"How would you re-envision Ravenloft for 4E?"
See, I kind of agree with Ivana: Darklords going, "Lawl you're not worth my time." is just an excuse to not have the Darklords be active villains. These guys should be /constantly/ schemeing, with and against eachother.
A compromise, I think, on the mobile Darklords bit could be to crib something from Birthright: Investichure. If a Regent beat another Regent, you could try and steal or sever that Regent's connection to the land, taking a province or holding for yourself. If Darklords went into conflict, a "win" could be rewarded/punished by the Dark Powers increasing the winning DL's power, and decreasing the loser's.
Suddenly, all those minor victories of Drakov's might start meaning something, when Azalin realizes he gained a tiny sliver of turf with each dead man's campaign...
A compromise, I think, on the mobile Darklords bit could be to crib something from Birthright: Investichure. If a Regent beat another Regent, you could try and steal or sever that Regent's connection to the land, taking a province or holding for yourself. If Darklords went into conflict, a "win" could be rewarded/punished by the Dark Powers increasing the winning DL's power, and decreasing the loser's.
Suddenly, all those minor victories of Drakov's might start meaning something, when Azalin realizes he gained a tiny sliver of turf with each dead man's campaign...
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
The problem with having Ravenloft = Shadowfell is that the Shadowfell is evidently more like Ravenloft's Near Ethereal than like Ravenloft, itself. It's a realm of ghosts and shadowy presences, which mirrors the darker side of a reality which it directly overlaps. Making Ravenloft a part of the Shadowfell means we wouldn't have a separate "Other Side" anymore, because the Land would be on the Other Side.
Personally, I don't see that it's necessary to pigeonhole Ravenloft into any one named plane of the new cosmology. Adding obscure new worlds to the cosmos as needed has been a D&D tradition, ever since Gary Gygax belatedly grafted the Demiplane of Shadow onto the 1E DMG's map of the multiverse. The Mists never honored the boundaries between worlds -- or between cosmologies, for that matter -- in the past; why can't they be a mysterious force from beyond the known planes, much as the Far Realm is in 3.5?
Personally, I don't see that it's necessary to pigeonhole Ravenloft into any one named plane of the new cosmology. Adding obscure new worlds to the cosmos as needed has been a D&D tradition, ever since Gary Gygax belatedly grafted the Demiplane of Shadow onto the 1E DMG's map of the multiverse. The Mists never honored the boundaries between worlds -- or between cosmologies, for that matter -- in the past; why can't they be a mysterious force from beyond the known planes, much as the Far Realm is in 3.5?
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
If Drakov had the power to relieve the prisoner of his prison, Azalin would give him Darkon lock, stock and barrel. Azalin's interest in the fate of Darkon and its inhabitants is but a measure of his distraction from the purpose of his existence, which is to escape the Mists at any price even at the cost of destroying the world. Now I will grant that the Gazzetteers suggest that Azalin may have decided that escape is not quite the panacea that he once thought it to be, but it is far from clear that his new goal in life is, or should be, the accumulation of land. I would think that breaking his curse would be a far higher priority. How the children of the Gentlemen caller fit into that has never been clear to me. Maybe they are to somehow grant Azalin mobility within the Core. But he would care not one whit about that compared to the real prize of being able to learn new magic again. And even for Drakov, wouldn't he, given the chance, take winning from Berlin without being able to himself walk down the Champs de l'Elyess over being defeated in person abroad?DocBeard wrote:A compromise, I think, on the mobile Darklords bit could be to crib something from Birthright: Investichure. If a Regent beat another Regent, you could try and steal or sever that Regent's connection to the land, taking a province or holding for yourself. If Darklords went into conflict, a "win" could be rewarded/punished by the Dark Powers increasing the winning DL's power, and decreasing the loser's.
Suddenly, all those minor victories of Drakov's might start meaning something, when Azalin realizes he gained a tiny sliver of turf with each dead man's campaign...
At bottom, how many Darklord's really want to get out and confront one another in personal combat, since that alone of their scheming cannot be done as they currently are?
Not Drakov. For he doesn't even know that he is a Darklord or that Azalin is or that Jacqueline, Ivana and Ivan are. Indeed given the chance, he would string up the entire Coucil of Brilliance, not in the least granting Dominic special recognition as being Darklord, since that is lost upon his military genius.
