Spell idea - please comment.
- Rock of the Fraternity
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 6844
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:16 pm
Spell idea - please comment.
Lia's Internal Analysis
Divination
Level: Bard 4, Sor/Wiz 4
Components: V, S, M*
Casting time: 10 minutes
Range: Medium (100 ft. + 10 ft./caster level)
Target: One item of food or drink
Duration: 5 minutes/ level
Saving throw: Fortitude negates
Spell resistance: No
When a spellcaster casts Lia's Internal Analysis on an item or liquid meant to be eaten, and that item or liquid is then ingested by another being, the spellcaster is provided with detailed knowledge of the diner's nature.
During the first round of analysis, the caster receives knowledge of the diner's physical attributes and disposition in physical skills.
During the second round of analysis, the caster receives knowledge of the diner's less directly physical properties, specifically of their mundane training: the caster learns the target's ability in all Intelligence-, Wisdom- and Charisma-related skills.
During the third round of analysis, the caster receives knowledge of the target's character and personality: the caster learns the target's strength in the area of Int., Wis. and Cha., as well as an indication of their feat disposition and spellcasting proficiency.
Note that all this information is not delivered in ability scores and skill ranks: The caster receives an indication of the areas in which the target is skilled, then gets a feeling for how strong the target is in those areas, relative to the caster's own skill in those same areas. A caster might feel a target is 'much weaker', 'weaker', 'equal', 'stronger' or 'much stronger' than the caster himself in a certain area when analyzing a target. Feat disposition is rendered into descriptive terms, which may be confusing. For example, 'the target has the ability to boost the strength of his spells' might just as easily indicate 'Empower spell', 'Maximize spell' or the 'Sudden' versions of these feats. This spell provides useful information, but it must be used wisely.
Material component: one item of food or drink meant to be ingested.
If the spell's duration expires before the item is ingested, it expires. All food treated with this spell radiates faint Divination magic for the duration of the spell. If multiple creatures share the same item of food or drink, they all become subject to the spell.
If the caster attempts to simultaneously glean a number of individuals greater than their own significant modifier (Int. for Wizards, Cha for Bards and Sorcerers), they must immediately make a Fort. save or be shaken. If the caster chooses to cease gleaning one individual in favour of another, this caveat does not apply. For every individual the caster attempts to glean that raises the total over the acceptable limit, the save DC rises by one.
Attempts to glean individuals must be made with care. If at any time the caster attempts to glean an aberration or an undead (and is not undead him/ or herself) they must make Horror saves at the DC of the spell itself each round. If the caster attempts to glean multiple aberrations/undead simultaneously, they must make a Madness save every round in addition to the Horror save.
If an aberration or undead being gleaned raises the total of individuals gleaned over the acceptable limit, the save DCs to resist being shaken , as well as for the Horror and possibly Madness saves rises by two.
===============================================
Please comment ...? ^^;
Divination
Level: Bard 4, Sor/Wiz 4
Components: V, S, M*
Casting time: 10 minutes
Range: Medium (100 ft. + 10 ft./caster level)
Target: One item of food or drink
Duration: 5 minutes/ level
Saving throw: Fortitude negates
Spell resistance: No
When a spellcaster casts Lia's Internal Analysis on an item or liquid meant to be eaten, and that item or liquid is then ingested by another being, the spellcaster is provided with detailed knowledge of the diner's nature.
During the first round of analysis, the caster receives knowledge of the diner's physical attributes and disposition in physical skills.
During the second round of analysis, the caster receives knowledge of the diner's less directly physical properties, specifically of their mundane training: the caster learns the target's ability in all Intelligence-, Wisdom- and Charisma-related skills.
During the third round of analysis, the caster receives knowledge of the target's character and personality: the caster learns the target's strength in the area of Int., Wis. and Cha., as well as an indication of their feat disposition and spellcasting proficiency.
