingdom of Darkon. Rather, it's an odd phenomena that occassionally occurs, but there is currently no known cause of it.

Considering that most people in that day and age never travelled more than 10 miles from the place they were born, I imagine most Darkonians would assume this to be a universal phenomena, that it occurs as often in Richemulot or Hazlan as it does in Darkon. There is nothing to lead one to believe that it's linked to the Land of Darkon, and even once noticed, it would be more sane to believe this phenomena linked to a disease, to an inbalance in the humors, to a defect in the nervous system, etc; to believe it linked to a physical landmass is insane.
Sylaire wrote:(They don't talk about it openly, but it obviously gets whispered about or no one would know about the effect.)

Thus when one leaves Darkon and regains one's true memories, there's no reason to doubt that they're actually the true ones, presuming that the person had spent any significant amount of time in Darkon and talked to people.
"There's no reason to doubt," eh? I beg to differ. If I heard about such problems of people losing their memory and getting different ones, my first reaction would be "huh, sucks to be them." If, upon crossing the border, I should happen to get an additional set of memories to my own, the reaction would be "But that's something that only happens to other people. There must be a logical explanation for this."

Yes, you see, *other people* might have false memories. Not me. I know exactly who I am and exactly who my friends and family are. Yeah, some people might have truly been from somewhere else and now believe that they're native Darkonians, only to have it revealed later to be false. But that can't happen to me. That only happens to other people. I just haven't eaten properly today, have been stressed out lately, am still reacting poorly to the mummy rot in my system, or perhaps this is a new assault from the Nighmare Court. But true memories returning to me? Hell no, I know exactly who I am and I'll get to the bottom of these false memories that are trying to convince me that I'm not Darkonian. After all, I know who I am.

Anyway, that's how I see myself reacting, considering how many things in real life that I've reacted to that way (that it couldn't be true because those things only happen to other people). So the whole "having no reason to doubt" doesn't ring true, considering what I know of my own life.
Sylaire wrote:(darn it, what IS the possessive form of "Darkon"?!?)
You were correct above with "Darkonese." I just couldn't remember it and went with "Darkonian." Although, honestly, since we're talking about fictional countries, I don't think it actually matters in the least.
Sylaire wrote:An interesting idea might be, though, to have a native Darkonese who crosses the border and then is preyed on by some kind of telepathic monster which starts playing games with his/her memories for its own nefarious purposes...
Might be cool to do that with a bastellus, considering their dream control. Then the PC could be made to roleplay out his/her own past through the dreams, whether as the old PC (original memories) again going through the trials of his/her old life and realizing what made him/her the way he/she is, or as the new PC (replacement memories) opposing his/her old self and the things that old life represented.

Regardless, it might be interesting to have the PC be conflicted for the entire rest of the game, never quite certain which life was real, but pulling strength from positive events of each lifetime and using both lives' lessons in becoming a true hero.
My name is lost to me
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

Lord Cyclohexane,

Congrats on your ebay purchase. Perhaps it will shed some light on the memory matter. Interesting to run across someone from the forum off forum for the first time.

cure
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

Lord Cyclohexane wrote:
HuManBing wrote:Once they cross the border, their false memories are shown to be false, but they do not regain their original memories.
If they do not regain their original memories, how do they know their memories are false? What would make them doubt their own memories?
The mechanic here would be rather like Darkon's Book of Names in Castle Avernus snatching away their memories as it writes them down. Then the land gives them new ones. Once they leave the land, the new ones either vanish entirely (leaving them completely clueless) or become weak and unconvincing. However, because the Book of Names still holds their memories, these do not return unless they proactively do something about it.
Lord Cyclohexane wrote:
HuManBing wrote:A black market of do-gooders and exploiters has sprung up near the border to help these unfortunates out if they need it.
An interesting idea, though I've never heard of any organized group actively preventing non-native native Darkonese from leaving the country.
You're right about that. This was entirely my interpretation, so it's not surprising it would be unsupported by canon. You also appear to have slightly misread my intention. I'm suggesting there are groups near the border that either try to help them (e.g. helping temples, saving their souls, and making the transition easier for them) or unscrupulous groups to exploit them (e.g. claiming to have some information about their true pasts and forcing them to work for it, etc.). None of the groups is trying to prevent them from leaving Darkon per se - they're just trying to engage with this trickle of humanity that has a somewhat disabling condition in that they can't trust their memories.
Lord Cyclohexane wrote:Perhaps. Although, like how the main character in "Momento" puts faith in the tattoo notes he's written, I believe the PCs would trust the memories that they have, the ones that show how they grew up in Darkon, how their parents died at a relatively young age, and how the PCs then grew up in one of Darkon's great quality orphanages.

Like the main character in "Momento", I doubt the PCs would believe in anyone having tampered with their "true" memories of being Darkonians (just as the main character never considered that he could have written a false tattoo note) and would instead disbelieve the "false" memories that flood into their minds.
That's assuming logic without any magical effect. Darkon's memories are somewhat contradictory if you look at it purely through how a rational person would act. (Why exactly do so many Darkonian citizens wait until they're, say, competent adults before setting up gravestones to long-dead parents? Do siblings have similar and supporting false memories of shared childhood and parentage? Will the magical effects construct love affairs, shared schooling memories, past social interactions, etc. between strangers who have never met each other but are both mindwiped? How about native Darkonian citizens who are never mindwiped? How do they fit in with the newcomers? If people lose their memories of family and fatherland, do they lose their memories of their own names? How about their own tongues? Many questions to be answered.)