Azalin and Strahd have been there, done that, and seem quite happy to have moved on.
Hazlik want's to destroy his own race across the multiverse not stamp out crime in Nova Vaasa and make himself chief horselord of the place.
Harkon might like to prove his musical genius to a wider audience, but he hardly seems to be suffering from an inability to serenade then devour Ivana and Gabey. And given that he can't muster the focus to slaughter Madame Fury in his own land, is he really going to lead a pogrom into Vebrek?
Timothy has his own personal problems that prevent him from leading a pogrom in his own land let alone abroad.
I suppose we could imagine our resident Catlord wanting to lead a pogrom in person into Vebrek, but that says more about his unmemorable purpose in life than what makes him tick.
Gabey might enjoy crashing one of Ivana's parties and setting guests at each other's throats. But Ivana is probably as good at the latter and Ivan does the first admirably.
Jacqueline has to turn everyone in Richemulot into a rat before she can worry about exporting her rat plague.
Dominic as charming as he is is not going to get anywhere with Azalin or Strahd. At best they would crush him like a bug. Jacqueline, Gabey and Ivana would take an instant dislike to him, for known reasons. And if he could sweet talk Drakov and command by proxy the armies of Falkovnia, is that really going to bring him love?
Will Adam find the acceptance that he wants from Dominic by forcing the man to call the monster 'uncle' before crushing his windpipe? Will Adam be invited twice or even once to Ivana's parties? Would he care to return a second time in any case? Does he want to rule the inhabitants of Barovia?
Does Malken think that Port-a-Lucine, let alone the Village of Barovia, would be a preferable place to practice his craft? Would he even want to make the effort of bothering to learn a foreign language?
Would the Hags have a significantly better time if they could export the Inquisition? If there was ever a stay at home bunch, it is them, for they are often enough content to let goblins and related agents do their work for them already.
In brief, maybe the Darklords' decidedly introverted purposes, save for that of Vlad, do make for stagnent international relations. But is it fair to judge Strahd a failure because he could care less about 'restoring' his authority over the people of Borca? For the most part, what makes a Darklord tick is the very stuff of his/her own domain. Which is emminently logical incidently. The Brain is Dominic's rival not because he is Lamoridan let alone operating out of Lamordia, but rather because he is right under Dominic's nose and using Dominic's methods. And that is something that a roving Adam never achieves. A Darklord needs a nemesis who is tailored to himself or herself. And the property owner next door is not that. Even Vlad feels this. For he can find no worthy opponents in his neighbours no military mind to match his own. Whereas Dragonnov and Gondegel fit the bill nicely.
Last edited by cure on Wed Jan 09, 2008 1:04 pm, edited 3 times in total.
The cure for what ails you
Well, it was an example using the most famous Not Rivalry in Ravenloft.
Personally, I still think Azalin's insisting on talking about how beneith him Drakov is, and how the man doesn't even fit into his plans as a distraction is a case of the big guy protesting a little too much, and he sure as hell wouldn't take his prison being /stolen/ from him by another inmate lieing down, but that's a matter of personal intepritation.
Personally, I still think Azalin's insisting on talking about how beneith him Drakov is, and how the man doesn't even fit into his plans as a distraction is a case of the big guy protesting a little too much, and he sure as hell wouldn't take his prison being /stolen/ from him by another inmate lieing down, but that's a matter of personal intepritation.
- Dion of the Fraternity
- Lurker Maximus

- Posts: 1092
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 4:20 am
- Location: Baguio City, Philippines
- Contact:
When I suggested that the domain lords would go mobile, I didn't mean an all-out shadow war amongst themselves.
That's the reason why I suggest that when a domain lord leaves the domain, his/her its powers are greatly diminished. They too, along with the player characters, will have to fear the foreign land they walk. On the off-chance that the native domain lord is within his or her land while the foreign domain lord is there as well, then the foreign lord has to endure the effects of the ruling lord's power--along with the rest of whoever's inside the domain.