Note that all this information is not delivered in ability scores and skill ranks: The caster receives an indication of the areas in which the target is skilled, then gets a feeling for how strong the target is in those areas, relative to the caster's own skill in those same areas. A caster might feel a target is 'much weaker', 'weaker', 'equal', 'stronger' or 'much stronger' than the caster himself in a certain area when analyzing a target. Feat disposition is rendered into descriptive terms, which may be confusing. For example, 'the target has the ability to boost the strength of his spells' might just as easily indicate 'Empower spell', 'Maximize spell' or the 'Sudden' versions of these feats. This spell provides useful information, but it must be used wisely.
Material component: one item of food or drink meant to be ingested.
If the spell's duration expires before the item is ingested, it expires. All food treated with this spell radiates faint Divination magic for the duration of the spell. If multiple creatures share the same item of food or drink, they all become subject to the spell.
If the caster attempts to simultaneously glean a number of individuals greater than their own significant modifier (Int. for Wizards, Cha for Bards and Sorcerers), they must immediately make a Fort. save or be shaken. If the caster chooses to cease gleaning one individual in favour of another, this caveat does not apply. For every individual the caster attempts to glean that raises the total over the acceptable limit, the save DC rises by one.
Attempts to glean individuals must be made with care. If at any time the caster attempts to glean an aberration or an undead (and is not undead him/ or herself) they must make Horror saves at the DC of the spell itself each round. If the caster attempts to glean multiple aberrations/undead simultaneously, they must make a Madness save every round in addition to the Horror save.
If an aberration or undead being gleaned raises the total of individuals gleaned over the acceptable limit, the save DCs to resist being shaken , as well as for the Horror and possibly Madness saves rises by two.
===============================================
Please comment ...? ^^;
Last edited by Rock of the Fraternity on Fri Feb 08, 2008 4:11 pm, edited 4 times in total.
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
I'm not a rules expert, but the duration seems a bit short. At minimum caster level, that's 12 seconds to get someone to eat something, after 10 minutes of preparation? Timing would be tricky. And how much would they need to eat to satisfy the spell? If you cast it on a single grape, or similar, they could eat it easily in 12 seconds, but how do you know which grape of the bunch they'll choose? Conversely, if you cast it on a steak, there's no way they'll finish the steak in 12 seconds.
Just some logistical technicalities.
As for the information revealed, it seems OK to me. A bit metagamey, but could be phrased by the GM in general terms.
Just some logistical technicalities.
As for the information revealed, it seems OK to me. A bit metagamey, but could be phrased by the GM in general terms.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Rock of the Fraternity
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 6844
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:16 pm
Hmmm ... How about Duration: 5 minutes/level?
Heh ... I could rename it Lia's Fractal Internal Analysis: the spell saturates the food or drink, and every part of the spell is similar in structure to the whole. Eating or drinking part of the food or drink, sharing it, has exactly the same effect as gobbling the whole of it.
Heh ... I could rename it Lia's Fractal Internal Analysis: the spell saturates the food or drink, and every part of the spell is similar in structure to the whole. Eating or drinking part of the food or drink, sharing it, has exactly the same effect as gobbling the whole of it.
- Rock of the Fraternity
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 6844
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:16 pm
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
If this is anything like Detect Thoughts in its progressive effect, you probably ought to set a limit as to how much information the caster can receive without being overwhelmed by the flood/weirdness of it. Just as reading a mind far smarter than your own can be dangerous to a thought-reader, so analyzing a target who's substantially higher-level than this spell's caster could be disorienting or worse.
Also, if this spell's to be used in Ravenloft, there should be further limitations as to what it can learn and/or who it can safely be used upon. At the very least, receiving insight into the "character and personality" of a darklord is sure to be grounds for a Horror save, if not Madness.
