*Sputter* are we looking at the same spell?Jester of the FoS wrote:So I might bump this spell down to 3rd-level.
Firstly, because it's not that powerful or game disrupting, and because it's not as powerful as scrying:
http://www.d20srd.org/srd/spells/scrying.htm
Looking at what an unwarded person is doing at this moment in time does not compare to a character sheet. Legend Lore, a sixth level spell, doesn't compare. Nothing does. Even Mass Read Thoughts doesn't, there's a chance they'll be thinking about their dinner party invites and nothing useful at all.
I stand by my previous statement that the spell as written should be 9th level, or epic even, and add another statement: it makes the game unfun.
It encourages metagaming in the worst kind of way. All it takes is an experienced player to reverse engineer the information she gets and have a complete character sheet.
What happens when the PC scans a creature that has all of its stats higher than hers? Chances are, the only way that's possible is if the NPC is monster.
What happens when the PC notices their friend Natalia has ranks in the Change Shape skill?
In some cases, a vague description of the feat might cause ambiguity, but sometimes it doesn't. How is the GM going to cover Spell Focus: Necromancy? Craft Construct? Emotional Purgative? How about feats which only monsters can take?
Spellcasters CAN'T defend against it. The NPC who burned his skill points putting them into Bluff, a crossclass skill, might have fooled you since first level, but one little spell and his cover is completely blown. He can't do anything to resist it because nondetection doesn't work, and fortitude is his weak save.
You can argue that the GM can find loopholes and crafty tricks to fool the spell, but that's the very problem. The GM is forced to pull cheap tricks and dirty ploys in reaction to one character. Everyone else gets to stand by the wayside while the GM and the spellcaster duke it out over one fourth level spell. If the other PCs are lucky, the get to be the caster's lacky and help them cast the spell. And once the spell is cast, you know everything about the person it was cast on and they can't surprise you at all. It's not fun. Isn't Ravenloft about surprises and discovery?