Here's an example: Strahd (for some reason) finds himself in Richemulot. He has a weakened status as a domain lord away from his domain (let's say he can only rest when there's Barovian soil around him). In the first place, does he even know that Jackie is the domain lord of Richemulot? If so, does Strahd know if she's in the domain at all? Who's to know what would happen if she finds out that a Barovian lord is in her domain, and weakened at the very least?
Strahd would have to act and think carefully about his actions and goals in Richemulot, lest powers obviously stronger than him would discover his presence.
The movie about Dracula in New Orleans comes into mind. I know it might be a bad example, but I hope everyone gets my point.
That's the reason why I suggest that when a domain lord leaves the domain, his/her its powers are greatly diminished. They too, along with the player characters, will have to fear the foreign land they walk. On the off-chance that the native domain lord is within his or her land while the foreign domain lord is there as well, then the foreign lord has to endure the effects of the ruling lord's power--along with the rest of whoever's inside the domain.
Here's an example: Strahd (for some reason) finds himself in Richemulot. He has a weakened status as a domain lord away from his domain (let's say he can only rest when there's Barovian soil around him). In the first place, does he even know that Jackie is the domain lord of Richemulot? If so, does Strahd know if she's in the domain at all? Who's to know what would happen if she finds out that a Barovian lord is in her domain, and weakened at the very least?
Strahd would have to act and think carefully about his actions and goals in Richemulot, lest powers obviously stronger than him would discover his presence.
The movie about Dracula in New Orleans comes into mind. I know it might be a bad example, but I hope everyone gets my point.
Recall Azalin telling Strahd to break his connection with the land of Barovia as an attempt was being engineered to build a gate out of the Demiplane. And Azalin understood belatedly that walking into the Mist was a monumental error for the Mist promptly bound him to a land. Recall the power rituals of fiends. The more you bind yourself to the lands of the Mist, the less chance you have of getting out should you ever find a gate. Finally, recall that Azalin understands that Gabey must live on as Darklord if Mallacio's potential is to ever be redeemed.DocBeard wrote:Well, it was an example using the most famous Not Rivalry in Ravenloft.
Personally, I still think Azalin's insisting on talking about how beneith him Drakov is, and how the man doesn't even fit into his plans as a distraction is a case of the big guy protesting a little too much, and he sure as hell wouldn't take his prison being /stolen/ from him by another inmate lieing down, but that's a matter of personal intepritation.
I propose then that the very size of Darkon is a testament to Azalin's strength in terms of his potential to escape. A chain the size of Darkon is needed to hold him. Conquests, the annexation of Arak, strengthen the chain. And after the Grand Conjunction the chain needed strengthening.
And the later loss of Il Aluk, however much it hurts Azalin's pompous pride, weakens the chain. Indeed is there even a drop of evidence that Azalin is bending his considerable resources to a scheme for taking back his capital city? None I believe. Why? He thinks it hopeless? Perhaps. He thinks doing so takes him no nearer to victory over his captors? Very likely. He thinks that taking Il Aluk from him was a significant error by his captors? A tantalising possibility.
So while Drakov schemes to make the prison in its entirety his own, Azalin pines for a way to escape it, and if Drakov could provide the distraction Azalin needs for a good shot at escape, why wouldn't he will the old warrior the dark, dank place?
Azalin plays at being the stern caring Rex of Darkon. And he no doubt puts in the time between inspirations that way. But his entire being is bent to understanding the Demiplane and his captors. And for him that is the only game in town and everyone else who is playing a lesser game is an ignorant fool unworthy even of contempt.
Now that is not to say that his contempt for Strahd's love of Tatyanna is wholly unlaced with jealousy. Nor is it to say that he learned nothing even from Drakov. Drakov's fruitless invasions resemble Azalin's fruitless escape attempts. And it is clear that Azalin has decided to take an entirely new approach to the matter, whatever that may be, just as Drakov is attempting something new in Invidia.
So maybe Azalin admires slightly Drakov's stubbornness, even his eventual innovation. And more perhaps Azalin can appreciate Drakov's military mind, and as a king is even jealous of it. Further he can sympathise as to bearing a curse that cuts off one's full potential at the knees.
But Azalin is not afraid of Drakov. He is not embarassed by the ability to raise the dead of any invader. And he realises that the Dark Powers have given him a secure prison cell the better to hold him. So what would be the point of acquiring a secure suite of prison cells, rather than striving instead to crack open just enough the prison itself and slip away?