Also, if this spell's to be used in Ravenloft, there should be further limitations as to what it can learn and/or who it can safely be used upon. At the very least, receiving insight into the "character and personality" of a darklord is sure to be grounds for a Horror save, if not Madness.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Rock of the Fraternity
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 6844
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:16 pm
How does this sound:
"If the caster attempts to simultaneously glean a number of individuals greater than their own significant modifier (Int. for Wizards, Cha for Bards and Sorcerers), they must immediately make a Fort. save or be shaken. If the caster chooses to cease gleaning one individual in favour of another, this caveat does not apply."
"Attempts to glean individuals must be made with care. If at any time the caster attempts to glean an aberration or an undead (and is not undead him/ or herself) they must make Horror saves at the DC of the spell itself each round. If the caster attempts to glean multiple aberrations/undead simultaneously, they must make a Madness save every round in addition to the Horror save."
"If the caster attempts to simultaneously glean a number of individuals greater than their own significant modifier (Int. for Wizards, Cha for Bards and Sorcerers), they must immediately make a Fort. save or be shaken. If the caster chooses to cease gleaning one individual in favour of another, this caveat does not apply."
"Attempts to glean individuals must be made with care. If at any time the caster attempts to glean an aberration or an undead (and is not undead him/ or herself) they must make Horror saves at the DC of the spell itself each round. If the caster attempts to glean multiple aberrations/undead simultaneously, they must make a Madness save every round in addition to the Horror save."
[Casts: Wall of Text]
Ok, first in the realm of absolute problems, you need to specify that the creature is the target, not the food; I realize what you're trying to do, but by the rules that you've written the food makes the fortitude save to resist the spell, not the person. Just write in the description that the target must eat the food for it to take effect and that if they don't eat it within the duration the spell fails.
Also, you should probably say that Spell Resistance applies; otherwise Nondetection spells won't prevent the spell from working.
This may only rarely come up, but you also need to say Fortitude negates (object) under the save description, or it will not work on undead or constructs (unless that's what you were going for, but keep in mind that will cause characters to make assumptions about anyone the spell won't work on).
Also, the idea that anyone who eats the food can be analyzed is neat, but is pushing it. The spell lasts half an hour minimum, and it only takes rounds to fully analyze a person; if you cast the spell on a banquet dish, even excluding the time it took to eat it, you could scan the entire nobility of Dementlieu for anyone with class levels. Best to limit the spell by number of targets.
There doesn't seem to be any concentration required, or even a sign that the spell exists, so there's almost no chance of anyone interrupting the spell after it's in effect. The way it's written, there's no way for anyone to interrupt the spell anyway, except for a sudden leap of logic that causes them to cast dispel magic for no good reason.
Are there any downsides to this spell besides the possible horror save? Are the targets aware of the spell affecting them if they make the save? If they make the save, can they project false information to the caster? Most divination spells in Ravenloft have some caveat to them, but the lack of one (as well as the fortitude save instead of the will save usual to divination spells) can be justified by the unusual delivery method.
Now, in the realm of more nebulous criticism, this spell is way too powerful. No other Divination spell in the game even comes close; you're essentially handing the player a character sheet. Maybe a vague character sheet, but the way you've written the spell I'd say it should be ninth level. Legend Lore is 6th level, and it doesn't even touch this spell.
Here's what I'd suggest the spell tell the caster:
-The target's highest and lowest stat (but not the number) - in the case of a tie the target picks which stat you get.
-If the target has arcane, divine, or maybe even psionic casting capabilities including spell like abilities, but not what they are (most psions don't get nondetection, however, so maybe not psionics - it would result in a lot of dopplegangers being flushed out by that spell and one of psionics big strengths is that it's hard to detect; something to keep in mind)
-A range for the target's Hit Die along the lines of detect undead or spells of that vein (Faint - 2HD or less, Moderate 3-8HD, Strong 9-20HD, Overwhelming 21 or higher)
From that the player can try to guess class levels, type, and so on, without getting the answers on a plate. It still leaves an element of uncertainty in the form of skills, feats, spell-like abilities, and possible monster HD; not to mention that if a player knows all of the creature's approximate stats and encounters a creature with unusually high stats, they can easily assume that it's a monster. I'd say the spell as written is gamebreaking, in Ravenloft even more so.
Ok, first in the realm of absolute problems, you need to specify that the creature is the target, not the food; I realize what you're trying to do, but by the rules that you've written the food makes the fortitude save to resist the spell, not the person. Just write in the description that the target must eat the food for it to take effect and that if they don't eat it within the duration the spell fails.
Also, you should probably say that Spell Resistance applies; otherwise Nondetection spells won't prevent the spell from working.
This may only rarely come up, but you also need to say Fortitude negates (object) under the save description, or it will not work on undead or constructs (unless that's what you were going for, but keep in mind that will cause characters to make assumptions about anyone the spell won't work on).
Also, the idea that anyone who eats the food can be analyzed is neat, but is pushing it. The spell lasts half an hour minimum, and it only takes rounds to fully analyze a person; if you cast the spell on a banquet dish, even excluding the time it took to eat it, you could scan the entire nobility of Dementlieu for anyone with class levels. Best to limit the spell by number of targets.
There doesn't seem to be any concentration required, or even a sign that the spell exists, so there's almost no chance of anyone interrupting the spell after it's in effect. The way it's written, there's no way for anyone to interrupt the spell anyway, except for a sudden leap of logic that causes them to cast dispel magic for no good reason.
Are there any downsides to this spell besides the possible horror save? Are the targets aware of the spell affecting them if they make the save? If they make the save, can they project false information to the caster? Most divination spells in Ravenloft have some caveat to them, but the lack of one (as well as the fortitude save instead of the will save usual to divination spells) can be justified by the unusual delivery method.
Now, in the realm of more nebulous criticism, this spell is way too powerful. No other Divination spell in the game even comes close; you're essentially handing the player a character sheet. Maybe a vague character sheet, but the way you've written the spell I'd say it should be ninth level. Legend Lore is 6th level, and it doesn't even touch this spell.
Here's what I'd suggest the spell tell the caster:
-The target's highest and lowest stat (but not the number) - in the case of a tie the target picks which stat you get.
-If the target has arcane, divine, or maybe even psionic casting capabilities including spell like abilities, but not what they are (most psions don't get nondetection, however, so maybe not psionics - it would result in a lot of dopplegangers being flushed out by that spell and one of psionics big strengths is that it's hard to detect; something to keep in mind)
-A range for the target's Hit Die along the lines of detect undead or spells of that vein (Faint - 2HD or less, Moderate 3-8HD, Strong 9-20HD, Overwhelming 21 or higher)
From that the player can try to guess class levels, type, and so on, without getting the answers on a plate. It still leaves an element of uncertainty in the form of skills, feats, spell-like abilities, and possible monster HD; not to mention that if a player knows all of the creature's approximate stats and encounters a creature with unusually high stats, they can easily assume that it's a monster. I'd say the spell as written is gamebreaking, in Ravenloft even more so.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
To avoid the "anyone who eats a piece" problem, I'd suggest to change that into "the first living creature to eat a part of it", so you're sure it hits just 1 target; on th other hand, if a vampire eats a piece it's unaffected, so you can take some conclusions from it (btw, detect undead is much lower in level, so that's not a problem)
Coltiviamo per tutti un rancore
che ha l'odore del sangue rappreso
ciò che allora chiamammo dolore
è soltanto un discorso sospeso
che ha l'odore del sangue rappreso
ciò che allora chiamammo dolore
è soltanto un discorso sospeso
- Rock of the Fraternity
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 6844
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:16 pm
Well, me and my little old SRD spells don't know anything 'bout that.Rock wrote:@Isabella: Ninth level? I do protest. Brain spider is only eighth level and allows you to eavesdrop on the thoughts of eight creatures simultaneously.
