Well heres a system I came up with just for you and I guess it is okay but it may need some fine tuneing.
Okay as an example of two guys using the skill of Diplomacy in a contested system I will now give you how I see that it could go in a combat encounter.
Here are our competitors...
Guy 1 has 7 ranks total with all modifiers to Diplomacy and is trying to resist Guy 2 and fight.
Guy 2 has 10 ranks total with all modifiers to Diplomacy and is trying to convince Guy 1 to be Indifferent from Hostile which is the highest result possible with his current ranks.
Here are standard rules in effect in 3 examples.
Example 1 standard: Now in a standard roll if both Guy 1 & 2 rolled, the higher would win automatically. Guy 1 rolls a 20 while Guy 2 rolls a 14. Guy 1 has won by luck and Guy 2 has failed and nothing is left but to fight.
Example 2 standard: In the reverse if guy 1 gets the 14 and Guy 2 rolls the 20 then Guy 2 according to the chart has made Guy 1 go to Indifferent. Even if Guy 2 rolled 6 less he would still make Guy 1 go to Unfriendly.
Example 3 standard: Now if Guy 1 rolls a 15 and Guy 2 rolls a 15 then Guy 2 will win and will according to the chart make Guy 1 go to Indifferent. Even if guy 2 rolled 1 less he would still make Guy 1 go to Unfriendly.
By standard rules though they would have to take 1 minute (10 rounds total) to do such. If they do it in one round then Guy 2 the one initiating the roll must take a -10 penalty to his roll. With this he still has a 20 due to his extremely lucky roll. and that still makes Guy 1 go to Unfriendly.
Now lets say we make them go head to head and the loser loses to his future rolls the amount the winner has beaten him by. This goes on till one reaches 0 ranks to roll total. Then the final total of the last check of the victor, is the total that determines the result.
Using the above examples results lets compare the conflict examples.
Example 1 conflict: Guy 1 has rolled a 27 total and is clearly ahead of Guy 2 who has rolled 24 total. Guy 1 has beaten Guy 2 in this first round by 3 and thus Guy 2 must decrease all future checks in this opposed contest by 3 giving Guy 2, 7 ranks left to use. This will go back and forth till one is reduced to zero and the outcome is now tied in it's chances as both Guy 1 and Guy 2 have the same total from the 2nd round on until one loses another amount.
Example 2 conflict: Guy 1 has rolled a total 21 and is now behind Guy 2 who through a lucky roll has gotten a total of 30. Guy 2 has beaten Guy 1 in this first round by 9 and since Guy 1 only had 7 ranks to begin with he is reduced to 0 ranks and has lost. Guy 2 has the winning result of 30 which is enough to get Guy 1 to Indifferent.
Example 3 conflict: Guy 1 has rolled a total 22 and is now behind Guy 2 who rolled a 25 total. Guy 2 has beaten Guy 1 in this first round by 3 and since Guy 1 only had 7 ranks to begin with they are now reduced by 3 giving Guy 1, 4 ranks left to use. This will go back and forth till one is reduced to zero and the outcome is now more in favor of Guy 2 but still not absolutely determined to be for one or the other.
Now how is this different you say.
In Example 1 standard the results we see are that Guy 1 automatically wins with no real contest through sheer luck Guy 1 with that 20 rolled a total 27 but Guy 2 would have gotten a total of 30 with the 20.
In Example 1 conflicting Guy 1 has earned equal footing and thus the next round is not in his opponents favor. Now no matter what in the next round both Guy 1 and Guy 2 roll 20 neither can roll higher than 27 total.
------------------------------
In Example 2 standard the results we see are that Guy 2 automatically wins with no real contest through sheer luck, Guy 2 with that 20 rolled a total 30 but Guy 1 would have gotten a total of 27 with the 20.
In Example 2 conflicting Guy 2 has still won and reduced Guy 1 to 0 and by doing such Guy 2 has succede because the final result of 30 is enough to change Guy 1 from Hostile to Indifferent. Still can't beat overwealming luck.
----------------------------
Example 3 standard the results we see are that Guy 2 automatically wins with with no real contest through sheer luck, Guy 2 that 15 rolled a total 25 but Guy 1 with the same result only could get 22.
In Example 3 conflicting Guy 2 has still won the round but has only reduced Guy 1's starting ranks of 7 by 3 to a new total of 4 ranks in future rounds. Now Guy 2 may still roll a maximum of 30 while Guy 1 may only roll a maximum of 24. This places the odds in Guy 2's favor even more than before but he could still lose future rounds. If however in those future rounds he continued to dwindle Guy 1's reserves then Guy 2 may roll high enough to still get Guy 1 to either Unfriendly or Indifferent or he may still roll too low to succede at either.
Now in these it is up to you if either side gets circumstance modifiers for thier arguements.
Just something I came up with in about an hour so maybe you will like it maybe not. I can help further in developing it if you want. Maybe it will inspire you. Either way hope it helps!
