Doppelgangers aren't generally seen to use weapons in their natural forms -- even when slam attacks are plainly inferior -- yet their disguises often require them to wield them. By the letter of the rules, they should (as monstrous humanoids) be proficient with only simple weapons, plus those weapons mentioned in their entry ... in dopps' case, none.The Giamarga wrote:Why o why do they gain so much from the Change Shape ability? I mean weapon proficiency? By looking at people? I can see natural attacks, but proficieny in weapons?
As there are numerous examples in Ravenloft and other sources of non-classed doppelgangers wielding weapons as part of their disguise (e.g. Sudji's use of a longsword in HotK), they needed more options than that. It would cripple their ability to infiltrate adventuring groups, police and military forces, and so forth if they couldn't wield weapons at least well enough to pass. As their metagame function would be ruined if they can't undertake such deceptions, an alternative had to be reached, else any doppelganger who engaged in even a brief skirmish while disguised (or was challenged to a fencing match by suspicious PCs) would be exposed immediately.
Note that proficiencies acquired via observation are only valid for the role of the person they'd watched using the weapon. If a dopp watches a fighter wielding a spear, it can only wield a spear while impersonating that particular fighter, and its base attack bonus and modifiers remain its own. (A fencing match might still expose it, it just won't be dropping its sword every other round.)
Getting movement modes is pretty standard for polymorphing effects. Wings wouldn't be available unless the dopp 1) has a feat that expands its repretoire beyond humanoids-only, or 2) has met a humanoid with wings. So far as I know, there are no such races in Ravenloft: wings tend to mean you qualify as a monstrous humanoid (ravenkin, gargoyles, etc).Movement modes ? Really? I can see that they would be better at swimming if they turn into a merfolk due to the webbed hands and feet but do they really get a swim speed of 50, withoug growing gills ? Can they grow wings?
Most of the time, it'd be just like a human. Under the full moon, quevari become feral and aggressive, and dopps can get "into character" enough to emulate that. Mostly, though, the "extraordinary attacks" allowance is for the benefit of dopps in other game-settings, who have a wider range of humanoids to imitate; quevari are the one Ravenloft-specific humanoid race that has an extraordinary attack and could serve as an example.What is the Quevari Bloodmoon ability again? I'm not sure if I am confortable with them gaining them. Shouldn't a quevari count as a disguised human for a doppleganger?
It's exactly the same as the Reduce Person spell.Also the Dex +2, Str -2 when shifting to Small size does somehow not sit right with me.