Last edited by cure on Wed Jan 09, 2008 12:55 pm, edited 1 time in total.
The cure for what ails you
In a perfectly hermetic gaming situation, which evidently doesn't exist, don't the players know far too much if they can appreciate the novelty of Lord Vasili awaiting them on a wharf in Ludendorf or, more finely still, Count Strahd in his proper personna chasing them beyond the invisible line that divides Barovia from Nova Vaasa?Dion of the Fraternity wrote:When I suggested that the domain lords would go mobile, I didn't mean an all-out shadow war amongst themselves.
There is Van Richtenesque knowledge presupposed here: Lord Vasili is a facade commonly adopted by Strahd von Zarovich when he doesn't want to attract attention to himself as the Count of Barovia and as the Devil Strahd, and presumably when he is weakend by being far from home; further Strahd von Zarovich is a Darklord; and as a Darklord Strahd von Zarovich runs into the equivalent of a perfectly impenetrable wall of force that invisibly surrounds his land which is to him as a Darklord an impregeable prison.
Maybe the eldars of the Fraternity of Shadows might be able to appreciate the novelty of the situation but few if any others if we are serious about Knowledge (Ravenloft) being a cross-class skill. And even then, is Strahd really going to travel using the well worn fasade of Lord Vasili rather than something uniquely and carefully calibrated for the occasion? So at best the players meet a mysterious and commanding gentlemen who lets a Barovian accent slip through his fasade. And if they fight him, he proves to be a tough customer. And if he flees and they manage to find his coffin, they put him down forever without even knowing that he is Strahd von Zarovich and we are rid of that thorn in our side without fanfare worth speaking of.
Hence I do not appreciate the novelty angle any more than the tearing-each-other's-throats-out angle.
And as to the weakening angle, Darklords can be weakened on their home ground if that is what we are after. Leo perhaps came closest to slaying Strahd by fighting him on holy ground and trapping him within a symbol of some sort. The reality wrinkle of a fiend could achieve much the same. Yes, the ultimate in unholy alliances, unless you can get Isolde on board, but who said that slaying a Darklord should be a fight just like any other?
The cure for what ails you
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Cure makes a good point. Are wandering darklords anything more than a DM fan service equivalent of Alien vs. Predator that will go over the heads of PCs, and maybe throw some knowledgeable players for a loop? As an RL fanboy, it'd be fun to see in a novel, but how does it help gameplay?
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Ivana_Boritsi
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 192
- Joined: Thu Dec 04, 2003 5:48 pm
For me, it's mainly that the Darklords, right now, don't interact very much. Yes, yes, I know. The Darklords have interacted with each other in the past. However, I think that Ravenloft would be much more dynamic if they interacted with each other all of time. For example, how much does Strahd interact with Hazlik, Gabrielle, Ivana or Harkon Lucas? Not at all. And these people border his own Domain. In feudal societies, the lords of different states had to interact all of the time, causing major conflicts and changes.gonzoron wrote:Cure makes a good point. Are wandering darklords anything more than a DM fan service equivalent of Alien vs. Predator that will go over the heads of PCs, and maybe throw some knowledgeable players for a loop? As an RL fanboy, it'd be fun to see in a novel, but how does it help gameplay?
Also, it would be nice if the PCs could have more opportunities to meet Darklords. Without question, the Darklords are the focus of Ravenloft. But as it is, if you want to meet more than one, your PCs wil have to travel about - you can't bring the Darklords to them.
So, I guess that I don't have to have Darklords with the ability to leave their Domains in a re-envisioned Ravenloft. But I would want some impetus and reason for them to be interacting all of the time.
Here's the thing - when these NPCs start interacting with each other on a regular basis, it creates conflict, which the PCs have to fix or participate in. Right now, all of the Domain are sort of self-contained. All of their cool story elements are contained within the borders of the Domain. I would love it if the story elements could spill over into other Domains.
For example, say Harkon Lucas wanders out of Kartakass and spies a woman that he likes. He uses his guile and charm and gets her to go back with him home - except that the woman looks a lot like Tatayana. Oops! Now, you throw the PCs in there. Maybe the family wants to hire the PCs to find their missing daughter, and they are thrown into the middle of Darklord conflict.
Let's say that Ivan goes to a ball in Invidia while heavy guarded and poisons one of Gabrielle's top advisors because of an insult. Then he flees Borca. The PCs might be hired to guard Ivan. Or the PCs might be hired to investigate the poisoning of one of Gabrielle's advisors.
Now I know, now I can divine. The reign of man is over, and He has come....
-Guy De Maupassant
-Guy De Maupassant
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
FWIW, I agree that a number of the domains are a bit too self-contained. However, I think that's got less to do with darklords' physical immobility than with the way the game-materials about those domains were generally written: each domain, described by a writer who wasn't necessarily working hand-in-hand with other domains' authors on a given project, and not at all for domains which didn't appear in the same game-supplement. The writers couldn't incorporate too many threads that crossed over between Gazetteers, for example, because that would have roused protests that the books were "useless" if you only bought one or two of them.
Building plot-hooks and so forth is a function which, in game products, is generally served by adventures, not sourcebooks. The Gazetteers' job is to establish a common baseline environment, with a few threads that can be further developed in the form of Dread Possibilities; they're not meant to be full-blown modules. Really, the "static darklord" problem stems from the fact that we haven't seen any "official" Ravenloft adventures that feature darklords or their evil schemes in the better part of a decade, not from the lords' inability to lay the smackdown on one another.
Building plot-hooks and so forth is a function which, in game products, is generally served by adventures, not sourcebooks. The Gazetteers' job is to establish a common baseline environment, with a few threads that can be further developed in the form of Dread Possibilities; they're not meant to be full-blown modules. Really, the "static darklord" problem stems from the fact that we haven't seen any "official" Ravenloft adventures that feature darklords or their evil schemes in the better part of a decade, not from the lords' inability to lay the smackdown on one another.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
Continuing what Rotipher was saying, take the Musard River. I have long argued that it is worthy of a Gazeetteer in and of itself. That would be just revisiting covered material, right? On the contrary. The Musard River is so poorly and inconsistently covered in the Gazeetters that it is impossible to give a cannon answer as to whether there is travel and trade on it from Ludendorf to Karina and from Karina to Skald. Go back to the adventures, as Rotipher points out, and it is clear that a certain class of riverboat can and does get from Skald to Karina and back again. Whether there is useful access to the Sea of Sorrows through the delta in Lamordia is sadly nowhere clarified.
Yet think on this. The navagability of the Musard and the trade that occurs on it is possibly the most important factor shaping the economies of Kartakass, Sithicus, Invidia, Vebrek, Borca, Richemulot, Dementlieu, Falkovnia, and perhaps Lamordia. It is also the key factor defining the movement of people north-south in the Western Core.
But the piecemeal, domain by domain, approach of the Gazeetters conceals all of this from us.
And the same point can be made about the roads of the core. Is there even so much as a decent map of them? Do you know how much digging it takes to even find their names? Do we have any suggestion of the relative security of each? What seasons they are open in?
Take Strahd and Harkon. There is an insurgency in the former Gundarak. Harkon bears a grudge against Strahd from their first encounter. But he is also smart enough to know that standing at the border and hurling taunts at the forests of Barovia is at best futile and at worst could get him cooked alive. So what does he do? He openly tolerates and secretly encourages insurgents to use northern Kartakass as a safe haven. But this presupposes trails away from the closely watched road into Barovia. Do you think that a Gazeetter would have so much as deign to have mentioned trails between two domains? The only trail I recall was between the village of Barovia and Imol in southern Barovia.
Now the insurgency is well enough discussed. But its cross-domain logistics are not. Where do you think that the pilfered goods from raids on Barovian agents and sympathisers end up. All that cannot be used directly by the insurency has to be recycled into weapons either in Kartakass or in Borca. But not by using the one and only cannon road.
Now Lukas in fact has not so much to do in his life and giving Stahd a hard time makes him feel important so this has become a bit of a thorn in the side of Barovian ambitions. Hence there are Barovian spies in Kartakass at least studying the situation and probably hunting key insurgents. And the same is no doubt true in southern Borca. Now would Stahd like to personally ring Harkon's neck for this? Well, if there is no sign of his lost love and given the chance, quite possibly. But Harkon is secure in a land that does not afford that chance, otherwise he would not be baiting Strahd in the first place.
The resistence against Drakov is another case in point. We know the Dementlieuse are involved, but we have barely any details, especially logistical one. Heck, we don't know the state of the river between the two lands.
The recent adventure A Calling from Vebrek, like the Eye of Evil before it, gives us valuable information about the relations between Kartakass and Invidia and Falkovnia and Invidia, plus valuable information about the relations between Vebrek and Invidia. Adventures do that. They are not constrained by borders. The Feast of Goblyns tied Gundarak and Kartakass together. The early part of the Requim series tied Darkon and Falkovnia together. I have an adventure in mind tieing Kartakass and Vebrek together, as Harkon plots to poison Timothy with wolfsbane. Adventures can and do cross-borders. The Gazeetters far less so.
So we need more adventures!
Yet think on this. The navagability of the Musard and the trade that occurs on it is possibly the most important factor shaping the economies of Kartakass, Sithicus, Invidia, Vebrek, Borca, Richemulot, Dementlieu, Falkovnia, and perhaps Lamordia. It is also the key factor defining the movement of people north-south in the Western Core.
But the piecemeal, domain by domain, approach of the Gazeetters conceals all of this from us.
And the same point can be made about the roads of the core. Is there even so much as a decent map of them? Do you know how much digging it takes to even find their names? Do we have any suggestion of the relative security of each? What seasons they are open in?
Take Strahd and Harkon. There is an insurgency in the former Gundarak. Harkon bears a grudge against Strahd from their first encounter. But he is also smart enough to know that standing at the border and hurling taunts at the forests of Barovia is at best futile and at worst could get him cooked alive. So what does he do? He openly tolerates and secretly encourages insurgents to use northern Kartakass as a safe haven. But this presupposes trails away from the closely watched road into Barovia. Do you think that a Gazeetter would have so much as deign to have mentioned trails between two domains? The only trail I recall was between the village of Barovia and Imol in southern Barovia.
Now the insurgency is well enough discussed. But its cross-domain logistics are not. Where do you think that the pilfered goods from raids on Barovian agents and sympathisers end up. All that cannot be used directly by the insurency has to be recycled into weapons either in Kartakass or in Borca. But not by using the one and only cannon road.
Now Lukas in fact has not so much to do in his life and giving Stahd a hard time makes him feel important so this has become a bit of a thorn in the side of Barovian ambitions. Hence there are Barovian spies in Kartakass at least studying the situation and probably hunting key insurgents. And the same is no doubt true in southern Borca. Now would Stahd like to personally ring Harkon's neck for this? Well, if there is no sign of his lost love and given the chance, quite possibly. But Harkon is secure in a land that does not afford that chance, otherwise he would not be baiting Strahd in the first place.
The resistence against Drakov is another case in point. We know the Dementlieuse are involved, but we have barely any details, especially logistical one. Heck, we don't know the state of the river between the two lands.
The recent adventure A Calling from Vebrek, like the Eye of Evil before it, gives us valuable information about the relations between Kartakass and Invidia and Falkovnia and Invidia, plus valuable information about the relations between Vebrek and Invidia. Adventures do that. They are not constrained by borders. The Feast of Goblyns tied Gundarak and Kartakass together. The early part of the Requim series tied Darkon and Falkovnia together. I have an adventure in mind tieing Kartakass and Vebrek together, as Harkon plots to poison Timothy with wolfsbane. Adventures can and do cross-borders. The Gazeetters far less so.
So we need more adventures!
Last edited by cure on Sat Jan 12, 2008 2:51 pm, edited 3 times in total.
The cure for what ails you
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
I've been thinking of this lately. And come to the conclusion I would start again fresh with Ravenloft if I was given the choice. A complete and total restart.
See, the old editions have one surviving use: fluff. The more the fluff is repeated, regurgitated or replaced the less useful the old books are. The descriptions of people, places, things, organizations and generally how the world works.
All that really *needs* to be updated for 4E is the hard rules: fear, horror, madness and dark power checks.
So I'd just make a new Masque and provide the rules. A dark fantasy world, possibly more akin to Midnight or a dark Forgotten Realms, or even the default world provided by 4E. Then I'd make it a Masque and add the fear and related rules, some gypsies, and make a brand new world without the oddness of a demiplane.
The Core setting would be untouched and fully usable, but there'd be this alternate world with villains that could be defeated without removing an entire region, and where you don't need to stop and wonder where all the food comes from or how people trade for spices and coffee.
See, the old editions have one surviving use: fluff. The more the fluff is repeated, regurgitated or replaced the less useful the old books are. The descriptions of people, places, things, organizations and generally how the world works.
All that really *needs* to be updated for 4E is the hard rules: fear, horror, madness and dark power checks.
So I'd just make a new Masque and provide the rules. A dark fantasy world, possibly more akin to Midnight or a dark Forgotten Realms, or even the default world provided by 4E. Then I'd make it a Masque and add the fear and related rules, some gypsies, and make a brand new world without the oddness of a demiplane.
The Core setting would be untouched and fully usable, but there'd be this alternate world with villains that could be defeated without removing an entire region, and where you don't need to stop and wonder where all the food comes from or how people trade for spices and coffee.
...so a sort of official "divergent universe" type of progression?
That could work. Gives the DMs who want to play it as a weekend in hell type of game that sort of in-your-face immediacy, while leaving everything intact fluffwise for the DMs who want to base a campaign there and interweave the background.
This sort of parallels (haha!) the Gazetteer metaplot with S, but I'm thinking that one thing Azalin (or the next Big Bad Guy Who Shakes Up the Core For A New Edition) could do would be to split Ravenloft into two or more parallel universes. One such could be a highly deadly and very simplistic realm of archetypes. Another could be the intricate detailed realm we see emerging from Domains of Darkness for 2nd ed. and carried on masterfully through 3rd Ed. in the Gazetteer series.
Whether the DM wants to adopt one or the other is up to them. Those who want to merge them at times can certain do so, with that "explained away" by using Minor Conjunctions as a plot device. There might even be a series of parallel universes, e.g.:
1. Similar to the present - flecks of bright lights of goodness in a backdrop of darkness and evil, with dark concentrations of darkness and evil in the form of darklords.
2. Worse than the present - the flecks of bright lights have been extinguished and the darklords' power is now so entrenched that they're now colliding up against each other in power plays directly.
3. Redemption of sorts - some of the major darklords have been killed off or escaped, and either replaced by inferior baddies (e.g. Soth) or not replaced at all (e.g. Gundar). Ironically, if Azalin's most cherished effort comes true, this is the likely outcome because he is among the more powerful darklords in Ravenloft, so if he escapes, Darkon does not currently have anybody quite as powerful as him to be the prime mover for evil plots.
Of course this is a crude strata but it might allow campaigns to be played either as a "nearly standard DnD crawl plus a bit of creepiness" or at the other extreme a "fight for mere survival and redemption".
If we had to work the reference to the "Time of Unparalleled Darkness" into it, one major conceptual problem I personally had was that the ToUD would have to exceed the previous extremes set by the Grand Conjunction, which would make Ravenloft quite inhospitable and likely only suitable for weekend-in-hell style play. If you use the multiple universes approach, that then ceases to be a problem since there are various canonical levels of play available.
It might also help the DM in scaling challenge levels concerning the three-tiered system that 4E is touting - of heroic, paragon, and epic (or whatever it was). They might hope to go up against Strahd as represented in EtCR if they're merely L1-10, or they could go against a more powerful version for L11-20, or even an epic version if it's L21-30. (They might even try to give Gwydion a run for his money.)
Just some thoughts clashing around in my marble-box this merry eve. [poetry]
That could work. Gives the DMs who want to play it as a weekend in hell type of game that sort of in-your-face immediacy, while leaving everything intact fluffwise for the DMs who want to base a campaign there and interweave the background.
This sort of parallels (haha!) the Gazetteer metaplot with S, but I'm thinking that one thing Azalin (or the next Big Bad Guy Who Shakes Up the Core For A New Edition) could do would be to split Ravenloft into two or more parallel universes. One such could be a highly deadly and very simplistic realm of archetypes. Another could be the intricate detailed realm we see emerging from Domains of Darkness for 2nd ed. and carried on masterfully through 3rd Ed. in the Gazetteer series.
