Rotipher of the FoS wrote:I think it's a deliberate retconn, to make Darkon a more viable place for campaigns. Too many players who'd heard about the memory-draining effect had their PCs avoid Darkon like the plague, for fear of having their backstories permanently tampered with ...
I'll admit, I have that problem myself. As such, I've only considered using Darkon as a beginning place for a campaign, and haven't considered it as somewhere that outside PCs might go to.
But, I don't really see how the "regaining your memories upon crossing the border" actually helps matters; there's still the terrible problem of having the players roleplay their PCs losing their memories and being someone else while in Darkon, and it's made worse by them now having to switch back again when leaving. Maybe it works better for people who have reliable players who don't metagame at all; hell, the fact that I've only just run across a group of such players is the only reason I'm even *considering* running a campaign with Darkon in it, since I know they're good about avoiding metagaming.
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:... this, despite the fact that it's the most comfortable environment in which players from traditional D&D campaigns can get used to Ravenloft (demihumans present, arcane magic tolerated, etc).
Not to mention being one of the most pleasant places to live anyway, with low taxes, ready food, well-kept roads, excellent orphanages, etc. Darkon is an absolutely ideal place to live.
But the memory drain doesn't tend to be my biggest problem. The biggest problem was, again, metagaming related. Since Azalin is one of those few recognizable names for people who know next-to-nothing about Ravenloft, if your players tend to metagame, then they're immediately interested in opposing and killing Azalin, in spite of the fact that Azalin runs the best kingdom in the entire Core.
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:While in-game it's a quandry, it makes perfect sense from a behind-the-curtain standpoint to make the memory-loss reversible. There's nothing that most players resent more than forfeiting their PCs' self-direction.
It was always reversible, just less easily. But then, you reference that below. Honestly, though, I'd never run across a
quill of law so I hadn't realized that was a minor artifact...
But then, I had just planned to have the PCs keep their normal memories anyway and have some reason for Azalin to specifically shield them from the memory drain. I hadn't yet figured what that reason might be, but whatever.
As I'm interested in starting this next game in Darkon itself, though (since most of the players enjoy playing demihumans; so start with something more familiar and then move from there), that really didn't come into play anyway; they'd start game with their memories removed, if they in fact weren't actually natives, so no worries on losing them later. Although, honestly, I could run an entire campaign in Darkon itself, and may do so, so I'm not sure this thread is even of any value to me: I just started it out of curiousity.
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Otherwise... the problem arises of The Shrouded Years: did non-native "native" Darkonians regain their true memories during those years where Death was the Darklord in Azalin's place?
Probably not, else S wouldn't have had any cause to doubt her own 'real' history. She'd surely have documented any memories that were revealed to her at that time, so even if the drain returned, she's have found her own notes about the discrepancy and realized the truth. So it's likely that the books of memories kept right on scribing themselves under Castle Avernus, the whole time Azalin's essence was dispersed.
A good point, if S were non-native. However, if S is a native, she'd see no change as her own memories would be true to begin with and so there'd be no false memories to replace. As such, she'd write nothing in her books about it as there was nothing to happen.
And considering that S had no real interaction with people during the Shrouded Years (was studying Necropolis most of that time, including when Azalin regained power), likely she wouldn't notice any of the non-natives having problems either, as she wasn't around any non-natives.
Not that that discounts your point. It could be completely true that the Book continued to jot down people's histories and that they retained their false memories. After all, Azalin still had some control of Darkon as a whole.
But I somewhat like the idea of having the false memories fail while Azalin was dead. Azalin has always been the linchpin holding his country together, being willing even to kill his own son for the good of his country. I rather like the idea of Darkonians losing their cultural identity with the demise of Azalin, as represented by the non-native "natives" regaining their true memories and losing their concept of Darkonian-ness.
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:The real question is, how many of the Slain spontaneously regained their memories of life in other lands, when Azalin returned and Necropolis was suddenly its own domain, entirely free of the lich-king's influence? What might they do about such revelations, if so?
Wow! Now that really *is* a good question!
Especially since, upon regaining your memories, you'll want to see your newly remembered loved ones again. Only now you've got three strikes against you: 1) you're undead, so your family is going to be rather afraid of you, 2) you're undead, so Death can control your ass and prevent you from leaving, and 3) you're undead, so even if you successfully get out of Necropolis, then Azalin can control your ass and prevent you from leaving Darkon.
I think I love your idea, Roti. It seems like such a beautifully torturous addition to the typical Requiem mindset.

Mind if I steal it?
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Likewise, while Azalin
could deliberately restore someone's past, most players would regard being forced to serve the lich's agenda with their memories as hostages as heavy-handed railroading, and resent it anyway. Plus, that's assuming they even trust him to give PCs back their
real memories, and not a different set of invented ones....

Awesome... Simply awesome...