My interpretation would be that the magical effect of Darkon suppresses the logical doubts, or makes the victims more accepting of the inherent contradictions. (See I, Strahd: The War Against Azalin for a well-written episode where Azalin tampers with Strahd's mind in a subtle way. Strahd never quite puts together the clues to guess Azalin's true nature until it's literally staring him in the face. I think my interpretation has a neat ironic echo of that.)
Lord Cyclohexane wrote:In any case, I'm half-thinking that a Madness check might be in order when leaving Darkon. Failure entails gaining a delusion, success means staying with the Darkonese memories, and success +10 means returning to their true memories from before entering Darkon.
I like that mechanic. I might stea- er-, adapt it for my own campaign.


And for what it's worth, I think officially the adjective has always been "Darkonese", which I do not like. I have always used "Darkonian" regardless of whether canon supports this or not. My rulebooks and players have yet to complain to me about this.
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

IIRC, "Darkonese" is the language, "Darkonians" are the people.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
Nathan of the FoS
Fiendish Enforcer
Fiendish Enforcer
Posts: 5247
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
Location: San Francisco CA

Post by Nathan of the FoS »

Rotipher of the FoS wrote:IIRC, "Darkonese" is the language, "Darkonians" are the people.
IMC the eastern part of Darkon uses "Darkonian", the western uses "Darkonese". IIRC I've seen both in official products, so that was my kludge. (I might have just invented it, though...confabulation strikes again!)
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
User avatar
Sylaire
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 280
Joined: Thu Mar 15, 2007 10:27 pm
Location: Maine

Post by Sylaire »

Okay, I went and dug out my Gaz. II. When in doubt, consult the books. Rotipher was right; Darkonese is the language and Darkonian the possessive for the population as well as for goods/customs/other objects and concepts...at least, since the Gazetteer was published. Before then, who knows? :)

Now, as for the memory loss:

"Darkonians are well aware of this phenonemon, but consider it a taboo topic for polite conversation. Instead, Darkonians euphemistically speak of Darkon as an ancient crossroads, where many visitors rediscover their roots. This, despite this widespread awareness of Darkon's memory leeching soil, most newcomers are still taken entirely by surprise when Darkon comes to claim them.

"The satisfaction I expressed earlier in knowing that 'I am real' is not overstated. The memory drain is exclusive to Darkon's planar fabric; the moment a 'claimed' individual leaves the kingdom, the false memories fade and their true pasts return, like a sleeper waking from a dream. In accepting this project, I was forced to confront every Darkonian's deepest, most private fear: that he does not exist..."

(pages 24-25)

That's from S, of course, and thus is subject to potential narrator inaccuracy, but the p. 25 sidebar also states unequivocably: "Most simply, a subject's true memories are restored the instant she leaves the domain."

That doesn't settle all the questions, but it does quantify canon on some of 'em...though, of course, canon as only as binding as the DM and players want it to be. ;)
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

To make it clear, I do not dispute what canon says on the topic. I merely hold that it's a bit of a cop out to just leave the domain and "zip!" all your memories come back.

At the very least I would require some spells to restore memories that were claimed by the Book of Names. I think there's a 9th level spell Modify Memory, but I can't remember if it's PHB or SC...
User avatar
Lord Cyclohexane
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 512
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 1:59 pm
Location: Tanelorn, OH

Post by Lord Cyclohexane »

Sylaire wrote:(Quoting Gaz II) "The satisfaction I expressed earlier in knowing that 'I am real' is not overstated. The memory drain is exclusive to Darkon's planar fabric; the moment a 'claimed' individual leaves the kingdom, the false memories fade and their true pasts return, like a sleeper waking from a dream. In accepting this project, I was forced to confront every Darkonian's deepest, most private fear: that he does not exist..."

(pages 24-25)

That's from S, of course, and thus is subject to potential narrator inaccuracy, but the p. 25 sidebar also states unequivocably: "Most simply, a subject's true memories are restored the instant she leaves the domain."
No, that makes sense, and apparently it'd been a bit since I'd last read it. The choice of description of it being "like a sleeper waking from a dream" works for me, since I've had a number of dreams where I remember being someone else and even remember that someone else accessing his memories of past events. So this works for me.

Interestingly, though, it also works with my girlfriend's idea, though slightly differently than she'd conceived. She wanted to play someone who was fiercely Darkonian but who, it turns out, was never a Darkonian at all. As such, when the false memories would disappear, her character would instead fight for the idea that the false memories were the true ones and try to regain them.

So, instead of her just doubting right off the bat, it'll have to work a touch differently, I see. She'll have to first see it as a depressing dream (like me waking up and realizing that I really can't fly, dream notwithstanding), and then, upon checking out Darkon further, seeing that her alter-ego indeed *was* real as her effects are quite well seen, people recognize her by the alter-ego's name, her deeds resonated in either a positive or negative way... So perhaps the Darkonian personality is indeed true...

But, as per the clarified description of how the memory-regaining works, this situation would only work because my girlfriend's character *wants* the Darkonian personality to be the true one and sounds likely to be able to successfully delude herself.

Anyway, cool, thanks for the help!
My name is lost to me
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
Post Reply