Whether the DM wants to adopt one or the other is up to them. Those who want to merge them at times can certain do so, with that "explained away" by using Minor Conjunctions as a plot device. There might even be a series of parallel universes, e.g.:
1. Similar to the present - flecks of bright lights of goodness in a backdrop of darkness and evil, with dark concentrations of darkness and evil in the form of darklords.
2. Worse than the present - the flecks of bright lights have been extinguished and the darklords' power is now so entrenched that they're now colliding up against each other in power plays directly.
3. Redemption of sorts - some of the major darklords have been killed off or escaped, and either replaced by inferior baddies (e.g. Soth) or not replaced at all (e.g. Gundar). Ironically, if Azalin's most cherished effort comes true, this is the likely outcome because he is among the more powerful darklords in Ravenloft, so if he escapes, Darkon does not currently have anybody quite as powerful as him to be the prime mover for evil plots.
Of course this is a crude strata but it might allow campaigns to be played either as a "nearly standard DnD crawl plus a bit of creepiness" or at the other extreme a "fight for mere survival and redemption".
If we had to work the reference to the "Time of Unparalleled Darkness" into it, one major conceptual problem I personally had was that the ToUD would have to exceed the previous extremes set by the Grand Conjunction, which would make Ravenloft quite inhospitable and likely only suitable for weekend-in-hell style play. If you use the multiple universes approach, that then ceases to be a problem since there are various canonical levels of play available.
It might also help the DM in scaling challenge levels concerning the three-tiered system that 4E is touting - of heroic, paragon, and epic (or whatever it was). They might hope to go up against Strahd as represented in EtCR if they're merely L1-10, or they could go against a more powerful version for L11-20, or even an epic version if it's L21-30. (They might even try to give Gwydion a run for his money.)
Just some thoughts clashing around in my marble-box this merry eve. [poetry]
- Lord Cyclohexane
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 512
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 1:59 pm
- Location: Tanelorn, OH
I could go for this, as I was really looking forward to the Masque of the Jade Dragon, mostly to reverse-engineer rules for making my own Masques.Jester of the FoS wrote:I've been thinking of this lately. And come to the conclusion I would start again fresh with Ravenloft if I was given the choice. A complete and total restart.
(snip)
So I'd just make a new Masque and provide the rules. A dark fantasy world, possibly more akin to Midnight or a dark Forgotten Realms, or even the default world provided by 4E.
Plus, I was tempted to do a similar thing, using Savage Worlds' system (due to the earlier discussions on people being less scared of Ravenloft if done in non-D&D terms), of just creating the rules for Fear/Horror/Madness, Sinkholes of Evil, modifications to magic, Powers Checks, different rules for demihumans (adding an extra ability to each while forcing the Outcast Hindrance on all of them, to represent the humanocentricity of the setting), etc.
Anyway, I'd plan it to go with the Savage Worlds' Test Drive booklet (free download of just enough rules to play a couple one-shots, but with no rules for levelling or gaining experience, etc; it's just to let people see what they'd be buying) so that people could try Ravenloft for free, and try to have a couple of short one-shot adventures to share the mood.
Then, I'd also hoped, since the Ravenloft 4E would be non-commercial, that perhaps I'd even be able to use the setting information from you guys (just cut-and-paste, with approval, of course) but with different mechanics in the spots where 4E mechanics would be mentioned.
My name is lost to me
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
This is something I might push for or work on as a side project. Update the rules but a new world with a tad more fantasy that the usual Ravenloft.
So regular 'loft would be this faerie-tale esque dark gothic horror world, while Masque of the Red Death remains a dark mirror of the real world as touched by the Mists.
This would would be more akin to fantasy horror, as coined in Domains of Dread with demihumans and minor magic but still fear and horror and monsters.
So regular 'loft would be this faerie-tale esque dark gothic horror world, while Masque of the Red Death remains a dark mirror of the real world as touched by the Mists.
This would would be more akin to fantasy horror, as coined in Domains of Dread with demihumans and minor magic but still fear and horror and monsters.