The point still stands: with a near infinite number of targets possible, the power to practically hand the player a character sheet for their foe, and no way to stop the spell once it's in effect, the spell as written shouldn't be 4th level. I'm looking at 8th level Divination spells and seeing the spell Greater Prying Eyes, which lets you send some eyeballs out to look at people. And the eyeballs are visible. And if they spot the eyeballs, the target can poke them out. And if they don't make it back to you, you don't learn anything. It just doesn't compare.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
I agree that the spell, barring significant changes, needs to be of a higher level. Perhaps not 9th, as it'd be a lot trickier to implement than Brain Spider, but at least 7th for wiz/sor and 6th for bards. And that's with Sorti's fix of limiting the effect to the first target who samples the food: if you want to learn about more people, you should have to cast it again.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Just FYI: doppelgangers' racial mind-reading is a supernatural ability, not psionic or spell-like.Isabella wrote: (most psions don't get nondetection, however, so maybe not psionics - it would result in a lot of dopplegangers being flushed out by that spell and one of psionics big strengths is that it's hard to detect; something to keep in mind)
For that matter, using this spell on targets who are possessed, suffer the Multiple Personalities Madness effect, or are otherwise "not themselves" might reveal a "character and personality" that's highly misleading.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
The closest other ability I can see is object reading:
http://www.d20srd.org/srd/psionic/power ... eading.htm
That's usable by a 3rd level character.
So I might bump this spell down to 3rd-level.
Firstly, because it's not that powerful or game disrupting, and because it's not as powerful as scrying:
http://www.d20srd.org/srd/spells/scrying.htm
And secondly because there are a metric tonn of 3rd-level spells that rock, it's the most crowded level. So adding another spell there it's a self-correcting way of balancing spells.
http://www.d20srd.org/srd/psionic/power ... eading.htm
That's usable by a 3rd level character.
So I might bump this spell down to 3rd-level.
Firstly, because it's not that powerful or game disrupting, and because it's not as powerful as scrying:
http://www.d20srd.org/srd/spells/scrying.htm
And secondly because there are a metric tonn of 3rd-level spells that rock, it's the most crowded level. So adding another spell there it's a self-correcting way of balancing spells.
- Nathan of the FoS
- Fiendish Enforcer

- Posts: 5247
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
- Location: San Francisco CA
I really like the basic idea of the spell (feed people stuff and learn their thoughts!). But the current implementation is...uh...well, I wouldn't allow it in a campaign at any level.
I'm typing this with one hand, so I'll be brief.
As described, the information given by the spell is mostly metagame, and the wizard doesn't have a PHB in front of him/her, so much of that info would help the player quite a bit, but the character very little--either that, or benefit the character principally through the player's metagaming.
That feeds into the second problem: since this spell involves eating a meal which the wizard has access to, which means the most likely targets are recurring villains/friends OR fellow PCs. As a DM I would be extremely reluctant to hand out character sheets for recurring NPCs, and even less enthusiastic about giving one PC information about the others through a homebrew spell designed for that purpose.
Maybe something along the lines of synergies...if the wizard has a feat and the target also does, the wizard recognizes the similarity in training and thought patterns; if the wizard and target both have more than 5 ranks in a skill, same thing. That would make the spell most useful against other wizards (bards, sorcerers), of course, because they would have the most similar thought patterns and training..so you might want to think of a more flexible (but similarly limited) thing?
I'm typing this with one hand, so I'll be brief.
That feeds into the second problem: since this spell involves eating a meal which the wizard has access to, which means the most likely targets are recurring villains/friends OR fellow PCs. As a DM I would be extremely reluctant to hand out character sheets for recurring NPCs, and even less enthusiastic about giving one PC information about the others through a homebrew spell designed for that purpose.
Maybe something along the lines of synergies...if the wizard has a feat and the target also does, the wizard recognizes the similarity in training and thought patterns; if the wizard and target both have more than 5 ranks in a skill, same thing. That would make the spell most useful against other wizards (bards, sorcerers), of course, because they would have the most similar thought patterns and training..so you might want to think of a more flexible (but similarly limited) thing?
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
