Have Outcast Ratings every been formalised?
The best that I can find is the following offerings from Mangrum that might be backed out and generalised:
Basilisk, spirit eater: Outcast Rating: 6 (+1 size, +3 appearance, +1 reputation, +1 unnatural powers)
Horsemen: Outcast Rating: 9 (+1 size, +3 appearance, +3 reputation, +1 beyond the pale, +1 unnatural powers)
Horseman's Steed: Outcast Rating: 9 (+2 size, +3 appearance, +2 reputation, +1 beyond the pale, +1 unnatural powers)
Kraken, soul: Outcast Rating: 10 (+4 size, +3 appearance, +2 reputation, +1 unnatural powers)
Pale Morph: Outcast Rating: 6 (–1 size, +3 appearance, +2 reputation, +1 beyond the pale, +1 unnatural powers)
Stakewood Tree: Outcast Rating: 10 (+4 size, +3 appearance, +1 reputation, +1 beyond the pale, +1 unnatural powers)
Thoqqua, corrupted: Outcast Rating: 7 (+1 size, +3 appearance, +1 reputation, +1 beyond the pale, +1 unnatural powers)
Vistani: Outcast Rating: 3 (+1 size, +1 reputation, +1 unnatural powers).
So there is Size, Appearance, Reputation, Beyond the Pale & Unnatural powers.
SIZE:
?
Small -1
Human +1
Large +2
Huge +4
?
APPEARANCE (ugly?; frightening?):
+3 Basilisk, Elemental (Death, Dream, Evil, Negative Energy, Fire/Earth), Kraken, Stake Wood Tree
REPUTATION (infamy?):
+1 Basilisk, Vistani, Thoqqua, Stakewood Tree
+2 Horseman's Steed, Kraken, Pale Morph
+3 Horsemen
BEYOND THE PALE (things that shouldn't be?; things that are alien?):
+1 Horsemen, Horseman's Steed, Pale Morph, Stakewood Tree, Thoqqua
UNNATURAL POWERS:
+1 everything listed
So what does the common skeleton or zombie rate?
+1 size
+3? appearance (is visibly lacking flesh or having rotting flesh good for 3?)
+1? or 2? reputation (does being undead get you 2?)
? beyond the pale (if a kraken is not beyond the pale is a skeleton)?
0 unnatural powers (hitting people is not unnatural)
+5? perhaps
and
+6 for a jolly rogers (unnatural powers)
and
+7 for a shadow (unnatural powers, beyond the pale)
Thoughts?
Outcast Ratings
Outcast Ratings
The cure for what ails you
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
The guidelines for figuring ORs are in the RLDMG, p. 102-104.
Size: as you say.
Appearance: +1 for slightly inhuman (e.g. demihumans), +2 for distinctly inhuman (weirder than demihumans), +3 for monstrous/ugly/scary
Reputation: ranges from -2 (angels) to +3 (fiends)
Other: Beyond the pale (= "unnatural" creature types like undead, fey, or constructs), culture shock, scarring, & unnatural powers (= innate special abilities/traits) all count for +1, possibly more
By those rules, I'd give a Medium skeleton or zombie an OR 6 (+1 size, +3 monstrous, +1 evil reputation, +1 beyond the pale). For a jolly roger, or a shadow, bump that up to OR 8 (+2 for a predatory reputation, +1 for unnatural powers).
Size: as you say.
Appearance: +1 for slightly inhuman (e.g. demihumans), +2 for distinctly inhuman (weirder than demihumans), +3 for monstrous/ugly/scary
Reputation: ranges from -2 (angels) to +3 (fiends)
Other: Beyond the pale (= "unnatural" creature types like undead, fey, or constructs), culture shock, scarring, & unnatural powers (= innate special abilities/traits) all count for +1, possibly more
By those rules, I'd give a Medium skeleton or zombie an OR 6 (+1 size, +3 monstrous, +1 evil reputation, +1 beyond the pale). For a jolly roger, or a shadow, bump that up to OR 8 (+2 for a predatory reputation, +1 for unnatural powers).
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow

